Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends don’t believe in vaccinations or calpol

187 replies

Campingcarryon · 12/08/2021 08:22

I have some friends who are new parents and have declared that their child won’t be having any childhood vaccinations and that they also don’t believe in giving kids calpol or other medicines either.

Honestly, I didn’t know what to say when they said that to me- I haven’t come accross people who were anti calpol before 🤦‍♀️

Aibu to think it’s quite irresponsible if your child is ill not to get their temp down with calpol and that you are risking things getting a lot worse, especially with really small babies that get ill and deteriorate really fast. Let alone the whole anti vax position.

Honestly, I am still really baffled by their position to be honest. I think it’s really weird and irresponsible not to want your child to feel well 🤪

OP posts:
Crowsaregreat · 13/08/2021 19:38

Tbh I wish there was another paracetamol product on the market for kids other than dayglo gloopy chemically syrup, even though my kids have had plenty of it. Suppositories or a water soluble drink for older kids or something.

In vaccination I bet they'd change their minds at the first whiff of the disease making the rounds. You only have to look up what people used to suffer with polio, whooping cough, measles etc to realise we don't know how good we have it. My GM used to tell me about how she'd keep her kids in for weeks on end when whooping cough was going round. Same as lockdown really.

MyrrAgain · 13/08/2021 19:30

Disgusting. Social should be onto people who put purposely decide put their children at increased risk and harm from serious illness and disease AND put other unvaccinated children at risk (e.g. Those who are too young or compromised). Except they don't. Because parents have the "choice" to allow harm to occur to their children and other people

MissyB1 · 13/08/2021 18:52

@SnottyLottie

I have a friend who wouldn’t give her son calpol because she said her sister (who was a college teacher) used to give her child calpol willynilly to make them go to sleep 🙄 I had to explain to my friend (who is intelligent in her own right) that calpol isn’t a sedative and doesn’t have any sedative qualities. I also asked her to explain why she wouldn’t give pain relief to a child in pain just because her sister misused it in an effort to sedate her child.

Some people are just morons!

Oh God yes the old “Calpol to make them sleep” crap!! No!!! Paracetamol has never been a sedative! I can’t believe people still fall for it! The only reason a child might sleep better after paracetamol is because you have A: relieved their pain B: Brought their temperature down which has made them feel more comfortable.
SnottyLottie · 13/08/2021 18:46

I have a friend who wouldn’t give her son calpol because she said her sister (who was a college teacher) used to give her child calpol willynilly to make them go to sleep 🙄 I had to explain to my friend (who is intelligent in her own right) that calpol isn’t a sedative and doesn’t have any sedative qualities. I also asked her to explain why she wouldn’t give pain relief to a child in pain just because her sister misused it in an effort to sedate her child.

Some people are just morons!

StoneofDestiny · 13/08/2021 18:41

A bit more Freda

The Church of Christ, Scientist, was founded in 1879 by Mary Baker Eddy from New Hampshire, USA. She herself suffered from a great deal of ill health, and believed that she experienced personal healing after reading of the healing power of the Lord Jesus Christ in the New Testament.
In 1875 she published her textbook now known as "Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures". This book, and the Bible, are central to the practice of the Christian Science faith.
To most people the faith is best known for its teaching about reliance on prayer alone for the healing of sickness and disease. When someone joins the Christian Science Church it is understood that there will be reliance on God for healing, rather than on medicines or surgery. There are over 200 Christian Science congregations in the UK.
Christian Scientists will not normally be treated in a hospital, but will seek treatment in a Christian Science Nursing Home, However, they may be admitted to hospital as a result of an accident or because of family and legal pressures. They will undergo medical treatment during pregnancy and allow medical treatment for their children in accordance with UK law.

millymoo1202 · 13/08/2021 18:38

My daughter had a febrile convulsion when she was one she’s now 21 and I thought she was going to die, only thing that helped was paracetamol and ibuprofen she was hospitalised. Your friends are idiots

StoneofDestiny · 13/08/2021 18:38

Freda they are a religious sect who seek healing from God and not by medical intervention. They tend not to go to hospital but to separate Christian Scientist places. Vac's aren't banned, but not encouraged. They believe mankind's medicine gets in the way of God's power to cure.

I'm summarising of course.

GintyMcGinty · 13/08/2021 18:38

I just couldn't be friends with someone whose values were so different to my own.

Justa47 · 13/08/2021 18:34

@Campingcarryon

Your friends are a disgrace and should be arrested for child abuse for not giving vaccinations.

It’s simply so irresponsible it’s like gluing your child to the outside lane of the M1.

It beggars belief.

RampantIvy · 13/08/2021 18:20

I breast fed DD, but there were occasions when she needed paracetamol - on the advice of a doctor while we were in hospital.

Gosh, there are some superior parents on here Hmm

MissyB1 · 13/08/2021 18:20

@Mtbdadder

Thanks *@MissyB1* for your medical perspective and agreed there is no glory in suffering pain.

You say that pain relief is "safe" hence you use it. I also use it but as sparingly as possible. Because as I pointed out above there is evidence that they have side effects, I've also had one friend addicted to painkillers, he developed lots of thyroid problems (no idea if thyroid was related but large quantities of painkillers are dangerous for your liver and kidneys).

Medical best practice on antibiotics has changed through the years as wider knowledge of impacts of overuse are better understood. So medical practice obviously evolves. I am not a professional but I think painkillers will be similarly evaluated in future, especially in very young children/infants. Any thoughts from yourself? Is it a possibility?

No I doubt there will be a day where we say it’s safer to be in pain than use pain relief responsibly. Addicts will be addicts unfortunately, some people have a propensity towards addiction. It’s something within themselves. Most people can use any medication responsibly. As regards side effects, from paracetamol these are vanishingly rare if it it is taken according to instructions.
Thedogscollar · 13/08/2021 18:14

@tootingbeclido

Sorry. .But I have no time for idiots like this.
Exactly this.
Mtbdadder · 13/08/2021 18:12

@Soontobe60 firstly you dont know me and I'm actually very empathetic. Secondly you've not engaged any of my questions...

Mtbdadder · 13/08/2021 18:10

Thanks @MissyB1 for your medical perspective and agreed there is no glory in suffering pain.

You say that pain relief is "safe" hence you use it. I also use it but as sparingly as possible. Because as I pointed out above there is evidence that they have side effects, I've also had one friend addicted to painkillers, he developed lots of thyroid problems (no idea if thyroid was related but large quantities of painkillers are dangerous for your liver and kidneys).

Medical best practice on antibiotics has changed through the years as wider knowledge of impacts of overuse are better understood. So medical practice obviously evolves. I am not a professional but I think painkillers will be similarly evaluated in future, especially in very young children/infants. Any thoughts from yourself? Is it a possibility?

Soontobe60 · 13/08/2021 17:58

[quote Mtbdadder]@Soontobe60 so by your reasoning children should never be in pain? Your position appears to be that it is essential to strive for a pain free existence for them at all times? In my opinion it isn't and so therefore of course they need to learn how to manage pain and discomfort, personally I would much rather they experience that learning process whilst being comforted by a primary caregiver.

What is going to happen when they grow up and you are not there to shovel painkillers down their throat?

Your analogy to chimney sweeps is both bizarre and irrelevant.[/quote]
And you are an uncaring adult.
Experiencing pain as a child is not a ‘learning process’. Why planet are you on that you think it is? Bizarre.

FredaFroo2 · 13/08/2021 17:52

Wtf are Christian Scientists @StoneofDestiny

DaisyWaldron · 13/08/2021 17:51

It is actually very effective as as a painkiller in newborn babies, although there's less evidence that it actually suppresses pain in older babies, just calms them down. Like the pp, my babies certainly responded better to breastfeeding than to Calpol for most illnesses in their first year or so. Breastfeeding - stopped crying, relaxed, eventually fell asleep. Calpol - screamed and cried and flailed around all over the place in a very distressed way, spat out most of the medicine, sometimes vomited.

StoneofDestiny · 13/08/2021 17:47

Are they. Christian Scientists by any chance OP?

Boredmotherofone · 13/08/2021 17:38

@Melassa

We didn’t really do paracetamol here either, as with PPs mine just breastfed more. I did have paracetamol suppositories in, which I must have used max twice, when fever was approaching 39 overnight, but during the day she just breastfed. Also we had a paediatrician who was a fan of letting a fever run if under 38.5° and under and no history of convulsions.

On the whole we tend not to use a lot of over the counter medicines in our house as many are pointless and nothing more than a marketing ploy and the others that do work aren’t entirely free of side effects. We do use pain relief for things like headaches but only if nothing else works.

We did do vaccinations though.

You avoided pain relief for your child and just shoved them on your boob???? Shock

Why do so many mothers assume breast milk is some kind all-encompassing magic liquid that cures anything and everything?! Breast milk is amazing I grant you, but it doesn't remove pain! Poor child

Waspsarearseholes · 13/08/2021 17:16

[quote Mtbdadder]@Waspsarearseholes not reaching at all it is what you said[/quote]
Could you quote where I said I reach for calpol at the drop of a hat, please?

passionfruitpizza · 13/08/2021 17:11

We don't really give calpol, partly because my kids hate it so much that giving it to them feels like assault and they usually vomit it back up anyway but also I don't really think it's essential a lot of the time. Like adult paracetamol I think it's a bit overused.

Herecomesthesun70 · 13/08/2021 17:06

I love calpol. They will too

MissyB1 · 13/08/2021 17:05

@Mtbdadder actually there’s no need to be in pain if pain relief is available. There’s no glory in suffering pain, and I’ve always found martyrs to be very tedious personally.

26 years as a nurse and despite seeing suffering that you can’t imagine in my work, I still never denied my kids some paracetamol if they had any pain or were just under the weather. But I’m not scared of medications because I understand them and know what is safe and what isn’t.

Mtbdadder · 13/08/2021 16:51

@Waspsarearseholes not reaching at all it is what you said

Swipe left for the next trending thread