Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS advert on TV

31 replies

JustGiveMeGin · 12/08/2021 07:40

I keep seeing an ad by the NHS about 'lockdown pounds' and how we should all be eating healthier to reverse the damage lockdown did.
I find this intensely (and probably irrationally)irritating and condescending. The damage was done when we were all locked up for months on end with nothing to do but eat and drink, AIBU to think they should back off and leave us to it now?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/08/2021 15:27

[quote vivainsomnia]@NeverDropYourMooncup, why are you making this personal? the majority of people didn't get Covid or if they did recovered quickly.

Your situation was different and in any case, the advert doesn't apply to you since you have lost the weight. That's great and well done you. You are exactly what the NHS want others to copy.[/quote]
Yours was just the quote I picked, rather than the frankly nasty ones others have made on here, as it provided a useful point I felt needed countering (after all, there's no point even giving the 'you're greedy and lazy and only have yourself to blame' posters the time of day).

I'm not feeling superior because I've lost weight now that I can move around and use the gym. I'm feeling good, but compared to last August, of course I bloody do.

I still recognise that multiple factors contributed to people putting on weight;

Lots being ill.
A ban on non essential travel.
Not being able to get supermarket deliveries. If you did manage to get one (I managed two in that time despite being on the list for priority access), no idea if you'd actually get something - one of my deliveries was planned to cover 21 days of being inside; I was delivered enough for exactly 4 meals.
Not being allowed to go into supermarkets after queueing up if you had small children with you. Not being able to go with somebody else to help carry things if you didn't have a car. Not being able to stand and wait in the carpark for over an hour.
Playgrounds and parks closed in many places.
Going by the number of dead bus drivers, even nearly empty buses were dangerous places. Even if you were prepared to risk being stopped by police and told this was non essential travel and to go back to your home area.
Exercising in attractive countryside or large parks is a whole lot different to walking around concrete oceans. Even before you allow for safety considerations.
The biscuits, tinned pies and packets in every food parcel for CEV people.
Having to homeschool and work from home, making up lost time in the evenings.
Being told if you were CEV that if you absolutely must, you could open a window or sit on your back door step if you had one, but other than that, to not even open your front door for months.
Safe places to exercise for disabled people - gyms, pools, physio units - were closed because they weren't safe in terms of airborne infection and physios being redeployed to teach people how to breathe, cough and stand up again after time on ventilators.
Arseholes (generally men) deliberately using the time to come up behind and cough to try and scare women - which backfired on my first trip out to the GP, as I still had a cough myself, so the twat nearly got himself run over trying to avoid me.
And people were, quite rightly, scared. The NHS was at breaking point. Emergency services couldn't handle extra people out and about and getting injured. You were told to Stay At Home.

and much more.

It's not right and it's not fair to write it all off as being entirely self inflicted. The circumstances were completely different to anything previously experienced. To think that it would completely change people's outlook so that they all come out of a situation where multiple factors made it even more difficult than usual to be as active as usual, to eat healthily, to increase intentional exercise to the extent that they are now being told on her that they only have themselves to blame for being greedy and lazy, is unrealistic.

JustGiveMeGin · 12/08/2021 15:24

Fair enough, I was a little blasé when I said there was nothing to do but eat or drink!
Most people understand what I meant, I did get out every day for more than an hour with my Family and dogs. Unfortunately this did not mitigate the takeaways we had or the gin I consumed Grin
My point is I don't need and NHS TV advert (costing how many millions of pounds???) to tell me I need to get a grip and stop putting weight on, my jeans and bras have been telling me that for free for a little while nowGrin

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 12/08/2021 14:11

@NeverDropYourMooncup, why are you making this personal? the majority of people didn't get Covid or if they did recovered quickly.

Your situation was different and in any case, the advert doesn't apply to you since you have lost the weight. That's great and well done you. You are exactly what the NHS want others to copy.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/08/2021 12:43

There was plenty of time to do family exercising. You were allowed to go out, there were plenty of free exercise videos on line

One slight problem with that.

I had Covid.

I couldn't leave the house from the end of March until July because my lungs were so fucked by it. The only reason I left the house in July was for a medical appointment and the next time I went outside (in August), it was to have chest x-rays to see if the damage was permanent or merely the nine month thing it turned out to be.

I was just about managing to increase my step count to 26 a day by then by deliberately choosing to go to the toilet upstairs - and that left me gasping for breath and my heart feeling as though it was going to burst out of my chest.

I was not going out for hour long exercise sessions or doing Fucking Yoga With Fucking Adrienne when the act of sitting upright wasn't just exhausting, it gave me repeated palpitations and ectopic beats that felt like I was being thumped in the chest.

Took me until May this year until I could actually exercise again, rather than just about manage the effort of being physically upright for the purposes of work.

In January, I was having 1200 kcals a day and wasn't losing weight because I wasn't capable of doing anything (I refuse to do crash dieting because that also affects the heart muscle, as there weren't any other muscles to be broken down for energy by that point and having had an ED before, I had no desire for that to come back with a vengeance). Come June/July, eating up to 2700 kcals a day depending upon what I felt I actually needed (probably did over 3500 on the day I felt I needed a chippie tea for the first time in two years) and I've lost 7.5kg in (checks app) the last 9 and a half weeks.

Not all of us could go out exercising. Not all of us could reduce energy intake enough to reduce weight without potentially causing even more medical issues. Being arses to those who couldn't exercise and weren't able to eat fewer calories really isn't going to help.

SarahTTCx · 12/08/2021 12:13

YABU.

Its clearly struck a nerve with you and maybe thats because you feel personally attacked having gained weight?

Its nobody elses fault that during lockdown you CHOSE to eat and drink and nothing else. You were permitted an hour exercise a day at the worst parts, this is plenty time to get out and do some intense exercise and keep the weight down. ALSO, weight gain is mostly from bad diet rather than lack of exercise, which is entirely the individuals fault. Nobody has forced anybody to eat poorly and lockdown really isn't an excuse for that.

Sorry to sound harsh, but at the end of the day, obesity is a national health crisis and is taking up so much of our NHS' resources and it doesn't need to be the case. Stop being greedy and lazy and look after your health (not you specifically, just anyone who wants to blame the government and lockdowns for weight gain)

vivainsomnia · 12/08/2021 11:14

Instead of being sanctimonious, try a bit of empathy
You've totally missed the meaning of my posts. I am not having a go at people who put on weight during lockdown. As you say, people crave comfort through food. Boredom will also increase appetite.

The issue I have is with those that don't acknowledge the above and try to make it that there had no alternatives to control their weight. They did, they opted not to, because they indeed needed food for comfort and to fight boredom.

It's ok to acknowledge this and indeed, the first step to making changes to start losing it now. The NHS advert is not condescending. It is highlighting the issue so that people affected do take initiatives to tackle their increase weight now that the lockdown is over.

LuaDipa · 12/08/2021 09:12

@kowari

They allowed the damage to happen in the first place. They allowed people to believe they could only leave the house for one hour of exercise a day, made people too frightened to sit on a bench (many people need access to a seat and some benches were literally roped off), and so on.
I would assume that was the government and local authorities. I very much doubt the NHS had anything to do with it. But they are having to deal with the fallout. And I very much doubt that most people complaining about this actually exercise outdoors for more than 1 hour per day at the best of times.
mum2jakie · 12/08/2021 09:03

@TheWayTheLightFalls

The damage was done when we were all locked up for months on end with nothing to do but eat and drink

I spent lockdown volunteering with the local mutual aid group and NHS responders. Without meaning to sound martyr-ish, I lost weight at first from the stress of the phone ringing off the hook with housebound people needing bread, milk and their prescriptions. When I wasn't doing that I was chasing my scooting toddler round the local park ad nauseum. I don't buy "nothing to do but eat and drink", tbh. Perhaps "stressed and the response was to eat more", but that's not the same thing.

Well done for volunteering but the reality, in my local area, was that all parks were locked up or cordoned off so your toddler was one of the lucky ones!
Ponoka7 · 12/08/2021 08:58

@vivainsomnia

"There was plenty of time to do family exercising. You were allowed to go out, there were plenty of free exercise videos on line."

Shock, horror but the NHS adverts are appealing to everyone. We don't all live in families. People who were in poor health anyway, people who live alone, people who might struggle to do an exercise video, suffered a lot during lock down.
You then start to get your 'good feeling' kick from fat/sugar combined. Plus in some areas takeaways were a reliable source of food and places like farmfoods never ran out of junk type food.
We know that part of the reason why poverty and obesity are linked is that as humans we need something to look forward to and our bodies crave what makes our brain feel good. Junk food does that.
Volunteer groups wouldn't take people who were vulnerable. Those people were cut off from family and their usual points of contacts in the health service.
Instead of being sanctimonious, try a bit of empathy.

Pissinthepottyplease · 12/08/2021 08:42

The government did a study of 5,000 people and Zoe covid app did a study of over a million people both on exercise, diet and weight during lockdown. The gov study found people put on weight, the Zoe app found the same number of people who put on weight lost weight but interestingly the people who lost weight were those who were most over weight/unhealthy to start with. I don’t think blaming the lockdown is correct.

vivainsomnia · 12/08/2021 08:36

People who are overweight are fully aware they need to do something about it
But many will put it at the back of their mind and try anything to no think about it. That's what they can annoyed at adverts like this, it brings back at the forefront, and they don't like it because it makes them feel guilty.

Losing weight is so incredibly hard. It is however a necessity for many, and no-one loses weight by just putting it out of the mind.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 12/08/2021 08:36

The damage was done when we were all locked up for months on end with nothing to do but eat and drink

I spent lockdown volunteering with the local mutual aid group and NHS responders. Without meaning to sound martyr-ish, I lost weight at first from the stress of the phone ringing off the hook with housebound people needing bread, milk and their prescriptions. When I wasn't doing that I was chasing my scooting toddler round the local park ad nauseum. I don't buy "nothing to do but eat and drink", tbh. Perhaps "stressed and the response was to eat more", but that's not the same thing.

vivainsomnia · 12/08/2021 08:34

Nothing more to do than eat and drink? I wonder how some people managed not to put any weight on....

There was plenty of time to do family exercising. You were allowed to go out, there were plenty of free exercise videos on line.

Another 'I let myself go but don't you dare say it was my fault' post.

Obesity is the biggest cost to the NHS, billions and billions. So yes, the NHS is right to be concerned and raise the issue. In any case, the lockdown is over, so no excuse not to try to do something about the extra weight.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 12/08/2021 08:33

People who are overweight are fully aware they need to do something about it

Some will be aware and know changes are needed. Many though have lost sight of what a healthy weight and size is, both for adults and children.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 12/08/2021 08:31

I think "lockdown pounds" for most of the population will be further to "general life pounds" - the UK stats on obesity and overweight are terrible, and the NHS - and therefore its service users - will bear the brunt.

I haven't seen the ad but this is one of those issues that comes down to whether or not you feel it's the remit of NHS to get people eating healthily and moving. I'm in camp "personal responsibility" (with very few exceptions), but that doesn't solve the problem of large numbers of people turning up at the NHS's door expecting support with diabetes, joint pain etc etc.

Ponoka7 · 12/08/2021 08:28

As someone who is obese I think that yabu. I put on weight when I was seriously ill. My consultants told me not to worry about it. I was housebound and exhausted and all I could do was enjoy food. I didn't know about the possibility of CF, on recovery. Now I'm stuck not going under 14 stone. I have pain from my joints. I've struggled in the heat. I've got clothes that I'm not comfortable in. But more importantly my risk of being hospitalised from Covid has increased. My risk of blood clots was higher from the vaccination. I was on the sheilding list but my consultant said that my weight is putting me at as much risk as my medical condition.

Dentistlakes · 12/08/2021 08:18

Obesity is a huge problem, but I don’t think an advert will do any good. People who are overweight are fully aware they need to do something about it. Only they can take responsibility and change their eating habits. I

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 12/08/2021 08:17

The damage was done when we were all locked up for months on end with nothing to do but eat and drink

There was plenty to do, not everyone ate or drank their way through it.

Obesity is a problem and costs the nhs in terms or care not to mention people’s health. It’s right to tackle it. Just as we have campaigns re the dangers of smoking and drinking.

amymel2016 · 12/08/2021 08:17

We are in the grip of an obesity crisis which costs the NHS millions of pounds a year. It’s something that is relatively easily fixed and we all have control over (I’m saying this as an obese person). The adverts are a bit condescending but I don’t think people realise quite how overweight we are.

GreenWhiteViolet · 12/08/2021 08:12

I haven't seen it but I imagine I'd find it immensely irritating and condescending too.

Anyone who gained lots of weight in lockdown is well aware of the fact. Everyone knows that being significantly overweight is bad for your health. The NHS is stretched thin enough without wasting money on stupid nagging adverts.

I'm in the process of losing my lockdown weight and the existence of this advert makes me want to go and eat a cake instead Wink

MoreAloneTime · 12/08/2021 08:10

This just makes me glad I don't have a lot of time to watch TV these days.

FuckMeGentlyWithAChainsaw · 12/08/2021 08:04

While obesity is a major problem in this country and lockdowns certainly won’t have helped, I’m not sure a tv advert pissing everyone off is the answer. Wouldn’t the money have been better spent elsewhere on the problem? But of course, the government do not care about that, only about lining the pockets of their friends and by extension their own.

LizzieMacQueen · 12/08/2021 08:01

I hear that profits are down at weight watchers.

Haven't seen that particular advert but if you live in Scotland you'll be used to the patronising messages coming from the TV.

Lockheart · 12/08/2021 08:00

@kowari

They allowed the damage to happen in the first place. They allowed people to believe they could only leave the house for one hour of exercise a day, made people too frightened to sit on a bench (many people need access to a seat and some benches were literally roped off), and so on.
The NHS was roping off benches?

You learn something new every day...

trunumber · 12/08/2021 07:58

The government did these things you speak of, not the NHS.

Obesity has a massive impact on health, and thus on an already struggling NHS.

YABU, it's only the same as the anti-smoking campaigns.

Swipe left for the next trending thread