Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GCSE hell. What can I say to get them to back off

317 replies

SVlover · 11/08/2021 22:33

I have a lovely daughter who just doesn’t do so well in exams. I have lovely friends who have A star exam performing daughters. And in-laws with daughters who are outstanding from an academic point of view. My friends. Tomorrow….They all want to celebrate!!! But I am sure results here won’t be wonderful. My daughter is distraught. 2 years ago she took an overdose. So good exam results, or lack of them, mean v little to me. My family are v academic. We feel sort of pressured by my side of the family and my friends about results. My daughter can probably repeat if things don’t go well. I’m ok about it. AIBU to tell everyone to back off.

OP posts:
Thedayohthedayohtheday · 12/08/2021 12:45

None of my children did well at GCSE. All have been very successful at work. I hate this obsession with how children have performed in exams. It hurts children who struggle, and judging by my brilliant cousin, who ended up a Gynaecology /Obstetrics consultant at age 28, it sometimes doesn't do much for personality/empathy either!!

NCBlossom · 12/08/2021 12:43

I have this too. Friends whose kids all do very well and my kid who can’t concentrate for more than a few seconds so school was a complete nightmare. My other child has learning difficulties too, serious ones and just doing an exam will be tricky (possibly never will).

I make a point of saying how proud I am of them to my friends for their achievements - kind of quite pointedly to give them a wake up call that some kids have enormous challenges and yet despite of that are amazing human beings (as my kids are)…
…it does the trick!

eyeoresancerre · 12/08/2021 12:41

That's fantastic news - off to FE. You must be incredibly proud of her. You sound a great mum too.xx

eeek88 · 12/08/2021 12:40

I tell my class not to share the results because it always leads to bad feeling of some kind. Either you feel bad because someone did better than you, or you make someone else feel bad by ramming your great results down their throat. And anyway it doesn’t matter!

They’re kids so they obviously ignore me in 99% of cases but it would be helpful if parents could back up this message instead of contributing to the overall pressure.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 12/08/2021 12:39

Good on her. Fantastic to get what's she's worked for.

I really don't understand parent sharing actual results, especially if they are very good. It just shows a total lack of empathy and consideration.

The only people we shared actual results with were grandparents and close family. For dd's leaving cert, I did also share with her friend's mother as our dc were away on holidays and the two of us were queuing up with the other kids to get the resultsGrin

Dd and ds1 didn't share their results particularly widely. It was pretty obvious they had done well in the leaving cert by the courses they did in uni but they had enough empathy with their classmates not to volunteer the information.

We're waiting for ds2's leaving cert results this year. He's unlikely to do as well as the other 2 but we'll still be going with the same strategy - he did very well. We're proud of him.

PhoboPhobia · 12/08/2021 12:35

Just joing to offer some solidarity. DS is currently very quiet as he got mainly 3s and will have to retake maths and english from September. But, he is not at all interested in 90% of the curriculum and didn't put in as much effort as he could have and struggled with motivation.

However, he showed up, he never got in trouble, his teachers have always said how lovely he is. One teacher told me should couldn't ever be cross with his lack of effort because he is such a nice lad and always makes her laugh! He is a great human being, a great brother, he has lovely friends and he will talk your ear off for hours on end about cars if he gets the chance. So, he's going to college to learn about cars, he has about 30 different car realted things he wants to do career wise and he is excited for his future.

My overwhelming feeling is just one of frustration with the education system and glad to be out of it as he's our youngest. I have huge admiration for schools and teachers but I think they often have an impossible task with some DCs who just aren't suited to this way of being educated.

I'm sorry your DD is feeling so low. It's a horrble feeling but you sound like a great Mum and she will be hugely grateful for that even if she's upset. I'm also sorry that people make you feel like you have to justify. People can get over excited when their kids do well and can be insenstive (if I'm being charitable). Focus on your DD and I hope she ends up doing something she loves.

Mogloveseggs · 12/08/2021 12:34

That's brilliant well done to your dd

mushroom3 · 12/08/2021 12:33

Well done you your daughter, you must be really proud of her that she got the grades she needs for college (and can emphasis that to those who ask! Star

fuxxake · 12/08/2021 12:31

Excellent stuff. Have a lovely day with your DD

purplemunkey · 12/08/2021 12:27

Congrats to your daughter. I'm glad she got what she needed to do what she wants to do next. That's all that matters - actual grades are no-one else's business.

ancientgran · 12/08/2021 12:27

@SVlover

THANKS so much to everyone who has been so supportive on this thread. Can’t reply individually to all. Here’s an update. After a very sleepless night I got dd up and we drove over to the school. She was in floods of tears and almost threw up. Eventually she got herself together and went in to get the dreaded brown envelope. She got on better than I expected! I’ve had a few texts from people who have listed their kid’s A stars but I have congratulated them and declined from offering the same level of detail. I understand parents are excited! I get that. I have since spoken to a careers advisor at my local fe college and she is confident that dd will get a place there to study! Grammar Schools aren’t for everyone. Again a big thanks to all you lovely mumsnetters for your support. BearFlowers
Glad she managed to get in there and get the results, glad they are better than you expected and so so pleased she can get onto a course at the local fe college.

I went to a grammar, didn't suit me and I left with nothing. Through day release and my local poly I ended up with good qualifications and a six figure salary when I retired a few years ago.

You are so right that grammar schools aren't for everyone. I hope she does well at college.

wewereliars · 12/08/2021 12:22

Well done to your girl OP, hope you both have a lovely day.

whenwillthemadnessend · 12/08/2021 12:19

Ahh well done to your dd. It's great she can go on to what she wants. Just focus on that if anyone pushes.

blahblahblah321 · 12/08/2021 12:18

@SVlover

THANKS so much to everyone who has been so supportive on this thread. Can’t reply individually to all. Here’s an update. After a very sleepless night I got dd up and we drove over to the school. She was in floods of tears and almost threw up. Eventually she got herself together and went in to get the dreaded brown envelope. She got on better than I expected! I’ve had a few texts from people who have listed their kid’s A stars but I have congratulated them and declined from offering the same level of detail. I understand parents are excited! I get that. I have since spoken to a careers advisor at my local fe college and she is confident that dd will get a place there to study! Grammar Schools aren’t for everyone. Again a big thanks to all you lovely mumsnetters for your support. BearFlowers
That's fantastic news! Well done to your girl
SVlover · 12/08/2021 12:14

THANKS so much to everyone who has been so supportive on this thread. Can’t reply individually to all. Here’s an update. After a very sleepless night I got dd up and we drove over to the school. She was in floods of tears and almost threw up. Eventually she got herself together and went in to get the dreaded brown envelope. She got on better than I expected! I’ve had a few texts from people who have listed their kid’s A stars but I have congratulated them and declined from offering the same level of detail. I understand parents are excited! I get that. I have since spoken to a careers advisor at my local fe college and she is confident that dd will get a place there to study! Grammar Schools aren’t for everyone. Again a big thanks to all you lovely mumsnetters for your support. BearFlowers

OP posts:
OchonAgusOchonOh · 12/08/2021 12:09

@Thehop

“I’m incredibly proud of her. Regardless of results.”

“ She’s decided not to share results, instead we’re celebrating her hard work and next steps. “

Second one of these is great but for the first one, I would leave out the "regardless of results" as it sounds like you think she didn't do well.

That said, I really can't understand people asking what someone got. I always ask in order to show interest but I ask "Was x happy with their results?". However, if I suspect they may not be happy I'll just say something like "Big day for x. Great to have got through it all" so it's not a question that needs an answer.

Anyone that asks directly is rude. Have a prior engagement for the celebrations and if they ask directly, just say something like "Yes, she did very well. We're extremely proud of her", rinse and repeat.

SVlover · 12/08/2021 12:05

Yes, Northern Ireland is a bit of a nightmare and so competitive. Look at the price of houses close to good schools. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Appreciate it.

OP posts:
SVlover · 12/08/2021 12:01

This is great advice!

OP posts:
Gilly12345 · 12/08/2021 11:58

People are very self absorbed about exam results and presume that everyone does well and want to celebrate.

Unfortunately some don’t get the top grades and celebrating is not that important even though we tell our children we are proud of them and there is a new chapter around the corner.

Tell them you have your own plans and thanks for thinking of us but we are celebrating on our own.

Xenia · 12/08/2021 11:56

No obligation to tell anyone. I was remembering today when my son got his results a good while back and we went up to the school and he was asked to leaev the school before sixth form as a result. In fact he had a remark in one paper which meant he DID by about Sept meet the requirements for the sixth form but they would not back down and he did A levels (CCC) elsewhere. With his third class university degree (which presumably is pretty hard to get so lowl.....) he was a happy post man and now is a very happy supermarket food delivery driver. They are just exams. They are a construct. They don't determine if you live a morally good and happy life and find personal contentment and balance.

Bythemillpond · 12/08/2021 11:54

I think having common sense and confidence is going to stand you more in good stead than any amount of GCSEs

Dd with these skills at 18 was manager of events with 300 + people and in charge 20+ staff members.some of whom had gone to university to one day get the job dd was doing
Her df was at an event she was managing and was having a hard time reconciling in his mind the stroppy teen who had got out of bed that morning to the slick manger who was directing staff to keep a few hundred people in drinks and canapés and then everyone being fed a meal that they weren’t allergic to.
After the first lockdown as both her business and the hospitality work was gone she hired herself out to work with groups of young teens who had SENs, adhd/dyslexia/ASD
She said the look on their face when she was asked which university she went to and she replied none. I didn’t get any A levels and only scraped a few GCSEs was priceless. She said she had heard the expression jaw dropping but never witnessed so many who’s mouth had fallen open in astonishment. She then told them that she too had ADHD and dyslexia. The person in charge said after that her admitting that she didn’t have a string of qualifications and had similar problems to them but could work and drive a nice car and make their way in life was so good for their confidence as they could see that for all their problems that they weren’t right offs destined for unemployment or minimum wage jobs.

Whatever your dd or anyone passes for their GCSEs seems like a huge deal at the time but it is the choices you make after which determines how you live your life.

Greystray · 12/08/2021 11:49

It sounds like you guys have plenty to celebrate regardless of what some letters on a piece of paper say.

pommedeterre · 12/08/2021 11:34

@toocold54

My mum got me a little present for my GCSE results. She gave it to me before I actually got the results, and I said 'why - you don't know how I've done?' and she told me the reward was for the effort and the work and the milestone - the actual grades were irrelevant to her. Good luck to your daughter today.

This is lovely and I’m going to steal this idea for my DC when they get to that age Grin

Me too! That means so much more than rewarding grades.
Goldensyrupissticky · 12/08/2021 11:21

It is nobody else’s business, only people who need to know are those at school and future employers. Your daughter sounds like she got top marks when it came to mothers. Everyone is right, it doesn’t matter what others get.

I have two children, both work very hard however one has Aspergers and is very dyslexic and the other doesn’t. My child with additional needs is struggling, is very downhearted and it is tough to watch. My friends with children the same age are all absolute academic whizzes, basically A grades expected for A levels. It sucks, last year I just hid from social media until the parade of A grades for GCSEs finished. Silly, I know but I know they want to share their pride but their journey isn’t mine or my child’s.

wewereliars · 12/08/2021 11:13

Fainasnowchild very well done to your boy. He's a credit to you.

GCSE's and A levels are such a blunt instrument, and ignore the fact that each child is running a different race.

Swipe left for the next trending thread