Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To build a fence and chop their hedge.

190 replies

Sportynotspice · 11/08/2021 21:42

There's a laurel hedge between our garden and next doors and it's only 5 foot at its highest; the garden slopes towards the back so there are sections even shorter and we can see straight into next doors garden and theirs ours. We have asked them politely to allow us to grow the hedge up as we'd like more privacy but they have refused and continued to cut the hedge ever shorter. They have extra long hedge trimmers and cut our half as well because apparently the previous owners never kept it neat enough for their liking and never protested when they started taking over the trimming. We've been polite but very clear that we don't like the height and would like it to grow up an extra foot but they have once again cut it too short and cut our side. The hedge actually sits much more into our boundary than theirs so DH, who has reached his final straw after coming home to yet another few inches off the hedge tonight, has declared he's ordering fence panels this weekend, chopping the hedge back right to the boundary and putting up the fence. The hedge will look utterly rubbish on their side because of how little actually encroaches their side of the boundary so I said to DH maybe we should just build the fence from when the hedge finishes now but DH, rightly, points out that means we lose a foot of our garden because the hedge takes up so much space as it is. As we have tried to be reasonable with them, DH doesn't care about upsetting them by chopping back so much of the hedge.
We have only lived here 9 months and they have been here 20 years plus and their argument for not letting the hedge grow is this is how its always been and no one that's lived here before has ever had an issue with it. But this is our home now and I really don't think it's unreasonable to have a proper barrier between our garden and next doors!
I will go speak to them tomorrow to advise that this is what we are going to do but we're not asking permission, just informing as a courtesy. Are we being unreasonable? I don't think they've really left us much more choice.

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 12/08/2021 13:56

How did the talk go op ?

godmum56 · 12/08/2021 13:40

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

I'm not sure hedges do much good for wildlife if people are chopping them back several times per year and especially during the bird nesting season.

We had to cut ours back several times a year as it was next to the front path and we wouldn't have been able to get to the front door if we hadn't!

yup...different wildlife friendly actions work in different places.
godmum56 · 12/08/2021 13:39

@DistrustfulDinosaur

For hedges to be of use to wildlife they shouldn't be cut at all during the nesting season....to provide winter shelter, they also shouldn't be cut until spring....tiny windows of opportunity that are getting smaller year by year. I understand why but I don't think it encourages gardeners to plant for nature Very true. I never allow neighbour to pressure me into cutting my side of the hedge before the birds are fully fledged. She also moans about dandelions every spring. I try to compromise and make a point of nipping off as many flowers once they start to turn into 'clocks' but I'm not going to dig up the plants just because she thinks they look messy.

oops forgot the link www.ashridgetrees.co.uk/blog/why-willows-and-drains-do-not-mix. I have had personal experience of this with an acacia....lovely tree but not near houses or drains It's been a while since I've researched fedges, but my understanding is there are varieties that aren't as invasive as a fully grown willow tree, providing you keep on top of maintenance. A bit like bamboo, certain ones will spread like wildfire others won't. I'm sure companies who sell the kits would be able to advise on whether they would be suitable in this case.

I do think something less solid than a fence would work better in the situation OP describes, perhaps hazel hurdling or trellis if something living would be unsuitable/more work than they want to take on. Also in terms of maintenance, planting a potentially unwanted (by the neighbour) fence very close to a hedge could prove problematic down the line. Presumably the hedge would still need cutting so it doesn't start to grow into the fence and push it over? I totally get the need for privacy and how frustrating it is when your neighbour encroaches on 'your side' of the boundary. Neighbours should really just let OP grow their side of the hedge how they want it and do as they wish with their own half.

"providing you keep on top of maintenance."

which negates the wildlife aspect...maintenance needs to be minimal in order not to discourage wildlife....also chopping down the top won't control the roots...see video

"I do think something less solid than a fence would work better in the situation OP describes, perhaps hazel hurdling or trellis if something living would be unsuitable/more work than they want to take on"

why?

"Presumably the hedge would still need cutting so it doesn't start to grow into the fence and push it over? "

nope. with the roots removed to erect the fence and the light at the fence side taken away by the fence, it will only grow outwards away from the fence

" Neighbours should really just let OP grow their side of the hedge how they want it and do as they wish with their own half."

indeed but they won't...thats the problem

Erwhatno · 12/08/2021 13:23

Good luck op!

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 12/08/2021 13:06

I'm not sure hedges do much good for wildlife if people are chopping them back several times per year and especially during the bird nesting season.

We had to cut ours back several times a year as it was next to the front path and we wouldn't have been able to get to the front door if we hadn't!

DistrustfulDinosaur · 12/08/2021 13:02

For hedges to be of use to wildlife they shouldn't be cut at all during the nesting season....to provide winter shelter, they also shouldn't be cut until spring....tiny windows of opportunity that are getting smaller year by year. I understand why but I don't think it encourages gardeners to plant for nature Very true. I never allow neighbour to pressure me into cutting my side of the hedge before the birds are fully fledged. She also moans about dandelions every spring. I try to compromise and make a point of nipping off as many flowers once they start to turn into 'clocks' but I'm not going to dig up the plants just because she thinks they look messy.

oops forgot the link www.ashridgetrees.co.uk/blog/why-willows-and-drains-do-not-mix. I have had personal experience of this with an acacia....lovely tree but not near houses or drains It's been a while since I've researched fedges, but my understanding is there are varieties that aren't as invasive as a fully grown willow tree, providing you keep on top of maintenance. A bit like bamboo, certain ones will spread like wildfire others won't. I'm sure companies who sell the kits would be able to advise on whether they would be suitable in this case.

I do think something less solid than a fence would work better in the situation OP describes, perhaps hazel hurdling or trellis if something living would be unsuitable/more work than they want to take on. Also in terms of maintenance, planting a potentially unwanted (by the neighbour) fence very close to a hedge could prove problematic down the line. Presumably the hedge would still need cutting so it doesn't start to grow into the fence and push it over? I totally get the need for privacy and how frustrating it is when your neighbour encroaches on 'your side' of the boundary. Neighbours should really just let OP grow their side of the hedge how they want it and do as they wish with their own half.

godmum56 · 12/08/2021 12:42

@seasonalremarks

If it is a boundary hedge it is illegal to remove it.
no it isn't
idontunderstandbananas · 12/08/2021 12:42

PeachesPumpkin Wed 11-Aug-21 22:48:47 I would leave the hedge. Just because hedges are so much nicer to look at than fences, support more wildlife, allow access for things like hedgehogs too

I'm not sure hedges do much good for wildlife if people are chopping them back several times per year and especially during the bird nesting season. I have a similar issue with my neighbour who has lived here longer than me and insists nothing can change on my property because 'it's always been that way'. People need to rethink this idea that 'the garden must be perfectly tidy and perfectly trimmed' while also saying 'we must be wildlife friendly'. There is nothing wrong with the OP trimming back the hedge (not getting rid just trimming back), installing the fence for privacy and then planting wildlife friendly plants on her side.

I don't think you are being unreasonable OP. You have tried talking with the neighbour they aren't listening so install the fence.

Parky04 · 12/08/2021 12:33

@Woodmarsh

If the hedge is 5ft and the maximum you're allowed to have it is 6.5ft it seems a lot of work for a small gain?
I can see over a 5ft hedge but I can't see over a 6.5ft fence so a massive gain I would say!!
Yahtze · 12/08/2021 12:23

Please consider a hedgehog hole in your fence. A fence will block their access to valuable habitat.

www.wildlifetrusts.org/actions/how-create-hedgehog-hole

godmum56 · 12/08/2021 11:01

oops forgot the link www.ashridgetrees.co.uk/blog/why-willows-and-drains-do-not-mix

I have had personal experience of this with an acacia....lovely tree but not near houses or drains

godmum56 · 12/08/2021 11:00

@DistrustfulDinosaur

If it's a bit of extra privacy during summer that you're wanting, I would cut your side of the hedge back a bit and put in a fedge. Something like this www.yorkshirewillow.co.uk/willow-screening. It would look nicer than a fence and not take up too much ground space. Cost seems reasonable when compared to a fence and potentially an easier DIY job than a fence.

I sympathise though, our neigbour is the same with our boundary hedge. When we first moved in, she told us how upset she was that the lady who here before us suddenly chopped the fence from 8ft to 4ft, as she her lost privacy. We told her that we're happy to let it grow talller again, but she insists on chopping back our side every time she cuts the hedge (which is at least once a week from March to October)! We've even been told off on occassion if we don't cut our side as often as she'd like us to as she likes the edges to look perfectly square. I personally think once a month during the summer is quite enough for a box hedge, plus we both work fulltime!

be really really careful with willow near a house or near drains. They are a water seeking species and the roots will grow long distances in search of water. If your drains have even a small crack or access route, the roots will find it and grow into the drain. For hedges to be of use to wildlife they shouldn't be cut at all during the nesting season....to provide winter shelter, they also shouldn't be cut until spring....tiny windows of opportunity that are getting smaller year by year. I understand why but I don't think it encourages gardeners to plant for nature :(
ScribblingPixie · 12/08/2021 10:59

Our neighbours at the bottom put up a really high fence & it's been a blessing as we don't have to see them at all now plus we can grow attractive climbers up it. Your neighbours sound like they're such good gardeners they'll be able to adapt to what you plan to do & it doesn't sound as if you're going to be on good terms anyway.

seasonalremarks · 12/08/2021 10:56

*theirs

seasonalremarks · 12/08/2021 10:55

It is also difficult to be exact with boundaries if for example a neighbour has taken a couple of inches of boundary over a number of years it then may become theres. The deeds are not exact. Old fence posts or irons are the only clues sometimes.

If a hedge has been planted on a boundary and it would be hard to prove one way or another you cannnot just dig it up for ecological reasons as much as anything else.

seasonalremarks · 12/08/2021 10:50

If it is a boundary hedge it is illegal to remove it.

godmum56 · 12/08/2021 10:46

@JennieLee

I too am not sure about the absolute need for privacy - which can be enjoyed in your house anyway.

Gardens with high fences - unless a garden is exceptionally large - always remind me of prison yards,. Huge lengths of shade are created by high fences and when I go out doors I like to be able to access light. There are lowish hedges between our house and the neighbours on either side. We tend to greet each other when going out - and will sometimes have enjoyable conversations at the gaps between the hedge - or even cross the boundary. But of course a lot of the time we'll just enjoy sitting there separately talking to family and friends, without feeling the need to wall ourselves off from one another. (Obviously if you own a dog there may be a need for secure fencing.)

your life your garden your choice, certainly not mine....and saying if you want privacy stay in the house is just cuckoo.....I bet you are one of those neighbours who want to chat regardless of what others want.
DistrustfulDinosaur · 12/08/2021 10:46

If it's a bit of extra privacy during summer that you're wanting, I would cut your side of the hedge back a bit and put in a fedge. Something like this www.yorkshirewillow.co.uk/willow-screening. It would look nicer than a fence and not take up too much ground space. Cost seems reasonable when compared to a fence and potentially an easier DIY job than a fence.

I sympathise though, our neigbour is the same with our boundary hedge. When we first moved in, she told us how upset she was that the lady who here before us suddenly chopped the fence from 8ft to 4ft, as she her lost privacy. We told her that we're happy to let it grow talller again, but she insists on chopping back our side every time she cuts the hedge (which is at least once a week from March to October)! We've even been told off on occassion if we don't cut our side as often as she'd like us to as she likes the edges to look perfectly square. I personally think once a month during the summer is quite enough for a box hedge, plus we both work fulltime!

godmum56 · 12/08/2021 10:43

Not a legal beagle butI know the story on this because have been there and have the T shirt. Your deeds may show an accurate boundary but may not. It may show definitively who owns the fence but is unlikely to show ownership of a hedge. Where the roots are does not show ownership.
Householders are entitled to cut branches and roots back to their boundary line unless the tree/hedge has got a preservation order on it but must offer branches back to the hedge owner if they know who it is. If removing roots to put in a fence kills the hedge ot tree then that is unfortunate but not illegal, again unless there is a preservation order in place.
Laurel is indeed poisonous and not the best hedging choice for wildlife. Indigenous trees and shrubs are better and a mixture is best of all.

I am on the side of team fence. Its going to be nigh on impossible to stop the neighbours trimming any hedge and its just going to get nastier. Putting up a fence changes the dynamic and will stop the arguments over trimming...I don't think anything will stop the disagreement and bad feeling regardless. Sad but true in my experience.
Some wildlife provision is impossible for some circumstances...no hedge doesn't mean scorched earth. Carefully chosen shrubs may actually be more wildlife friendly than a laurel hedge, especially if it is continually kept short as nesting birds will not stay where there is continual activity and laurel does not support native insect life.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/08/2021 10:43

Check deeds to ensure you are 100% clear on boundary line. It will be a big job - roots, soil level etc all need dealing with before you can fence. Check planning regs for how high you can go.
It might be worth getting some quotes from companies to see extent of work. A company doing work rather than diy also provides a buffer between you and neighbours.
I’d tell them you are fencing your boundary. You don’t need to go into detail if a fence is your preference that’s up to you.

Porcupineintherough · 12/08/2021 10:41

Most small birds dont like to use "the whole sky" @tanstaafl because that's where the predators are. That's why they dart in and out of cover.

That said, a 5' laurel hedge is hardly an amazing wildlife habitat and there's nothing to stop the neighbours allowing it to increase its width on their side. I actually get why they dont want it taller. That puts more work onto them. Maybetheyll be perfectly happy for the OP and her dh to pay for the privacy they desire.

timeisnotaline · 12/08/2021 10:33

@JennieLee

I too am not sure about the absolute need for privacy - which can be enjoyed in your house anyway.

Gardens with high fences - unless a garden is exceptionally large - always remind me of prison yards,. Huge lengths of shade are created by high fences and when I go out doors I like to be able to access light. There are lowish hedges between our house and the neighbours on either side. We tend to greet each other when going out - and will sometimes have enjoyable conversations at the gaps between the hedge - or even cross the boundary. But of course a lot of the time we'll just enjoy sitting there separately talking to family and friends, without feeling the need to wall ourselves off from one another. (Obviously if you own a dog there may be a need for secure fencing.)

Well, gardens with high fences feel like secluded green oasis’ to me, for pure relaxation and contentment. Maybe the op feels like me.

Imagine saying to someone with a garden if you want to feel alone you should stay in the house!

NinaBallerinaShoes · 12/08/2021 10:32

Check the boundaries. Cut the hedge. Put your fence up. Don’t tell the neighbours what your intentions are. They do not inform you or show you any consideration when cutting both sides of the hedge.

Warmduscher · 12/08/2021 10:31

@TatianaBis

I absolutely do not want to see my massive twat of a neighbour in the garden or anywhere.

The neighbours on the other side are lovely though.

Grin Grin Grin
tanstaafl · 12/08/2021 10:30

@CherryMaple

The hedge is like a wildlife corridor helping birds get from one garden to the next. They fly in at the back of the hedge, and then out at the front.

I mean they realise they have they whole of the sky to do that as well ?