Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That it's not fair!?

267 replies

StompingMyFeet · 11/08/2021 20:27

I've NC for this because I'm aware I'll sound like a Daily Mail article in my rant. I'm just so (irrationally) hurt and upset right now.

We own a 1 bed flat. We do ok, but there's basically no way we'll ever be anywhere bigger even though we both work.We have a DD already , but for the past 3 years I've desperately wanted another baby. There's no room, money would be tricky, childcare , going back to work , OH is getting quite old etc. Plus the impact on DD by having less .. attention,time,space etc. So I know it's a know, I try to make my peace with it and forget about it. Sometimes it just fucking hurts though, so much so that it becomes physical.

Today I saw one of our old neighbours who got moved last year (council) into a two bed. She had DS with her and a baby. While we were chatting she casually said "oh this is what happens when you get a two bedroom" and laughed. I kinda hated her a little bit then, smiled ,fussed over the baby again , said my goodbyes and walked away in tears.

This is the DM part, they don't work , mid twenties , barely good enough parents . It just feels so fucking unfair that I have to consider all the risks and cons and disadvantages because there is no safety net, and tell myself no. I don't begrudge them benefits,or the flat or whatever.. I know they need it and in a way we're a million times more fortunate. But fucking hell, I do begrudge them that baby.

I'll get over it, but today I just want to cry and stamp my feet and rant and shout It's not fair!

OP posts:
Anon778833 · 13/08/2021 04:17

Oh I see the thread has moved on to bashing the disabled. What lovely people you all are(!)

If you think PIP or DLA is easy to get you're very much mistaken. Most genuine claimants have to go to appeal to get their award. And at that point a doctor and a lawyer decides if they are entitled to it.

Still think you know better? Wind your bigoted necks in Angry

Saoirse82 · 13/08/2021 02:16

YANBU to be upset about your situation however YABU thinking that being on benefits is some easy lifestyle with money handed to you, the reality is massively different.
My MIL is on benefits and because she's registered disabled and partially sighted I have to deal with a lot of her finances and it's a fucking nightmare, if you don't have family to help you out at times you'll find yourself without food, heat or out on your arse and living on the streets as the sanctions and cuts are ridiculous. For instance she's just moved house and because her new landlord didn't fill something in on time all her benefits have been stopped, if in those situations someone doesn't have family to help then you're left with nothing. Nobody would choose that life if they had options. To get a proper insight on what living on benefits is like I recommend the film 'I am Daniel Blake'. It's a very accurate portrayal.

lemmein · 13/08/2021 01:14

[quote Ideasplease322]And I said I was out, but if I am stung by the accusations. Changes like this help, and won’t impact genuine claimants.

www.autoexpress.co.uk/car-news/35165/25k-cap-motability[/quote]
That article is 10 years old!

The tories have really played a blinder getting everyone to kick down haven't they?

My friends young daughter had her disability benefits removed for over a year. The kid has had op after op over the last 4 years; needs a morphine patch for the constant pain, needs assistance through the night, help with showering, etc. She also uses a wheelchair if they go anywhere for the day.

She originally got the higher rate for mobility/care but then they were removed after an annual review even though her condition hasn't changed. Completely removed, not reduced! She's not disabled enough apparently - well, she wasn't until the court stepped in and rightly reinstated it at the higher rates. Yeah, it's a piece of piss claiming benefits in this country Hmm

People talk absolute shite on here.

Scornedwoman67 · 13/08/2021 01:11

@HelenHywater

Of course YABU OP, and I expect you know that. People on benefits live a miserable life. Your friend will have to find work when her child is 3. Benefits levels are so low, and there is the 2 child limit and the benefit cap. It's shit.

But it's also shit that in this country wages are so low and housing costs are so high, as are childcare costs. That even if you work full time you can't afford more than one child, or more than one bedroom. But that isn't the fault of benefits claimants. They aren't taking what is due to you. Direct your anger elsewhere.

Utter nonsense. I have a relative who has lived on benefits for 25 years, fathered eight children & has never attempted a days work. He's quite happy.
DeflatedGinDrinker · 13/08/2021 00:56

Yanbu. Council house next to me is a 2 bed and my neighbour and her 4 kids have just been moved to a 3 bed house. She only had 1 child when she moved in.

Ideasplease322 · 13/08/2021 00:14

And I said I was out, but if I am stung by the accusations. Changes like this help, and won’t impact genuine claimants.

www.autoexpress.co.uk/car-news/35165/25k-cap-motability

sst1234 · 13/08/2021 00:02

@Clocktopus

Fraud and claimant error accounts for less than 2% of the overall welfare spend. There is more money goes unclaimed by people who don't realise they're entitled or who don't want to claim than there is paid fraudulently. It is nowhere near as widespread as you'd think.
2% is the fraud that is proven and known about. Most fraud goes undetected. If everyone was honest, nearly everyone knows or has known someone who is abusing the system. The examples we see and hear about are not imaginary. It makes it worse for genuine claimants. But the general electorate didn’t just become hardened to the welfare system by accident, people see what goes on around them and it grates.
bp300 · 13/08/2021 00:00

Vehicles being new does not mean they are more reliable. Emissions regulations mean that new vehicles are vastly more complex and more likely to go wrong. A 10 year old Toyota is far more reliable than most new cars.

Ideasplease322 · 12/08/2021 23:56

I am going to bow out of this row.

No ones mine will be changed and it is a hugely emotive subject.

I would again reiterate I wasn’t making a blanket statement that everyone who get a disability car doesn’t deserve it. Far from it, the majority do.

In my personal experience, some are able to access the cars when they don’t genuinely need it. However I meant no offence to those genuine cases who we as a society should be charitable to.

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 12/08/2021 23:55

The motability scheme is Brighthouse Cars for the Disabled.

They pay every penny of their mobility component for most cars, often at significantly higher prices than a standard lease for a lower spec. They have to pay extra for particular types. And then they have to still pay for fuel out of their income (which could be wages as disabled people do have jobs) or from their care component. The company makes a fortune out of the scheme and manufacturers are happy because it can be a significant driver of car sales during times of recession.

It's not and has never been a free car.

Clocktopus · 12/08/2021 23:52

But the benefits are providing free money which is covering the cost of running a brand new car so essentially the claimant getting a brand new car for free. The benefits system is far too generous if they are providing this. If a vehicle is required for mobility purposes a basic used car would be sufficient.

Jesus fucking Christ.

Disability benefits are not "free money". You don't just rock up at the DWP and say "I have a hurting foot, gimme". Disability payments are for people who are disabled, they are to assist with the increased cost of living - and often reduced income - associated with being disabled. It is not a brand new car for free. The disabled person pays for it. The system is not far too generous and disability benefits are much lower than you'd think, do you know Carers Allowance equates to less than £2 an hour for 35hrs a week of care? Yeah. Totally fucking generous. A basic, used vehicle would not meet the requirements of the motability scheme, would not have the reliability needed, and is also unlikely to have required adaptations such as a lift or wheelchair access.

x2boys · 12/08/2021 23:50

You really think PIP/DLA is far too generous @bp300? the reason the mobility system provides brand new cars is because they need to be reliable, some people do get top of the range cars, but they will have paid a hefty deposit, and might be paying extra monthly in addition to the PIP /DLA payment, and im well aware working people are often driving around in cars that are 10-15 years old, my dh was untill we got the mobility car, the problem old cars is lots tend to go wrong with them

Ideasplease322 · 12/08/2021 23:43

[quote Clocktopus]@Ideasplease322 people with mobility cars are playing the system? Seriously!? In order to qualify for a mobility car you need to in receipt of the higher mobility rate of disability benefits, to get these benefits you need to have provided evidence to the DWP that you are both disabled and have high level mobility problems. No one gets a mobility car by playing the system.[/quote]
I am sorry I have clearly offended you.

But in my experience mobility cars are abused.

I live in an area where there has been scandals about them being used as taxis etc. It is a local joke, certain types are cars are notorious,

Unfortunately they are abused. This does not in any way mean that they are not needed. My goodness they are. They are an incredible resource which have been a valuable lifeline to thousands of people In our society.

But we must be realistic, some people (hopefully a minority) take advantage.

bp300 · 12/08/2021 23:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Clocktopus · 12/08/2021 23:36

Fraud and claimant error accounts for less than 2% of the overall welfare spend. There is more money goes unclaimed by people who don't realise they're entitled or who don't want to claim than there is paid fraudulently. It is nowhere near as widespread as you'd think.

Clocktopus · 12/08/2021 23:34

The motability scheme provides you with a brand new car where as many people who work are driving around in 10-15 year old cars and are worried they will be priced off the roads when electric cars become complulsary.

It's not a free car, you pay for it using the mobility component of your qualifying benefit (e.g., PIP or DLA) and you must be on the high rate which denotes significant mobility issues.

Anyone is receipt of high rate mobility for PIP or DLA has gone through the application process, has provided medical evidence to support their application, and in the case of PIP will have also attended an assessment with a claims processor. You don't qualify for "having a (made up) bad back".

Ideasplease322 · 12/08/2021 23:33

And I am not at all disabilist. I am angry that some people take advantage of the system designed to help people of need and deserve extra help.

I do worry that we are in a society that we can’t question anything without being accused of being in some way bigoted.

Again, I would, stress that many people need and serve help. I am happy to contribute to that. I do think the system needs to be improved to ensure we target that help towards those who need it most. There will always be an element of fraud attached to benefits, and I appreciate it can be difficult to manage this without impacting the genuine cases.

No easy answers,

bp300 · 12/08/2021 23:30

@Ideasplease322

I am sorry, my post was clumsily worded.

I did not meant hat everyone who has a mobility car does not deserve it - far from it.

I simply meant there are some who work the system. I grew up in an area where nearly every family had a mobility car - and they still do. These are for things like bad backs etc. I absolutely understand that many are deserving, but it’s hard to see when so many milk the system.

When you live in these types of areas, and I have family who still do, it’s hard to see.

I have a relative in his late fifties ago have never worked. Had five children and a nice enough council house. Always had a fairly new mobility car.

May parents both worked, owned their own house and really struggled to give us an amazing childhood, my dad works two jobs and could never have afforded the car this man was handed.

I absolutely know many are deserving of the cars, but some aren’t.

That is the reality of the situation.

I don't think there was anything wrong with what you said.
bp300 · 12/08/2021 23:28

@x2boys Nobody is accusing you of playing the system. I have no doubt you are a genuine claimant but a believe the system is far too generous. The motability scheme provides you with a brand new car where as many people who work are driving around in 10-15 year old cars and are worried they will be priced off the roads when electric cars become complulsary.

Ideasplease322 · 12/08/2021 23:27

I am sorry, my post was clumsily worded.

I did not meant hat everyone who has a mobility car does not deserve it - far from it.

I simply meant there are some who work the system. I grew up in an area where nearly every family had a mobility car - and they still do. These are for things like bad backs etc. I absolutely understand that many are deserving, but it’s hard to see when so many milk the system.

When you live in these types of areas, and I have family who still do, it’s hard to see.

I have a relative in his late fifties ago have never worked. Had five children and a nice enough council house. Always had a fairly new mobility car.

May parents both worked, owned their own house and really struggled to give us an amazing childhood, my dad works two jobs and could never have afforded the car this man was handed.

I absolutely know many are deserving of the cars, but some aren’t.

That is the reality of the situation.

Clocktopus · 12/08/2021 23:14

I reported that comment yesterday and I can't believe @MNHQ allowed it to stand when it has a blatantly disablist comment.

x2boys · 12/08/2021 23:02

@Ideasplease322

I can absolutely see why there is resentment.

Society does need to have a safety net to ensure people have a roof over their heads and food on the table.

However, that safety net isnt always set at he right height. We have all seen the people who work the system, who seem to be able to access a good income, housing and mobility car all through benefits. And yet others who really struggle on benefits, with children still living in poverty.

I wouldn’t want to live in a society we’re children go without the basic necessities, in fact as I type that I realise I do live in a society where that happens. And yet some adults can live reasonably comfortably never working.

The system isn’t really working, and it is desperately unfair on those who are being failed.

We have a mobility car, as my son gets high rate mobility under SMI rules, hes non verbal severely autistic, will never live independently i can assure you we are not playing the system 🙄
Anon778833 · 12/08/2021 22:45

It really pisses me off when people still think it's great to be on benefits. Because it isn't. And you should be ashamed of yourselves if you think people deserve to suffer just because they fell on hard times Hmm

There but for the grace of god go you. And I'm not sure this thread is genuine tbh

Generalpost · 12/08/2021 22:30

The person you know or anyone else in a simlar position are stopping you from having another baby. I don't know what your bring home income is . But for all anyone knows you could be spending on lots of luxurious or expensive things. It could be your money is getting lost in the wrong places. I have no idea if that's right or not. If you was to cut back a bit maybe you could afford another baby. If you suddenly had a baby tomorrow would you find away ?

You don't get council places because your on benefits. People that work have them as well. Maybe you could give up work and go on the benefit system probably won't be able to afford the mortgage. So then you could go through the eviction route end up homless in some hostel and wait for a council place like people on benefit often have to do. ( I know you can't really do that) but being on benefits is really not as great as you think .

Kendodd · 12/08/2021 21:07

You really haven’t travelled the world much.

Ooh, is this were we start comparing ourselves to Egypt, or India or Sudan and taking about how lucky we are?
Why not compare ourselves to our neighbours instead? See how we're doing compared to Germany or Sweden or Belgium?

Swipe left for the next trending thread