Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That it's not fair!?

267 replies

StompingMyFeet · 11/08/2021 20:27

I've NC for this because I'm aware I'll sound like a Daily Mail article in my rant. I'm just so (irrationally) hurt and upset right now.

We own a 1 bed flat. We do ok, but there's basically no way we'll ever be anywhere bigger even though we both work.We have a DD already , but for the past 3 years I've desperately wanted another baby. There's no room, money would be tricky, childcare , going back to work , OH is getting quite old etc. Plus the impact on DD by having less .. attention,time,space etc. So I know it's a know, I try to make my peace with it and forget about it. Sometimes it just fucking hurts though, so much so that it becomes physical.

Today I saw one of our old neighbours who got moved last year (council) into a two bed. She had DS with her and a baby. While we were chatting she casually said "oh this is what happens when you get a two bedroom" and laughed. I kinda hated her a little bit then, smiled ,fussed over the baby again , said my goodbyes and walked away in tears.

This is the DM part, they don't work , mid twenties , barely good enough parents . It just feels so fucking unfair that I have to consider all the risks and cons and disadvantages because there is no safety net, and tell myself no. I don't begrudge them benefits,or the flat or whatever.. I know they need it and in a way we're a million times more fortunate. But fucking hell, I do begrudge them that baby.

I'll get over it, but today I just want to cry and stamp my feet and rant and shout It's not fair!

OP posts:
minatrina · 13/08/2021 12:08

@vivainsomnia

Data on benefit fraud is irrelevant because it only records fraud that has been identified and confirmed, not the fraud that takes place unindentified.

My friend used to work for the DWP. She said that it was well known that there was quite a bit of fraud taking place, they did receive so much reports, but they just didn't have the resources to investigate it, so they prioritised the cases where they knew it would take little work to evidence, and where there where the fraud was higher value to justify the investment.

That's why data shows that the highest fraud is housing benefit. It's much easier to evidence and the highest value.

She said that the highest estimate fraud is with CA, with people not providing anywhere 35h of care above what would be expected. This however is not worth the investment to investigate. Low value and almost impossible to evidence.

No, that's not the only data or research we have on this topic, despite what your mate down the DWP might tell you.

Academic research on this topic is a mere Google away!

minatrina · 13/08/2021 12:05

@worriedatthemoment no, not all of the research is just based on who is 'caught'. Again, you're just spouting stuff based on your own personal experience. I don't understand why people can't grasp the well-established limitations of anecdotal "data".

worriedatthemoment · 13/08/2021 11:53

@minatrina research is only what is uncovered over the years I have known lots of people claim benefits not entitled, none have been caught, I also know some who especially years back knew how to play the system, same family in same circumstances and one would know how to claim more than the other, I know of people now claiming for things they shouldn't , none have got caught so won't be in the research, but when you live surrounded by people then you know it happens and its frustrating as I also know those on benefits doing it right who really struggle, or those on low incomes barely getting by.
The op is not wrong for feeling upset that she cannot have another child despite working , yet a neighbour who can work doesn't and has been moved to a larger property and have a second child, she wasn't nasty to the person , just upset with the situation
There are lots on genuine people on benefits but also a small few who abuse the system which then means less for those that need it.
Its not living in the real world if you think this does not exist it then makes it a stigma for the genuine ones, no one should be better off on benefits than working if they can and thats where the system is sometimes wrong
Same as large familes being paid for 11 children or so is a choice, near me is. 6 bed council house you have to have minimum of about 9 children to get it , how many people working can afford that , very very few. That house would make a great house for a foster carer or someone like that

Generalpost · 13/08/2021 11:45

@StompingMyFeet

It's fine to be jealous or envy people. We all do it. It's just how we manage it. For me it would be a split second thought. Because I'm me, I'm not that person our lives are different.

I'm sure you know how theses threads turn out . Even people claiming mobility or disability. A disability or illness that they have no control over something they have to live with for all their live weather It's them or their child. And as usual they are getting a hard time . Because of thresds like this. Them people must feel awful reading threads like this

lannistunut · 13/08/2021 11:09

[quote toconclude]@lannistunut
You need to study a bit more history if you imagine the post war era was full of generosity and goodwill towards the disadvantaged just because of the legislation that was passed.[/quote]
Yes, I know it wasn't all peace and harmony but I just despair of how many nasty bastards there are about today.

toconclude · 13/08/2021 11:02

@lannistunut
You need to study a bit more history if you imagine the post war era was full of generosity and goodwill towards the disadvantaged just because of the legislation that was passed.

Clocktopus · 13/08/2021 10:11

The carers unit also do their own checks on your income, etc even you make your claim to them and if you are qorking/studying you have to send additional evidence (e.g., course details showing the hours of study, pay slips, etc).

Clocktopus · 13/08/2021 10:10

Much more money is lost due to tax evasion - perhaps we should be focusing our anger at the other end of the spectrum?

But we were all told by the higher-ups that this evasion was fine because the wealth will trickle down. Who could have predicted that instead of trickling down, those fuckers would use that wealth to buy space rockets instead...?

She said that the highest estimate fraud is with CA, with people not providing anywhere 35h of care above what would be expected. This however is not worth the investment to investigate. Low value and almost impossible to evidence.

The evidence for Carers Allowance is done as part of the DLA/PIP application as it is based on the care needs of the person you are caring for and these are assessed as part of that.

Kendodd · 13/08/2021 10:03

You're being extremely unreasonable tbh. You're clearly not happy with the decision not to have another child. That's not their fault and your resentment is quite nasty.

I don't think the OP is being unreasonable.
I don't think she's been nasty about this other couple either. She's jealous because her neighbour has another child and she dearly wants another herself be feels circumstances don't allow.

I don't think the OP is being unreasonable because two working people being able to afford a two bed home and two children in 21st century Britain is about as far from an unreasonable expectation as I think you can get imo. She's not stamping her foot because she can't have a Ferrari and a trip to the Maldives.

Hugs OP, its shit.

Kendodd · 13/08/2021 09:50

The tories have really played a blinder getting everyone to kick down haven't they?

Yep!

I don't fully understand what has happened to make people so bitter and ignorant, but the views about benefit claimants and benefit fraud people hold are not supported by any research done.

Well researched by Channel 5 shows like 'Benefits Street' and Fat Immigrants on Benefits though.
I wonder why they don't make programmes about super rich tax dodgers on their yachts will their employees are so poor they visit food banks to feed their children? Oh, and claim top up benefits to bridge the gaps.

StompingMyFeet · 13/08/2021 09:02

@Alltheprettyseahorses

You're being extremely unreasonable tbh. You're clearly not happy with the decision not to have another child. That's not their fault and your resentment is quite nasty. You're not a better parent for espousing some of the reasons listed such as giving your child more attention (an attack on all people with more than 1 child and I only have 1 myself). Either come to terms with your choice or change it. It's not fair to be so envious you start a thread that's designed to pull all the anti-benefits sneerers to the yard.
Yes I know. When I'm able to think logically and reasonably I agree with the majority of posters on this thread. I wasn't in that place when I posted. I was hurt and upset with a huge dollop of jealousy and envy. I posted on MN because it often helps me process things when I'm off balance.
OP posts:
Alltheprettyseahorses · 13/08/2021 08:20

You're being extremely unreasonable tbh. You're clearly not happy with the decision not to have another child. That's not their fault and your resentment is quite nasty. You're not a better parent for espousing some of the reasons listed such as giving your child more attention (an attack on all people with more than 1 child and I only have 1 myself). Either come to terms with your choice or change it. It's not fair to be so envious you start a thread that's designed to pull all the anti-benefits sneerers to the yard.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 13/08/2021 08:13

I have felt the same as you, we had to move to a cheaper area miles away and start over.

HelenHywater · 13/08/2021 08:04

@lannistunut

I think of where Britain was post-war and the aspirations then to invest to create a better society through investment in housing, compared to all the petty jealousy and hatred there is now.

I don't fully understand what has happened to make people so bitter and ignorant, but the views about benefit claimants and benefit fraud people hold are not supported by any research done.

This.

I know nothing will change your narrow little minds but the reality is NOTHING like you are all spouting.

SerendipityJane · 13/08/2021 08:03

Some data.

That it's not fair!?
vivainsomnia · 13/08/2021 07:58

Data on benefit fraud is irrelevant because it only records fraud that has been identified and confirmed, not the fraud that takes place unindentified.

My friend used to work for the DWP. She said that it was well known that there was quite a bit of fraud taking place, they did receive so much reports, but they just didn't have the resources to investigate it, so they prioritised the cases where they knew it would take little work to evidence, and where there where the fraud was higher value to justify the investment.

That's why data shows that the highest fraud is housing benefit. It's much easier to evidence and the highest value.

She said that the highest estimate fraud is with CA, with people not providing anywhere 35h of care above what would be expected. This however is not worth the investment to investigate. Low value and almost impossible to evidence.

minatrina · 13/08/2021 06:46

@lannistunut

I think of where Britain was post-war and the aspirations then to invest to create a better society through investment in housing, compared to all the petty jealousy and hatred there is now.

I don't fully understand what has happened to make people so bitter and ignorant, but the views about benefit claimants and benefit fraud people hold are not supported by any research done.

Absolutely.

And there are several people on this thread asserting that their ~personal experience~ should somehow be held as equal to the findings of actual research. I'm increasingly finding (especially amongst Gen X and older) that your average Joe thinks their opinion is worth the same as the opinion of actual experts who have done research and dedicated their career to a particular topic.

anon12345678901 · 13/08/2021 06:45

YANBU and I have been on benefits myself. For a year when my partner left until I got a job because my child went in to early childcare. It's frustrating to see people stay in council houses when their situation improves and they can easily afford to move. There is a lack of social housing and that does not help it.
The benefit cap has stopped large families from being able to claim, which I think is correct. If you choose to have a large amount of children you cannot and should not expect the state to pay.
I'm not talking about disability benefits. They are rightly given.

minatrina · 13/08/2021 06:34

[quote bp300]@x2boys Nobody is accusing you of playing the system. I have no doubt you are a genuine claimant but a believe the system is far too generous. The motability scheme provides you with a brand new car where as many people who work are driving around in 10-15 year old cars and are worried they will be priced off the roads when electric cars become complulsary.[/quote]
Oh yes, it's awful when disabled people have access to nice things Confused

What exactly would make you happy about working people driving an old car? Would it make you happy if it was decreed that disabled people who get mobility cars aren't allowed cars that are any newer or nicer than their neighbours' cars?

I am so sad to see so much bitterness on this thread.

lannistunut · 13/08/2021 06:31

I think of where Britain was post-war and the aspirations then to invest to create a better society through investment in housing, compared to all the petty jealousy and hatred there is now.

I don't fully understand what has happened to make people so bitter and ignorant, but the views about benefit claimants and benefit fraud people hold are not supported by any research done.

minatrina · 13/08/2021 06:28

@Womaninthemirror1

It’s not that the couple shouldn’t be getting benefits. It’s that there should be more support for families like yours. Childcare for starters should be much, much cheaper, and the Tories need to stop supporting house price inflation.

It isn’t benefits that are making things unfair here.

Exactly. I can't fathom the thought process behind being in a financially tough situation with no support, seeing a family who do get support, thinking that it's unfair that they get it and you don't, and come to the conclusion that you begrudge them for getting support and not the government for nurturing a societal situation in which two working adults cannot afford to have the children they want?

Seems a very nasty attitude to me. The constant desire to punch down is my least favourite things about our culture. It seems that a lot of people are happy to live in undesirable conditions as long as people they deem unworthy have it worse off.

P.S. amazing how everyone and their mam knows "benefit scroungers" yet the research shows that the amount of people cheating the system is very small. Much more money is lost due to tax evasion - perhaps we should be focusing our anger at the other end of the spectrum? Confused

Ideasplease322 · 13/08/2021 05:42

Again i Am not in any way bashing disabled people. I am saying people absolutely should have benefits and the system is broken with many not getting enough, or having difficulty accessing the right benefits at the right time. It needs to be fixed to ensure people have the right help.

Benefit fraud isn’t about the disabled at all - only in that it harms genuine cases, taking resources away from those in need.

Everything I say is being taken up wrong so I best say no more.

But honestly not attacking disabled people - those who need help should absolutely get it.

That little girl does of course need transport, and it should never have been removed. That was not my point at all. I have never said the benefits should be removed.

Greentrianglesarethebestones · 13/08/2021 05:31

God this is a horrible and depressing thread. I despair that people struggling to afford a half decent lifestyle still think that those with the least money and fewest prospects are the people deserving of their resentment, hatred and anger.

nosafeguardingadults · 13/08/2021 05:06

Is very dangerous being on disability benefits and in private rented. You never safe. Few months from being homeless permanent risk. If homeless you either left to die on streets or put in dangerous hostels and HMOs mixed with people including just out of prison and often mixed sex. Is vicious circle trap cos bad dangerous housing makes you more ill and disabled and no chance of ever being well enough to maybe work. Some jobs can fit around some disabilities but you stuck in trap and focused on surviving not being homeless takes everything out of you so trap. If you not well enough to work you in serious trouble.

nosafeguardingadults · 13/08/2021 04:51

Am on disability benefits and maybe being nasty bad person but agree with first poster things not fair always. Not to do with being on benefits. It's more it's if you in council housing. If in council, you not rich but can manage. In private and you in serious trouble. Rents more than housing money and cos of that only dodgy landlords with dangerous bad housing will take you. You not allowed to be safe if disabled. Know unreasonable but is unfair cos some disabled are allowed to be safe. If you have social housing. Unfair some allowed it but not rest of us. Am domestic violence victim and can't leave cos no safe home to go to. If was in council housing, would be rehoused cos is scheme to rehouse domestic abuse victims but only if already in social housing. Know unreasonable of me but feel like first poster things not fair. My disability is partly cos of abuse. Councils try to get rid of you and send you long way from home in unsafe private or hostels. They say no housing in their area but if you already in social housing, there is housing for you. If I had safe home, could recover and rebuild my life. Get well enough to work again but not allowed the chance.

People saying just have children and you get council housing not true. In my area, people who need housing like if homeless or lose their jobs or disabled and can't afford private, council does same as with abuse victims. Gets rid of the family to far away areas in the worst private rented. Only get rehoused bigger home by council if already in social housing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread