Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That it's not fair!?

267 replies

StompingMyFeet · 11/08/2021 20:27

I've NC for this because I'm aware I'll sound like a Daily Mail article in my rant. I'm just so (irrationally) hurt and upset right now.

We own a 1 bed flat. We do ok, but there's basically no way we'll ever be anywhere bigger even though we both work.We have a DD already , but for the past 3 years I've desperately wanted another baby. There's no room, money would be tricky, childcare , going back to work , OH is getting quite old etc. Plus the impact on DD by having less .. attention,time,space etc. So I know it's a know, I try to make my peace with it and forget about it. Sometimes it just fucking hurts though, so much so that it becomes physical.

Today I saw one of our old neighbours who got moved last year (council) into a two bed. She had DS with her and a baby. While we were chatting she casually said "oh this is what happens when you get a two bedroom" and laughed. I kinda hated her a little bit then, smiled ,fussed over the baby again , said my goodbyes and walked away in tears.

This is the DM part, they don't work , mid twenties , barely good enough parents . It just feels so fucking unfair that I have to consider all the risks and cons and disadvantages because there is no safety net, and tell myself no. I don't begrudge them benefits,or the flat or whatever.. I know they need it and in a way we're a million times more fortunate. But fucking hell, I do begrudge them that baby.

I'll get over it, but today I just want to cry and stamp my feet and rant and shout It's not fair!

OP posts:
worriedatthemoment · 13/08/2021 16:42

@minatrina your very condescending its not that small amount ans my education is fine , just because I don't totally agree with you doesn't make me stupid
Its not just about fraud and any amount matters if taking from people who need it.
The post was more about how 2 full time working people can't afford to have a 2 bed home and 2 kids which isn't exactly wanting the world, and can understand why op may think not fair that 2 able people not working can have all that ?

lannistunut · 13/08/2021 16:15

If the economy is fucked then it fucked for ordinary working class people too. Who are imo allowed to feel resentful at the fact that there is little incentive to work and 'be a good citizen' when it pays to sit on your arse.

Again I say if you think it 'pays to sit on your arse' why are you not doing this? You must be a fool if you are not availing yourself of this marvellous life opportunity.

The argument rings so hollow. Yes there are people not working and not dying of starvation. But do you really envy their lives? I don't think many do, it is just an easy thing to moan about when people feel miserable about thier own life. But if you do envy them, there is nothing stopping you from doing the same.

HelenHywater · 13/08/2021 16:13

but @Iloveginger yes, it's fucked for all working parents/people. But it's the govt you should all be angry at. Not benefits claimants. I can assure you it's harder for them. You're all directing your anger and envy at the wrong people.

HelenHywater · 13/08/2021 16:12

You all just believe the tory propaganda and the tory press. It's all bullshit.

HelenHywater · 13/08/2021 16:11

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

A very high proportion of UC claimants are actually working

How many where all the adults in the household work full time so 37 hours plus? I’d imagine many have one adult not working, a single adult just doing the minimum hours needed etc.

pretty irrelevant when it comes to the sums though. why would people choose to work if they are better off on benefits

That’s the point though it shouldn’t be a choice or an option. Certainly not when others are funding it.

It doesn't pay to work full time - the childcare costs are barely covered at all (as I said, the amount paid is stuck at 2003 levels) and it is simply unaffordable to work full time. This isn't because people are workshy losers. It's because childcare costs are high, salaries are low and UC isn't enough to meaningfully help working parents.

We have some of the highest childcare costs in the world. The lowest benefit rates and we force working parents back to work sooner than other countries. It is the system and the economy that is fucked, not workshy, benefits cheats parents.

worriedatthemoment · 13/08/2021 16:05

@HealthKick2021 I know pkenty with over 3's who don't work and child benefit isn't capped and its onky capped at 2 from a certain date so people knew that was happening so could stick to 2 children

Candydreamer · 13/08/2021 14:46

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss me and my partner both work full time jobs and everyone I know who is claiming and are entitled to even a small amount like we are, are also working. wages are just crap.

obviously, not everyone but there are commitments you have to meet in order to get them. that's not to say noone plays the system, you will always get those who try, but a lot of people claim simply to make ends meet.

it wouldnt be a choice if the cost of living matched the average wage though would it. most people are just trying to get by - I know me and my partner are. and as full time workers we pay into the system so I feel no shame whatsoever in benefitting from it.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 13/08/2021 13:41

A very high proportion of UC claimants are actually working

How many where all the adults in the household work full time so 37 hours plus? I’d imagine many have one adult not working, a single adult just doing the minimum hours needed etc.

pretty irrelevant when it comes to the sums though. why would people choose to work if they are better off on benefits

That’s the point though it shouldn’t be a choice or an option. Certainly not when others are funding it.

Iloveginger · 13/08/2021 13:29

@HelenHywater

But *@Iloveginger* they can't do nothing. They have to work. Most UC claimants work. Albeit in shit, low paid, gig economy jobs. But that isn't their fault - the economy is fucked. There aren't the jobs to support them, and I guarantee most people would rather earn more than £18k a year and be in far more fulfilling jobs.

I work with people in poverty and benefits claimants - I believe I'm far more qualified and knowledgeable than you to tell you what it's really like.

But there's also a proportion of them that don't (members of my own wider family included) that do ok. If the economy is fucked then it fucked for ordinary working class people too. Who are imo allowed to feel resentful at the fact that there is little incentive to work and 'be a good citizen' when it pays to sit on your arse.
HelenHywater · 13/08/2021 13:14

Yes @Candydreamer - but they don't have much choice because they get sanctioned once their child is 3. It is shit I agree -there's no choice really.

fwiw I don't think the vast majority of people who claim UC are privileged or taking the piss. A very high proportion of UC claimants are actually working. Rishi Sunak always forgets to mention that when he's spouting his shit. (as do the Daily Mail).

Candydreamer · 13/08/2021 13:11

and I am not looking at this from a position of privilege, trust me. we get 120 a month in universal credits and I dont feel bad about it at all. if cost of living vs wages wasnt so shit we wouldnt have to claim at all. we both work full time jobs.

Candydreamer · 13/08/2021 13:10

@HelenHywater yes I know you have to meet certain commitments to continue receiving benefits, I'm just saying that its not hard to see why some dont have the incentive to go out and look for themselves/give up time with their children when they are younger when the wages are so shockingly low.

HelenHywater · 13/08/2021 13:05

they have to work @Candydreamer. The govt makes them when their child turns 3 and doesn't fund more than 2 children. It also ensures the benefit cap doesn't cover their costs, that the childcare element is stuck at 2003 levels and the amount that they receive isn't enough to live on.

Oh and to add insult to injury they are stuck in low paid jobs that barely feed their families.

And if you're disabled or have a disabled child? What do you think life is like then?

HelenHywater · 13/08/2021 13:03

But @Iloveginger they can't do nothing. They have to work. Most UC claimants work. Albeit in shit, low paid, gig economy jobs. But that isn't their fault - the economy is fucked. There aren't the jobs to support them, and I guarantee most people would rather earn more than £18k a year and be in far more fulfilling jobs.

I work with people in poverty and benefits claimants - I believe I'm far more qualified and knowledgeable than you to tell you what it's really like.

Candydreamer · 13/08/2021 13:02

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

Working should be something to inspire to

I disagree. It should be the norm to do some form of work. Yes certain career choices will be ones to inspire to aim for but self responsibility and working should just be expected.
The fault lies with having a system that lets people opt out of that or to make a token few hours. A welfare system should be a last resort and cover the minimum basics.
Too simple to blame on employers, they have no say in the lifestyle choices of employees.

pretty irrelevant when it comes to the sums though. why would people choose to work if they are better off on benefits? why would they choose to be away from their children if childcare eclipses what they earn?

the fact cost of living had gone up but wages havent is despicable

Iloveginger · 13/08/2021 12:56

@Babyroobs

A couple over 25 with 2 small children on Uc would get around £980 to live off a month after their rent is paid. If their rent element doesn't cover all their rent then they may have to pay the rent shortfall from that ?
That's going to work out at nearly 12,000 per year net. They are also getting their rent paid and council tax and other subsidised services. Depending on were they live that could be worth anything from 6000 - 12000 per year. approx £20,000 per year tax free for doing nothing. It not a huge amount, but it is to lot of regular working class people that are probably working for less. This is what a lot of middle class hand wringers don't understand, when they come on to shut down people that rightly complain about how unfair the system is, all the while buying shit from amazon and supporting minimum wage jobs that keep people trapped in poverty.
IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 13/08/2021 12:45

Working should be something to inspire to

I disagree. It should be the norm to do some form of work. Yes certain career choices will be ones to inspire to aim for but self responsibility and working should just be expected.
The fault lies with having a system that lets people opt out of that or to make a token few hours. A welfare system should be a last resort and cover the minimum basics.
Too simple to blame on employers, they have no say in the lifestyle choices of employees.

PizzaPiePizzaPie · 13/08/2021 12:39

It’s shit.

The problem isn’t that people on benefits are paid too much, but working people are paid too little.
Working should be something to inspire to, you should be significantly better off.

I hate it when people say oh you’ll be better off working in 10 years than being on benefits, but if you are on the bones of your arse just now it makes no difference.

twinningatlife · 13/08/2021 12:36

Yes we fucked up. Massively. I know. I have the guilt and shame of that to deal with as well. We lost nearly everything and at some point we ended up in a room in a house share above a pub riddled with bed bugs and mice and getting more and more in debt. Buying this flat was amazing (we have already moved further away) , and we felt very grateful and lucky. I still do most days.

I'm guessing there is a huge back story to how you have ended up in a 1 bed in your current situation?

UC isn't available when you have a mortgage....presumably you had good enough credit to get a mortgage on this flat so one wonders why you didn't just decide to rent and then you'd be eligible for UC?

minatrina · 13/08/2021 12:29

I'm actually shocked that I've been asked to explain why peer reviewed data is more valid than personal anecdotes 😭 cba

minatrina · 13/08/2021 12:27

[quote worriedatthemoment]@minatrina academic research is not the be all and end all and research shows just a small amount of what goes on
How can you estimate how much fraud happens of many is undetected ?
Data can only be drawn by whats available, why is your data so superior to other peoples real life experiences ? What because an academic produced it so they must be right over many of us , who live this life day in day out
[/quote]
If you're asking me if I think researchers are more intelligent and have a better perspective on their field than you or I, my answer would be yes.

Candydreamer · 13/08/2021 12:26

I think what I find the most dismaying is the fact that two full time employed adults, like myself and my partner, can just about afford the sky high rent we pay on a small two bed house.

I feel absolutely zero shame in the measley 120 pound top up we get extra a month in Universal credits, a top up we do only get because we have 2 children and our rent is so high.

You want to direct your anger anywhere, direct at whoever is responsible for living costs going up so much over the last 20 years but wages not matching it. Sometimes, those on benefits end up better off than those working, and sometimes I do think well can I blame them? It's not a huge incentive to work is it, especially when you have children and often childcare costs eclipse what you earn anyway.

minatrina · 13/08/2021 12:25

@minitrina I'm confused as to why you think I'm denying the existence of benefit fraud. At no point did I say or even suggest that it doesn't happen. I clearly stated that in my opinion it's a small enough percentage that it's not worth worrying about compared to much other pressing issues. I think that's easy enough to understand.

"Data can be manipulated" yes, that's kind of the point of data? You read the research, you look at the raw data provided, you read what the researchers have done with the data and how they obtained the data, and then you can evaluate how much you agree with the researchers' conclusions based on the data and the research methods used.

But no! You have no need to do this because you've come across some people in your time that you have deemed unworthy of state support, and your anecdata is apparently above scrutiny.

What's sad is that a surprising number of people think this way. It's an indictment of our education system imo.

worriedatthemoment · 13/08/2021 12:21

@minatrina academic research is not the be all and end all and research shows just a small amount of what goes on
How can you estimate how much fraud happens of many is undetected ?
Data can only be drawn by whats available, why is your data so superior to other peoples real life experiences ? What because an academic produced it so they must be right over many of us , who live this life day in day out

worriedatthemoment · 13/08/2021 12:18

@minatrina i can't understand why people can't accept it happens and data can be manipulated in many ways
I can say what I have seen and know in real life as thats real true life experience , that many in middle class england have not experienced. Are you saying it never happens? And its not all about cost its about how it then causes stigma for those that are genuine of which there are obviously many more

Swipe left for the next trending thread