Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Biden is wrong to pull out of Afghanistan

180 replies

bluewanda · 11/08/2021 14:15

Biden says he doesn't regret the decision to withdraw US troops from Afghanistan. Really?!!

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9883367/Taliban-going-door-door-forcibly-marrying-girls-young-TWELVE.html

I know the Americans can't be expected to sort out every problem on the world stage, but how can we just turn our backs and leave those poor girls in the hands of these monsters Sad There isn't any alternative IMO but to keep the troops there.

OP posts:
samyeagar · 11/08/2021 16:32

@Panickingpavlova

Samy

What do you suggest right now to stop another single girl taken right now from her family and passed to a fighter like a chattel?

I am very hesitant to answer this question because the unemotional answer to it is not very palatable, but here goes anyway.

In short...Nothing.

The western way of life is so vastly different currently and historically, not just militarily, economically and technologically, but far more importantly culturally and religiously that there is no foundation to even begin to build a bridge.

Short of full scale military occupation and enforcement of western ideal, there is nothing. Even then, compliance would be under duress. You can't force change of hearts, minds, and way of life.

That has to wanted and to come from within, and like it or not, understand it or not, these nations and cultures, and people don't want it.

Martianworld · 11/08/2021 16:31

🙄 To compare the American army to the Taliban is ridiculous! The Americans spent a huge amount trying to improve welfare standards in A to empower people. The Taliban is only interested in destroying everything so they empower themselves. I'm sure there are bad apples in the US army but the vast amount are doing their best in challenging surroundings with their life on the line every day. In contrast there may a few good apples in the Taliban but they are ineffective against the majority.
If I were a girl or woman who was living in A, I know who'd I prefer to be in charge of my welfare.

Panickingpavlova · 11/08/2021 16:27
  • whatever the complex motives of any power being there, a by product was the protection (as far as that ever goes in a Muslims countryside) of women and girls to go about their lives.

Not be dragged out of the their homes by wild medieval neanderthals who want to rape and enslave them.

Panickingpavlova · 11/08/2021 16:25

I can't understand some of of these posts.

Right now there is a targeted assault on the women and children going on.

I think that should be stopped.

I don't think it's soley down to the Americans to stop it.

But I think it should be stopped.

WTFisNext · 11/08/2021 16:25

YABU

The Afghanistan people need to sort out their own country.

The US and UK sending troops there was never about protecting women and girls...it was an ego trip from start to finish because a terrorist group used the country openly as it's base yet similar countries in the region aren't being invaded

That things improved for the non-radical Afghanistan residents was a side effect rather than intent of the invasion.

Globaluser · 11/08/2021 16:22

*People into
It’s meant to say 😁

Globaluser · 11/08/2021 16:17

No denying the taliban are truly disgusting vultures. They live in a land that believes what they’re doing is right. It’s despicable!
But how can any educated man or woman of any western army turn into people sadist rapists and killers,who don’t value the life of inccoent civilians?
So shouldn’t really be rooting their horn, should you?

AuntMasha · 11/08/2021 16:15

Poor Afghanistan, ravaged by century upon century of war. It’s not named ‘The Graveyard of Empires’ for nothing.

The plight of the women and girls is heartbreaking.

CremeEggThief · 11/08/2021 16:15

YANBU to think he's wrong, but this is what the Americans always do. I think I'm coming at it from a different perspective from you, as my attitude and experience from growing up (and also, my mother is from Latin America) is that loads of countries hate them, because they go around sticking their nose in and interfering in other countries' business and then they leave when they feel like it! Whether or not the problem has been solved, or made worse by their interference. There's certainly no gratitude from me for them going around acting like the policeman of the world, whereas you seem to have that.

Martianworld · 11/08/2021 16:13

@Globaluser

Think about it; Afganistan is well and truly fucked up, no one is going to disagree on that. But you really think Americans troops are in there to protect the inccoent civilians? If that was the case, don’t you think Trump would’ve pulled them out during his presidency? Hmm
To be fair, the Americans carried out all kinds of engineering and infrastructure projects to help improve lives. And whilst they were there, women could work and girls could get education. They helped facilitate medical services to be carried out across the country. But if a country cannot keep that going on its own, how long can you expect other countries to keep asking soldiers to risk their lives?

Why are you involving Trump in any of this? He didn't invade Afghanistan; he didn't keep troops in Aghanistan; he withdrew some troops as did Obama; he didn't withdraw all troops. Not everything in the world has to be a stick to beat Donald Trump with.

Globaluser · 11/08/2021 16:12

@Panickingpavlova all those things you stated, happen by the hands of the American army also!

Topseyt · 11/08/2021 16:12

No. I think it is the right decision as there is no ideal solution. There never will be no matter how long the US and maybe the UK remain there.

They would just be sacrificing the lives of their own servicemen and women with no realistic hope of gaining anything useful.

Acknowledging this does not mean that we do not care about the women and children involved, or that the US doesn't. Sadly though, we simply can't sort out all of the world's problems.

I think that the US has done all that it realistically can. There is no longer any point in staying there.

Panickingpavlova · 11/08/2021 16:12

Samy

What do you suggest right now to stop another single girl taken right now from her family and passed to a fighter like a chattel?

Globaluser · 11/08/2021 16:11

Like I said, if America were there to “protect” then Trump would’ve pulled them out as one of his first acts of president.

samyeagar · 11/08/2021 16:08

So is this another case of western self soothing and lets celebrate multi-culturalism and diversity...so long as it doesn't differ tooo much from our own, and if it does, then we have to throw our militaries around to get them back in line?

Globaluser · 11/08/2021 16:06

@Frodogo so you know 99.999% of Americans population, do you?
That’s a very false fact you made!

Panickingpavlova · 11/08/2021 16:06

What we are now witnessing is a humanatrian atrocity
And I don't believe the world should stand by and watch those women, girls taken and enslaved and raped, men killed etc.

lancashirelady · 11/08/2021 16:03

The only reason the Americans and the British were in Afghanistan was because of Bush and Blair, nothing at all to do with the plight of the Afghanistan women. Countless civilian and military deaths are on their hands. Bush because of revenge for 9/11 and Blair because he wanted to be a world player. Both should have been tried and committed for war crimes. The plight of Afgani women didn't even register on their radar.

Panickingpavlova · 11/08/2021 16:02

Glob... The fact is ordinary civilians were protected and now they are not.

Globaluser · 11/08/2021 16:00

Think about it; Afganistan is well and truly fucked up, no one is going to disagree on that. But you really think Americans troops are in there to protect the inccoent civilians? If that was the case, don’t you think Trump would’ve pulled them out during his presidency? Hmm

Panickingpavlova · 11/08/2021 15:57

How is it girls going to school?
Because they will raise the boys?

How much difference will this make when they are beaten and used as chattels and spoils of war..

I don't think any more than American blood should be spilt there.
I'd like too see other countries helping out or and the un

I really don't want think the world stage can ignore this though.

Lollipity · 11/08/2021 15:57

As devastating as it is for the people of Afghanistan, I'm not sure there is much Western governments can do in terms of troops on the ground. Any non-Muslim incursion simply brings forth jihadists from across the region and can be used as a tool to radicalise and subsequently threaten the safety of populations here.

samyeagar · 11/08/2021 15:54

And why the expectation that western nations continue to force their own style of democracies and social and religious structures on nations that historically have rejected such?

Yes, many of these nations are a complete mess by western standards, but they have been so for a long time. Far longer than the western enlightenments.

As atrocious as many of these nations are socially, religiously, governmentally, militaristically, it is not the wests right to reshape them in our image, and impose our will upon them, no matter how right, or how much better the wests way would be for the people in those countries.

Nandakanda · 11/08/2021 15:53

It seems to be their culture.

Would you be prepared to sacrifice your own kids in unwanted wars or occupations because you find their practices distasteful?

Let the Chinese have a go. Militarism seems to be on the increase there.

Lollipity · 11/08/2021 15:48

Screenshot attached. Author: Peter Bergen

AIBU to think Biden is wrong to pull out of Afghanistan