Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Handmaids tale

82 replies

OttilieStonelady · 11/08/2021 10:49

I've only just started watching (not a huge TV fan). Does anyone else find it heart wrenching? Impossible to watch? I don't get emotional about TV shows. I actually feel sick watching it. I can't even explain it. I feel like I need to stop watching as I always feel really down after. Anyone else feel like this with handmaids tale (or any other TV show)?? I can't stop watching but also want to turn it off!!!

OP posts:
ponyexpress22 · 11/08/2021 18:17

[quote CheekyChewinski]@ponyexpress22 yes I must admit I struggle with her character. Did you see the episode last Sunday?[/quote]
Like the awful cruelty to the girl scrubbing the floor.....in contrast to the way she hugged Janine as if she loved her?

SchrodingersImmigrant · 11/08/2021 18:15

@hamstersarse

It’s hits right in the heart of women’s fears and anxieties around their children and bodily autonomy

It’s harsh. But not stuff none of us haven’t ever felt or know deep down. I think we all fear for our bodily autonomy pretty much all the time subconsciously, we know it could be gone in a heartbeat because of our biology.

Ive never met a man who even ‘gets’ THT never mind he harrowed by it

Tbh I don't "get" it fully either. I certainly don't worry about my bodily autonomy all the time.
SchrodingersImmigrant · 11/08/2021 18:13

@ponyexpress22

I found "Aunt Lydia" an unbelievable character. To change so much from a normal warm human being into the monster she became just because a man rejected her.
I actually believe it. Bitterness and unhappiness can do Incredible daamage. Combined with ehat eas happening and Gilead, I can absolutely imagine someone turning like that.
hamstersarse · 11/08/2021 16:42

It’s hits right in the heart of women’s fears and anxieties around their children and bodily autonomy

It’s harsh. But not stuff none of us haven’t ever felt or know deep down. I think we all fear for our bodily autonomy pretty much all the time subconsciously, we know it could be gone in a heartbeat because of our biology.

Ive never met a man who even ‘gets’ THT never mind he harrowed by it

Wheresmrpenguin · 11/08/2021 16:42

Yeah it's tough. The scene where they're all in the office and you see it all change rapidly, like it's a completely normal day. Plus having your child ripped away. I started watching it when I was at the end of my pregnancy and my DD is 17 months now and the thought of having her taken away and my family ripped apart tomorrow if scary. There's so many things I've seen in the last year too which makes me think it could happen. Having rights taken away, the vaccine messing with women's periods and what if infertility becomes an issue in a few years. Its too close to home!

LifeInAHamsterWheel · 11/08/2021 16:36

The book is better. Much better. I totally disagree! I am a big reader and almost always feel the book is better than anything dramatised for screen. But this is one of few exceptions for me. I liked the book but it didn't affect me the way the screen adaptation did. I think the book lacks context, you've no idea what year or era it's set in and I struggled to feel any connection with June. However, on screen its clear that it's now and how this could happen to any of us in the 'normal' western world. I also think casting the characters of Fred and Serena-Joy as the same age as June was a really good move. The dynamic is totally different. In the book, they are old and have nothing in common with June. It's not a very long book either, so the screenplay can go into far more detail which really adds to the story in my opinion.

But there is no doubt it's a hard watch. I was always glad of the week between episodes and I don't think I would have binge-watched even if I could, I needed the week to process it all!

SleepingStandingUp · 11/08/2021 16:33

We "enjoy" it bit def one episode a week at most and we record it so watch ot when we want to in the week
I found the end of this week's particularly awful when Serena and Dick came out on the way to court.

MazDazzle · 11/08/2021 16:26

@AnneLovesGilbert it reads like fan fiction. I enjoyed it, even though I thought it was shite. It’s an easy read. The writing is on par with 50 Shades. Very plot driven. It’s hard to believe both books are by the same author. The style of writing in the original book is so tight, by comparison The Testaments is waffle. There were pages where I shouted out loud ‘Oh come on!’ and Atwood writing from the voice of a modern day teenager is laughable. I still enjoyed delving back into Gilead though.

Tattiespuds · 11/08/2021 14:43

I found it an uncomfortable but compiling watch. I binged watched it and now up to date, the current and last season aren't as brutal. There was times in the earlier season I felt j couldn't keep watching but I couldn't stop myself from watching.

CheekyChewinski · 11/08/2021 14:32

@ponyexpress22 yes I must admit I struggle with her character. Did you see the episode last Sunday?

ponyexpress22 · 11/08/2021 14:30

I found "Aunt Lydia" an unbelievable character. To change so much from a normal warm human being into the monster she became just because a man rejected her.

mammummt793 · 11/08/2021 14:26

I was exactly the same OP! I've watched a lot of bleak stuff and work in child protection/domestic violence so I have seen a lot of awful stuff in real life too but I just can't, I feel tearful and sick even thinking about some of the bits I have seenConfused

dapsnotplimsolls · 11/08/2021 13:59

I have to watch something fluffy after each episode on Sundays before I go to bed! I understand what you mean by harrowing but also addictive - I re-watched series 3 before series 4 then struggled with it just being on once a week so re-watched 1 and 2 in between the new episodes!

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/08/2021 13:42

Oh and yes, the music is outstanding.

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/08/2021 13:42

I do agree to a certain point with DrS that the show does get repetitive at times and it is definitely implausible that June escapes state sanctioned punishment when other women do not for the same or lesser crimes. However, I haven’t read the book and I wait for the next episode every week in anticipation despite it being a harrowing watch.

CheekyChewinski · 11/08/2021 13:25

Yes agreed the music is superb!

@AntiFlag Sad I can't even say it surprises me.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 11/08/2021 13:24

It's not an easy watch but it's absolutely brilliant. I love it.

imaginethemdragons · 11/08/2021 13:24

Yes very tough watch but I live for June’s victories, no matter how small, they are magnified because of the bleakness.
The music is superb, the way that you get washed along in the history of it then get shocked like a punch in the guts when the modern world intersperses the story and you think, “oh god yeah, it’s not in the past, this is modern life”…but how? How is this going on?
It’s so so clever.

I have enjoyed it because I have been forced from my world into this world without ever knowing it existed.

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 11/08/2021 13:24

I love it!! Totally agree with the comments about you want to switch it off, but can't. I binged it when I was off on maternity leave a few years ago, it made me cry so much!

SirenSays · 11/08/2021 13:23

I love the show, though I do think the book was better. I have felt like I'm just gritting my teeth and waiting for a break during some moments. I found the scene with the handmaid's punished in the rain particularly hard, especially because Hollywood rain like that is hell for the actors.
I felt the same way during certain parts of breaking bad. Desperate for the never ending tension to break and give me a bit of respite.

AntiFlag · 11/08/2021 13:23

@CheekyChewinski this was also revealed to be happening in clothing factories - was it Levi’s maybe? Women being raped daily and they feel they have to put up with it otherwise they’d lose their jobs.

CheekyChewinski · 11/08/2021 13:19

I am a huge fan. It is harrowing. And I wait until I'm in a good mood to watch the next ep or it can really get you down if you're not in a great headspace.

I was talking about it coming back for s4 to a mum from school and she hadn't heard of it so started watching it on my recommendation. She's from Africa and caught me at pick up and said to me, you know this is real? She went on to explain that she escaped from Africa and it happens there. Woman work on the farms (black African woman) and they are expected to service the (usually white men) farmers. She said the whole set up is so similar. The children are then kept there and raised to do the same from a very young age.

I felt really stupid for recommending it to be honest.

Arsebucket · 11/08/2021 13:18

I’ve never watched it.

I’ve read the book a few times so I have my own “film” version of it in my head if that makes sense. Seeing someone else’s interpretation of that would ruin it for me.

TheTingTing · 11/08/2021 13:10

Loved the book but stopped watching the series as it was rubbish. Bough the second book but didn’t read it in case it tarnished the first!

HelenHywater · 11/08/2021 13:07

Yes, it's exceptionally harrowing. Until the recent episodes, I cried in every one. (I binge watched series 2 and 3 and part of 4). It's just such a hard watch. Because it's shocking and based in reality.

I'm not sure I could have watched it while pregnant tbh. It's hard enough being a mother and woman and watching it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread