Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have being branded a ''paedophile supporter''.

88 replies

Balgoresboy · 10/08/2021 23:57

Tonight we were at a mates and 1 of them was going on about how Prince Andrew should be sent to US to answer the charges and it was a disgrace he wasn't.

I responded that that was fair enough but if that was the case America should send the diplomat's wife who killed the boy in the car back to the UK to answer the charges as that too was unfair.

Friend raged at me that my
attitude was disgusting and that I was defending a paedo. Was my point unreasonable?

OP posts:
Why2why · 11/08/2021 01:21

Very well put @Fiddliestofsticks. Point well made. Makes clear the unreasonableness of the OP’s position.

Sparklfairy · 11/08/2021 01:20

No one doesn't depend on the other but what the OP said encourages wider debate about the imbalance with US-UK extradition.

If she said "we shouldn't send Andrew until we get Anne Sacoolas" that would be different.

Its a nuance in language that the OP's friend completely missed.

Fiddliestofsticks · 11/08/2021 01:18

If Andrew were to be indicted, and somehow the UK agreed to send him over, would you protest it? Would you go out there shouting that he should get to stay and avoid punishment unless someone in a totally unrelated case, who has no connection to Andrew's victim, is sent here?

Or, what if the US actually decided to send Anne back here? Would you go out and protest that? Would you say, "do not send her back here unless we agree to give you Andrew?"

Why2why · 11/08/2021 01:18

*should NOT be dependent on each other

Why2why · 11/08/2021 01:17

@DdraigGoch, I agree but this should not be used by either side to deny justice to the victims involved. These victims should not be played off against each other and their cases, quest for justice, should be dependent on each other.

The debate must be had but victims must not be used as pawns.

ElliottSmithsfingers · 11/08/2021 01:15

One doesn't depend on the other, does it? Your attempt to link the two was misguided at best.

sergeilavrov · 11/08/2021 01:15

Was his primary point on extradition policy, or moreso the child sexual exploitation by Prince Andrew? If the former, your point was fine; if the latter, it’s whataboutism and YABU.

DdraigGoch · 11/08/2021 01:12

@Why2why

Each crime and the circumstances stand on its own. One is not contingent on the other.

Reducing the crimes to politics between the two countries is a disservice to the victims involved.

Both alleged crimes are serious crimes and the victims deserve justice. To make Dunn’s access to justice depend on PA going over to the US and Virginia’s justice dependent on the diplomat’s wife returning to the IK is plain wrong.

They deserve justice on the merit of their case.

There's a wider debate to be had on UK-US extraditions to be had. There have long been complaints that it's imbalanced
FortVictoria · 11/08/2021 01:10

You were right on both counts.

DdraigGoch · 11/08/2021 01:10

Only to people who don't listen and lack critical thinking.
@Sparklfairy that's most of Twitter for a start.

Why2why · 11/08/2021 01:10

It is defending Prince Andrew. What else is it? Why should any victim’s entitlement to justice depend on the case of another victim in a totally different case?

Consider it from a victim’s person and you will see that the argument that PA should only answer for his alleged crimes, if and only if, the woman who killed Harry Dunn is returned to the UK.

Why2why · 11/08/2021 01:06

Each crime and the circumstances stand on its own. One is not contingent on the other.

Reducing the crimes to politics between the two countries is a disservice to the victims involved.

Both alleged crimes are serious crimes and the victims deserve justice. To make Dunn’s access to justice depend on PA going over to the US and Virginia’s justice dependent on the diplomat’s wife returning to the IK is plain wrong.

They deserve justice on the merit of their case.

Sparklfairy · 11/08/2021 01:06

exactly but to some that's defending Andrew

Only to people who don't listen and lack critical thinking.

People like this hear anything that isn't sycophantic agreement to their opinions as a personal attack, so go on the attack themselves missing the point and ignoring what you actually said completely name calling and throwing their toys out of the pram.

Drives me nuts.

Fiddliestofsticks · 11/08/2021 01:03

Andrew is being sued privately. He is not being indicted on criminal charges.
Do we really want to go down the route were people are extradited due to private litigation? That could be seriously abused.

Saying that, Andrew should be facing criminal charges but until he is, what grounds are there to extradite? Anne S should have been sent back here long ago.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 11/08/2021 01:01

Yanbu op your friends an idiot.

JaneJeffer · 11/08/2021 01:00

@Richardjeff I hope you'll be more careful where you put your genital part in future.

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2021 00:48

YABU @Balgoresboy. Your reply to your friend's reasonable statement was "Whataboutery".Hmm

SinisterBumFacedCat · 11/08/2021 00:45

Yes, it’s fair swap. Your mate is being a dick.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 11/08/2021 00:42

Your friend is clearly not very bright. I wouldn't worry about it.

Hecatestorch · 11/08/2021 00:24

I think they are relevant to eachother.

Both accused of commiting crimes in each others countries. Both status as 'immune' is in question. Both have some sort of protection by their respective authorities.

There are alot of similarities in the Position of AS and PA.

While not identical, and one could be sent to face justice and the other not. I can see the comparison.

Cam2020 · 11/08/2021 00:22

I agree. Also, even if he has done what he is accused of having done, that still doesn't make him a paedophile. I dont mean to denegrade the accusation at all, but that's just factually incorrect.

AimingForSerenity · 11/08/2021 00:22

It occurred to me earlier that it would not be a good idea for him to go to the USA as they may not let him return despite their refusing to send back Anne Sacoulas. Sometimes the USA seem to think it should be one rule for them and one rule for everybody else

8Track · 11/08/2021 00:20

Great news for you doll @Richardjeff

HopeYourHighHorseBucks · 11/08/2021 00:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 11/08/2021 00:19

Your friend doesn't sound too intelligent. Calling PA a "paedo" for example. Even assuming he is guilty of something it isn't paedophilia. But your friend seems to think a person saying something to her/him that isn't "Oh I totally agree and have no thoughts of my own!" is someone who agrees with the crime.