Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have being branded a ''paedophile supporter''.

88 replies

Balgoresboy · 10/08/2021 23:57

Tonight we were at a mates and 1 of them was going on about how Prince Andrew should be sent to US to answer the charges and it was a disgrace he wasn't.

I responded that that was fair enough but if that was the case America should send the diplomat's wife who killed the boy in the car back to the UK to answer the charges as that too was unfair.

Friend raged at me that my
attitude was disgusting and that I was defending a paedo. Was my point unreasonable?

OP posts:
Brefugee · 11/08/2021 07:27

YANBU to point out that when the boot is on the other foot it's shit because the USA won't play.

YABU to make the connection. The cases are different and not connected and frankly they should both be travelling across the Atlantic to answer to the courts.

Why did you feel the need to say that instead of just agreeing that he should go?

Hecatestorch · 11/08/2021 07:08

People keep mentioning PA cases is a civil case I don't think that's what the friend was say she they specifically said answer charges

I am assuming they feel he should be sent to the US to face criminal charges.

MrsTophamHat · 11/08/2021 06:31

They have made the inference that you would be happy to see Andrew escape justice for as long as Sacoolas does. I wouldn't have made that interpretation.

Plumtree391 · 11/08/2021 06:16

You weren't unreasonable, nor were you supporting Prince Andrew or any paedophile.

However the two cases are poles apart. From what I have read, PA is prepared to answer questions from the FBI.

It's best not to get into such discussions, views are so polarised.

phishy · 11/08/2021 05:38

I agree with her a bit. Why not engage on the issue being discussed - the sexual abuse of a US minor (she was 17), rather than engage in whatabottery?

LoislovesStewie · 11/08/2021 05:33

@x2boys

I would say PA was more of a sexual predator and maybe a rapist if everything that he is accused of is true as a paedophile is someone who is sexually interested in pre pubescent children
Actually I want to make this point often, paedophilia is sexual attraction to prepubescents, Andrew may well be attracted to very young women, but that does not make him a paedophile. Regarding the whole extradition to the USA problem, if you look at this the USA rarely sends its citizens back to face justice, the whole extradition treaty seems to work entirely in their favour.
Applesandbaynay · 11/08/2021 05:28

To clarify I mean morally Prince Andrew should go to the US and cooperate with the investigation. He is a member of the royal family and should behave in an open and transparent manner. He can’t be extradited unless he is charged.

Whether Anne Sacoolas should actually be entitled to diplomatic immunity in the circumstances is I think debatable. However they are two completely separate matters.

Applesandbaynay · 11/08/2021 05:20

They should both face justice but they don’t have anything to do with each other. I don’t see what the point is here. That we should protect a man who is accused of raping a child (whether you want to split hairs about the meaning of the word paedophile supporter this is what he is accused of) because the US haven’t ‘swapped’ him for Anne Sacoolas. Is that who we are as a country?

If there is enough evidence for him to be prosecuted in the civil or criminal courts then he should do so. No matter how the US has behaved in another case. Justice for a victim and prosecuting someone who has (allegedly) committed a sex offence should not be dependent on ‘swapping’.

The fact that he is not being prosecuted here despite the fact the offence was alleged to have been committed in London shows the absurd deference to the Royal family in this country. If he was an average Joe his feet wouldn’t have touched the ground.

MrsTerryPratchett · 11/08/2021 04:53

@DewDew83

Isn't that rather the point of questioning him and getting him into a Court? Not in a civil claim, no.
OJ Simpson may have some thoughts about that.
DewDew83 · 11/08/2021 03:26

Isn't that rather the point of questioning him and getting him into a Court?
Not in a civil claim, no.

avamiah · 11/08/2021 03:26

Who knows what will happen to him ,look at Harvey Weinstein, he was a multi multi millionaire film producer now look were he is.

MrsTerryPratchett · 11/08/2021 03:04

PA is not a proven sex offender.

Isn't that rather the point of questioning him and getting him into a Court?

VeniVidiWeeWee · 11/08/2021 02:55

@MrsTerryPratchett

The difference for me is risk.

Sex offenders have a very high recidivism rate. I think it's the highest of any class of crime.

People who kill by dangerous driving don't.

Risk to the public is massively higher in the first case.

Sorry, but what is your point?

PA is not a proven sex offender.

MrsTerryPratchett · 11/08/2021 02:49

The difference for me is risk.

Sex offenders have a very high recidivism rate. I think it's the highest of any class of crime.

People who kill by dangerous driving don't.

Risk to the public is massively higher in the first case.

Pallisers · 11/08/2021 02:09

Your logic was all over the place.

You can't extradite someone to meet civil charges. Andrew is a piece of shit but no one in his position would be "extradicted" to another jurisdiction to meet civil charges. And he isn't accused of paedophilia.

Anne S was clearly a member of the CIA and was being protected under diplomatic immunity. Absolutely horrible for the family of the boy she killed but not the only case of it. And it happens in other countries too where someone gets out of jail free because diplomatic corps.

one is not the equivalent of the other and extradicting Andrew is a moot point anyway.

Still, if he even was indicted for a criminal offense - does anyone seriously think he'd be sent to the US to meet the charge??? I'd bet good money against that ever happening.

NumberTheory · 11/08/2021 01:59

*to me, not I me

NumberTheory · 11/08/2021 01:59

I agree that Anne Sacoolas should return and face prosecution. But if someone was talking about anyone being investigated for sexual assault rather than about diplomatic immunity in general, I wouldn't be bringing her up even if that person had diplomatic immunity.

Since Andrew doesn't have diplomatic immunity bringing up her case is a real dick move. I me it does seem like you are more concerned about some kind of tit-for-tat US v. UK thing than about systematic child sexual abuse.

LovePoppy · 11/08/2021 01:58

@VeniVidiWeeWee

One is a civil case, the other criminal.

What do people not understand about that?

Everything
VeniVidiWeeWee · 11/08/2021 01:51

One is a civil case, the other criminal.

What do people not understand about that?

Mamanyt · 11/08/2021 01:35

You were absolutely right, and we SHOULD send her back. And Prince Andrew SHOULD answer to those charges.

I'm fed up to the gills with diplomatic immunity from HORRID crimes, world-wide. There is so little accountability!

Bigballer · 11/08/2021 01:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Sparklfairy · 11/08/2021 01:33

@Why2why according to the OP, she said that too was unfair, keeping the two incidents separate but drawing attention to the double standard. So in answer to your question, unfair to Harry Dunn. Not because Andrew may be forced to answer, but because Anne still isn't. Theyre still separate.

Sparklfairy · 11/08/2021 01:28

@ElliottSmithsfingers don't be daft. Its perfectly possible to think Andrew should be forced to cooperate but also think that Anne should too, without holding one to ransom to get the other.

Why2why · 11/08/2021 01:26

Sparklfairy where is this so-called nuance in the OP’s post? It came across clearly as a whatabouterism.

If it was a debate about the perceived imbalance, the OP certainly missed the mark. In fact the OP said it would be unfair for PA to go to the US to face justice. Unfair to whom?

Every victim deserves to be treated fairly and that is not dependent on another victim in an unrelated case being treated fairly.

ElliottSmithsfingers · 11/08/2021 01:25

@Sparklfairy

No one doesn't depend on the other but what the OP said encourages wider debate about the imbalance with US-UK extradition.

If she said "we shouldn't send Andrew until we get Anne Sacoolas" that would be different.

Its a nuance in language that the OP's friend completely missed.

Classic deflection tactic / whataboutery. Hardly an example of nuanced discourse!