Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disgusted with the GP.

256 replies

Daisymae15 · 10/08/2021 19:27

This is not a bashing the NHS thread we are so angry with the GP.

My Mil 92 is in a nursing home last Thursday she had a minor stroke the home called the GP and all she has done is send aspirin, wouldn't visit.
Yesterday she had a fall, banged her head, shoulder and back. Not injured enough to call an ambulance.
The GP was called yesterday and was supposed to phone, as of 7pm tonight she still hasn't rung. When WE phoned the surgery told that she is on the list to be called.
The home are frustrated at not being able to give anything stronger than paracetamol. We are frustrated because of covid we are not allowed to visit.
(Someone tested positive on Saturday so they have gone back in lockdown)
We feel as though the GP is hoping she dies so she doesn't need to bother. DH has spoken to the home and they have said that they are worried about her, she is in a lot of pain, very depressed and not even got dressed today. Last night she slept in a chair as she couldn't lie down.

As I have said I'm not bashing the NHS as in the last year I have had breast cancer and my treatment has been first class.(Not under the same surgery)
We can't change surgeries as each home in town has an allocated practice.

Is covid to blame or is it possible that she is a shit GP.

OP posts:
LemonRoses · 10/08/2021 22:00

Private nursing homes can set their own terms and conditions. Only in respect of financial arrangements and contractual obligations. The way care and treatment are provided are very strictly controlled through regulation and commissioning.

LemonRoses · 10/08/2021 21:58

I’m curious as to what treatment people would want the poor woman to have?
Surgery for a partially blocked carotid and a stay in a HDU unit?
Anti hypertensives that increase her risk of falls?

What treatment are people thinking she might benefit from?

You don’t need to go to hospital for pain killers or good nursing care. You are safer in your usual home. People in nursing homes have a typical life expectancy of under two years from admission. They are approaching life’s end and recognition of this allows for proper holistic palliative care.

Yellowmellow2 · 10/08/2021 21:56

@LemonRoses

Some real misconceptions about DNACPR forms.

In care homes now all residents should have a ReSPECT form completed on admission. Some are completed in hospitals, some by GPs. Certainly every resident in a nursing home should have one.

ReSPECT stands for Recommended Summary Plan for Emergency Care and Treatment. The ReSPECT process creates a summary of personalised recommendations for a person’s clinical care in a future emergency in which they do not have capacity to make or express choices. Such emergencies may include death or cardiac arrest, but are not limited to those events. The process is intended to respect both patient preferences and clinical judgement. The agreed realistic clinical recommendations that are recorded include a recommendation on whether or not CPR should be attempted if the person’s heart and breathing stop.

DNACPR does not require consent. It is a clinical decision made in discussion with patients or LPA. You cannot consent to treatment that isn’t offered. To attempt resuscitation on a very elderly person in a nursing home would be cruel.

The idea of a ReSPECT form is to allow people to remain in their usual home. Transfer to hospital is rarely in people’s best interest by the time they need a nursing home.

It is entirely possible they are very good GP who has had the conversation with your mother in law. What would you expect from transfer? A long wait in a busy confusing environment, on a trolley? Far better to remain at home. What treatment would you want for a TIA on someone of her age and frailty?

Your GP can prescribe painkillers and the home should have stock supplies, so perfectly able to give without a pharmacy dispensing personal ones. Many Many GPs are working through calls at 7pm.

A resident in a nursing home isn’t going to be a top priority because they have professional oversight already. The elderly person at home would take precedence. The person with chest pain would take precedence.

This. Absolutely correct. Lying on a trolley in a and e should be the last resort. A nursing home should be well equipped to deal with a TIA.

My mum had a fall in her care (not nursing) home recently. They called an ambulance as it’s their policy for all falls. The paramedic phoned me at home to say she’d fallen and that they’d done all the checks and she seemed ok - just a bit sore and bruised. They said they could take her in but a and e was overflowing and she’d get better care where she was. I didn’t hesitate to agree that she should stay put.

DamnUserName21 · 10/08/2021 21:55

@lostfrequencies

It was a condition to get into the care home to have a DNAR in place!? What the actual fuck?
Private nursing homes can set their own terms and conditions. To hazard a guess (I could be way off!!!) but they possibly implemented the DNR requirement for admission in response to covid (CPR being an aerosol generating procedure) to minimise risk to staff and other residents (and their liability!!)
LemonRoses · 10/08/2021 21:53

@Looubylou

Lemon Roses - it's a nursing home not a care home. There has to be a RN on duty. (Though I still question the decision making in this scenario, also the GP stating the covid status of another patient as a reason not to visit someone who needs assessment is negligent in my opinion).
No. In law it doesn’t actually need an RN. It needs sufficient suitably qualified staff to meet people’s assessed needs. Most would, of course require at least one RN but that’s not because of the name of the home. It’s because of people’s needs.

Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014: Regulation 18 Regulation says simply “Sufficient numbers of suitably qualified, competent, skilled and experienced persons must be deployed in order to meet the requirements of this Part.”.

BastardMonkfish · 10/08/2021 21:52

@LemonRoses

If a ReSPECT form has determined the ceiling of care, an ambulance will most likely not transfer to hospital for most things. A home calling an ambulance to transport a frail elderly patient against a clinical decision isn’t acting in their best interests. They are not providing good care by so doing.

Most nursing home residents would be offered a natural and dignified death rather than a ham fisted resuscitation attempt and inappropriate transfer only to die on the journey or with strangers in a busy accident department. Resuscitation on a frail 90 year old is futile.

It certainly doesn't sound from what the OP says that MIL is particularly frail or nearing end of life. Clearly if she's in a nursing home her health isn't brilliant but she needed and should have been given medical treatment. She should at least have proper pain relief and I doubt what she's getting tomorrow will cut it.

lostfrequencies · 10/08/2021 21:50

It was a condition to get into the care home to have a DNAR in place!? What the actual fuck?

frumpety · 10/08/2021 21:47

All this talk about DNACR shouldn't detract from the fact that there is a 92 year old woman who is going to be spending yet another night in a lot of pain. Is there anything that can be done to change that ? At the very least can 111 and the out of hours Doctors provide pain relief for tonight ?

Reallyreallyborednow · 10/08/2021 21:45

Why didn’t the home/you call 999 when she had a mini-stroke? They are often precursors to more serious events and need to be assessed by experts

Generally because dragging old ladies from their home environment, usually against their will, to wait hours for an ambulance, then hours on a hospital trolley in a&e, subjected to scans, tests and whatnot, then sitting on a ward, is not best care.

Many elderly are terrified of going into hospital because it’s well known that most don’t make it out again. They’d rather be in familiar surroundings. The issue is there should be policy in place to enable this, especially if there is a DNR in place.

TatianaBis · 10/08/2021 21:45

Oh missed update from OP. Well done.

lljkk · 10/08/2021 21:45

Just to say all the residents have a DNR in place.

I'm surprised a random relative would know that about "all" -- is that because it's a facility policy, they must all have DNR? Or only a handful of people so not many people to know about?

Looubylou · 10/08/2021 21:44

Lemon Roses - it's a nursing home not a care home. There has to be a RN on duty. (Though I still question the decision making in this scenario, also the GP stating the covid status of another patient as a reason not to visit someone who needs assessment is negligent in my opinion).

DamnUserName21 · 10/08/2021 21:44

They only have one registered nurse for each shift otherwise it's HCAs. This home has 60 patients.

Yowzers!! I do hope the home is split into units and the RN just works on the nursing unit (the unit for residents with nursing needs....)

sleepyshiftworker · 10/08/2021 21:43

This issue does not lay with the GP the home has a duty to provide care and that right now is in the form of an ambulance.

EspressoDoubleShot · 10/08/2021 21:42

@Pixie2015

Also DNAR in England do not need to be signed by family they are a medical decision
Yes that’s correct Good practice is a discussion and formally record the decision
TatianaBis · 10/08/2021 21:42

With a suspected minor stroke, MIL needs to be assessed. They can be precursors to more major ones. Anticoagulants such as warfarin or rivaroxaban may be more appropriate than aspirin.MIL can’t be fully assessed without tests.

Soontobe60 · 10/08/2021 21:41

@Daisymae15

DH is on the phone to the home now. Just to say all the residents have a DNR in place.
I don’t see how you can know this. Their private medical notes are just that - private. Do you actually know what happens if someone is resuscitated? It’s brutal, usually unsuccessful and where successful can lead to severe injuries.
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 10/08/2021 21:41

@LemonRoses

Some real misconceptions about DNACPR forms.

In care homes now all residents should have a ReSPECT form completed on admission. Some are completed in hospitals, some by GPs. Certainly every resident in a nursing home should have one.

ReSPECT stands for Recommended Summary Plan for Emergency Care and Treatment. The ReSPECT process creates a summary of personalised recommendations for a person’s clinical care in a future emergency in which they do not have capacity to make or express choices. Such emergencies may include death or cardiac arrest, but are not limited to those events. The process is intended to respect both patient preferences and clinical judgement. The agreed realistic clinical recommendations that are recorded include a recommendation on whether or not CPR should be attempted if the person’s heart and breathing stop.

DNACPR does not require consent. It is a clinical decision made in discussion with patients or LPA. You cannot consent to treatment that isn’t offered. To attempt resuscitation on a very elderly person in a nursing home would be cruel.

The idea of a ReSPECT form is to allow people to remain in their usual home. Transfer to hospital is rarely in people’s best interest by the time they need a nursing home.

It is entirely possible they are very good GP who has had the conversation with your mother in law. What would you expect from transfer? A long wait in a busy confusing environment, on a trolley? Far better to remain at home. What treatment would you want for a TIA on someone of her age and frailty?

Your GP can prescribe painkillers and the home should have stock supplies, so perfectly able to give without a pharmacy dispensing personal ones. Many Many GPs are working through calls at 7pm.

A resident in a nursing home isn’t going to be a top priority because they have professional oversight already. The elderly person at home would take precedence. The person with chest pain would take precedence.

All of this. I'm a GP; I started work at 8 am this morning, and I still have 213 documents and medication requests to go through and action before I finish (before anyone asks, I am reading MN while I take 10 minutes to eat supper). Two of my colleagues are off with Covid. There are no locums available.

I need to prioritise the patients in greatest need. I would expect someone in a nursing home to receive proper care after a fall without needing intervention from me. The callback request on the GPs' list probably says something like "review painkillers" so the GP probably thinks it is a routine medication issue and has no idea that your mother is in distress.

Daisymae15 · 10/08/2021 21:40

DH has persuaded the home to call for an ambulance after a lot of pressing from him. They are going to call him when it gets to the home.
Re the DNR all the residents do have one in place. It was a condition to get in the home last April.
This was told to Mil as she has full mental capacity.
We both have POA for health in place.
They only have one registered nurse for each shift otherwise it's HCAs. This home has 60 patients.
Regarding registrating for another surgery. 5 homes in town and 5 surgeries so it was decided that each surgery would take all patients in one home.
This is something that happened from covid.

OP posts:
FixTheBone · 10/08/2021 21:39

@MorganKitten

DNRs must be signed by family or this is worked out when you create the care plan. Ambulances are called at the care homes discretion.
They definitely don't need to be "signed by the family"

It's good practice to involve family in discussions and to record that discussion, some forms even have a space where the family can sign to say they were consulted but it's not a legal requirement. Some institutions could mandate this as a local policy, but I've never worked in one that has.

Resuscitation is like any medical treatment, it should only be provided when it is appropriate and stands a good chance of working. No patient, competent or otherwise, and definitely not their family even with an LPA can compel a healthcare practitioner to provide an inappropriate or futile treatment. No different to someone going to their GP and demanding a antibiotics for a viral infection, arsenic for covid or a heart transplant for an ear infection...

OrangeSharked · 10/08/2021 21:38

I would have thought the majority of patients in a nursing home would have DNR, this is entirely appropriate. However I dont think you can be privy to everyone's medical records. She is 92, requires nursing home care, had a recent TIA. CPR is unlikely to add anything to her life

However DNRdoes not mean do not treat. If the fall has caused pain severe enough to need more than paracetamol then Ibwould have thought A&E was appropriate. Even if just to assess, images to know exactly what's going on so it can be prescribed for appropriately

Luckymummytoone · 10/08/2021 21:38

I’d be putting a complaint in about the nurses to be honest. They have a duty of care. And as pp said just because a DNAR is in place doesn’t mean you can neglect and not provide basic nursing care for patients. I really hope she’s ok and gets seen properly soon! X

Wam90 · 10/08/2021 21:36

I’d definitely be more annoyed at the nursing home than the GP. Unless she has an advanced care plan in place then they should be calling an ambulance. They surely don’t have a policy that says that they have to wait for a GP to authorise the need for one! I hope your MIL is okay.

LemonRoses · 10/08/2021 21:35

@reesewithoutaspoon

A nursing home is only required to have 1 nurse on duty for legal reasons. The bulk of the actual care is done by carers
No. A nursing home in England is required to provide sufficient, suitably qualified and experienced staff to meet the needs of the people receiving care. That has to be properly assessed based on numbers and complexity of needs. In a small home it might be one RN, but in bigger homes or where people have more complex needs it would be more. NI, Scotland and Wales have similar legislation but specify numbers. .
TatianaBis · 10/08/2021 21:34

I had elderly aunt in very good care home until she died recently. There’s no question they would have called an ambulance for both events.

  1. DM should have been sent to hospital after the TIA and after the fall. The two things may be related.
  1. Don’t bugger about with the GP or the home, call the ambulance yourself, tell them you’re concerned she’s not getting appropriate care, then call the home and notify them one will be arriving.
  1. While legally a DNR order does not need consent of the patient or family, good GPs and care homes do not put them in place without the family’s agreement.
Swipe left for the next trending thread