Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there needs to be a different way to test young kids

36 replies

Fifimoomon · 10/08/2021 18:43

DS (2.5) has a cough, again. So got a PCR test booked, again. It's the third one in the last four months. He's at nursery so is constantly picking up bugs and getting temperatures and coughs. He absolutely hates it, we have to pin him down and swab his nostrils while he cries his eyes out. The poor sod now cries whenever we even walk past the test centre.

I have tried and tried with him this evening with a swab, trying to get him to do it himself or let me do it, but he grabs it, licks it, will stick it up his nose but only for a second (and then grabs it again anyway). So pinning him down is the only way.

Surely we can come up with something better for young kids? Salvia tests? My poor kid is going to be permanently traumatised if we have to do this once a month forever!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bunnycat101 · 10/08/2021 22:35

I’d hope they could make it easier. My 5yo is somewhat traumatised but my toddler has been ok thus far. But, trying to shove a stick down a child’s nose in a car when everyone is stressed and there is no space doesn’t make for a good experience.

Last time I had to do the toddler, my eldest was screaming at me not to hurt her sister. Last time I had to do the eldest it was a bloody nightmare. I think the thinner tests are worse. With the thick ones you could shove it up the nostril and it would at least get some snot. The thin ones seem to be harder work and more liable to be tickly/go wrong.

YoBeaches · 10/08/2021 22:26

Same here, 2yr old DD I think we just did test 7 or 8 yesterday in the last year. I have made it into a game to tickle her throat and let her do it on me too, then I get one sweep up the nose which she hates. But she now finds it funny and will ask to 'do testing do testing' how sad.

My main concern is quality of the swab as her nursery closed last week due to an outbreak, she spent at least one day with the kid who had it, in nappies putting paint over each other, and on day 5 she came down ill, temp, cough, complaining of 'taste' and now snotty nose (she's not very verbal yet) and off her food etc but both PCR and lateral flow are negative. I'm struggling to make sense of that given the apparent ease of transmission and the proximity and duration she was exposed. Kid was symptomatic on the day too, sent home with a cough.

They have to find a different way.

Polkadots2021 · 10/08/2021 22:14

@Fifimoomon

DS (2.5) has a cough, again. So got a PCR test booked, again. It's the third one in the last four months. He's at nursery so is constantly picking up bugs and getting temperatures and coughs. He absolutely hates it, we have to pin him down and swab his nostrils while he cries his eyes out. The poor sod now cries whenever we even walk past the test centre.

I have tried and tried with him this evening with a swab, trying to get him to do it himself or let me do it, but he grabs it, licks it, will stick it up his nose but only for a second (and then grabs it again anyway). So pinning him down is the only way.

Surely we can come up with something better for young kids? Salvia tests? My poor kid is going to be permanently traumatised if we have to do this once a month forever!

Drives me nuts, in some European countries they test school kids two or three times a week and the kids do their own tests before handing it back to the teacher to be analysed/checked/whatever. I read somewhere kids as young as 5. They're different tests too, doesn't have to be PCR. Probably a combination of Brexit and an incompetent govt have left our poor kids with the short straw.
Combustablecustard · 10/08/2021 22:14

Completely agree. Took dd this afternoon- prepped her in advance (shes had one before and was ok, unpleasant but okay). Problem is shes not well (obviously!) So is hysterical anyway and she just lost it, screaming, shouting, pushing me away. Ive swabbed something, no idea if it was what they wanted. If this is something we need to live with then agree this needs to change.

Fifimoomon · 10/08/2021 22:10

I think isolating would be as horrible for him as the test. We live just me and him in a small top floor flat, he would hate being stuck inside for ten days. If we did isolate instead of test, we would have spent 30 days at home in the last four months.

Plus, I have to work!

OP posts:
whatsmybabysname · 10/08/2021 22:02

I parked my car on a fairly empty car park, just to go to the shops and my 4 year old DS looked out of the window and started crying that he didn't want a nose test!!! He clearly thought we were at a drive in test centre (again) all the tests have definitely traumatised him.

Treaclepie19 · 10/08/2021 21:53

My son hates it too. He's older so I have explained and he goes along with it (with a bribe)
If he didn't and I was able to I'd just isolate because it's awful. It's like you say, its not a short term thing and it's too often for them to not get worried about.
He's always been fine with blood tests and things and we've never been a family to let him opt out but yeah, it's still not nice.

Jacketpandbeans · 10/08/2021 21:53

Yes, I completely agree there needs to be an easier method to test young children. Maybe when Boris has to do a PCR on his son he'll realise what a challenge it is to test young children and the government will order some of the lolly tests!!

RealHousewifeOfEastLondon · 10/08/2021 21:44

Have commented on previous threads and absolutely agree. My four, almost five year old daughter is now petrified of "that stick thing" and I have also had to restrain her to test her. She screams and cries and no amount of bribery of chocolate or time in the ipad makes any difference. It's barbaric and I dread her going to school and having to do it more frequently.

Also massively disagree with suggestions up thread of testing while asleep. I have never and won't ever try this. Simply as I think the shock of waking up with "that stick thing" up her nose and her privacy, safe sleep space broken, would result in screams that could be heard worldwide.

LividLaVidaLoca · 10/08/2021 21:29

There’s no way the last couple of PCRs done on my toddler could have been anything other than useless.

I’m not doing them again unless I REALLY have to. The result comes back negative after it’s barely been near his nostril so what’s the point? He was so distressed despite all my best efforts.

I’ve also seen an HCP in hospital do one on a low-risk adult patient and it was frankly equally shit. Not sure if it was lack of care/lack of training or what but I’d be very surprised if it was enough to detect anything but the most virulent case.

camelfinger · 10/08/2021 21:24

Definitely. Surely there must be loads of positive results missed using this method. All feels pretty pointless.

Sirzy · 10/08/2021 21:12

@Fifimoomon

Thanks Sirzy, sorry to hear that. You're right, I need to be calm and breezy. I always bring biscuits and chocolate for after, he does calm down after five minutes.
I often describe myself as being like a swan, calm on the surface but paddling like mad underneath to keep going
Fifimoomon · 10/08/2021 21:11

Thanks Sirzy, sorry to hear that. You're right, I need to be calm and breezy. I always bring biscuits and chocolate for after, he does calm down after five minutes.

OP posts:
Cardboardeaux · 10/08/2021 21:10

Completely agree. When they start to roll back the mass testing programme I hope they prioritise exempting under 5s from being tested. It feels like such an invasive procedure for little children, particularly as covid is so low risk for them in 99% of cases

Fifimoomon · 10/08/2021 21:09

whatswithtodaytoday that's interesting. I've been trying to do it for the set amount of time when I do it, my thinking is if I'm going to put DS through it I might as well do it properly. Maybe I'll do a quicker go tomorrow!

OP posts:
Sirzy · 10/08/2021 21:09

You can just tell him something like “it’s to test how strong he is” or even “to check if you need some medicine”

I get it’s tough, I have had to put DS tjough some horrible tests and procedures BUT a key part is as far as the child is concerned staying nice and calm and positive.

Fifimoomon · 10/08/2021 21:06

Sorry to hear that doodlefare, I'm glad your boy is ok.

I think covid testing might be required for a really long time though.

OP posts:
whatswithtodaytoday · 10/08/2021 21:04

I completely agree, if there is an easier way it should be made available for young children. Mine cries when he sees the testing centre too. We have tried doing it when he's asleep but he wakes up immediately and thrashes around, it's no better than two of us holding him down.

However, we were recently in hospital with him and were tested on admittance, and the nurse did the fastest, most perfunctory swipe at his nose - I figure they must know they get enough in a couple of seconds to test positive, as they surely don't want to risk a Covid+ child on the children's ward.

Fifimoomon · 10/08/2021 21:03

It takes two of us to do DS, have to get his dad to come with us (we aren't together) and wrap him in a towel with arms pinned down and head held while I do the swab while he sobs. It's fucking horrible, and I can't even tell him it's to make him better like I do with other medical stuff like jabs. I was tearful myself last time.

I've just been googling salvia tests, you can buy them online, though they are expensive, but next time I think I'll try those. Just need to get him to practice spitting in a tube!! And save up Hmm

OP posts:
Doodlefare · 10/08/2021 21:02

I don't think it'll have long term effects, DS has had to have a load of medical procedures, and we had to restrain him for a while to administer his inhalers a few times a day. Admittedly testing isn't as essential as those, but it won't be forever.

butwhatcanwedo · 10/08/2021 20:55

I agree it isn’t ok to have to physically restrain children and force a stick up their noses. My youngest is nearly 3, it’s basically impossible to do the test. I really object to having to hurt her and I hope it isn’t giving her a long term fear of medical procedures

TheGriffle · 10/08/2021 20:53

There does need to be a better way. It is traumatic to have to shove a swab up their noses. Dd is 4 now and it took me over half an hour to test her with her screaming, thrashing and crying. There would be no way in hell I could get it to her tonsils as well. She’s a strong bugger and kept swiping my hand away when I tried to do it.

Sirzy · 10/08/2021 20:51

It takes seconds. It not nice but a big hug and do it followed by something tasty.

Chocolateemergency · 10/08/2021 20:50

I also tried doing it on my child whilst she was sleeping and she woke up as soon as it went up the first nostril. I felt like the screaming was significantly worse on that occasion as well.

Doodlefare · 10/08/2021 20:49

I order home tests and then just swaddle and go for it, not ideal but has to be done at the moment.