Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that women are being encouraged to expect too much from birth?

161 replies

Parsley1789 · 10/08/2021 18:19

Something I’ve thought about for a while. On Mumsnet today came across three threads in which the poster clearly feels very upset and disappointed with their birth experience and feels that they have failed. One poster refers to how her friends had ‘textbook births’ - the underlying belief clearly being that there is a ‘right’ way to give birth and that she didn’t ‘achieve’ it.
I am not blaming these women at all, I feel very sad for them. Early motherhood is hard enough without feeling that on top of that you are a failure for not having a water hypnobirth. I asked my mum about this the other day, she had two c-sections in the ‘80s, and she said that it never occurred to her to feel remotely guilty about it.

I’m not saying we should go back to women having no say or power over how they give birth, but I feel that Instagram/NCT/hypnobirthing etc all paint this idea that birth can be this wonderful empowering event when for a lot of people it’s just bloody painful and hard work and thank goodness for medical advancements.

For context, I did not have an easy birth with my first and found breastfeeding a struggle. I have so many friends who have felt like failures after birth, and it saddens me to see it on MN too. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HeddaAga · 11/08/2021 19:02

So much of birth is just random depending on your body and baby on the day and it's horrible that we try and tell women that if they do everything right they'll have a certain birth.

Couldn't agree more with this. And I do believe all practitioners should be really clear about this from the off. I also experienced a post-trauma mental struggle and I do believe if I had expected less, known more about how difficult and painful breastfeeding would be and more about the impact of severe sleep deprivation (with a v disgruntled baby) I'd have coped better. Instead I had countless cards and messages to look at saying 'enjoy the baby love bubble'.

JustLyra · 11/08/2021 16:15

I think one of the things that needs to happen is honesty about facilities as well.

My local hospital heavily heavily promotes their lovely water births that they offer. It’s a lovely beautiful suite, but they don’t actually mention that they have one. And they have such a lack of cleaning staff that it’s often used for a birth and then out of use until the next day because it can’t be cleaned properly…

The vast majority of women give birth in tiny rooms, several without windows, and often without access to epidural because there’s a shortage of anaesthetists in the hospital.

They also bang on about how important continuity of care is yet you don’t see the same person twice.

Yet the smaller hospital in the next town gets comments because their facilities are a bit less shiny, but they have a better staffing ratio, strong push continuity of care and are very honest about what they can and can’t offer. They’re a much better option imo.

toffeeandcream · 11/08/2021 14:04

I also belong to the birth trauma association group on FB with tens of thousands of women on it, all with a degree of trauma from giving birth.
Ime reading their stories, there is really a very small number (if any) that feel their trauma came from being fixated on the ‘perfect’ birth or having a rigid ‘whale music and fairy lights’ plan. Most of the stories involve poor and disrespectful care, an unnecessary lack of consent and dignity.

One woman whose story stuck out to me had actually had 2 very similar on paper elective c-sections. The first had been extremely positive for her, however the 2nd at a different hospital had left her with a degree of trauma- the care was poor, the same measures for dignity and privacy that she’d experienced before didn’t happen, staff were rude and disrespectful, things weren’t explained and consent wasn’t sought properly. She felt like a piece of meat through the process.

So again whilst I strongly believe in women having proper information before childbirth, I’m not convinced on the angle that a lot of birth trauma is down to women being fixated on ‘Instagram-worthy’ births.

Plumtree391 · 11/08/2021 13:56

Monday 26July: saw someone the other day tell a group of women that birth is no different to taking a shit, it's a natural bodily process
........
That made me laugh.

Of course it is much more than opening bowels. However I used to be very constipated, for nearly all my life, and when it came to giving birth I felt as though I had been doing it for years! So there is a grain of truth in it.

Hardbackwriter · 11/08/2021 13:45

Do people really say that about c sections? I'm so sorry if they do.

Personally I've noticed the opposite, both on MN and elsewhere, people saying that c sections are absolutely horrific to recover from so you should always opt for a vaginal birth as the recovery is much easier and you bounce back better. Which really bothers me tbh, as for many women a vaginal birth can take a long time and lots of pain to recover from, can leave permanent injuries, and zero bouncing back happens!

I've seen both. I think that's the really shit thing about the competitive birth thing, it's like the breast vs. formula battle (equally pointless) - both sides imagine that the other is getting all the praise and approval and feel hard done that they aren't, whereas in face everyone feels criticised. I've seen women on MN be very smug about choosing elective caesareans and epidurals and talk about how silly and brainwashed women who want vaginal births with minimal pain relief are ('you don't get a medal, you know'). I've also seen the holding up of vaginal with minimal pain relief as the ideal (less often on MN, tbh - that seems a much more Instagram thing).

The problem with MN as well is that different threads attract different posters - when people post saying they're scared of either a vaginal or a caesarean birth people will fill the thread with positive stories about beautiful experiences and being able to cook roast dinners and play tennis the next day. If the OP has themselves had a bad experience then people post about their own bad experiences, whether it's of vaginal or caesarean births. Any thread where the OP is weighing up which to have attracts evangelists on both sides.

Makingnumber2 · 11/08/2021 13:41

I had similar experience to you @Anchoredowninanchorage
Did a lot of reading- Ina May, Milli Hill, Naomi Wolf and NICE guidelines stuff, attended NCT classes that looked at all types of birth and I made a birth preferences sheet for all scenarios e.g my ideal birth, induction, EMCS. I also did a hypnobirthing audio book which did wonders for my anxiety.
I am quite shocked by some comments on this thread which seem to imply women wanting to make choices where they can about their birth experience are selfish or woo or not putting baby first and only thing that matters is a healthy baby. I don't think that's the ONLY thing that matters- I think it's really important women aren't left with physical or psychological damage after birth and unfortunately this is all too common.
I also went into birth prepared for the worst and hoping for the best, knowing what complications may or could come up and happen but feeling empowered that I and my partner had the info and knowledge to give informed consent to any recommended interventions etc. I don't think doing NCT or hypnobirthing is 'woo' or 'fuckery' as others have said here. Horses for courses at end of the day.
I also think it's disgusting when women make derogatory comments towards other women about the type of birth they had- all birth is hard whatever way you've birthed and it isn't or shouldn't be a competition or battle between different birth methods. I think there is a lot about our maternity system which unfortunately is not conducive to supporting women to have more straightforward births e.g. pressure to undergo inductions, inducing women on wards with 5 or 7 other women where there is no privacy or escape from the sounds of others labouring etc., forcing women to jump through tons of hoops before agreeing to an elective CS- it all contributes to making a woman's pregnancy/birth experience that little bit less positive.

Monday26July · 11/08/2021 13:35

@BrilloPaddy

I had 2 vaginal births that were both horrific and left me traumatised and with long term complications from (I was badly stitched both times). Then I went onto have 2 C sections, 1st emergency and 2nd elective. I then went on to have serious complications with surgical adhesions, further surgeries and have had 20 + years of pain on and off. C sections aren't for the faint hearted either. I find the glib "oh get a section, it's so easy" comments on MN very hard to stomach tbh.

Giving birth is literally taking two lives in your hands and hoping for the best. And we should be more honest about it.

Do people really say that about c sections? I'm so sorry if they do.

Personally I've noticed the opposite, both on MN and elsewhere, people saying that c sections are absolutely horrific to recover from so you should always opt for a vaginal birth as the recovery is much easier and you bounce back better. Which really bothers me tbh, as for many women a vaginal birth can take a long time and lots of pain to recover from, can leave permanent injuries, and zero bouncing back happens!

I genuinely don't think there's an 'easy' or 'easier' way to birth, so much of it is luck and whether it goes well or there are complications. But I do feel personally like it was a massive shock when my recovery was so difficult and took so long, hurt so much, and left such permanent problems, when all I'd seen everywhere was how much better a vaginal birth was to recover from.

BrilloPaddy · 11/08/2021 13:26

I had 2 vaginal births that were both horrific and left me traumatised and with long term complications from (I was badly stitched both times). Then I went onto have 2 C sections, 1st emergency and 2nd elective. I then went on to have serious complications with surgical adhesions, further surgeries and have had 20 + years of pain on and off. C sections aren't for the faint hearted either. I find the glib "oh get a section, it's so easy" comments on MN very hard to stomach tbh.

Giving birth is literally taking two lives in your hands and hoping for the best. And we should be more honest about it.

Monday26July · 11/08/2021 13:10

@Eeeb

I think the pain level is underplayed, as is the helplessness, and there seems to be this bravado about making women go through unnecessary pain. If a person wants to labour without pain relief, then I respect their choice, but so many women who don't want to are pressured or coerced through lack of choice.

For example, I have endometriosis, so am familiar with severe pelvic pain. The midwife at the prenatal appointments tried to guilt me into not having an epidural. I made clear that I understood the pain level, and she backed off. I put on my birth plan that I'd like an epidural. They held off giving me one for hours just in case I might be able to do it without (spoiler alert: I passed out and took 2 infusions of epidural to come back).

Healthcare staff would never dream of making a person undergoing a major surgery do it without sedation, so why is it okay to do to labouring women, who need to somehow have the energy post-birth to feed and care for a newborn?

Yeah. The number of times I told a midwife I was in absolute excruciating pain, the worst I’d ever experienced, in absolute desperation, and was met with ‘I know love, it’s a bit uncomfortable isn’t it?’

It was actually terrifying. Before that experience I always thought if I was in a hospital surrounded by medics that if I needed help they’d help me. I learned differently and it shattered a lot of my sense of security and what I thought I knew about the world. It was like I was speaking English and they could only understand Russian or something. Total mind fuck.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 11/08/2021 13:09

@BlueLobelia

I had a birth plan for DS1 and when I got to the maternity unit I told my MW that i had it. She rolled her eyes and said that birth plans were just something 'they' make you do to keep your mind occupied. It was never looked at. Did not even bother with DS2.
That's appalling midwifery. She shouldn't be doing it.
Monday26July · 11/08/2021 13:08

TL;DR: by all means share 'positive' birth experiences. But acknowledge the massive role played by luck. Don't pretend that you had a specific birth because you tried hard enough and planned and prepared in the right way.

Monday26July · 11/08/2021 13:07

To be fair, when I had the 'writing the birth plan' session with my midwife, he was very clear about the fact that it wasn't a statement of what was going to happen, but rather an opportunity to discuss preferences and educate women on the possible interventions they may require ahead of time. It's a lot less terrifying if you require forceps or ventouse to understand what those things are ahead of time and understand that they might happen, than to suddenly have them offered to you without knowing what they are. Ditto in terms of there might not be the time to thoroughly explain the risks and benefits of those in an emergency situation without endangering the baby. The birth plan was to express preferences where possible but obviously that's as far as they go.

I agree with you altogether though. There's a massive industry set up to promote the idea that if you do everything right, you'll have a specific type of birth. It appeals to women because the reality, the fact that birth is actually a pretty brutal, dangerous and unpredictable process, is difficult to swallow. So they flog you massage, breathing techniques, with the suggestion that it'll equip you to have the birth you want.

A friend of mine is super into the whole natural, attachment parenting thing, and ended up with an epidural, to this day she talks about how she 'had no choice' and 'had to have it' or her body wouldn't have relaxed enough for the baby to make it out or something. It's so sad that she feels she has to justify why she had an epidural, as if it's the worst thing in the world and some kind of failure.

I had a horrific birth, a five day induction followed by 13hr of intense, 100/10 contractions due to the induction meds, totally unmedicated because they refused to give me anything as I wasn't dilated, followed by an epidural, baby in distress, ventouse, episiotomy, stitches, a permanent birth injury and long and painful recovery. I have had women tell me it would have gone differently if I'd just relaxed and trusted my body. I mean, I was pretty relaxed other than the 13hr of unmedicated contractions (which I have PTSD from :( ), I felt safe and secure in a hospital environment surrounded by trained staff and equipment and couldn't have been more chilled about birth, I was actively looking forward to it and ready to embrace it.

So much of birth is just random depending on your body and baby on the day and it's horrible that we try and tell women that if they do everything right they'll have a certain birth.

And on the same note, we need more honesty about breastfeeding, not just that it can be hard, but that it isn't always possible for every mother, and that a percentage of people don't produce enough milk for exclusive breastfeeding regardless of effort put in. That has traumatised me way more than the birth. Being an insufficient supply parent surrounded by people telling me that wasn't a thing and being gaslit into believing that my body would meet my baby's needs, when in actual fact he was starving in front of us and came very close to brain damage and requiring a full blood transfusion.

I saw someone the other day tell a group of women that birth is no different to taking a shit, it's a natural bodily process and if you're afraid of it it's just because you've been indoctrinated into that fear. Utter, utter hogwash, and an insult to the many thousands of women who die in childbirth every single year across the world.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 11/08/2021 13:05

@EvilEdna1

It is really odd to me that there is blame being placed on antenatal education providers (of which NCT is just one of many) and women themselves for crap birth experiences.
Just read that and found myself nodding. There are loads of different antenatal education classes out there and why is it their fault if the woman doesn't have the birth she wants? I have done both NCT and NHS classes. My NCT mentioned caesarean, induction and pain relief. The NHS classes were really badly organised and the best bit was seeing the rooms where you birth. They also got out a set of forceps and scared the living daylights out of us. I've just looked on the NCT website and they mention all forms of intervention. There are a lot more caesareans and inductions over the last 10 years. That's not the fault of the education classes, it's the state of our NHS. If women choose a provider who doesn't acknowledge that birth has become more complicated in the last 10 years or only choose just to do the hypnobirthing bit that's down to the women - surely if you're spending money to prepare you make sure that the provider is qualified and balanced? Looking at my own family, maybe spend more time researching and getting informed rather than planning the colour of the nursery and ridiculously priced pram that the baby doesn't even care about (or probably need for months).
Skybluepinkgiraffe · 11/08/2021 13:00

@PJday41

I agree, it is women putting pressure on themselves. On here today a women wanted to read positive birth stories only. She did not want to read the truth that a large number of women experience when giving birth.

I had a traumatic birth with my first child and an emergency c section. I had a planned section with my second and still had a crap time at the end of it TBH. I'm honest with people who ask for my story. There are people who want to judge me for having c sections and they're entitled to their opinion. I know my eldest child would have died without it.

I don't think it's coincidence that there seems to be a push towards natural births with less intervention at a time that there are being huge cuts made to the NHS.

I agree
LittleMysSister · 11/08/2021 12:56

Maternity provision and care in the UK is dire. The attitude to women is horrific (what other major abdominal surgery would you ever leave hospital with two paracetamol for?) and unfortunately other women are often very much part of the issue

10000000000% agree with this. It's unbelievable the way women are treated during and after birth. Absolutely appalling that we are expected to just pick ourselves up and get on with it after suffering the most painful, exhausting, and often traumatic experiences of our lives.

Any kind of surgery and you are expected to take it easy after, look after yourself, don't do this and that for a few weeks, but giving birth or having a C-section you should just be able to cope.

JustLyra · 11/08/2021 12:50

@SheABitSpicyToday

I’ve never understood it. For me, birth is about safely delivering a baby, not about what the mother wants. I don’t agree with home births and all the other stuff where the baby’s safety isn’t top priority. I think it’s selfish.
If you’re all about baby’s safety why would you ban something that’s statistically safer?

I had home births for my last two pregnancies because it was safer than the absolute shambles of my local maternity hospital.

In my case, straightforward pregnancies, being attended by one midwife from the start of established labour and then a second for the birth, neither of them focussed on a dozen other women was much safer than giving birth in a room with my DH ready to catch the baby while MIL tried to get one of the few overworked midwives on the ward to come in.

Women should have good, educated, choices about births. They should be given the choice of well staffed and well equipped hospitals and the option of the likes of home births.

Maternity provision and care in the UK is dire. The attitude to women is horrific (what other major abdominal surgery would you ever leave hospital with two paracetamol for?) and unfortunately other women are often very much part of the issue.

TotoAnnihiliation · 11/08/2021 12:35

Pregnant women are bombarded with information on how to make their birth 'a textbook birth.' We are told breast is best, try and move during labour, have a birth plan etc.

However, the reality never reflects these textbook scenario. Babies don't read the manual. I think everything should be fully explained to women with the expectation or expect the unexpected and the medical profession will do their best to support you.

My birth experience was traumatic, a prem and breech birth that could have killed both of us if I hadn't of been in the hands of an excellent medical team. I couldn't fault the kindness and the care of the delivery team.

The care when I arrived on the ward a few hours later to the moment I left a week later was awful. Meds were forgotten about, I had conflicting advice on how to care for my baby, berated for not breast feeding despite not having any milk come in. All of this on top of being in shock.

I really feel that the whole maternity experience needs to be reviewed, too many women are being let down.

LittleMysSister · 11/08/2021 12:27

I think the main thing for me is that the reality of birth isn't really apparent until you look into it, which is likely what drives expectations. You rarely see any 'problems' included in the portrayals of childbirth in TV and film, unless it's in an actual medical drama.

I genuinely believe most women expect it to be horrifically painful and take a long time, but that's it. They don't expect potentially lifelong problems from tears or prolapses, or all the other things that can go wrong. That info just isn't pushed out. It's there to find when you look into it but it's not widely disseminated.

ExpressDelivery · 11/08/2021 12:26

An acquaintance of mine has been posting her pregnancy on FB. She's a fitness instructor and has been running and lifting weights right through. She and DH, plus baby no 1 have been doing daily fitness classes on Zoom all the way through, she did parkrun the day before the birth and the implication is that if only mothers tried a bit harder they could all be just as "good".

The best bit is the labour was at home and so quick the midwives only arrived with 5min to spare so she had no gas and air.

Obviously I should be pleased for her, but...

Starlight86 · 11/08/2021 12:26

@SheABitSpicyToday

I’ve never understood it. For me, birth is about safely delivering a baby, not about what the mother wants. I don’t agree with home births and all the other stuff where the baby’s safety isn’t top priority. I think it’s selfish.
This is a fantastic example of being uninformed.

had you read the stats on home births for example you would actually see that they are SAFER than hospital births for second and subsequent births.
You would also know that there are certain factors that are taken into consideration when having a homebirth.

On the flip side i think its selfish that somebody doesnt become informed when they are carrying a baby.

beigebrownblue · 11/08/2021 12:21

Just wanted to post this about AIMS

It was helpful for me to r

www.aims.org.uk/about-aims

read the magazine when I had DD.

LaBellina · 11/08/2021 11:59

@Parsley1789 you indeed only hear the bad stories because often women need to vent and so these are the most shared.
I had a good experience giving birth to DS, I can honestly say that the midwife that took care of me was truly an angel, very kind, understanding and treated me with respect and dignity. There’s rotten apples everywhere but I really hope you’ll get a lovely midwife who is supportive when it’s your turn. If not, don’t be afraid to ask her to leave, you’re the star of the show so to speak, you’re not there to be well liked but to safely deliver your baby in an environment as stress free as possible so don’t be afraid to ask for a change of midwife if you’re feeling uncomfortable with someone.

Movingsoon21 · 11/08/2021 11:39

Thanks @Parsley1789 that is helpful to remember x

Parsley1789 · 11/08/2021 11:27

@Movingsoon21 I’m sorry if this thread has scared you, please remember that you tend to only hear about the really difficult births, or the really straightforward water hypnobirths. I think for most women, the truth is somewhere in the middle. Hard work, might need an epidural, might not, but generally ok in the end. And I found my midwives on the whole very helpful. They’re not there to be your friends, and I feel my NCT course perhaps suggested they were, but they were very professional and kind.

OP posts:
Movingsoon21 · 11/08/2021 10:23

*EMCS are quite common, I meant

Swipe left for the next trending thread