Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lying to friends about degree classification

84 replies

doctormusic · 10/08/2021 17:31

DS 21 got a 2:2 in his degree, he's recently been messaging some old friends from school, they've asked him about what he got in his degree. DS is a bit embarrassed about getting a 2:2 as everyone who he went to school with and on his course have been posting on Facebook how they have got 1st's and 2:1's. DS didn't know what whether to lie and say he got a 2:1 but said that he morally thinks it's wrong and it's not a good habit to start telling lies. DH has told DS that he's blowing it out of proportion, he can say he got a 2:1 if he wants to but he should not feel embarrassed in any way of getting a 2:2 and these friends he hasn't seen in at least 2 years and it really doesn't matter.

Is this something which DS has blown out of proportion?

OP posts:
TableFlowerss · 10/08/2021 19:18

I would just joke if he’s that bothered and say ‘Not as good as I’d hoped, but I suppose not everyone can get firsts…🤣’

No one gives a shit in the real world generally

icedcoffees · 10/08/2021 19:13

I agree, although it's getting the job first. Because so many get 2:1s these days it must be difficult with a Desmond.

I didn't struggle at all and now run my own business after 10 years in management at other jobs.

I suppose it depends on where you live and what career yo want to get into, though.

HmmmmmmInteresting · 10/08/2021 19:12

@icedcoffees

Well, saying you graduated with a 2.1 or a First would be a lie, wouldn't it

Well, of course @jimmyhill but I've never been asked.

The point is - he has no reason to lie. Once you get a job, your degree classification is pretty much irrelevant.

I agree, although it's getting the job first. Because so many get 2:1s these days it must be difficult with a Desmond.
HmmmmmmInteresting · 10/08/2021 19:10

@KingdomScrolls

I don't know anyone in real life who talks about their degree classification more than a year after they graduate, if these are people he doesn't really see much there's no harm in letting them think what they want and not correcting them. It's not like lying on your CV to get a job. I'm very surprised by a previous poster's comment that only five percent of her department get a 2:2 or less. Isn't that akin to half of A level candidates getting A's
I actually checked the stats yesterday because of a conversation I was having with my DC and it's something like 75% of people get 2:1 or above these days. We were talking about grade inflation because this percent was much lower when I graduated.

Anyway I agree that it's not talked about- I can't recall ever talking about my degree classification to friends. Your DS should just say nothing rather than lie.

lannistunut · 10/08/2021 19:09

Better to tell the truth and focus on the future.

If he lies, it will follow him around and weigh more heavily on his mind.

newnortherner111 · 10/08/2021 19:06

They are not worth keeping as friends if they respond badly to someone getting a 2:2 instead of a 2:1. I don't think your DS should lie.

icedcoffees · 10/08/2021 19:06

Well, saying you graduated with a 2.1 or a First would be a lie, wouldn't it

Well, of course @jimmyhill but I've never been asked.

The point is - he has no reason to lie. Once you get a job, your degree classification is pretty much irrelevant.

doctormusic · 10/08/2021 19:05

Yes DS was expecting to get a 2:2, that's the one thing he regrets because for DS to get a 2:1 was never a given and he was going to have to work hard for it but because the course he's starting in September he needed a 2:2 for DS feels that he tried not to stress to much when he was doing his assignments but looking back DS wonders if he took his eye of the ball a bit.

OP posts:
CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 10/08/2021 18:58

If he got into the course he wanted, then that’s all that matters.

So much snobbery on here. OK, I may have got a first in the 90s, but heck, I’d never do the head tilt to one side & say, “Well, it’s not very good these days”, as some posters have.

Getting a Desmond is great in his case, as it got him onto the course he wants next.

(Shhh…Don’t tell anyone, but as an employer I couldn’t give a monkey’s bum if it’s a 1st or a 3rd. It’s their experience - even as a hobby - & aptitude at interview that matters. Oddly, the only woman who really came a cropper at interview had an Oxbridge doctorate & was arrogant enough to think it made her the Second Coming of The Messiah. Yeah. Right. Nope).

Jerseygirl12 · 10/08/2021 18:57

OP was the DS expecting to get a 2:2?
I think lying to friends is okish as they’ll only ask once and then it’s done but it’s a slippery slope if he then starts believing the lie himself or lying when applying for jobs etc.

TerribleCustomerCervix · 10/08/2021 18:56

@FakeTanandProsecco

When I graduated everyone's degree award was listed in the Graduation handbook thing (sorry having a complete mental block about what it's called!) So it's pointless lying.
Same here when I graduated with a 2:2 back in the mists of time (2010).

Then when you were presented with your certificate all the firsts got theirs as a group, then the 2:1s, then 2:2s etc.

I don’t think many people would give a shit that he got a 2:2, but eyebrows would definitely be raised if he was found out to have lied about his results.

If these are friends that are likely to find out the truth, I’d tell one final white lie and say that his miscalculated his final results/ misread the letter or email and tell them his real result.

Zealois · 10/08/2021 18:53

I think it's fine to lie to friends as presumably they'll never find out and it really shouldn't matter to them. They'll move on and stop talking about it soon.

My DP got a 2.2 in his undergrad degree 6 years ago and he has a great job, which he's had since a few months after finishing uni.

I have a First in my undergrad and postgrad and when I also have a great job, my employer wasn't interested in my degree classification so I can't say it mattered that much.

Looubylou · 10/08/2021 18:51

Honesty is best policy - he could admit to being a bit disappointed not to have worked harder but also be thrilled to still be accepted on his next course. With the crap time students have had, he should be proud to have achieved that. When I completed a degree 10 years ago not 1 person got a 1st, some of us got 2:1 but most common was 2:2, and we were all already graduates in a related field! Everyone was juggling other responsibilities and priorities. Hopefully how he feels now will spur him on to pull all the stops out for his next challenge. Onwards and upwards🙂

Bollockstothat · 10/08/2021 18:49

I'm very surprised by a previous poster's comment that only five percent of her department get a 2:2 or less. Isn't that akin to half of A level candidates getting A's

5% is probably an over-estimate. This year, all our students graduated with a 2.1 or 1st. And it's not just my department or my university - I know it's similar at comparable universities elsewhere.

I really think the degree classification system should be scrapped altogether - it was always pretty shit and now it's completely useless - to work at all as any kind of indicator of anything you'd need to split the 2.1 and 1st classifications. Much better just to give students a percentage grade (and a class ranking where employers or masters applications ask for it).

Kanaloa · 10/08/2021 18:48

Of course if it’s the case. If he has had illness or difficulties then different case, but as you mention I presume he didn’t work as hard as he might have done otherwise.

Kanaloa · 10/08/2021 18:48

I wouldn’t lie. I would just say I got a 2.2, bit bummed out but at least I got on my course.

I would encourage him to hold onto that feeling he has of wanting to turn back time and do everything he can to get a better grade though, rather than just lying that he got a higher one. It might be that he can improve on his performance in this new course, sometimes it’s hard but we need to accept that it’s our own actions that have let us down.

PeonyTime · 10/08/2021 18:46

Dont lie, but you dont have to answer the question! He could just reply by saying hes got what he needed and is off to his MSC course in Sept.

nancydroo · 10/08/2021 18:44

I've experienced degree snobbery but not the classification on the university. The idea being that a third from Oxford is worth more than a first or 2:1 at standard uni. But then there are snobs everywhere so it never landed

FakeTanandProsecco · 10/08/2021 18:43

When I graduated everyone's degree award was listed in the Graduation handbook thing (sorry having a complete mental block about what it's called!) So it's pointless lying.

jimmyhill · 10/08/2021 18:42

@icedcoffees

I got a 2:2 and I don't think I've ever been asked about what classification it was, to be honest.

My CV just says I graduated from X university with a degree in Y.

Well, saying you graduated with a 2.1 or a First would be a lie, wouldn't it
BakedTattie · 10/08/2021 18:41

I’ve got a 2:1, graduated 12 years ago and don’t think anyone has ever asked what my degree classification is.

PJday41 · 10/08/2021 18:39

@MikeWozniaksMohawk

“It wasn’t as good as I would have hope but I got onto the course I wanted to do so I suppose that’s what’s important”

Honest without actually telling them his result, and focuses on the positive of him doing his next course.

I'd go with this.

I left university 20 years ago with a 2:1 and honestly no one gives a flying shit. Like all qualifications, a degree is just the next step now.

My DH left school with absolutely no qualifications and he is now more qualified and earns more than all the people at school who laughed at him.

Withgasoliiiiine · 10/08/2021 18:38

Yeah he should just not disclose it if he doesn't want. I wouldn't recommend lying though, it's always going to be a lot more embarrassing to be caught out than to get a lower grade than you'd hoped for and in a few years, he won't even care.

Bollockstothat · 10/08/2021 18:37

Oh that's great that he's got a place on the course he wanted. The result he gets on that will be more important than his undergrad result.

Tell him not to worry about what other people on the course have got for their undergrad degrees. If he's really committed to getting a good result on this one - and it sounds as if he probably is - then that's going to be a much greater help to him than whatever other people did or didn't get (and some of them will be lying anyway). Some of my best masters students are people who didn't do brilliantly at undergrad but are very motivated to do well at masters - and some of the worst masters students are the ones who got a 1st and think they know everything already, so never learn anything.

Really, though, he needs to appreciate that graduating at all this year is a big achievement and he should be proud of himself.

doctormusic · 10/08/2021 18:36

When I mean lie I'm only talking about friends not jobs or university or any other thing. What I think DH was trying to say even if you lied about his result those friends are not in DS's life anymore apart from occasional messaging so just telling them he got a 2:1 instead of a 2:2 is not going to be the end of the world. DH obviously would prefer DS to tell the truth but DS is an adult so it his choice to make.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread