Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lying to friends about degree classification

84 replies

doctormusic · 10/08/2021 17:31

DS 21 got a 2:2 in his degree, he's recently been messaging some old friends from school, they've asked him about what he got in his degree. DS is a bit embarrassed about getting a 2:2 as everyone who he went to school with and on his course have been posting on Facebook how they have got 1st's and 2:1's. DS didn't know what whether to lie and say he got a 2:1 but said that he morally thinks it's wrong and it's not a good habit to start telling lies. DH has told DS that he's blowing it out of proportion, he can say he got a 2:1 if he wants to but he should not feel embarrassed in any way of getting a 2:2 and these friends he hasn't seen in at least 2 years and it really doesn't matter.

Is this something which DS has blown out of proportion?

OP posts:
nancydroo · 10/08/2021 20:06

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

A few years back graduate schemes stopped hiring people with 2.2s. Probably a response to the big boom in graduates in the 90s, the elevation of less academically selective institutions to university status, employers were seeking to narrow their applicant pool. In response however, because employment numbers factor into rankings, universities now simply give out fewer and fewer 2.2 & below degrees.
Yep back in 2005 graduate programmes were mainly restricted to 2:1. There was some 2:2s but actually I had a 2:1 but I had crap a levels and couldn't get passed some application forms as my a levels were so rubbish
Bollockstothat · 10/08/2021 20:03

It does depend on the degree of course but performance is much much more than academic achievement

Of course it is, and I don't think most jobs need a degree at all. But if where employers ask for a degree, the one with the degree result that puts them in the bottom 20% is going to be at a disadvantage. Doesn't mean other things can't compensate for it.

Mreggsworth · 10/08/2021 20:02

I don't think any harm can be done lying about it.

I got a 3rd (7 years ago) and I'm doing well for myself.

bunnybuggs · 10/08/2021 20:01

it is all part of the grade/degree inflation which helps no-one.
when I graduated in 1970 (that makes me ancient!) only one person got a 1st (and he went on to become a professor). The rest of us got a 2.1 (or a 2.2 like myself). As others have said - no-one gives a stuff during your career about what degree classification you obtained - so long as you are intelligent enough to do the job.
When I started work in IT some of us were graduates, while others were school leavers or A level entrants we were all equal in our ability to do the job.

Similar situation with A levels - I obtained 4 - grades B,C,D,E and I had been clever enough to pass the 11+ and attend grammar school from a small village school. Incidentally those A level grades were considered good enough to get me into a good University

If most people get A or A* how will the best candidates for Uni or the workplace be identified.

HollaHolla · 10/08/2021 20:00

My first degree (Russell Group, Scotland) was a 2:ii in 1997. 🤷🏻‍♀️ In hindsight, I was too young, and was only 16 when I went to Uni; graduated at 20.
But, I got onto an MSc (overseas), which I got a Distinction in. This led me into doing my PhD in 2011, which I did alongside working in my Uni. (Still Russell Group, Scotland.)

I think it’s different now, in that now students get higher grades, as a classification no longer relies on your results from 7 exams in 10 days - and your dissertation, of course.

The year after me was the first time Edinburgh even did split finals, never mind any continuous assessment. I was gutted at my classification at the time, and almost didn’t go to my graduation. I messed up on two exams, which was enough to make me bomb down - I was predicted a high 2:i. How wrong could I be!

Anyway, degree classifications aren’t the be all and end all, and I think it’s more important to be honest; own it, and he’s gotten in to his masters programme, which is really to be celebrated!

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 10/08/2021 19:59

A few years back graduate schemes stopped hiring people with 2.2s. Probably a response to the big boom in graduates in the 90s, the elevation of less academically selective institutions to university status, employers were seeking to narrow their applicant pool. In response however, because employment numbers factor into rankings, universities now simply give out fewer and fewer 2.2 & below degrees.

lap90 · 10/08/2021 19:55

'old friends from school' - he really doesn't need to tell them much if not at all.

TwoLeftElbows · 10/08/2021 19:50

I can see your husband's point. There was a thread recently about the "say something interesting about yourself" icebreaker and so many people just said invent something ... Duh, can't believe that had never occurred to me before!

I'm not sure he needs to volunteer his degree classification to friends at all, but if he must I'd go with something like "2:2, a bit disappointed but main thing is I got onto the master's." But, see above, I'm a compulsive truth teller.

Bollockstothat · 10/08/2021 19:49

So much snobbery on here

It's not snobbery, it's realism. As with other commodities (and for employment and masters programmes, that's all a 1st degree is), value increases with rarity. When you graduated, about 10% of students got 1sts; now it's three times that.

But of course it only matters for employers who think it's relevant - if you don't then that's very lucky for some of your applicants.

I'd be impressed if you managed to hire a recent graduate with a 3rd, though - rarer than hen's teeth. I don't think my department has awarded a 3rd for at least 10 years. It's like a 4th used to be at Oxford.

TractorsAndHeadphones · 10/08/2021 19:46

Also to add - Id advise against lying because it’s a small world. You never know where everyone might end up.

3scape · 10/08/2021 19:45

It's kind of crazy. It's 1st 2nd 3rd. The 2:1 (which I have) i don't bother with
Stating as it sounds petty. I didn't do well enough to get a first. I think it's a bit much to then dance around saying it's not a 2:2.

BikeRunSki · 10/08/2021 19:43

When I graduated degree results were published in the national newspapers! And I really didn’t go to a fancy university!

TractorsAndHeadphones · 10/08/2021 19:41

@Bollockstothat

I didn't struggle at all and now run my own business after 10 years in management at other jobs.

Things were different 10 years ago, though - and even more different 20 or 30 years ago. These days, 80% of students graduate with a 2.1 or 1st (more than a third of all students now graduate with a 1st). That makes it harder for the people who don't, because why would you want to hire someone who performed in the bottom 20% of their year when you could hire someone who did better?

Most corporate graduate schemes require at least a 2:1. But it also depends on subject and university. As some take all years into account, some place a greater or emphasis on the final year (meaning you’re finished if you messed that up even with previously stellar results).

My uni placed an equal weight on 2nd and 3rd year , a bit on the first. It’s impossible to get a 2:2 in a humanities subject unless you did zero studying. People have done nothing but read lecture notes and managed a 2:1.

TableFlowerss · 10/08/2021 19:40

To add- Having a 2:2 doesn’t mean you won’t be able to do the job as well as someone with with a first. It could just mean that you’re great at academic writing!

Ivegotanewfridge · 10/08/2021 19:38

Agreed @icedcoffees

TableFlowerss · 10/08/2021 19:38

@Bollockstothat

I didn't struggle at all and now run my own business after 10 years in management at other jobs.

Things were different 10 years ago, though - and even more different 20 or 30 years ago. These days, 80% of students graduate with a 2.1 or 1st (more than a third of all students now graduate with a 1st). That makes it harder for the people who don't, because why would you want to hire someone who performed in the bottom 20% of their year when you could hire someone who did better?

Well I think it just shows that degrees are probably easier these days. Well, easier to get top marks in anyway.

As you say, things were different 30 years ago, but why is that, it’s certainly not because the students weren’t as smart.

Let’s be honest, it was only the truly academic then went on to university back then, until 1997, when someone decided everyone should go!

It dilutes it now and even saying you have a first isn’t as prestigious as it once was.

Ivegotanewfridge · 10/08/2021 19:37

because why would you want to hire someone who performed in the bottom 20% of their year when you could hire someone who did better?

We have people with 2:1’s, and Masters, working in a call centre. We have some C Suite with no degrees. It does depend on the degree of course but performance is much much more than academic achievement

BareVanilla · 10/08/2021 19:36

Advise him not to lie. His CV will be on linked in and surprisingly there lots of jobs that require a 2:1 or above. How will he explain his lying once he gets found out?

icedcoffees · 10/08/2021 19:33

@Bollockstothat

I didn't struggle at all and now run my own business after 10 years in management at other jobs.

Things were different 10 years ago, though - and even more different 20 or 30 years ago. These days, 80% of students graduate with a 2.1 or 1st (more than a third of all students now graduate with a 1st). That makes it harder for the people who don't, because why would you want to hire someone who performed in the bottom 20% of their year when you could hire someone who did better?

I hired people who had 2:2's as late as last year - it really didn't bother me what classification they got.

Whether someone got a 1st or a 2:1 (or not) is only a tiny part of whether they're worth hiring.

Ivegotanewfridge · 10/08/2021 19:33

What was his degree subject OP?

Christmasfairy2020 · 10/08/2021 19:29

What was the discipline in. My dh failed his disertation and only got an ordinary degree

Kanaloa · 10/08/2021 19:28

That’s true as a pp said, nobody will remember he got a 2.2 but everyone will remember if it comes to light he lied.

I wouldn’t look badly on someone for getting a 2.2 but if I discovered they had lied about it I would think a bit less of them.

Bollockstothat · 10/08/2021 19:28

I didn't struggle at all and now run my own business after 10 years in management at other jobs.

Things were different 10 years ago, though - and even more different 20 or 30 years ago. These days, 80% of students graduate with a 2.1 or 1st (more than a third of all students now graduate with a 1st). That makes it harder for the people who don't, because why would you want to hire someone who performed in the bottom 20% of their year when you could hire someone who did better?

GrrRightBackAtYou · 10/08/2021 19:26

@doctormusic

When I mean lie I'm only talking about friends not jobs or university or any other thing. What I think DH was trying to say even if you lied about his result those friends are not in DS's life anymore apart from occasional messaging so just telling them he got a 2:1 instead of a 2:2 is not going to be the end of the world. DH obviously would prefer DS to tell the truth but DS is an adult so it his choice to make.
But imagine the humiliation if they found out.

Someone would be very quick to say
“Hey, remember doctormusic jr said he got a 2:1? He never did. He lied “

I got a 2:2. I do remember feeling a bit gutted. No one in the real world has ever actually asked me tbh.

HmmmmmmInteresting · 10/08/2021 19:19

@TableFlowerss

I would just joke if he’s that bothered and say ‘Not as good as I’d hoped, but I suppose not everyone can get firsts…🤣’

No one gives a shit in the real world generally

Haha, that's a good idea!
Swipe left for the next trending thread