Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lying to friends about degree classification

84 replies

doctormusic · 10/08/2021 17:31

DS 21 got a 2:2 in his degree, he's recently been messaging some old friends from school, they've asked him about what he got in his degree. DS is a bit embarrassed about getting a 2:2 as everyone who he went to school with and on his course have been posting on Facebook how they have got 1st's and 2:1's. DS didn't know what whether to lie and say he got a 2:1 but said that he morally thinks it's wrong and it's not a good habit to start telling lies. DH has told DS that he's blowing it out of proportion, he can say he got a 2:1 if he wants to but he should not feel embarrassed in any way of getting a 2:2 and these friends he hasn't seen in at least 2 years and it really doesn't matter.

Is this something which DS has blown out of proportion?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HSHorror · 10/08/2021 23:58

Tbh employers considering all 2.1 good vs 2.2 bad is ridiculous.
Dp has 2.1 at what was a poly.
Ive a 2.2 at a uni. Different subjects different requirements to get in. Different numbers on course around 50-200. The standards were completely different. (And im sure mine vs oxbridge).

Anyway my 2.2 came after i was very ill and only sat 50% of finals and missed the last few weeks before exams too. Im not sure i would have done better however i was very ill so could have done even worse.

I dont think he should lie ive had coursemates at same company etc.
It's annoying it's so important to employers. And stupid really as i didnt get into company as grad scheme nor via interview (im useless at them) but ended up asa temp and was taken permanent within a yr and within around 2yrs was grad level anyway. Without needing to pretend to do stuff i cant do.
Other temps were similar and progressed right up.

Too much value is put on interviews though.

ErrolTheDragon · 10/08/2021 22:55

@Embracelife

Don't lie on social media. It will come back to bite you.
This. Employers may well check social media, and lying about your degree classification is an extremely serious matter. And it's a small world - you can't be 100% sure that at some point one of these old friends won't crop up in a work context.
EmbarrassingMama · 10/08/2021 22:53

@Happycow37

The snobbery on this thread Shock

I think unless you’ve had your whole academic life turned on it’s head by lockdown and learning online, you don’t get an opinion on whether a 2:2 is shit or not.

There’s people on my course who are academically gifted and can churn out A* essays no bother at all but our course is mostly based on a practice element (which didn’t go ahead) and these people will therefore be lacking in the skills needed to get a job once qualified.

I was flying high last year, on track for a high 2:1, possibly a 1st if I really applied myself and now, thanks to Covid and online learning, which for the most part has been wholly inadequate and incredibly inconsistent, I am now looking at a 2:2. But as I have years of experience in the field, I’m not worried about gaining employment once I graduate.

I don’t think your son should lie because it’s no ones business, he got onto his course and that’s all that matters.

And for what it’s worth, we’ve been told on numerous occasions that our degree classification really doesn’t matter and won’t be asked for at interview, it’s our real life skills that will matter once on the job.

This, 100%. I’ve been in my field for 12 years and no one has once asked what I got in my degree or whether I went to university.
EmbarrassingMama · 10/08/2021 22:51

He should tell them the truth. It really doesn’t matter but it will backfire if he’s found out. Also, his friends are arses if they react poorly.

Happycow37 · 10/08/2021 22:47

The snobbery on this thread Shock

I think unless you’ve had your whole academic life turned on it’s head by lockdown and learning online, you don’t get an opinion on whether a 2:2 is shit or not.

There’s people on my course who are academically gifted and can churn out A* essays no bother at all but our course is mostly based on a practice element (which didn’t go ahead) and these people will therefore be lacking in the skills needed to get a job once qualified.

I was flying high last year, on track for a high 2:1, possibly a 1st if I really applied myself and now, thanks to Covid and online learning, which for the most part has been wholly inadequate and incredibly inconsistent, I am now looking at a 2:2. But as I have years of experience in the field, I’m not worried about gaining employment once I graduate.

I don’t think your son should lie because it’s no ones business, he got onto his course and that’s all that matters.

And for what it’s worth, we’ve been told on numerous occasions that our degree classification really doesn’t matter and won’t be asked for at interview, it’s our real life skills that will matter once on the job.

Confusedandshaken · 10/08/2021 22:45

@doctormusic

DS is disappointed in his result, he still has got on to the course he wanted to do with a 2:2 but seeing most people on his course get a good honours degree made him feel like he wished he could turn back the clock and do everything he could to get at least a 2:1.
In a couple of years time it will be of no more significance than his GCSE results or his KS3 levels. What's important now is the next set of exams.
Embracelife · 10/08/2021 22:43

At least not aBout a qualification which employers will check

Embracelife · 10/08/2021 22:42

Don't lie on social media. It will come back to bite you.

Embracelife · 10/08/2021 22:40

@doctormusic

DS is disappointed in his result, he still has got on to the course he wanted to do with a 2:2 but seeing most people on his course get a good honours degree made him feel like he wished he could turn back the clock and do everything he could to get at least a 2:1.
So he can say

"I got a,2.2 but still got a place on xxxx course to do xxxx which is what I always wanted so I am so happy "

So 2.2 really does not matters how many of his 2 1 friends are moving on to what they want uo do?

smileandsmilessooooo · 10/08/2021 22:39

@54321nought

I've got a third, and always been totally upfront about it and have never been unemployed for a single day.

If I'd lied 40 years ago, I would have had to keep a careful lie diary, so I could keep up the lie to the lie-ees, and make sure they never met the people I had told the truth to....

Hmm

@54321nought I got a third too, no one else I know would ever admit that. Grin Must just be me& you then.
Waterfallgirl · 10/08/2021 22:32

I think honesty is the best policy, but in reality are friends asking him over and over about this ? After a few weeks surely it’s a non issue and to be honest will one 21 yr old really bother about another getting a 2-2? Don’t they all have better things to do?

NCwhatsmynameagain · 10/08/2021 22:30

@MikeWozniaksMohawk

“It wasn’t as good as I would have hope but I got onto the course I wanted to do so I suppose that’s what’s important”

Honest without actually telling them his result, and focuses on the positive of him doing his next course.

This. He shouldn’t lie. DH would be better helping him to reflect upon his mistakes snd their inevitable consequences, then learn to live with and accept them and just move on. Lying about something like this is not good for the psyche!
MushMonster · 10/08/2021 22:29

@MikeWozniaksMohawk

“It wasn’t as good as I would have hope but I got onto the course I wanted to do so I suppose that’s what’s important”

Honest without actually telling them his result, and focuses on the positive of him doing his next course.

I second this. When I graduated nobody asked anyone for their results, only whether they had finished their degree or not. And we celebrated together or wish luck for the next term exams. End of. Only myself knows my final marks, still to this day.
WellTidy · 10/08/2021 22:24

I am amazed that it is estimated that a third of all students graduate with a first.

I went to a pretty average (old) university in the 1990s and there were two firsts in my year of about 130 odd students.

When I did my masters degree at the same university, there was one distinction (the classification was distinction/pass/fail) out of 30 odd students.

I am just surprised at how different things are now. Proper old codger, me.

5475878237NC · 10/08/2021 22:22

I think it’s quite bizarre that your DH would tell your son to lie about his qualifications if he wants to.

^ I agree. You need to build up his self esteem if his role model is a man who thinks it's OK to lie to friends to not feel shit about himself. DH should be telling him that anyone who would judge him isn't a true friend.

TractorsAndHeadphones · 10/08/2021 22:18

@bunnybuggs

it is all part of the grade/degree inflation which helps no-one. when I graduated in 1970 (that makes me ancient!) only one person got a 1st (and he went on to become a professor). The rest of us got a 2.1 (or a 2.2 like myself). As others have said - no-one gives a stuff during your career about what degree classification you obtained - so long as you are intelligent enough to do the job. When I started work in IT some of us were graduates, while others were school leavers or A level entrants we were all equal in our ability to do the job.

Similar situation with A levels - I obtained 4 - grades B,C,D,E and I had been clever enough to pass the 11+ and attend grammar school from a small village school. Incidentally those A level grades were considered good enough to get me into a good University

If most people get A or A* how will the best candidates for Uni or the workplace be identified.

Lots of graduate schemes now do ‘first come first serve’. The first candidates to pass all stages get the job . It’s the stragglers who have to compete.

IMO less people should go to full time university and more into vocational courses or part time degrees. The majority of jobs don’t require degrees and ‘critical thinking’ blah blah blah doesn’t need 3 years of pure study to develop. In fact it’s possible to graduate by having a piss up and not having learned anything at all.

BananaMilkshakeWithCream · 10/08/2021 22:16

I got a 2:2 and I’m a bit embarrassed tbh. I avoid telling people where I can and if they ask I tell them it was a 2:1 😂 It practically was anyway, if my grade average had been something like 0.5% higher I’d have had the 2:1. Honestly, at the time it felt like the end of the world but 13 years later I don’t give a shit.

MereDintofPandiculation · 10/08/2021 22:11

@Bollockstothat

I'm very surprised by a previous poster's comment that only five percent of her department get a 2:2 or less. Isn't that akin to half of A level candidates getting A's

5% is probably an over-estimate. This year, all our students graduated with a 2.1 or 1st. And it's not just my department or my university - I know it's similar at comparable universities elsewhere.

I really think the degree classification system should be scrapped altogether - it was always pretty shit and now it's completely useless - to work at all as any kind of indicator of anything you'd need to split the 2.1 and 1st classifications. Much better just to give students a percentage grade (and a class ranking where employers or masters applications ask for it).

I graduated nearly 50 years ago, and at that time 2.2 was the bog standard degree, 3rd was below average, and Pass almost akin to a fail. About 10% got a 2.1 and one or two outstanding students got a first.

So yeah, from my perspective, the degree classification system is no longer doing its job. If students have got better over the years, then the standards should be raised across the board, and a higher mark required to get a 2.1 or a first. Same applies to A levels.

Katefoster · 10/08/2021 22:02

My husband got a 2:2 in dentistry, his mum calls it the drunken degree. He then got a place on a masters course to specialise in a field of dentistry. There's only 5 places a year for people in the UK and overseas and he got a place on his first try. Your son got a degree that's all that matters.

Daphnise · 10/08/2021 22:00

Do degree certificates nowadays actually show the class of degree?

As for lying about it, best not to.

Undersnatch · 10/08/2021 21:43

I got a first and barely anyone knew about it, it was never discussed other than close family. I always felt it made little difference and I’d never drop it into conversation as I’d sound like a dick! Are people actually asking him what he got or is he wondering what he should post on FB because that’s what others are doing? FB wasn’t around when I graduated hence no dilemma!!

crasscloud · 10/08/2021 21:39

He should definitely be honest about it.

The most important thing is he's onto the next stage without a problem. That's great.

However things do come out and it will seem a much, much bigger deal if it becomes something he lied about.

Perhaps he can work his socks off and get a Distinction in the next bit? Use this as fire in his belly?

TableFlowerss · 10/08/2021 21:36

@Lonelylooloo

I graduated in 2019- mature student

The guardian reckoned about 30% of students graduating my year for first class with a further 50% getting 2:1’s

Most grad schemes won’t take you with less than a 2:1 now. In my honest opinion it’s not worth going to uni for a 2:2 nowadays and I’d be disappointed if I’d got that or my kids did. I can fully empathise with why he doesn’t want to tell them but they’re gonna know when he doesn’t answer right away. People who get firsts or 2:1’s are usually very wiling to tell you so

Whilst I agree in part with what you’re saying, it could be argued (I remember using that phrase during my assignments a fair few times 🤣) that what uni someone attended could be equally important, then the subject.

A 2:2 from Oxbridge in Maths, English etc…would hold far more clout that a first from a former polytechnic in a subject such media studies….

Whatinthelord · 10/08/2021 20:19

I guess my quandary is about whether lying is a useful strategy to develop to avoid embarrassment/disappointment or whatever other feeling is making him want to lie.

I suppose in the future they’ll be other things he will be disappointed about. Is he going to lie about that to friends too? When he’s 33 and hasn’t bought a house but his friends have, does he lies about that? Etc etc etc

I think maybe learning to manage situations like this without lying is probably useful to everyone.

Also I’m thinking the fact he lies to friends about the 2:2 will feel more shameful than the 2:2 itself after a month or two.

As you say though. He’s an adult so will make his own choice.

Lonelylooloo · 10/08/2021 20:14

I graduated in 2019- mature student

The guardian reckoned about 30% of students graduating my year for first class with a further 50% getting 2:1’s

Most grad schemes won’t take you with less than a 2:1 now. In my honest opinion it’s not worth going to uni for a 2:2 nowadays and I’d be disappointed if I’d got that or my kids did. I can fully empathise with why he doesn’t want to tell them but they’re gonna know when he doesn’t answer right away. People who get firsts or 2:1’s are usually very wiling to tell you so