Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your real advice about deciding to have a third child

417 replies

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 10/08/2021 13:50

We're at the point of deciding whether to ttc or not. I have a soon to be 4yo and an 18mo, same sex, in a three bed house with no desire to move house. Not rich (at all) but wouldn't consider us to be poor either. Both in stable jobs or as much as we know, but I did have health problems at the end of second pregnancy which meant I was off sick for the final few months (makes me nervous it was frowned upon), I needed c sections with both pregnancies. I'd love another baby but need to be sensible which is really tough! Had an early mc with unplanned preg back in Feb Sad

Can you share your experiences please. Good and bad?

OP posts:
juliainthedeepwater · 11/08/2021 09:22

For me, the climate crisis comes into play from a different angle to the usual impact of a third child on resources thing.. it’s more that I think the future is looking increasingly scary and increasingly expensive (I’m quite pessimistic about state healthcare continuing in its current form for instance) so really want to be able to support my current children as much as poss both financially and just as a resilient person. Think both money and resilience would be severely stretched by any more so we’re stopping at two. I know it’s a depressing reason, but there’s some depressing news out there at the moment!

Onehotmess · 11/08/2021 09:19

@ and this is about OP. if parents can’t afford to send them, they can go to work apprenticeship or similar.

Stickytreacle · 11/08/2021 08:29

[quote Onehotmess]@ItsAllBlahBlahBlah i’m not saying it’s not sensible to plan. But why is everybody assuming that all three children will go to university. There are plenty of work-based training opportunities and university isn’t for everyone.[/quote]
I suppose because it would be good if your children had the choice instead of having to do work based training, which may not even be as readily available in 18 years time.

I think I a lot of the issues are that we tend to view things from our own perspectives, so we think about how we would feeling with tight finances, lack of opportunities, environmental factors etc. when we should be considering that the proposed child and existing children may feel very differently!

Bunnycat101 · 11/08/2021 08:29

You seem to be on the ‘Have a third’ end of the wavering spectrum and I’m on the stick at 2 end. Reading this thread made me focus on the reasons not to and agree with them whereas you sounded disappointed. I think that’s quite telling.

Im 80% sure we’d stick at 2. For me, things have just got a bit easier, I feel like I’m back on track with work and we’d like to do private school later down the line which wouldn’t be an option with 3. The biggest thing for me though is attention. I already feel bad that my 5yo spends a lot of time in wrap-around. I feel torn with 2 a lot of the time and wouldn’t want to add a third.

user97495 · 11/08/2021 08:27

In the end I just had to follow my head and think about the children I already had. We have a 4 bed house and good income but we'd go from being comfortable to "a bit more stretched". We have a good quality of life, I genuinely believe my children gain more from what we can provide them financially and emotionally divided by 2 than an additional sibling would give them at the cost of having our resource divided by 3. When I thought of it mathematically like that, the decision was easy and I knew I shouldn't do it. If I was more time and money rich, I would consider it more. But it's the time element I was very mindful of, being able to be a present parent but not to the detriment of my own mental well-being, I still value time to myself and with my husband, which would be that much harder with 3.

behindhereyes · 11/08/2021 08:13

I have 3, and I I love it! I felt that 2 was too "neat and tidy" and I needed a third to have a proper big family feel. I completely understand that others don't have that feeling or need but we did. Both me and my husband came from bigger families so our feelings probably came from that. I sincerely believe that the more there are the more love there is, it just multiplies. Money, space and all the concerns just become part of life and seem so insignificant compared to the third wonderful child you have.

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 08:09

He might not be joking but it comes across that way, we're yet to have a chat about it so I can't answer 110%. I'm not trying to sway him in any way, I'm trying to work together to come to the best decision for all of us. This thread has been really helpful to highlight a few things.

OP posts:
Summergarden · 11/08/2021 08:04

Having our 3rd was definitely a tipping point for us.

I found having 2 pretty much a doddle and people said that having one more wouldn’t make much difference. Wrong! So much extra to think about in terms of practicalities- immediately had to buy a bigger car= more expense. Personally no way would I have gone for it if we didn’t have 4 bedrooms as I’m an introvert and hugely valued a (small) private sanctuary away from my own 2 siblings as a child and it didn’t seem fair to have another child if I couldn’t provide them with the same.

Most significant of all though was that having a third was what made me feel I could no longer balance working with the needs of my larger family and I ended up quitting work. It wasn’t even so much the huge childcare costs for 3 as we are fortunate to have other income streams in addition to DHs job but the sense of needing to be around more with having an extra child.

Sorry but in your situation I’d listen to your husband and stick at 2.

Needapoodle · 11/08/2021 08:02

Is he? Because when people ask me when I'm having another they might think I'm mucking about because i make a joke of it. In reality im 110% sure i don't want any more.

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 07:52

@needapoodle no because he's mucking about

OP posts:
Needapoodle · 11/08/2021 07:43

DH has said to every one he can't handle more than two (in that manly sarcastic annoying down the pub way)

Doesn't this tell you all you need to know?

Needapoodle · 11/08/2021 07:41

Its clear that a lot of the people who are saying go for it have rather a lot of money. Able to put lots aside for university savings, investments, still able to afford holidays, able to upgrade houses and cars without too much trouble. Do you have that much money?

I've got two (twins) and i won't be having any more because we can't afford to put any savings aside, we have quite a bit of debt, and can't afford to move to get more bedrooms. It's seems obvious to me. The children we already have need the resources we've got (money, time, energy, space). Another child would spread them too thin.

Jerseygirl12 · 11/08/2021 07:14

I didn’t find having 3 DC particularly loud or expensive, it’s been wonderful.

Mistyplanet · 11/08/2021 07:10

We have 3 boys snd I've had 3 sections. We are happy with the decision. It is hard work but all my boys get on well. We currently live in a 3 bed too but one room is a box room. We are going to be moving to a 4 bed though. I think having 3 kids in a 3 bed might be hard if the rooms are small. Especially once they become teenagers.

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 07:03

Morning everyone Smile

Thanks @Violet1988 that would be helpful

@elfdragon DH has said to every one he can't handle more than two (in that manly sarcastic annoying down the pub way) but, he absolutely dotes on his two kids and he's very much one to notice a tiny baby and look as though he softens up when it's brought up. He has mentioned he's worried about the impact on my eldest who starts nursery school in September who obviously now demands a different type of attention (say sat a table practising writing for example as opposed to bundling about with toys on the floor with his little brother) I think he's worried we will be overloaded and loose more time 'just us' because we will be even more invested into the children (more time spent at bath time, more time at meals etc with a baby on top iyswim)

OP posts:
ElfDragon · 11/08/2021 06:28

I have 3, and I wouldn’t change it. I am also a single mum. Add in that all 3 of mine have ASD (one with learning difficulties too, which means they won’t ever be independent), and it’s certainly not the life I would have chosen, but I still wouldn’t change it.

I am fortunate in that finances are not a huge problem (although obviously different now that I am divorced).

I had 2 for a while before dc3 (6 year gap between dc2 and dc3), and for a while it looked as though dc3 wouldn’t happen and I really struggled. I’m sure I would have got over it eventually if dc3 hadn’t happened, but I just wanted to let you know there is sometimes that emotional side to it too. For many reasons (not least the difficulties brought by ASD) it would have made more ‘sense’ to stop at 2, but it was so tough.

I’ve never found it too difficult to find 2 bedroom places willing to accommodate the extra child for holidays etc - in fact, I need 3 bedrooms, as dc with learning difficulties can’t share, and whenever I search I always have to Wade through pages of ‘sleeps 6’ which aren’t actually suitable!

House wise, we do now have a house that is more than big enough, but when the dc were smaller there was a time when all 3 dc shared a room (for about 18 months) - bedtime was absolute chaos and carnage, but we got through it.

Car seats/car size can be a problem, which doesn’t end once they get bigger (top tip: if your dc play musical instruments, try to influence them into something portable! My three are out of car seats now, but I can’t downsize the car due to giant teenagers and impractical instruments that need ferrying about!

Logistics can be tricky: I’ve got 1 at primary, 1 at secondary and the third at a SN college. All in totally different directions. But then, for us, the logistics of SN have added far more complications than dc3 ever did (eg dc1 is 19 now, and cannot be left alone, so planning always takes place around that)

How does your DH feel about having a third?

54321nought · 11/08/2021 02:15

Having more then 2 children is the worst single thing you can do for the environment

KingofQueens · 11/08/2021 01:46

No, I wouldn't have my third if I could change it.
Obviously I love and adore her, but 3 is just so much harder.

Yumsnet · 11/08/2021 00:50

I know there are many different & important considerations to weigh up. However, just on a personal level, I was very happy with 2. But my third has made me even happier and brings me so much joy.
I’m an only child and love having 3 (even if I am always exhausted!)

OnTheHillNotOverIt · 11/08/2021 00:38

I have four but they are older now. I think it’s important to really think ahead as well as thinking about the practicalities of little ones. Parenting teens and young people can be tough in a totally different way to the noisy, messy, physically exhausting years.
I’m not saying to do it or not to.

I’ve seen smaller families spend loads on toys, clothes, multiple expensive holidays so I think you can claw some of the budget back. A cabin/caravan for 5 doesn’t cost much more than for four (if anything).

I wanted a third so badly it was like being hungry. I think some people definitely feel more broody than others and it’s a case of deciding when to stop listening to that feeling.

Parenting has been harder than I ever expected but I don’t think it was the number of children per se. Sometimes it does feel like a relay race where I’m worried about them in turn but now they are older they help each other out with their lives and choose to spend time together so no regrets (apart from the planet - not being sarcastic).

twilightermummy · 11/08/2021 00:23

Haha badg3r My house is also very loud! Grin

twilightermummy · 11/08/2021 00:21

I love my son with all of my heart, he brings me so much joy but, if I knew how difficult things would be (and I didn’t know him) I wouldn’t have had him.

My pregnancy was much more difficult. The first 2 were fine but then I ended up in hospital for a week with him which was just terrifying. He also has additional needs so that makes things more difficult. If you’re fortunate enough to have two healthy children the odds may decrease as you have more.

Things are very expensive particularly now that I am single. Holidays are lovely but a fortune as are extra curriculars.

You also just don’t have the same time to give any of them!

Bedrooms are a big hassle for me now as the younger 2 aren’t the same sex so eventually I may have to give up my room or extend.

These may be small things if my third was a walk in the park, but he isn’t unfortunately! God do I love him though.

falgelednl · 11/08/2021 00:15

I love having 3!
We created spreadsheets to check we could afford having a 3rd - childcare costs were the largest outgoing for quite a long time.
They are now 14,12 and 8 and I just live my family.
We are fortunate that we can afford what they need - large enough house and car, although the years when we employed a nanny were tight but that was not much more expensive than having all three with a childminder and gave a lot more flexibility (as well as some help in the house).
We’ve never had problems with holidays although tend to go Airbnb, camping or self- catering anyway. Yes we book two rooms in premier inn type places. Tickets to attractions include family of 2+3.
The house is the same one we bought pre-children. It’s just more full of stuff now but they all have their own rooms. It’s nit usually very noisy - but it can be! They get on really well most of the time - as someone else said upthread, number 3 brings huge joy to our lives!
As for the future, we will help them as we are able to. If they choose to go to university then we’ll help as much as we can. They will all get more help than my DSis will be able to give her two simply because our situations are different.
Environmentally, we don’t fly, we have just one car, we recycle and reuse, we frequent charity shops - but also accept that we provide our three a pretty fortunate up-bringing.

OP I don’t actually think anyone can answer this one for you. I don’t think there is ONE right number of children - ideally, you will be happy with whatever number you end up with.

badg3r · 11/08/2021 00:04

We have three. My third pregnancy was much harder than the first two. I haven't watched tv since March (Frozen doesn't count 😉). Our house is LOUD. My DH and I are chronically exhausted and spend most of our home life picking things up and putting them down somewhere else. But I really love having three so it is worth it!