Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your real advice about deciding to have a third child

417 replies

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 10/08/2021 13:50

We're at the point of deciding whether to ttc or not. I have a soon to be 4yo and an 18mo, same sex, in a three bed house with no desire to move house. Not rich (at all) but wouldn't consider us to be poor either. Both in stable jobs or as much as we know, but I did have health problems at the end of second pregnancy which meant I was off sick for the final few months (makes me nervous it was frowned upon), I needed c sections with both pregnancies. I'd love another baby but need to be sensible which is really tough! Had an early mc with unplanned preg back in Feb Sad

Can you share your experiences please. Good and bad?

OP posts:
hibbledibble · 11/08/2021 12:32

I love my third, but life is very expensive. The UK is designed in general for 1 or 2 children families, and everything with more is very expensive, including days out, holidays, and harder to do. Childcare costs are also extortionate. I worry how I will afford to support them through university and as young adults.

ZeldaPrincessOfHyrule · 11/08/2021 12:30

But @Ralph871, how can you believe that anyone and everyone could just "find a way to afford it"? That's such an irresponsible stance on something as massive as deciding on another child. Finances can and do force major decisions for families all the time, and while it's a shame, that's responsible parenting.

PattyPan · 11/08/2021 12:14

@cookofcastamar you can if you are a family of 4 in the middle block on a jumbo jet

cookofcastamar · 11/08/2021 11:59

@SummerSaladsAreBack unless you're a family of 3 you can never sit together in an airplane.

Ralph871 · 11/08/2021 11:57

@threerugrats

I'm one of 3. I have 3 children. Some of the replies have made me laugh, in a nice way.

Some of the issues some people fret about really don't need to be a problem (and reflect very middle class privilege/attitudes).

Things I considered as key were: childcare costs, more years doing the school run, car size (as both DH and I drive and we run a car). The first of those was the biggest consideration. The car size ended up being the least as we decided we'd want a 7 seater anyway for the primary school years for our first two children.

Numbers of bedrooms? I shared a bedroom growing up and loved it. Loads of my peers shared bedrooms with a sibling too. My children have a bedroom each yet sleep in one room together most of the time. The rest of the time two are in together and the youngest is in with me and DH! We joke we'd have been better off with just one giant bedroom. Yes, this will change as my children reach their teens but still.

Costs such as university, driving lessons, etc? Well, if I had just one child and was loaded I wouldn't be paying for all their driving lessons anyway! Do teens not get part time jobs any more? I live in a city with good transport systems. University- it's not a given all my children will want to go to university or have the ability. Plenty of students work part time or in the holidays. Who knows what the costs might be when my children are 18 and who knows whether I'd be in a financial position to even send one.

Food - I spend about half of what another poster spends! I foresee this being a huge expense in the teen years, but childcare costs will have gone.

Clothes, shoes, etc. I save and budget and my kids don't get hugely expensive stuff. Shoes at the biggest expense. Clothes - In my circle of friends clothes are passed on and, of course, clothes get passed down between siblings, lots of reuse. Teens will want more new stuff, I'm sure but if they each have slightly fewer items in their wardrobes than if I had two, then so be it! As long as they have enough.

Activities - yes, ferrying three school age kids around is a logistical nightmare at times. But I consider that we're lucky to be in a position to afford after school activities, etc. Each child doing slightly fewer activities than they would if I just had two children is an incredibly privileged position to be in really, isn't it? And they do the same as they would if I had two. My DH AND I spend less on ourselves and we lift share with other parents to ensure that happens.

Holidays? We tend to go for self catering, camping, etc type holidays anyway. Places are getting more flexible on family tickets but also it's not like days out for a family of four are cheap and then that fifth child's ticket is hugely expensive, is it? So we budget for the fact it will cost us, for example, £35 instead of £30 - more packed lunches for example.

If I had been worried whether I could genuinely afford to house, feed and clothe three children then I would have stopped at two. But that was never a concern, it's been more about how we budget and how much money I'm prepared to spend on a teen and young adult. And, for me, I won't consider my children to have suffered in any way or that I've failed to provide, if I don't pay for every single driving lesson they have or they have to find paid work during their time at university. I'll still consider that my children will have had a pretty privileged lifestyle, much more so than mine was!

And the joy my youngest brings to us all means more than money and means I could never think of saying to another parent "don't have a third".

What I would say is consider how much you can juggle, how much can you add to your mental and emotional load of the logistics, and practical care of being a parent of three, how much attention can you give them all, and how would you cope if they don't get on? That all matters far more than anything else.

This comment is fabulous. I am a big believer that if you want more children then you will find a way to afford it.
SummerSaladsAreBack · 11/08/2021 11:32

My DC3 was (is) a joy - now an adult. But one thing I had not bargained for was never being able to sit together as a family when travelling especially on aeroplanes. You are always a 3 and a 2.

Monday26July · 11/08/2021 11:29

@CounsellorTroi

Well, apparently Jools Oliver wants another one even though she’s 46 and already has 5. I’m sorry for her miscarriages but still......why can’t she be happy with what she has.
It’s easy to keep having more and more kids when you have millions to pay for night nannies.
cookofcastamar · 11/08/2021 11:29

I find people with three close in age tend to be exhausted and it can be expensive childcare. My three are 8, 6 (two days ago) and 11 weeks. I have no childcare expenses for the older two as they'll be finished at 2:30, club until 3:30. DH works from home and will collect at 3:30 and help with homework. Only full time childcare for baby and we're considering doing 4 day weeks each. DH will take parental leave if around 16 weeks when I go back to work.
We have to plan ahead as we have no help with childcare. I'm an only child and I knew I'd regret not having a third.
My first was my toughest, apart from the usual ftm he had eczema, reflux, allergies and tongue tie. I thought long and hard about the second child but went ahead and second did not have any of the above. I should add that we already have a 4bed house, didn't need to change cars but might in the next year or two. Best of luck with your decision.

CounsellorTroi · 11/08/2021 11:15

Well, apparently Jools Oliver wants another one even though she’s 46 and already has 5. I’m sorry for her miscarriages but still......why can’t she be happy with what she has.

BastardMonkfish · 11/08/2021 10:55

I have two children, I'd love 3 or 4 but don't really want the work or expense tbh. Plus you can never guarantee a child won't have a health condition or disability and you need to consider if you are prepared for that and how that would impact on your existing children.

Mreggsworth · 11/08/2021 10:48

There is definitely not a need for increased birth rates please dont factor this into your decision making, countries will be back tracking on this message in the near future.

The risk of a decreasing population is that there wont be enough people to care for an aging population, however that worry pales in comparison to the risk that certain parts of the world may become uninhabitable in the next 50-100 years (including London) if climate change/population isn't tackled.

If you want to have multiple children as that's best for you and your family thats ok, but there isn't any justification that it's being done for the sake of society.

Lavender24 · 11/08/2021 10:46

Honestly OP I wouldn't do it if the kids would have to share. Probably not a popular opinion but my bedroom was my sanctuary growing up and I think I'd have lost my mind if I'd had to share, especially as a teen.

diddlediddle · 11/08/2021 10:42

Having three doesn't make sense on any level - financial, health, environmental - except emotional/biological drive. Depends which you're going to listen to, I suspect most people ignore logic and go with what they want

Binkybix · 11/08/2021 10:30

‘Us’*

Binkybix · 11/08/2021 10:29

Me and DH are in the middle of this conversation too.

Money wouldn’t be an issue, but what has swung it for me is this advice:

Only do it if you absolutely can't not do it

I think if I take the environmental impacts, the reduced amount of ‘is’ we could give, plus the chance of twins/health issues for a third, my mind has been made to stay at 2.

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 10:29

@workwise work isn't an issue. And I don't object to my children sharing a room, I did, I was the youngest of four.

OP posts:
Caritas · 11/08/2021 10:24

Definitely have 3 if you want to, children can easily share rooms (I am one of 4 and we lived happily in a three bed house until we all left home)! God willing I would love to have 5+, birth rates in many countries (including the UK) are in significant decline, hence I admire Hungary’s approach.

Dozer · 11/08/2021 10:21

It doesn’t sound like it’d work for you financially, workwise or housing wise.

I originally would’ve liked three DC but didn’t ttc DC3 for fertility / health reasons. Two has worked out lovely for us. Sometimes feel v stretched and like we don’t have enough time/resources for two! Also don’t enjoy sibling rivalry!

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 10:16

Now I'm insanely jealous of all of you that have managed it. I take my hat off to you Smile there's some wonderful stories on here.

OP posts:
ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 10:16

To answer an earlier question, yes, I do feel something is missing, that one more would make us 'complete'. I love the chaos of being in a family. It's bloody hard but I love it. I'd love another shot at having a baby, I'd love to see my boys bond with another.. I think this mornings sum's has just hit me how hard it would be and I can't think that can be fair on my current two 😢

OP posts:
ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 10:13

Thanks for your responses. I'm just not sure how we'd now get through the cost of the bit of having 3 kids needing wrap around care in the holidays, it seems such a huge cost. God I've been really thrown by this Sad

OP posts:
Chimchar · 11/08/2021 10:03

I'm sorry for your loss @ItsAllBlahBlahBlah. Sad

I have 3 older kids, youngest in mid teens.

The food they eat is significant! Holidays etc become very expensive, and the reality is that we haven't had many big holidays compared to friends simply because we couldn't afford it.

Cost of clothes etc obviously increases, and instead of 3 pairs of Clarks school shoes at £30 each, you're looking at £70each for a pair of Nikes for school, the same for out of school, and the same for sports and PE kits. Then they grow and they need replacing.

But that's only money..if you've got it, great, Not a problem.

For me, the real impact has been on me. Mentally. And career wise. The career thing was an active choice. I wanted to care for my kids (and couldn't afford childcare!) so we muddled through, dh working days and me working evenings and weekends. That was pretty exhausting. I've got a job now that I'm happy in and pays ok, but not compared to other women my age who have SIGNIFICANTLY higher incomes than I do. Having a third child made that last a few years longer.

Mentally, the load of 3 kids has just about broken me! Confused Problems in pre teens are generally easily sorted. As they've got older, life has become more complicated. There is never a time when all 3 are on an even keel... mental health, broken hearts, alcohol, sexuality, friends, bullying, self esteem, boundaries, education, all sorts of things happen and need supporting.

On saying all that, I wouldn't be without my 3 kids, and I really did enjoy having number 3... you know what you're doing, and are somehow more confident in parenting by that stage. The dynamic of 3 is great, and when we go anywhere as less than a 5, it feels so neat and tidy. Now they're older, they still get on really well, and it's lovely to see their relationship continue to grow and change as they become young adults.

That one extra does change everything. Smile

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 09:58

Thanks all. Currently sat trying to project finances regarding wrap around care for my boys in years to come, they are looked after by a childminder atm. Taking into account paying for the school holidays it would seem out of reach for us without taking a significant financial hit. By the time I have two in wrap around car plus a full time little one the cost is quite eye watering. I of course could go back to work for extra days as I only work 3 atm although it wouldn't give me the time I want with them so it negates the benefits in the long run.

I am trying not to feel disappointed as I have two wonderful boys. God I hate that money rules our life choices sometimes l

OP posts:
Hlgwsbytktu · 11/08/2021 09:58

Having lots of children is amazing for some people. But it's not for me. I find parenting very draining and tiring. Yours are still quite young yet. You haven't experienced the issues that come with schooling, friendship, any SEN that may develop. I have found it gets harder and harder as they get older.
That, mixed with covid enforced homeschooling has put me off having anymore children 100%.
Then in addition everything previous posters have said, cost, family tickets, holidays, being outnumbered, middle child issues which are very common, not enough time to give all seperate attention. I absolutely love and adore my children, I live for them, they are my whole life. But no more for me thanks!

PattyPan · 11/08/2021 09:45

They gain a sibling/friend for life

There’s absolutely no guarantee of this, they might hate each other, they might be indifferent to each other, the new baby might be severely disabled such that they barely have a relationship. Not all siblings are friends!