Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your real advice about deciding to have a third child

417 replies

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 10/08/2021 13:50

We're at the point of deciding whether to ttc or not. I have a soon to be 4yo and an 18mo, same sex, in a three bed house with no desire to move house. Not rich (at all) but wouldn't consider us to be poor either. Both in stable jobs or as much as we know, but I did have health problems at the end of second pregnancy which meant I was off sick for the final few months (makes me nervous it was frowned upon), I needed c sections with both pregnancies. I'd love another baby but need to be sensible which is really tough! Had an early mc with unplanned preg back in Feb Sad

Can you share your experiences please. Good and bad?

OP posts:
Mary46 · 11/08/2021 18:41

Op my sil has 5!! 3 nice childcare is alot though. I have 2. Find it expensive as had 2 in secondary. Good luck.

GinJeanie · 11/08/2021 18:33

Interesting that anyone who cares about the environment and our kids' futures is "banging on". I think I've heard that phrase WAAAY too much on the Covid thread in the past year when people don't want to hear about the fact they might have to give up anything they want to have. It's important we don't carry on living with our heads firmly in the sand just because it's easier, although I understand it's scary.
@Ralph871 - your comment about migrant families sounds quite racist tbh

ZeldaPrincessOfHyrule · 11/08/2021 18:33

@Ralph871 I'm really sorry but I just can't see it from that point of view, so we'll have to agree to disagree. We budget, that's how we could afford two, and does not mean that we could afford three. I don't think I'm the only one on this thread in the same position. It's not a bad thing we want to maintain our current lifestyle, and carefully weighing up the possible financial issues of the future doesn't mean we fritter our third child money away on holidays and fancy stuff. DH and I didn't decide we couldn't afford a third child because we're materialistic, we did it because we're realistic. A third child would mean giving up a lot of things that enrich our existing family's lives, and DH and I would prefer our DC have those opportunities and experiences instead of a hypothetical third sibling. That's not every family's situation, but for us it is. All the juggling in the world wouldn't free up enough money in our family budget for me to think another child would be wise, not without making a lot of sacrifices, however much my heart might want that third child.

As for materialism, you're absolutely right, there is too much materialistic thinking in society. The world would be a lot better off if people could find happiness with the things they had, instead of always feeling they need to acquire more.

user97495 · 11/08/2021 18:29

@Ralph871 it's not just about material gain, it's security too. If anything happens to the relationship; split, death, illness, ensuring you have a manageable amount of children to care for is a responsible thing to do, not greedy. And as has been stressed over and over, it's just basic maths that you can provide more attention to 2 children than 3, it's not all about expensive holidays. I personally think that's priceless and it's the very fact I value my children that I have limited myself to 2 to concentrate on them, not because I have supposedly less family values.

Ralph871 · 11/08/2021 15:46

@ZeldaPrincessOfHyrule The majority of negative comments on this thread as regarding not being able to afford expensive holidays and material items. There are plenty people on average incomes with larger families and it is because they budget. Most people don't want to give up fancy trips and meals out hence they tell themselves they can't afford a third child. Children don't need fancy overseas trips and a constant stream of new clothes and toys, we live in a completely materialism driven world and would do well to learn from other cultures that put more emphasis on the importance of family and appear much happier for it.

@ItsAllBlahBlahBlah I don't know about you but I am BORED of the number of comments regarding the negative impact on the environment. It's funny how the same people that bang on about the environmental effects are perfectly happy to jet all over the world on holiday and kill the plant with fast fashion whilst supporting migrant families coming to the country (who traditionally have lots of children) but make us westerners feel like it's our job to save the planet by dying out.

I am in a similar situation to you currently, I have a 3 year old and 16 month old and also want another baby however my husband who previously wanted a larger family is on the fence for various reasons. We live in a large three bed flat (would need a bigger house at some point I suppose) with a small mortgage, still have all the cots and car seats and clothes from the first two and already own a 7 seater car. I still work full time but I have good options for part time if I have another baby, however I am also the main breadwinner and currently earn twice what my husband does as he is trying to do a career change. I'm only 34 so I'm unsure if it would make more sense to wait a bit longer however part of me thinks that if you know you want another baby then should you just go for it?

I will say that I can see the concerns for our children's future given how much future generations are going to pay for the absolute disaster that has been the response to the pandemic.

Good luck whatever you decide and sorry for your recent pregnancy loss

Rosebel · 11/08/2021 15:17

I have 3 but it's a bit different as I have a huge age gap. My DD1 was 14 and DD2 was 12 when I had DS. So I only have one lot of childcare expenses and DS is too young for evening activities from that point for me it's not too different to having 2.
I have wanted a 3rd child for years but suffered multiple miscarriages and was then put off trying.
Total surprise when I got pregnant again and carried to full term. I honestly feel like our family is complete. Ideally I'd have liked them closer together but I absolutely wouldn't change this for the world.
We did have to get a bigger car and our girls share a room (but always did through choice) and some things are more expensive but that doesn't stop it being the right decision.
Obviously all families are different so it's a case of what feels right for you.

user97495 · 11/08/2021 15:04

I had acquaintances, in my teens, who had a lot materially. Some had a heck of a lot. But in some cases, they'd have swapped their parents brand new car, their designer clothes, their music lessons, etc for a life with much less "stuff" and parents who engaged with them more.

So the answer to that is to have another child and divide the parental attention by 3 rather than by 2? I don't think so, for me time and money are mutually exclusive, another child reduces my available time as much as it does my finances. The main reason I have stopped at 2 is to be able to give them a good amount of attention each, as well as the financial benefit. If a parent is the type to throw stuff at 2 kids in lieu of attention they're very unlikely to give said children more attention by having a third.

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 14:34

OK rephrase the work isn't an issue.. . Current manager is very sympathetic, I work from home and this is permanent. I live approximately 2 minutes from my childminder, 5 minutes from the school. I get that the kids may get sick etc but that may happen with the two I already have. Noone can forsee that, but I understand that it increased the likelihood.

OP posts:
Dozer · 11/08/2021 14:30

You say work ‘isn’t an issue’ but PT working for many years has significant, negative implications for your personal earnings, career progression and pension. And more DC means more juggling, time off etc, even more so if your H works FT and you do a larger share of parenting, time off etc.

Sceptre86 · 11/08/2021 14:20

Depending on your age I would give it longer. Maybe when your youngest can get free hours at nursery. I have two, a girl and a boy . Both kids born via section and am weeks away from having my third baby. Dd is 5, ds 4. Dd is starting school this year and ds will be at nursery in the mornings allowing me one on one time with baby. I am trying for a vbac but it is an uphill struggle. I don't know if you would be wanting to consider one or of a 3rd section would be the safest option for you but from my own experience the recovery gets harder the more you have (appreciate you might have felt differently).

I don't think having two kids share is a big deal although on mumsnet people are often aghast at this. I don't know why, it really doesn't harm kids as far as I am concerned. Car wise your eldest can sit in the front in a booster eventually with either you or your op, the baby and your other child in the back. It might be snug but can be done. 3 kids though equals more clutter, more laundry, more admin, more responsibility however we still went for it as there are loads of positives too. As for family help depends on whether you rely on it already, we don't. If you do asking them to have three young kids might be a push, so you either have a few quiet years or factor in costs of childminders or babysitters.

To be honest in your situation I think the biggest concerns would be your finances and your own health. Lots to think about x

cookofcastamar · 11/08/2021 14:05

@PattyPan I didn't think about that! Sure we can always take two rows.

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 13:56

@Amima I'm not asking for permission, I'm asking for advice. I'm not damned for thinking.

OP posts:
Amima · 11/08/2021 13:51

The news was talking about climate change and reducing the birth rate literally yesterday, but you’re still asking whether to have a third child?

gwenneh · 11/08/2021 13:50

Working FT with 3 children is challenging.

This. One of the things I needed to plan extensively for was making sure #3 did not derail my career trajectory.

It either involves a very flexible employer or self employment in the kind of role that can be done around a changing schedule, or the money to purchase wrap around care and pay full time nursery fees. Or obliging family members to provide care (we don't have those!)

I suppose a lot of it will depend on how flexible your employer can be. Mine has always been supportive allowing me to bring the children to the office instead of using wrap-around care prior to the pandemic, for example but since the pandemic they've been even better. If you have that kind of latitude, it's not as bad!

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 13:44

And I agree, there's no NEED to have children. Also no need to have pets, cars, big houses with or without a person per room to fill it. We all want different things. I don't own anything special myself, I have my children and I am very content with that. I just would like, and yes I am saying like, another baby if its feasible. I'm just trying to make sure I've considered everything I can at this point. I don't want to be pregnant and then fearful for my children's future if I realise I really cannot afford to live comfortably. If the answer is no, then I will have to live with it.

OP posts:
PhantomErik · 11/08/2021 13:44

I have 3 & I love having 3, however...

Yes we all fit in a standard car but there's not a lot of room so on journeys they annoy each other.

We have a 3 bed house but ended up moving our bedroom into the dining room so they could have a bedroom each. Our 2 ds's are very different boys & need space. They're much happier & get on better now they can get away from each other sometimes.

Holidays are much cheaper & easier to book with 2 dc. Places like travelodge/premier inn require 2 rooms to be booked & either get them with connecting doors or have to split the adults.

DC get more expensive the older they get, extra curricular activities, clothes, entrances to theme parks, food etc

Savings/inheritance - more kids = smaller % inheritance.

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 11/08/2021 13:41

I don't work full time, I work part time 3 days. My employer was very flexible I was just sadly unable to work for the last few months of my second pregnancy due to unforseen circumstances. It doesn't mean it will happen again. I would need a c section as I had difficulties at birth for my first so I've know any additional children will be born by a cesarean. The issue I have atm is predicting the childcare costs for having three children in wrap around care. It would only be for three hours a day for three days a week but as soon as you throw the school holidays into the mix it becomes complicated. I can have six weeks off a year which is great but I still need to pay my childminder a fee if my children aren't there, it's half pay for absences. I just need to figure it all out.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 11/08/2021 13:33

I think in your circumstances your health and your job are considerations.

In your situation I would think not.

Working FT with 3 children is challenging.

Even more so with an inflexible employer.

I have heard of acquaintances over the years regretting wishing their children's childhood away because of the pressure of a difficult employer that made holidays/illnesses very stressful.

If you have to work FT, it is very hard juggling childcare without huge support, which many don't have.
Flowers

OnTheHillNotOverIt · 11/08/2021 13:32

That’s pretty unlikely!

Harlechh · 11/08/2021 13:29

@OnTheHillNotOverIt so according to you we should aim to let human life die out?! No thanks.

OnTheHillNotOverIt · 11/08/2021 13:18

Tootsey11 nobody needs any children. The completely rational response would be to choose none. They are costly environmentally and financially and emotionally draining.
Better to have none and volunteer in your community with older people or foster or run a Brownie pack. Much better for the planet, your pocket and your community.
Nobody’s genes are so amazing that you have to pass them on.
It’s not a rational decision. It’s an emotional (vs practical) one which is what the OP is struggling with.

For some people the “now or never” moment is tricky to navigate. Especially after loss. It’s hard to close that window and look forwards to what’s ahead with what you’ve got. It can be hard and sad to draw that line. If it wasn’t for you then that’s great.

Hardbackwriter · 11/08/2021 12:56

I had acquaintances, in my teens, who had a lot materially. Some had a heck of a lot. But in some cases, they'd have swapped their parents brand new car, their designer clothes, their music lessons, etc for a life with much less "stuff" and parents who engaged with them more.

But surely that's also an argument for stopping at two children in and of itself. If anyone has a third child they have less money and time for each child.

Tootsey11 · 11/08/2021 12:39

Why do you 'need' 3 children? No one does. You might want them but no one actually needs them.

As to the replies of 'I've got 7, or we' re planning 4 or 5'. Where are peoples heads at with everything going on.

YouMeandtheSpew · 11/08/2021 12:39

Not in the same situation as I have one child and am pregnant with my second, so I’m not telling you anything you haven’t already experienced.

I have always thought of three as a perfect number of children. Don’t know why, I didn’t grow up as one of three, just in my fantasy world I think 3 seems like the perfect number.

But the thing that’s really taken me by surprise is this - I’ve been quite ill during this pregnancy (unexpectedly as I had an easy time the first time round). And I can barely look after one toddler when I’m not feeling 100% - honestly the standard of parenting I’ve been giving my toddler while I’ve been pregnant hasn’t been great (a lot more screen time than I’d like for starters). It’s just really brought into focus for me that actually having another child isn’t the same as having one child again.

Also, I grew up poor. Not in poverty - I always had enough to eat and heating etc. But poor. No tv, no garden, clothes were always secondhand or from charity shops. And I’m ok and grateful for what I had but honestly it wasn’t much fun. So I’m very conscious that I don’t ever want my children to experience that. I think if we stick at two they won’t, but at three it’s much more likely.

GinJeanie · 11/08/2021 12:35

@CounsellorTroi - I've just been reading about Jools Oliver and words literally fail me... 😬 I totally understand the biological urge to have another baby as have been through it after my second baby died in infancy (although the whole thing was complicated by grief/trauma) but she has 5 beautiful children and is nearly 47. Added to this, her children are going to be facing whatever climate change brings - obviously we don't know the true timescale but it will likely affect them and their lives far more than it will her tbh...

Swipe left for the next trending thread