Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your real advice about deciding to have a third child

417 replies

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 10/08/2021 13:50

We're at the point of deciding whether to ttc or not. I have a soon to be 4yo and an 18mo, same sex, in a three bed house with no desire to move house. Not rich (at all) but wouldn't consider us to be poor either. Both in stable jobs or as much as we know, but I did have health problems at the end of second pregnancy which meant I was off sick for the final few months (makes me nervous it was frowned upon), I needed c sections with both pregnancies. I'd love another baby but need to be sensible which is really tough! Had an early mc with unplanned preg back in Feb Sad

Can you share your experiences please. Good and bad?

OP posts:
Marty13 · 17/08/2021 21:20

I read the whole thread with interest as considering the same decision as OP.

The whole environmental debate doesn't really seem relevant to me. The birth rate in most developped countries is already in decline so I'm not sure why everyone is fixated on two children as some magic number. And if this is about the environmental impact of children as individuals then how do you justify having any at all, let alone two ?

Someone suggested a birth rate control by the state as they did in China and... Really ? Because I mean clearly that worked out SO well for them.

The fact is, this forum is a world unto itself and not at all representative of society at large. Some of the standards parents are held to on here are properly ridiculous. So if OP wants a balanced opinion, I'd suggest asking on other forums too. But most of all you need to do what works for you.

No, for me the most relevant factors would be :

  • whether I'd have enough time for three plus myself
  • the logistics of having three (activities, handling them on holiday, etc)
  • whether I could shoulder the cost

In my case I've decided to wait a bit and see how I manage it all as kids grow a bit older. I definitely want a bigger gap (the first two have a 18 months difference).

InvincibleInvisibility · 17/08/2021 19:58

DH wanted (wants) 3. I wanted 2 or 3 and after 5 years of in-depth discussions, me reading every thread on MN about it, me doing excel sheets on how much said 3rd baby would cost us, I eventually had to say a definitive no to DH for a 3rd.

It's not for financial reasons as we are in the top 10% of earners but health (mental and physical).

DS1 (9) has always been very difficult and has had several medical issues since birth. He's recently been diagnosed with ADHD and dyspraxia. He is fabulous and utterly exhausting. And now we know he will need a LOT of support (time and emotional) through the teenage years.

Ive had 2 burnouts in the past 5 years and am quite simply struggling. DS2 shows a couple of signs of ADHD too. Fortunately not the emotional rollercoaster and sleep-dodger which is DS1 but my god the word hyperactive was invented for DS2!

I adore both of them and want to do my very best for them. Ive put juggling their needs and having time for them above our wanting to have a 3rd DC (both boys also want a sibling but I just can't do it without bringing in lots of paid extra help and the whole point is I want to be with my DC not outsource).

I don't regret my decision. I wish I'd been better able to cope so that I could give DH the 3rd he really wants. But at the end of the day I have 2 gorgeous boys who are extremely fun to be with (we're a sporty fanily and as they're getting older can do more and more things together).

Good luck OP. It's a very difficult decision.

fuxxake · 17/08/2021 15:33

We've had a third, almost a year ago. Everything pp have said re the negatives is prob true but the bottom line for us is she's perfect, she completes our family and there's no regrets here. Even after just 3 hours sleep Grin
I couldn't imagine being without her.

Mreggsworth · 17/08/2021 15:10

@Bluebellsinparadise

Bit of a tangent but that school situation is not the norm, my mother in law works in school admissions for greater Manchester and every school is over subscribed, she is dealing with numerous families where children from the same family have had to go different schools on opposite side of town which is a logistical nightmare for drop offs and pick ups. She has several schools with a waiting list for one year group alone is exceeding 30, children being placed in special needs school in emergency situations as they cant place them elsewhere. Theres children due to start secondary and primary school this year (in just a few weeks away) who still have not received any place at all even in schools way out of catchment.

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 17/08/2021 11:49

Thanks for the latest comments... I think 🙈

OP posts:
Bluebellsinparadise · 17/08/2021 11:47

Fair play @PattyPan and I wish you well!

PattyPan · 17/08/2021 11:40

Yes I agree everyone has to make an effort stairway.

Bluebells, I’m not trying to be mean, I’m trying to be honest. Op wanted to know if people would judge behind her back so I told the truth that I would. I do plenty of other things, don’t worry. Which I have time for, because I don’t have three children Wink

Bluebellsinparadise · 17/08/2021 11:20

@AudacityBaby yeah but she’s preaching so the chatter behind her back is fully deserved!

Bluebellsinparadise · 17/08/2021 11:18

*happening anyway

Bluebellsinparadise · 17/08/2021 11:18

What @stairway said!

But @PattyPan we don’t have a problem with the birth rate in the U.K. It’s falling so rapidly that our oversubscribed, popular school now has lots of spare places in nursery/ reception. The world doesn’t need your judgement- it’s happening away without your unhelpful judgement. You’re not having any impact - you’re just being mean. Maybe try changing the world through more positive action that will actually have results?

stairway · 17/08/2021 10:45

Pattypan, if we as a society had a very low carbon footprint then it wouldn’t matter if a few individuals didn’t. We don’t though so everyone has to make an effort.

AudacityBaby · 17/08/2021 10:27

@ItsAllBlahBlahBlah

I do understand what people are saying about viewing families with more than two children as selfish but I've never ever came across that. Is this something that's mumbled behind people's backs? Genuine question, as I have friends with 3 or 4 children and noone has ever said they've received any hostility about it
I posted earlier in the thread about my colleague with 5 kids and the big diesel car, who spends her time lecturing others (including childless colleagues) about the world her children will inherit. I've never said anything to her, but have there been comments behind her back? You bet there have.
PattyPan · 17/08/2021 10:15

I disagree, stairway. That’s like saying the individual’s carbon footprint doesn’t matter because it’s about the total society’s impact. Well it does matter because we all need to take responsibility for our actions and the total impact is made up of that of each individual! Also, in this country and developed countries in general the impact of a child is much higher than in developing countries where the birth rate is higher.

stairway · 17/08/2021 08:29

Pattypan the number of children an individual family has is irrelevant, how many a society has overall is what matters and it’s well under 2 in this country and declining in most countries as well as sperm count. It’s the same as people judging women for having no children, because if all women had no children the human race would be finished in 100 years.

PattyPan · 16/08/2021 23:39

@Bluebellsinparadise if they were choosing to have a third child now no. If they had three adult children it would be different because the circumstances were different then. But I wouldn’t be friends with eg an anti vaxxer or gun nut either. People don’t tend to want to be friends with people with opposing values. The environment is an emergency and ignoring it in favour of just feeling like your family could do with another child in the face of all evidence means our values wouldn’t be compatible.

Bluebellsinparadise · 16/08/2021 21:53

Sorry you’re getting such a hard time OP.

I don’t think there are many people in the real world who would be so judgemental, so please don’t take these comments to heart. Especially given you already had a third child, who you lost.

The environmental concerns are valid and definitely worth taking seriously, but people shouldn’t be judged for their family planning decisions.

Who knows.... your third child could be John Connor Grin

Seriously though, we haven’t yet got a 2 child policy, and many people will be deciding not to have children now. So if you want 3, have 3 without feeling guilt! The birth rate is going to go down anyway!

Bluebellsinparadise · 16/08/2021 21:46

@PattyPan Wow. Just wow! You wouldn’t be friends with someone who has 3 children?! That’s crazy.

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 16/08/2021 17:30

OK @PattyPan I appreciate your comments, thanks. I am having a search through mumsnet for some previous threads

OP posts:
PattyPan · 16/08/2021 17:27

@Iusedtobesoooomuchfun no I wouldn’t stop my child being friends with someone from a bigger family. I wouldn’t stop them being friends with the children from your polluting example either - the kids don’t make those decisions. But would I choose to become friends with these children’s parents myself? Maybe not.

@ItsAllBlahBlahBlah I wouldn’t say or think anything about the children - it’s not their fault. It’s the parents that made the decision so they’re the ones that get the judgement.

stairway · 16/08/2021 17:21

I have 4 so 3 seems a doddle now. I don’t think it’s that much different a bit more juggling here and there but no biggie. The Uk birthrate is really low so I wouldn’t be too concerned about the environmental reasons.

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 16/08/2021 17:18

Thanks, it's honestly something I've never come across but if there's reason to think my children would be targeted by any kind of hostility as a result of my decision it's a no from me from the off. All of my children (2 or 3) are very much wanted by us so I'd hate for them to question beyond that.

Lots to think about. We've had a chat last night and it's proving tricky. We both definitely WANT another baby (child) , it's realising of its the right thing to do on about 20 different levels.

OP posts:
cjpark · 16/08/2021 17:16

Ive got two teenagers. I wouldn't have three. I'd struggle with guilt of the environmental impact of bringing more than 2 people into the world. I'd struggle with the cost of more than two. Feeding 4 adults is expensive. I'd rather do 2 well than spread myself and resources thin for 3.

Mreggsworth · 16/08/2021 17:16

@KazenoTaninoNaushika

No worries Smile

Mreggsworth · 16/08/2021 17:15

@ItsAllBlahBlahBlah

I do have a few friends and family members who have more than 2 children, in all honesty in real life I wouldn't be anywhere near as opinionated on the subject. I would not tell them my opinions unless asked, and if asked I would not say it is selfish but I'd suggest considering the environmental impact. I wouldn't risk straining a friendship over this topic by being overly judgemental on the subject but I would want people to be aware that I have my concerns....but yes there may also be the odd behind the back bitchy comment, but I think that is just part in parcel with motherhood and parenting decisions anyway so not point worrying about that.

Iusedtobesoooomuchfun · 16/08/2021 17:11

@PattyPan
But you're honestly saying you couldn't be friends with someone with 3 children?

What if one of your children become friends with a 3rd child? Would you make them stop being friends with them?

Swipe left for the next trending thread