Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Theresa May was given a very hard time?

131 replies

plodalong12 · 10/08/2021 11:36

Just as the thread title says really. I feel like she had a really hard time whilst trying to manage a poisoned chalice in the form of Brexit.
I also think it’s interesting that it’s the tories and other political parties that have had female leaders but the Labour Party has so far had none despite putting themselves across as the party of equality.

OP posts:
plodalong12 · 10/08/2021 16:14

@plodalong12

The US. Special relationship etc etc Wink

Oh ok, I was asking just in case you were from some country that was not renowned for a racist past and who was nice to nearby folks in another country, like Mexicans, but I see from your response that you’re not. It’s a bit galling to bemoan racism here when your country had a very recent president whose motto and pledge was “Build The Wall”.

That was to @Beachhuts90
OP posts:
plodalong12 · 10/08/2021 16:13

The US. Special relationship etc etc Wink

Oh ok, I was asking just in case you were from some country that was not renowned for a racist past and who was nice to nearby folks in another country, like Mexicans, but I see from your response that you’re not. It’s a bit galling to bemoan racism here when your country had a very recent president whose motto and pledge was “Build The Wall”.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 10/08/2021 15:56

Whether there’s another Tory election win will depend on them getting a lot of money into red wall areas very quickly and very visibly. We were in the north east last week visiting relatives and it was very clear that Tory votes up there are only on loan. Unless they make a substantial mark very quickly, those votes will be taken back again.

VladmirsPoutine · 10/08/2021 15:56

Theresa May is racist. As is Boris Johnson.

Tories and racism go together much like cheese on toast. However, they do treat their token minorities with a great deal more respect than Labour does.

Superb0wl · 10/08/2021 15:53

Theresa May - windrush, the hostile environment, her response to Grenfell

Boris Johnson - picaninnies, watermelon smiles, letterboxes...

Honestly that you had to ask this question says it all really, it's not like any of this is hidden away.

MondayYogurt · 10/08/2021 15:53

You could say a lot about May but she was not corrupt.

Martianworld · 10/08/2021 15:51

@stuckdownahole

I have a relative who worked in a minister's private office when May was Home Secretary. She was viewed by those with close access as hardworking and dogged rather than intelligent and empathetic; someone lacking the star quality characteristic of a successful PM. Cameron was viewed as an outstanding salesman, Osborne was seen as impressively clever.
Just what Cameron was saying really. I know people on here hate Boris Johnson, but he has massive appeal and relateability to people across different classes. You can't manufacture that. Whether people will see past that and decide they've had enough will ultimately depend on how the Labour Party operates over the next couple of years. Neither party is impressive a0t the moment but who knows what might come along and be a knockout blow for either of them. Even a week is a long time in politics.
MiddleParking · 10/08/2021 15:50

Fuck her.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/08/2021 15:50

They may be. What's your evidence?

That's a request that might require a bit of digging and subsequent qualification in the case of May, but I think it's empirically obvious in Johnson's case.

Piccaninnies, watermelon smiles, letterboxes, verminous race, and so on.

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2021 15:49

Cameron was not a good PM, he was a terrible PM

Understatement of the thread. History won’t treat him kindly.

Naunet · 10/08/2021 15:48

As for sexism, that definitely plays a part. In the 1970s,and 80s Mrs T was definitely abused on a sexist fashion, she just didn't seem to give a shit

It didn’t stop in the 80s. What male MP has ever been treated like this:
www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-22145306

AntsInPenzance · 10/08/2021 15:47

@ChainJane

She was given a hard time because she was a poor PM. Johnson is given a hard time because he is a poor PM. It's not "because she's a woman" - it's because she was shit. Even "good" PMs like Cameron were given a hard time, so the crap ones are really going to have people gunning for them.
Cameron was not a good PM, he was a terrible PM.

Brexit, austerity, pushing disabled people to their deaths, scrapping SureStart. All Cameron's fault.

Martianworld · 10/08/2021 15:44

@Superb0wl

Theresa May is racist. As is Boris Johnson.
They may be. What's your evidence?
Naunet · 10/08/2021 15:44

Misogyny exists, of course she was treated differently! I didn’t like her, don’t like a lot of her choices, but that doesn’t mean I turn a blind eye to the sexism she faced.

Superb0wl · 10/08/2021 15:40

Theresa May is racist. As is Boris Johnson.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/08/2021 15:39

I don't think Cameron's big mistake was calling the referendum, it was an election pledge after all, it was facilitating the referendum, then running a half-arsed, half-hearted 'remain' campaign, presumably on the back of the fact that he believed it was a foregone conclusion and the UK would vote to remain in the EU.

The entire remain campaign was terrible from start to finish, but the absolute worst culprit for standing by and doing nothing when he could have had an overwhelmingly decisive input, was Jeremy bloody Corbyn. He paid lip-service to the prospect of remaining within the EU, which is completely unforgivable for a man that built his house on being 'down to earth' and caring about working class people. Given that it's working class people who are going to be utterly humped by the UK's race to the bottom, the fact they voted for it in huge numbers is a damning indictment of the non-performance of one man who could, and should have been able to get the message across that what they were thinking of doing was tantamount to an enormous, catastrophic act of self-harm.

But no, he just lingered in the background hoping the entire thing would just sort itself out without him, somehow.

Twat

Beachhuts90 · 10/08/2021 15:28

@plodalong12

Oh yes. And I am aware that I have it way better than others because we qualify for the visa financially etc. I see a lot of cases on fb groups of people being desperate to bring their spouse over but because they earn less than £18.6k they can't qualify.

I have had a not zero number of people talk to me here about how they want immigrants to go home, and then say "but not ones like you". I'm white and speak English as my first language, it feels a bit racist (towards others, obviously) when they say that to me and I don't look kindly on it at all.

What country are you from?

The US. Special relationship etc etc Wink
stuckdownahole · 10/08/2021 15:25

I have a relative who worked in a minister's private office when May was Home Secretary. She was viewed by those with close access as hardworking and dogged rather than intelligent and empathetic; someone lacking the star quality characteristic of a successful PM. Cameron was viewed as an outstanding salesman, Osborne was seen as impressively clever.

Martianworld · 10/08/2021 15:11

@OzMoz

She was terrible. As is Boris. I couldn't give a hoot what sex either of them are. Useless is as useless does.

Genuinely wonder what it would take for them to be voted out.

Get yourself a credible opposition party and leader. It's not rocket science.
Martianworld · 10/08/2021 15:06

David Cameron said about Theresa May that she was good at her job but you just couldn't reason with her so it was just easier to let her get on with it. But when there was a problem in the Home Office, it's interesting to note that it was Cameron that came out and did the PR on it, not May. I think that shows 2 things. One, maybe she didn't take advice when she was PM on how things looked, and 2, she lacked resonance with the public.
Both reasons why she didn't do well as PM.

As for sexism, that definitely plays a part. In the 1970s,and 80s Mrs T was definitely abused on a sexist fashion, she just didn't seem to give a shit. I think it was the 1987 election, Kinnock looked a shoe in. The Labour Party were doing a behind the scenes documentary they were so sure they were going to win. Then about 2 days before the election, labour did satirical party political broadcast aimed at wavering tory voters, criticising Thatcher in a sexist way, talking about handbags, bossiness, etc. Unfortunately for the men who made that PPB, Scarfe, Rushton et al, it seemed the voters didn't appreciate the blatent sexism couched as a bit if banter, and the LP documentary that was subsequently released said that they felt the pushback immediately from voters, and, of course, they lost the election.

I'm not sure how much has changed since the 1980s and I think Mrs M was also undermined because of being a woman, just these days they have to be a lot more underhand about it. But, mainly, she was unsuccessful at the general election and the Tory party are all about winning. If they think they'd win, they'd elect a chewing gum on a stick. Equally, if they display they can't win, they'll discover just how many knives can be stuck in their back at one time!

plodalong12 · 10/08/2021 15:05

That was to @Beachhuts90

OP posts:
plodalong12 · 10/08/2021 15:02

Oh yes. And I am aware that I have it way better than others because we qualify for the visa financially etc. I see a lot of cases on fb groups of people being desperate to bring their spouse over but because they earn less than £18.6k they can't qualify.

I have had a not zero number of people talk to me here about how they want immigrants to go home, and then say "but not ones like you". I'm white and speak English as my first language, it feels a bit racist (towards others, obviously) when they say that to me and I don't look kindly on it at all.

What country are you from?

OP posts:
Beachhuts90 · 10/08/2021 14:36

@VladmirsPoutine

As an immigrant here because my husband is British, she has personally made my life very difficult, by making the path to indefinite leave to remain much longer and more expensive. Of course, that's what a lot of you like about her.

This is just the thing isn't it. I'm a second-gen immigrant and even from the recent discourse on the RNLI it seems the majority of the populace really couldn't give a flying about the wellbeing of immigrants.

Oh yes. And I am aware that I have it way better than others because we qualify for the visa financially etc. I see a lot of cases on fb groups of people being desperate to bring their spouse over but because they earn less than £18.6k they can't qualify.

I have had a not zero number of people talk to me here about how they want immigrants to go home, and then say "but not ones like you". I'm white and speak English as my first language, it feels a bit racist (towards others, obviously) when they say that to me and I don't look kindly on it at all.

Blossomtoes · 10/08/2021 14:24

She also came out with that horrible “magic money tree” phrase in response to a nurse

Amber Rudd said it first in the leaders’ debate, to be fair.

Doomscrolling · 10/08/2021 14:13

She was useless and out of her depth. However, she was a beacon of competence and rationality in comparison with the venal lazy narcissist we’ve got now.