Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A level grades

678 replies

DolphinFC · 10/08/2021 10:25

If feel that value of an A grade ar A level has been reduced dramatically. I feel truly sorry for those very bright, hard-working students who would've got an A grade no matter what. Their deserved A grade is now lost in a pile of undeserved A grades.

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 12/08/2021 11:10

I’m not demanding. You were quite happy to “demand” an answer yourself. from a poster if they worked in a private school or not.

You’re deliberately avoiding the obvious end point of your arguments throughout the thread. You have asserted that these grades are all fully deserved. I’m trying to ascertain if that means you genuinely hold that belief and there can’t possibly be any inflation. You’re refusing to answer because you know deep down of course there are going to be kids who are thanking their lucky stars and you know deep down that if 50% of kids are considered elite enough to get an A/A then an A/A isn’t worth a dime and we can’t tell who the really good kids are. If you had courage in your convictions that the marking has been flawless you would say these aren’t possibilities.

So many people who want the pretty lie rather than the ugly truth.

Notthemessiah · 12/08/2021 11:08

@hedgehogger1

I did not write the following but think it needs sharing here

You will read a lot this week about inflated A-Level grades with teacher's predictions and how teachers have deliberately exaggerated grades for their own gain.

Think again. We haven't. Let me explain.

Let's take five members of an A-Level class who are all slated to get B grades overall. They have been progressing all through the course towards those grades and look pretty good so far.
Now let's take a NORMAL examined year. Your five sure-shot B grades go into that exam room and sit those papers. Now let's go to August and you get the following:
Students 1 and 2 get B grades as expected
Student 3 spends extra hours revising, practising and practising, manages to revise the one question that comes up and gets an A
Student 4 drops to C because they were one mark off the higher-this-year boundaries. Any other year would have been a B.
Student 5 missed either one question/one text/one case study/one equation and dropped to a low C or even a D. Yup they screwed up, either by accident/stress/personal circumstances and there's at least one every year in every class who does.

Now let's take THIS year. Your five sure-shot B grades are back again, only now you have to predict their grades. They have all been consistently working to this level.

Do you give them all B's? Of course you do because that's your evidence. Which student becomes your scapegoat? Which one do you 'assume' will be the screw up or victim of boundaries? Student 1 who had that one bad assessment? Student 2 who has bad attendance? Student 3 who works at B grade but it is really low in the band? Student 4 who has major family issues? Student 5 who is actually capable of more but doesn't revise and blags assessments? No. You don't. Because you don't let (you are also forbidden to let) bias cloud your judgement. So they all get B's sent off, including that one student who may have managed an A.

So grades will go up and be artificially high, but of course they will, it's an anomaly year. You have no data to draw your usual bell curve from (what makes a B one year may not another).

Teachers haven't exaggerated grades, instead we are working against:

  • Previous years boundaries that go up and down, sometimes quite dramatically. I have had students get A's one year and C's in another with exactly the same mark.
  • Not knowing what is on the paper (e.g. mine only get examined on 2 out of 3 possible topics and if one particular one comes up, some students will do better)
  • Each year also brings 'bad' papers and 'good' papers - you get one bad paper/poor question/poorly worded section and that's your cohort all down - teachers have been asked to predict against this too.
  • Giving students the benefit of the doubt because you know they COULD and have demonstrated in assessment that they CAN so why not give them the grade?
  • Exam marking is notoriously unpredictable, inaccurate and uneven - particularly in essay based subjects even in regular years.
  • Also I cannot speak for other teachers but this year's group for me have been one of the most able I have had - and having a student's personal progress judged against previous who may have been less able/more disadvantaged/more scuppered by course changes seems ridiculous.

Also, quite bluntly, predicting and ranking exam candidates for teachers has been hellish. I don't think anyone would like to be asked to rank a group of people on their POSSIBLE performance knowing that the grades they give will make or break a student's future.

And finally, students WORKED for these grades. Teachers didn't magic them out of thin air. We based them on eighteen months of evidence, assessments and grades. And every time someone declares 'oh they aren't real grades' you belittle their work and achievements.

Save your judgements for the govt who turned schools into exam factories which means it's all on one or two papers at one moment in time.

(EDIT: This example can also be applied to the upcoming GCSE results too)

EDIT 2 - Also this year's grades will not be included in schools progress/judgements and league tables so it is literally in no teacher's interest to inflate grades artificially.

@hedgehogger1

Did not need to read any further after this reply. You explained perfectly why the grades are as they are this year and its just a shame that more people won't have seen it or glossed over it because it was a long post (probably the same ones complaining how much easier it is to get a-levels than in their day).

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 10:59

I don't answer on principle on here when people start demanding you answer their questions @NotBadConsidering

NotBadConsidering · 12/08/2021 10:56

But you have lots to say on the broad context of these results, but now you’re not prepared to wager an answer on how accurate they might be for kids overall? You honestly think that every single kid got the grades they deserve and there isn’t a single candidate whose results will be raising eyebrows among those who know him or her?

You don’t honestly think there isn’t someone who is truly exceptional who is pissed off because they got the same grades as someone they know isn’t actually that good?

It’s not judging the teen, it’s judging the marking.

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 10:50

@NotBadConsidering

But when I say benefited, I mean kids who clearly aren’t in the upper echelons of ability but somehow clearly came out with a grade that has raised eyebrows.

I find it impossible to believe that already, or in the very near future, everyone won’t know of a candidate who got a grade that didn’t make people go “Really?Hmm”

It won’t be anyone’s own kid of course, it will be other people’s Wink.

Maybe I'm just not thst interested in what other people's children got in their A levels because I can't imagine judging any teen like this, I have no idea how clever or not my children's friends are or what they are capable of academically
NotBadConsidering · 12/08/2021 10:47

@Bryonyshcmyony

Any thoughts on the questions I asked?

capturedbyasquid · 12/08/2021 10:18

Incidentally, the chair of the association of school leaders has just been quoted as saying that comparisons between this year's results and other years are 'somewhat meaningless'. Unfortunately that's not much comfort to kids that are scrambling for university places (or for next year's cohort who are going to be competing for places with the students from this year's cohort who have in some cases been paid to defer).

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 12/08/2021 10:12

@Bryonyshcmyony

It might be interesting but it's pointless and irrelevant as it's done
Not if this is going to happen going forward…

Changes to current gcse may be made, although I doubt it

Lots of things that are interesting are irrelevant

NotBadConsidering · 12/08/2021 10:11

But when I say benefited, I mean kids who clearly aren’t in the upper echelons of ability but somehow clearly came out with a grade that has raised eyebrows.

I find it impossible to believe that already, or in the very near future, everyone won’t know of a candidate who got a grade that didn’t make people go “Really?Hmm”

It won’t be anyone’s own kid of course, it will be other people’s Wink.

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 12/08/2021 10:10

@Bryonyshcmyony

And she is typical hard working diligent female student, slogging away at each piece of coursework and upset if anything is below an A Exams could have gone either way tbh
Same with my eldest

Dont get me wrong….he had a habit of writing A* essays which bore no resemblance to the actual question

But usually he was very good, very diligent (and much cleverer than i thought 😳 but then how am I supposed to know he’s clever when even at 15 he didnt seem to understand what wardrobes were for)

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 10:09

It might be interesting but it's pointless and irrelevant as it's done

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 12/08/2021 10:08

Sorry

I think it would be interesting to see the schools percentage increase

The local state secondary had higher grades last year by about 2/3%, (pre algorithm which was partly to blame for last year’s inflation) which wasn’t particularly unreasonable

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 10:08

And she is typical hard working diligent female student, slogging away at each piece of coursework and upset if anything is below an A
Exams could have gone either way tbh

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 10:06

Yes, dd probabiy benefited from no exams as she gets so anxious. No argument there. Although she was quite up for taking them when we thought that might be an option

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 12/08/2021 10:05

Now we have two years of results (from teacher assessment) that are obviously unbelievable

Thing is those grades aren’t unbelievable for some students, so obviously if a thread is started from people saying that ‘grades were handed out etc’ then people are going to say no they weren’t

I think everyone knows children who have benefited, ds1 wasnt great at exams so although his results years ago were good they'd be much much better this year. And i know he is intelligent…we had him tested 😀

And obviously if the best pieces of work children did were picked as evidence the grades are going to be better

Who are we picking to have the undeserved Higher grades…..quite obviously ds2 deserved his

capturedbyasquid · 12/08/2021 10:00

I haven't RTFT, but it was interesting (but sadly unsurprising) to see the media seize on any opportunity to complain about private schools having an unfair advantage. I listened to the BBC interview with BoJo's short-lived catch-up tsar, and what he repeatedly said was that this wasn't (just) about private vs state schools. He said that the grades this year have shown up the inequalities in the state system just as much as, if not more than, the inequalities between state and private. There were strong regional disparities, for example - grades in the deprived NE went down, while grades in state schools in more affluent areas soared. And these disparities affect far more children than any state v private divide. But what does the media seize on? 'The system favours private schools again.'

NotBadConsidering · 12/08/2021 09:31

I mean honestly Bryonyshcmyony can you put your hand on your heart and say you don’t think a single candidate has benefited from inflation? Or even a percentage of them? Of all the 18 year olds who sit A levels, who we all know are a mixture of all sorts of people, you think that half of them are A/A* standard? You don’t think at all that there are some kids (or their parents or teachers) who deep down know they’ve come out of it lucky? Or that there aren’t some kids (or their parents or teachers) who are truly exceptional now feeling jibbed they are now indistinguishable from Billy Slacker?

The only way that half of them can be considered A/A* standard is if the grades are worthless. Anyone who got a B or below is now in the bottom 50%. Any grade of C or below means you must be hopeless. And people are ok with this?

So many people who want the pretty lie rather than the ugly truth.

Absolutely.

herecomesthsun · 12/08/2021 09:28

If you have basically a child who does not excel at exams, they won't pass tests to get into competitive schools.

But then you wouldn't want them to languish in a comp.

So you find a nice school that will nurture them instead and make them feel special, and entice out hidden talents.

That is your market for St. Whatsits.

Could get that for ballpark £17k/annum on a quick google, less up North.

Kids that are not-very-good-at-tests are still probably not going to ace exams (except in a pandemic when there aren't any) but in normal times might at least leave with some qualifications whereas they would struggle to get any at the comp.

There's also the class thing. If you send your kid to St. Whatsits they will make friends with the children of other small businessmen, whereas if they go to the comp, their friends might not be so "nice".

TheReluctantPhoenix · 12/08/2021 09:27

@Bryonyshcmyony,

Not at all.

The grades did have to be evidence based, so if the most a pupil had ever achieved was a C, they would get a C.

However, if their topic test average was a B, but they had never achieved more than a C in an exam, the school could grade that pupil a B and back it with ‘evidence’.

Also, if any (non top) school exaggerated ridiculously, it would be moderated down by the boards.

The process was generally an objective and scientific way of awarding very optimistic (but not totally impossible) grades to every pupil. In an actual exam, some would have achieved this grade, most would average half a grade or so under it, and another few would actually have a bad day and have missed the TAGs by two grades or more. This is how a (log)normal distribution works.

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 09:20

Well I don't know because that would suggest 100% of pupils would get as or as and that definitely wasn't the case. The results for us were only slightly up on years before but they already get strings of As and As, I think the lowest anyone got in 2019 was one D in the whole sixth form

TheReluctantPhoenix · 12/08/2021 09:17

@Bryonyshcmyony,

You are not competing with the state sector, you are competing with the private school down the road.

So, if they are ‘adding’ a grade to the Midyis predict (Allis at A level), you want to be adding at least 1.2.

A business (which is essentially what a private school is) being able to review its own product is a recipe for grade inflation….

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 09:13

[quote TheReluctantPhoenix]@herecomesthsun,

It is not just tiny St Whatsits that worries about filling their sixth form. Many relatively well known London private schools have their top GCSE pupils creamed off by the same names: St Paul’s, Westminster, Latymer Upper etc.

In addition, quite a few pupils are lost to the state sector at this point, some for financial reasons and others who are playing the game of having their Oxbridge (or other top Uni) application looked upon more favourably as coming from the state sector.

Although there are many ways of increasing sixth form retention (fantastic facilities being one), grades and added value will always be a major part of it. Who would pay £20k plus to send their child to a school with average results?![/quote]
Well people do, but I agree with you that I can't quite understand why

If a school has all the benefits of small class sizes, less teacher churn, up to date tech and an excellent board of governors and still produces poor results then it must be pretty awful

TheReluctantPhoenix · 12/08/2021 09:10

@herecomesthsun,

It is not just tiny St Whatsits that worries about filling their sixth form. Many relatively well known London private schools have their top GCSE pupils creamed off by the same names: St Paul’s, Westminster, Latymer Upper etc.

In addition, quite a few pupils are lost to the state sector at this point, some for financial reasons and others who are playing the game of having their Oxbridge (or other top Uni) application looked upon more favourably as coming from the state sector.

Although there are many ways of increasing sixth form retention (fantastic facilities being one), grades and added value will always be a major part of it. Who would pay £20k plus to send their child to a school with average results?!

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 09:10

Well good for them! I expect that individual attention is what makes parents choose it in the first place plus the continuity of teaching was a big draw this year

Our school is full with a long wait list

herecomesthsun · 12/08/2021 09:07

@Bryonyshcmyony

Why would St whatsists care? Those kids have left and no league tables this year

In fact parents lower down the school wouldn't want rampant grade inflation thst doesn't benefit them at all

St Whatsits predicted As across the board this year, and is presumably included in the stats.

Its teachers cared very much about their little group of pupils and carefully provided a large amount of individual help in fashioning beautifully organised folders to evidence their grades.

The headteacher is delighted with the results and plans to mention them as often as possible when speaking to prospective parents.

They have already posted letters from grateful parents and students on the school website, about how wonderful to was over lockdown Smile