[quote NoIDontWatchLoveIsland]**@hedgehogger1
The challenge is that if you KNOW every year one of your 5 "sure shots" stuffs up, and you know one might be close to the boundary in a tough year, really you need to take the two poorest of the 5 and predict they won't make it. It feels tough because you are focusing on the individual students and considering how you explain to them that they didnt get there. By making you predict, they made you answerable.
And the only way to answer those students is to say "the boundary was tough to hit this year".
Of course it was never going to be done this way, so here we are with half the kids getting top grades. Yes they've worked hard but no, half the kids do not deserve top grades or they wouldnt be top grades, would they.[/quote]
Absolutely this ^
The answer from @hedgehogger1 contained an example of a student who was close to the B/C boundary but predicted a B.
Educators have accepted, apparently unanimously, that the correct thing to do is to predict a B for that kid in the knowledge that they are equally likely to get a C. The exams then resolve any disconnect between prediction and reality.
We all know that exams are not totally fair. Even if you accept that they test how well one deals with pressure as well as pure academic ability, they take no account of the student who received bad news last night, or who is feeling unwell but will be fine tomorrow. But looking at this year's results it brings to mind Churchill's quote about democracy: it's the worst system of government except for all the others.