Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A level grades

678 replies

DolphinFC · 10/08/2021 10:25

If feel that value of an A grade ar A level has been reduced dramatically. I feel truly sorry for those very bright, hard-working students who would've got an A grade no matter what. Their deserved A grade is now lost in a pile of undeserved A grades.

OP posts:
RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 12/08/2021 13:43

@SerenaCat

I guess the proof will be in the pudding when this year's A level students get their University results in 3/4 years time...
Nah

I reckon they’ll be threads on here saying they shouldn’t have firsts and 2:1s as they are too easy and being given away

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 12/08/2021 13:41

I think the ranking system was still in place….which is a smidge unfortunate for ds2 (as with others obvs) as he was working at a higher grade but was downgraded because of a very bright cohort (in that subject)

SerenaCat · 12/08/2021 13:41

I guess the proof will be in the pudding when this year's A level students get their University results in 3/4 years time...

igelkott2021 · 12/08/2021 13:24

The other issue, of course, is schools knew uni offers before awarding grades

not necessarily

I actually thought the system would have worked better if schools had been allowed to tell students what their grades were likely to be so they accepted offers accordingly. Not much point accepting an AAA offer if you were going to get BBB. And despite the hysteria on this thread about "everyone getting As", there were plenty of kids who did not get what they needed.

stuckdownahole · 12/08/2021 13:07

[quote NoIDontWatchLoveIsland]**@hedgehogger1

The challenge is that if you KNOW every year one of your 5 "sure shots" stuffs up, and you know one might be close to the boundary in a tough year, really you need to take the two poorest of the 5 and predict they won't make it. It feels tough because you are focusing on the individual students and considering how you explain to them that they didnt get there. By making you predict, they made you answerable.

And the only way to answer those students is to say "the boundary was tough to hit this year".

Of course it was never going to be done this way, so here we are with half the kids getting top grades. Yes they've worked hard but no, half the kids do not deserve top grades or they wouldnt be top grades, would they.[/quote]
Absolutely this ^

The answer from @hedgehogger1 contained an example of a student who was close to the B/C boundary but predicted a B.

Educators have accepted, apparently unanimously, that the correct thing to do is to predict a B for that kid in the knowledge that they are equally likely to get a C. The exams then resolve any disconnect between prediction and reality.

We all know that exams are not totally fair. Even if you accept that they test how well one deals with pressure as well as pure academic ability, they take no account of the student who received bad news last night, or who is feeling unwell but will be fine tomorrow. But looking at this year's results it brings to mind Churchill's quote about democracy: it's the worst system of government except for all the others.

BumbledBee · 12/08/2021 13:05

@TheReluctantPhoenix

The other issue, of course, is schools knew uni offers before awarding grades.

If a pupil is expected to get AAB, and has an AAA offer to read medicine, how tempting is it for the SLT to bump up that B to an A?

I can't speak for other schools but my DH teaches a-level at a grammar and they did not look at what the DC needed for courses and were careful not to inflate grades - both on an individual basis and beyond a typical year's results. He found out today that 15% of the DC in his subject weren't given the grades they needed for the course they wanted, but some of them were taken by the university anyway.
herecomesthsun · 12/08/2021 12:59

ah re GCSEs

"Grammar schools usually outperform those in the independent sector, in part because many private schools choose to take so-called international or IGCSEs or similar qualifications, rather than the exams regulated by government agencies."

maybe that helps account for some of the discrepancy

herecomesthsun · 12/08/2021 12:56

@TheReluctantPhoenix

The other issue, of course, is schools knew uni offers before awarding grades.

If a pupil is expected to get AAB, and has an AAA offer to read medicine, how tempting is it for the SLT to bump up that B to an A?

Veeeery hard to mark down, even more so if we are talking Oxbridge, very hard for the school to deny kids opportunities like that (I am told)
herecomesthsun · 12/08/2021 12:54

Very interesting that selective state schools got higher grades awarded at GCSE than the indies.

GCSE grade 7-9
68.4%...... state selective
61.2 .........independent
28.1...........academy
26.1...........comp

So how did kids at indies do so much better comparatively at A level?

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 12:53

It's probably more useful to here from non parents

Useful how?

TheReluctantPhoenix · 12/08/2021 12:50

The other issue, of course, is schools knew uni offers before awarding grades.

If a pupil is expected to get AAB, and has an AAA offer to read medicine, how tempting is it for the SLT to bump up that B to an A?

blubbebubba · 12/08/2021 12:16

It's probably more useful to here from non parents. Parents are more likely to be biased. Everyone wants the best for their kid, so parents whose kids got top grades won't mind and wonder what the big deal is. "My DC worked hard, so they deserve an A*"

herecomesthsun · 12/08/2021 12:01

I don't have a child taking public exams yey, but I do care about the issues for example with competition in clearing. Children who were very carefully graded at state schools to be in line with past performance will be at an unfair disadvantage competing with kids whose independent schools marked them overgenerously.

If it weren't for the element of competition for University places (or jobs) and it was just a pat on the back, it wouldn't matter.

ThatFlamingCandle · 12/08/2021 11:56

@Bryonyshcmyony

One big happy group kids all lumped together who all deserve a participation medal like on sports day aged 6

🙄

Amazing someone with no skin in the game can get so angry about it.

I agree with @NotBadConsidering and I have skin in the game. You don't need a kid this age to see it might be a bit of an issue.
Saucery · 12/08/2021 11:51

I do think this year’s dc have been amazing. From Reception to 6th Form, every single one of them.

For those fretting about OPK, maybe there’ll be a news story in a year, or 3 years, about the failure rate at Uni and you can be all smug about how you were right and 50% of the A level cohort this year are useless entitled thickies who didn’t deserve their place. Warm your cockles with that thought Smile
Alternatively, you can read the posts explaining exactly how the grades were arrived at, from people actually doing the job and accept that assessment over a two year period will give different results to intensive exams. Perhaps even accept there are many contributory factors to attainment of A level grades (opportunity, class, type of school, parental engagement in education right through 3-18…….).

ThatFlamingCandle · 12/08/2021 11:51

@Bryonyshcmyony

I think if any kid who normally would have got a B gets an A it doesn't matter a jot and good luck to them

I don't believe D students would have been given As, no

Sorry, I'm not sure if you have an A level dc or not

Of course it doesn't matter to you because you're not impacted by it! What about tpeiple who sat exams 2019 and previous, or 2022 and after? Talented (esp. working class) kids who's hard work is undervalued because everyone got the same? Students mislead into thinking they can handle an intensive STEM course?

Why even have formal education if everyone just gets an A? Let's just give out participation certificates. Even with coursework, 50% of the cohort are not deserving of the top grade.

You can make the argument exams aren't the best method of assessment, but this botched batch of grades is not the answer to that

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 12/08/2021 11:51

@hedgehogger1

The challenge is that if you KNOW every year one of your 5 "sure shots" stuffs up, and you know one might be close to the boundary in a tough year, really you need to take the two poorest of the 5 and predict they won't make it. It feels tough because you are focusing on the individual students and considering how you explain to them that they didnt get there. By making you predict, they made you answerable.

And the only way to answer those students is to say "the boundary was tough to hit this year".

Of course it was never going to be done this way, so here we are with half the kids getting top grades. Yes they've worked hard but no, half the kids do not deserve top grades or they wouldnt be top grades, would they.

NotBadConsidering · 12/08/2021 11:36

I do have skin in the game. I just explained why.

Amazing how people with skin in the game are unable to think objectively about it and think their kids are all amazing and can’t possibly entertain the idea that the cohort of 2021 isn’t actually a bunch of geniuses.

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 11:32

One big happy group kids all lumped together who all deserve a participation medal like on sports day aged 6

🙄

Amazing someone with no skin in the game can get so angry about it.

herecomesthsun · 12/08/2021 11:32

This is a fairly decent independent, #achievetheextraordinary, fees 15k, up to 37k boarding

A LEVEL RESULTS
...............2016.......... 2017 ............2018 ..........2019 .......2020.......2021
A*.......... 12% ...........8% ............3%.................. 4% ..........16%
A*-A .......35% ..........30%.............. 23% ..............18% .........41%........approx 60%
A*-B ........61% ...........49% .........51% ............47%............69%
A*-C ........82%........... 71% ...........79% ...............71% ..........88%
A*-E .......99% ............93% ...........98%................ 98% .........100%

NotBadConsidering · 12/08/2021 11:28

@Bryonyshcmyony

I think if any kid who normally would have got a B gets an A it doesn't matter a jot and good luck to them

I don't believe D students would have been given As, no

Sorry, I'm not sure if you have an A level dc or not

If you think it doesn’t matter that any kid who normally get a B ended up with an A, you’re saying to all those kids who normally get As that you don’t care their result has been devalued. One big happy group kids all lumped together who all deserve a participation medal like on sports day aged 6.

Why does it matter if I have an A level kid or not? It’s only those that do who are seemingly blind to the idiocy of all this. I actually have a nephew who is A levels next year. This will affect him massively as there will likely be huge recalibration with tougher marking to compensate, plus competing for places for all the decidedly average students who got inflated marks this year who didn’t start uni this year. I have every confidence that whatever grades he gets, there are people in this year’s cohort who will have better grades than him that won’t be as deserving.

But yay! Let’s all give everyone a medal this year because they deserve a break! Who cares about those that follow this shit show eh?

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 11:22

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

Universities arent stupid. They will simply start ignoring grades, and will simply request module by module % and will select the top students based on those. If the government/ofqual allow too many students to all get 100% and it gets too hard to distinguish the best, universities will start demanding international baccalaureate or other alternatives to ensure they can select.
Well they haven't done this for this year or next year and then afer that things will be back to normal so I doubt they'll do this
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 12/08/2021 11:20

Universities arent stupid. They will simply start ignoring grades, and will simply request module by module % and will select the top students based on those. If the government/ofqual allow too many students to all get 100% and it gets too hard to distinguish the best, universities will start demanding international baccalaureate or other alternatives to ensure they can select.

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 11:18

@hedgehogger1 explains things perfectly btw

Bryonyshcmyony · 12/08/2021 11:15

I think if any kid who normally would have got a B gets an A it doesn't matter a jot and good luck to them

I don't believe D students would have been given As, no

Sorry, I'm not sure if you have an A level dc or not

Swipe left for the next trending thread