Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A level grades

678 replies

DolphinFC · 10/08/2021 10:25

If feel that value of an A grade ar A level has been reduced dramatically. I feel truly sorry for those very bright, hard-working students who would've got an A grade no matter what. Their deserved A grade is now lost in a pile of undeserved A grades.

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 10/08/2021 15:58

@HappySonHappyMum

Lovely goody OP there. Can only surmise that you've paid for private education for your DCs to get yourself shiny As for your kids. Of course 70% of them got As against the 39% from state schools - which dramatically skewed the results that are all over the news. Takes the shine off your privilege I suppose! Perhaps we should all be thinking how private schools can achieve such high results and try to replicate them in our state schools so everyone - not just the rich - can achieve. Oh sorry Gav's sorted it hasn't he - our DCs are going to start learning Latin soon aren't they Hmm
Would you like salt and vinegar to go with that huge chip on your shoulder?
longlivesheeples · 10/08/2021 15:56

@herecomesthsun

It doesn't really affect us, as not year 12. However, my son's state school normally gets in excess of 45% A and A* grades in sixth form.

The results went up by about 2% this year, as opposed to nearly 20% nationally.

I can see why there might have been pressures on grade inflation generally though, how could teachers not give kids the benefit of the doubt.

It's a shame that this is going to cause so much confusion and oversubscribing at universities.

I wish them all well however, I'm sure they would all have rather had a normal year by far.

Yes, this is what I was wondering. Super selective grammars must be a little fed up and their students are at a disadvantage this year (and probably next) in relative terms because these are the grades their students would normally achieve and there is no opportunity for the kind of grade inflation other students and schools are benefitting from as there is no grade A** or grade 10 etc (not that I think there should be, but this year is not a normal situation).
bevelino · 10/08/2021 15:55

I help manage graduate recruitment in the firm I work for and we will not be penalising any student, A’level or otherwise for the results they received in the pandemic. It appears clear that the way in which grades have been awarded for the last two years may be inconsistent from school to school. However, there are plenty of ways for employers to assess candidates applying for graduate roles besides looking at their exam results.

ineedaholidaynow · 10/08/2021 15:53

Following on from @hedgehogger1 post, do teachers think the exam system is flawed, with everything hinging on 1 or 2 days for each subject.

I was a nervous wreck in exams, would sit, for what seemed like hours, just plucking up the courage to open the paper, then would cry, so would have a reduced time to actually answer the questions, and wasn't really in a fit state to do my best. Luckily I managed to pass all exams taken of various forms, but put huge mental toll on me (and my parents watching me fall apart in exam season). However, it didn't stop me taking A-levels, a degree and professional exams!

Still feel sick when I see an exam hall. Think I am stressing more than DS about his GCSE results on Thursday.

Although I passed all my exams my grades were always lower than the work I did in class, sometimes by about 20%. I am old so did O-levels so have never experienced coursework being used for grades.

I'm not sure I would have coped with the extreme pressure students were under in their last term doing continual assessments (or the pressure I would have put on myself)

But is there a fair way to ensure as many candidates as possible achieve their true potential. The exam system certainly didn't let me achieve my true potential, but being someone who worries a lot and puts huge pressure on myself, not sure what system would have worked for me.

herecomesthsun · 10/08/2021 15:48

Also curious about the 70% for private schools (that sounds well dodgy if true)

herecomesthsun · 10/08/2021 15:46

It doesn't really affect us, as not year 12. However, my son's state
school normally gets in excess of 45% A and A* grades in sixth form.

The results went up by about 2% this year, as opposed to nearly 20% nationally.

I can see why there might have been pressures on grade inflation generally though, how could teachers not give kids the benefit of the doubt.

It's a shame that this is going to cause so much confusion and oversubscribing at universities.

I wish them all well however, I'm sure they would all have rather had a normal year by far.

HappySonHappyMum · 10/08/2021 15:46

Lovely goody OP there. Can only surmise that you've paid for private education for your DCs to get yourself shiny As for your kids. Of course 70% of them got As against the 39% from state schools - which dramatically skewed the results that are all over the news. Takes the shine off your privilege I suppose! Perhaps we should all be thinking how private schools can achieve such high results and try to replicate them in our state schools so everyone - not just the rich - can achieve. Oh sorry Gav's sorted it hasn't he - our DCs are going to start learning Latin soon aren't they Hmm

reallyisthisallthereis · 10/08/2021 15:42

And to add to that. I marked the mocks blindly (which works for most students except when their handwriting is really distinctive) and moderated with another school. I'm also an experienced examiner so pretty confident in my marking.

reallyisthisallthereis · 10/08/2021 15:37

Agree that hedgehogger's post is spot on.

In addition I have to say that I've found the year 13's this year have worked above and beyond. The extra uncertainty and possibly lack of social life means they have thrown themselves into their work. My grades are slightly above expected but they have more than earned it and I have solid evidence to support it. I don't know whether this is the case in other schools but I suspect it is.

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 10/08/2021 15:35

Oh and the 44.3% is 70% for private schools

Is it?

Do you happen to have a link for that

stoneysongs · 10/08/2021 15:34

and some will use their political bias to try and change society

Surely this is quote of the day 😂😂

noblegiraffe · 10/08/2021 15:31

Sadly the shambles of a government/education department has failed totally in this, why no planning for a worst-case scenario given last years joke.

Boris Johnson instructed the DfE not to come up with contingency plans for cancelling exams this year because he thought that the existence of contingency plans would make it more likely to happen.

schoolsweek.co.uk/institute-for-government-covid-handling-report-lockdown

And the DfE thought exams were going ahead right up to the point where Johnson closed schools and cancelled exams.

The failures came right from the top.

Congratulations to those getting good exam results today and on Thursday. Even getting through this year and through the assessment process has required remarkable resilience on their part, so to come out with good results as well is something they should be very proud of.

JanetheObscure · 10/08/2021 15:22

Yes, excellent post from hedgehogger.

It's possible to acknowledge that the percentage of "top" grades is significantly higher than usual the year, without denigrating the students' efforts during what has been an extraordinarily difficult time.

Cheeseismymiddlename · 10/08/2021 15:12

@hedgehogger1 Thank you for your brilliant post .

dameofdilemma · 10/08/2021 15:05

Can everyone pls read Hedgehoggers post on the first page before swearing at the OP....
(Thank you Hh, really interesting to read about the actual grading process. The lack of bell curve absolutely makes sense...there's no real comparator this time).

(Oh and the 44.3% is 70% for private schools)

Purplepeoniesdroppingpetals · 10/08/2021 15:03

Oh and quite a few of the teachers moderating are normally employed by exam boards to do it, so they did the work that they’re normally employed to do for free as well. They’re knowledgeable and qualified.

Purplepeoniesdroppingpetals · 10/08/2021 15:01

@Franklin12

It shows that the teachers should not have been given this level of responsibility. Some will have used this as an opportunity to move their students upwards, some will not understand what they are doing, and some will use their political bias to try and change society.

I feel desperately sorry for the students who do deserve these grades and the figure is not 44%.

Bizarre. Teacher here. Our moderation process was to set exams based on exam board material. We also used our formal mocks. We marked. We moderated internally and then moderated again, without prejudice, by using teachers from another school. Finally, we blind marked anyone who was close to a boundary. No time for social engineering; instead, knackered teachers doing all of this extra, vital work for free whilst also supporting the mental health of many fragile students.
DolphinFC · 10/08/2021 14:47

Next year exams will be back and the number of A grades will fall.

Mumsnet will be full of threads moaning about their child will be disadvantaged compared to this year's.

OP posts:
Twinsmum2003 · 10/08/2021 14:32

What do you mean?

Worldwide21 · 10/08/2021 14:24

Whaylt do you guys think will happen in future years as although it was fair to allow teacher assessed grades this year, this level of inflation is unsustainable going forward. Unis wont know who to accept without resorting to entrance exams which would make the whole experience more stressful

Bryonyshcmyony · 10/08/2021 14:03

School actively said they were going to downgrade predicted and estimated grades because they were worried about over inflation. Ie if you achieved grade B in year 12 end of year, they were going to predict you would achieve a grade C at A level because work gets harder

Yeah that didn't happen

Twinsmum2003 · 10/08/2021 14:01

I know of two girl’s who got their A level results today:

1 fairly bright, goes to decent but not massively over achieving comp. been awarded 3 A*’s.
1 very bright and diligent goes to very successful grammar, awarded far less than expected (so did my year 12 son in his grammar). School actively said they were going to downgrade predicted and estimated grades because they were worried about over inflation. Ie if you achieved grade B in year 12 end of year, they were going to predict you would achieve a grade C at A level because work gets harder.

How is this fair? Girl B definitely the brighter and very hard working. I feel so badly for this cohort. I was hoping it would all be back to ‘normal’ next year when my two sit their A levels but in the news this morning it said it probably wouldn’t be. I can only hope it comes out ‘in the wash’ in the next stage of their eduction, although some won’t have the opportunity to show that.

3teens2cats · 10/08/2021 13:18

My ds was one of those getting top grades today and he bloody deserved them. Here are my thoughts based on my limited experience of having 2 now go through a levels.

Firstly, I think btec etc are now seen as a real alternative to a levels so students who are not aiming for top grades will explore them as an alternative option. Lots of ds friends have done them instead of a levels.

Secondly this cohort have not had a normal 'coming of age' type experience. No drunken house parties, no clubbing, less opportunity to meet girlfriends/boyfriends so have actually knuckled down and focused on their studies like adults have been begging them to do for generations. Our older ds who took a levels long before the pandemic certainly had more distractions in his life.

Thirdly, as pp have already pointed out you have removed the potential to fuck up on the day. Turn 2 pages over at once, miss reading a question, nerves make the mind go blank etc now have far less of an impact.

Combine all this together and i can see why the grades have worked out how they have. Ds has performed consistently well throughout his education and predicted high grades from the start. He deserved what he got today.

phlebasconsidered · 10/08/2021 13:07

@SafeMove I agree totally.
@Saucery - no surprise there! Or that it's not being widely reported.

Sparklybanana · 10/08/2021 13:05

At the end of the day, grades are there to get you into university nowadays. You will soon find out if your abilities don't tie up with your grades and most jobs now have some sort of test to see if you are capable of doing the job. I would probably keep an extra eye on anyone who got grades this year as I just don't believe that almost half of students are bright enough to get the top grade. Statistically it just doesn't work that way. No one is saying these kids didn't work hard but it's doing no one any long term favours. The ones who always would have got an A are now not distinguishable on paper, the ones who shouldn't have got the grade will find it hard to keep up, the ones who didn't get the top grade will now be feeling way worse because half their peers got an A so how can they not berate themselves and think down on their abilities.

But at the end of the day, it's not fair however its done. It's not right the way its fallen but it has allowed a lost generation of kids who have had suffered these past two years to get a step up where they need it and I for one am not going to scream for fairness to other years because these kids haven't had fair. They deserve a little helping hand like a lot of the rest of us have had.

Swipe left for the next trending thread