Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help understanding autism

111 replies

Candice34 · 10/08/2021 07:50

I'm looking for help understanding autism as it's causing issues in my family. The girl in question is 14 and has been assessed for autism several times but not officially diagnosed. I know it's hard to get an official diagnosis at times.

What I'm trying to find out is, if you are autistic, do you know you are being autistic?

In my head, I would have thought your brain is telling you to do this and you think it's a normal behaviour to do. For example she made a big thing at a family meal because one piece of food touched another piece of food on her plate and she couldn't eat the food because it was contaminated. However she told everyone that she'd read something about autism and food not touching so now she has to behave like that because she is autistic. This is what I don't understand as if she knows she is doing it, surely we can support her and help her understand that it is ok if food touches etc.

Other instances have included us all ready and waiting to go out, but we all had to wait for about 15 minutes as she was watching something on Netflix and because she is autistic, she can't stop a video until the end as it would upset her balance. They didn't attend another family day out at very short notice as she decided she decided seeing her family was too overwhelming and she needed time to "rebalance her equilibrium". Another one was paid for museum exhibition to celebrate another family members birthday, but she decided on arrival that she didn't want to do it because she's autistic and couldn't cope with it. She wanted to sit in a coffee shop and watch Netflix so her and her mother went and did that while the rest of us did the exhibition the birthday boy wanted to do.

None of us know how to handle her autism and her parents say we just have to do as she says and follow her lead. Callous as it sounds, family members are getting irritated at everything revolving around her and her wishes and we all have to jump to her tune. I feel stuck in the middle as some want to plan things without her and I feel bad for leaving her out but at the same time, others are getting upset at her turning up and everything having to change because it's affecting her autism.

What is the best way of handling her autism? How do you do it to keep everyone happy in family situations like this?

OP posts:
NotPersephone · 10/08/2021 11:01

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

ShowMeHow · 10/08/2021 10:58

Soup gate

What a nightmare. If she has autism which she may well have then you need to make adjustments for her if you can and you did.

Food is perhaps a difficulty for her that does not make you a magician.

She or her parents need a fallback for such situations. The responsibility beyond what you already did really is theirs.

Clocktopus · 10/08/2021 10:55

She ain’t autistic, OP

Yet another poster who has had sight of this girl's medical record...

Clocktopus · 10/08/2021 10:53

I found the asessment process very in depth and went on for a couple of years from start to finish. If she has had that (did you say twice?!) and they say she isn't autistic, then she isn't autistic.

Have you had sight of her records? Unless you have have you don't know. One of my DC was assessed three times before being diagnosed and the final assessment concluded they should have been diagnosed the first time around and certainly the second time around as there was more than enough evidence there to support a diagnosis. The team who did that final assessment raised a complaint about it.

spongedod · 10/08/2021 10:52

What I'm trying to find out is, if you are autistic, do you know you are being autistic?

I'm autistic. I'm never 'being' autistic, because I am autistic. I don't keep my autism in a bag and pull it out sometimes - it's who I am. I may recognise a behaviour as happening because I am autistic, but I not 'being' it. It's not something you pick and choose.

That said, I don't think it bears much relevance here, I just wanted to say my piece because I hate the misunderstanding:

NotPersephone · 10/08/2021 10:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

liveforsummer · 10/08/2021 10:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

FatCatThinCat · 10/08/2021 10:36

I suspect that if she's had multiple autism assessments and the results say she doesn't have autism then she doesn't have autism.

Yes it is very difficult for females to get diagnosed, but that is because it's difficult to get referred in the first place. I know several females who struggled to get assessed but I don't know any who didn't get a diagnosis once they did get assessed.

My own DD was assessed as a teen (having had all her symptoms dismissed as down to poor parenting for many years). The assessment she went through took months and was way more in depth than when I subsequently went through it and then 4 year old DS. The psychologist explained that it's actually harder to diagnose in teens because there is so much more learned behaviour and attention seeking behaviour and finding ones identity at play.

coodawoodashooda · 10/08/2021 10:23

At one point i found something that i think was called, 'asd simulation,' online. That might help.

AlfonsoTheMango · 10/08/2021 10:22

@OaxacaChihuahua

It’s not a case of her recognising that’s she’s ‘being autistic’ about something so that she can stop it. Autism isn’t something you can separate out from the person, as though it’s a layer on top of who they really are. It’s totally fundamental to their identity, an inextricable aspect of their personhood.

There’s a really good Instagram account I would recommend called @ the.autisticats - it is run by autistic people it has really helped me have a better understanding of what it’s like to be autistic.

What a lovely, helpful post! Thank you.
AlfonsoTheMango · 10/08/2021 10:21

@Peanutsandchilli

I'll be honest, it doesn't sound like autistic behaviour. It sounds like attention seeking for another reason, possibly some anxiety too. The fact that she's been assessed for autism, and told she's not, only backs up my thoughts. Teenagers will push boundaries, and it sounds like that's exactly what she's doing.
I totally agree.
TonkaTrucker · 10/08/2021 10:18

You can be anxious and highly strung without being autistic.
From the snapshot of this post I would land on the side of high anxiety/desire for control.
That doesn't devalue the teen's feelings, but in my experience anxiety can be misattributed to ASD. It has overlaps and can be a great mimic.
There could be no malice in the attachment of the 'autism' label, it can be a great relief to individuals/families to have a framework to work with/an explanation and can legitimise the adaptions the teen feels she needs.

beautifullymad · 10/08/2021 10:18

@Runnerduck34

I can feel your frustration. I am learning about autism too, my DD 14 has recently been diagnosed privately as wait for nhs diagnosis is 2 years+ where we live. We have heard that some NHS trusts are moving away from diagnosis or are making criteria for diagnosis more difficult. Girls are often diagnosed later and are good at masking, things coming to a head at puberty is very common. TBF your family member does sound that she has autistic traits ,is highly anxious and needs to control things, all very common with autism. We struggle to get DD out and any busy,family event is likely to cause her enormous anxiety. So speaking personalIy I would try and support and be as flexible as possible and dont make a fuss, keep it all low key. Regarding food I would just say explain I made the pie for her and say this is what we have if you don't want it and let her choose. She might be happy with toast or a bag of crisps. Try not to take any rejection personally and really important keep trying to engage and keep communication light with minimal expectation and demand. Since DD has been diagnosed it made me look at family traits in a new light , Ive always thought MIL was a bloody difficult woman, now I am pretty certain she has autism too!
Yes to looking with new eyes at family members. My grandmother was displaying very autistic traits. I remember the penny dropping and realising that many of the older 'quirky' family members were behaving in quite autistic ways.

They are all 55+ so no possible diagnosis available for them as children.

It's given me a whole set of things I can do to minimise their anxiety. It also makes me less frustrated when trying to make sense of quirky relatives. I can see it clearly now, so clearly it's upsetting they have never been able to access help or compassion.

Three out of my five nieces and nephews are diagnosed.
I think autism runs in families.

Foobydoo · 10/08/2021 10:17

[quote Candice34]@Warmduscher

She's referred by her GP, assessed and referred back as not autistic. The parents think the diagnosis is wrong and that she definitely has autism so she goes back to the GP and gets referred back again.

@Sirzy I've been trying to do that. They were coming here for an evening meal, so I rang her in the morning for a chat and asked what she would like us to eat. She said steak pie, so I made a steak pie. When I was dishing it up, she decided she didn't want pie and wanted soup. I did have a couple of tins of broth in the cupboard but it had lumps of veg in and she only wanted smooth soup. I offered to put it in the blender for her, but she couldn't have it as the lumps of veg had already contaminated it. I ended up keeping everyone else's food warm and walking round to the corner shop and bought her a tin of tomato soup as that was the only soup they had without lumps in. She complained it wasn't carrot soup but then did eat the tomato soup but she was unhappy while she was here. If she'd said she wanted carrot soup earlier, I'd have sorted that out for her.

It's frustrating as I tried so hard to get it right for her but I didn't and I upset her.[/quote]
She this is pandering. Autistic or not, I wouldn't do this.
I would have just said, im sorry that is all I have but I completely understand if you cannot eat it. Especially when you cooked what she asked for.
Anyone can be spoiled autistic or not. A full on autistic meltdown is distressing for others to see so I can understand why her parents give in to her but it wont do her any good in the long run. I would have briefed my dd before we came saying it was ok if she couldn't eat her food for any reason, she could just politely say she wasn't hungry or something and she could have supper later. I wouldn't let her disrupt everyone elses meal.

Foobydoo · 10/08/2021 10:08

It is difficult because all autistic people are different.
My dd has issues like the ones you described but she doesn't talk about being autistic, she would probably have orchestrated a row so she could run off and not eat a dinner where food had touched or do something she felt uncomfortable with rather than tell us what was wrong. She has a need to be in control that is rooted in anxiety and as other posters have said that is getting better the older she gets as she has more control over her life.

With dd she often cannot do things like attend certain events and cannot explain why. She gets very upset about this as it is often things she really wants to do.
It is very complex and hard to unpick, on the surface she may appear difficult but her life is much harder than other teens her age and she really struggles at times.
As others have said the diagnostic process is rigorous but girls do slip through the net as they mask so well.

FrenchBoule · 10/08/2021 10:05

@TimeIhadaNameChange

She might be autistic, but to me it sounds like she's jumped on the Autism bandwagon, is milking it for all it's worth and her parents are enabling it. If this is the case she's going to be awful when she's an adult.

I'd be tempted to stop jumping to her tune. She doesn't want pie? Give her toast. Let her parents spoil her if they want but I wouldn't go along with it.

I await flaming.

I agree.

Let her parents sort her out, nobody else has to jump to her tune.
I would have not gone to the shop to cater for her whims.

You don’t like the food you requested? Fine, there’s toast,cereal and beans/tuna on the offer. No? Well sorry,don’t have anything else.
If parents are unhappy then they could sort something out.

Peanutsandchilli · 10/08/2021 10:01

I'll be honest, it doesn't sound like autistic behaviour. It sounds like attention seeking for another reason, possibly some anxiety too. The fact that she's been assessed for autism, and told she's not, only backs up my thoughts. Teenagers will push boundaries, and it sounds like that's exactly what she's doing.

AvaCallanach · 10/08/2021 09:58

My ds is autistic

I wouldn't "pander" this much. For example, since he was 12 or so, if he doesn't want to join us on an outing that's fine, but I wouldn't miss it to sit with him. I would have said to ds that of course he could sit in the cafe while we look at the exhibition. I would have made sure he had his iPad and headphones in a bag somewhere for such an eventuality.
In the steak pie situation, I would have offered the pie, or the available soup, or bread and butter/cheese. You already made the adaptation by discussing what she wanted in advance. You didn't have to run down to the shop to get smooth soup. That crosses the line between being flexible and pandering imo. We know what DS will eat and he gets family meals with minor adjustments. Eg when we have spag bol, he hates Bolognese sauce so he has the same pasta with butter and cheese. If we have rice and meatballs, he has his meatballs not in the tomato sauce. But I am buggered if I am prepping completely different meals for him.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 10/08/2021 09:53

I found the asessment process very in depth and went on for a couple of years from start to finish. If she has had that (did you say twice?!) and they say she isn't autistic, then she isn't autistic.

AntiSocialDistancer · 10/08/2021 09:48

@UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme

That's complicated because in your 08:34 post you have an example of a teen who's a little bit spoilt. An autistic teen will be doing some of the things they do because they are autistic, but autistic isn't the sum of all they are. In fact they are a teen with autism - a complex human impacted by their environment (people around them and how they react, parents' responses, what's going on in the moment etc) and hormones/ puberty and personality and also by autism...

Its very difficult to unpick what is autism and what is upbringing and personality and of course puberty. However yes, individuals with autism and the ability to read about autism will often follow the"rules" of being autistic when they first learn what they are - it can be a relief, but parents completely reinforcing that every whim is "the autism" and has to be indulged won't do her any favours - its about finding the right line to follow, and that's challenging.

As a family member who isn't her parent you need to find a way to work around this without inappropriately trying to tell the family how to handle the teenager. You don't have to be ruled by her whims but it is not your place to tell her or her parents how to handle situations she might find overwhelming. Generally though she should have space to remove herself safely from overwhelming situations - nobody should demand she joins in - without the extended family having to change their plans.

The whole of this message!
Punxsutawney · 10/08/2021 09:48

Seems to be some posters on this thread suggesting parents of autistic teens can 'handle it badly' or 'reinforce every whim'.

Unless you are actually living it, it's not really fair to suggest it's a parental thing. Many autistic teenagers have really complex difficulties that can impact hugely on their lives, often there is little to zero support for them or their families. Ds who is autistic has been on the CAMHS caseload for a year and had yet to access any therapy. Parent blaming does not help.

And autistic bandwagon..... seriously?

At 17 Ds wishes he had never been born and feels like life is hopeless, some days I wonder if he will ever be able to live a functional life. Autism is not fun or quirky in our house....currently it's shit. I'm not sure anyone would want to fake this life.

abcx · 10/08/2021 09:45

She's old enough to know what she wants to eat. I would've said you choose steak pie so that's all on offer.

With or without autism the behaviours described need to be addressed by firm parenting. Kids need rules and boundaries. They also need to feel in control in the teenage years.

If she feels she is living with autism who are we to argue? It doesn't give her the excuse to be rude. I say that as a mother of a dx son with autism. He can be very rude at times and we always remind him of a better way to say something in social situations.

Cabinfever10 · 10/08/2021 09:44

@Candice34
Both my ds and I have autism, I am high functioning ds is much more severely affected.
I am very aware of my limitations when it comes to things that I know will cause me problems and as such I can and avoid these triggers as much as possible. One of my issues is crowds, I absolutely cannot deal with people in my personal space. I have agreed to go places which should have been quiet and found them instead mobbed and have had to pull out at the last minute. I find somewhere quiet and wait on everyone else. I rarely go to large family/friends get togethers for the same reason. Yes when I can put myself out of my comfort zone but it comes at a high emotional cost to me.
My ds is much less able to recognise his triggers as everything causes him issues so for him it's about minimizing how the world impacts on him.
The thing about autism is that no two people are the same and someone can have autistic traits without having autism

girlofthenorth · 10/08/2021 09:43

@AlfonsoTheMango
Completely disagree , it can take years and and several high specialised opinions to get the diagnosis of ASC correct . If the person is displaying autistic tendencies , which this young person clearly is, then it's likely that they are autistic, or have autistic traits which is the same thing . Are you a specialist in autism ? Clearly not. Or it could be an associated issue which needs further understanding .

I can't believe some of the blatantly ableist comments on here , it's really disgusting !! Especially the use of the term bandwagon .

Whatever your family member is going through OP, if she is on the spectrum or not, or has mental health issues , or going through something else , it needs understanding , and support , please don't listen to these derogatory comments ! Some autistic people like to have a diagnosis , it's something they can cling to whereas others reject it .
It's a cliche, but we are all on a spectrum . The world is full of neuro divergent people . Not everyone fits into one mould. It sounds like you're really trying to understand her , I would just carry on as you are, you will get there , and probably be the one that has the best relationship with her . With something like the soup issue , I would pre empt that situation with , 'we are having soup today , I have x,y and z but if you don't want those , we can make a sandwich ' . Small choices are a start .

Runnerduck34 · 10/08/2021 09:37

I can feel your frustration.
I am learning about autism too, my DD 14 has recently been diagnosed privately as wait for nhs diagnosis is 2 years+ where we live.
We have heard that some NHS trusts are moving away from diagnosis or are making criteria for diagnosis more difficult.
Girls are often diagnosed later and are good at masking, things coming to a head at puberty is very common.
TBF your family member does sound that she has autistic traits ,is highly anxious and needs to control things, all very common with autism.
We struggle to get DD out and any busy,family event is likely to cause her enormous anxiety.
So speaking personalIy I would try and support and be as flexible as possible and dont make a fuss, keep it all low key.
Regarding food I would just say explain I made the pie for her and say this is what we have if you don't want it and let her choose. She might be happy with toast or a bag of crisps.
Try not to take any rejection personally and really important keep trying to engage and keep communication light with minimal expectation and demand.
Since DD has been diagnosed it made me look at family traits in a new light , Ive always thought MIL was a bloody difficult woman, now I am pretty certain she has autism too!

Swipe left for the next trending thread