Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mask at work/exemption

111 replies

Candleropeheart · 10/08/2021 06:56

Have been WFH since last march, they started to return us one day a week in June. Ive gone in 4/5 weeks and due to being exempt of the face coverings I wasnt wearing a mask and nothing said to me either.
Until last week when it was almost home time & boss pulled me on it. She did this in front of colleagues too and kept pushing with comments such as id offended someone, others are worried they are more at risk and youve not covered up for the bathroom trips etc.. i said my reasons again and felt very pressured and watched.. but still said no. She got up and and came back 5 or so minutes later with a box full of visors for just me to wear...

I am hurt, and annoyed at this behaviour. Surely she cant behave like this! & surely she can't force me when ive clearly stated why im not wearing one to her.

Ive hearing aids in both ears, nhs ones not private as my earing is too far gone. I used to wear masks at the very start but they get caught around them and ive lost/broken hearing aids before so now ive decided along with my GP that i am exempt. (A broken hearing aid that i cant fix could mean waiting 6 months on a new one! I cant hear without mine at all! & ive two children this was also explained to boss who clearly didnt care..

OP posts:
TheGumption · 10/08/2021 10:39

You can get masks that tie up at the back of your head so really, you're not exempt, you never really were exempt. You just don't want to wear a mask. In fairness to people that are exempt, you should be honest about that.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 10/08/2021 10:38

Because there are visors or other masks that don't go behind your ear that you can wear. You are just making a nuisance of yourself.

gardeninggirl68 · 10/08/2021 10:35

Op just tell them you have a diagnosed condition deeming you exempt

They can then go through the legal rigmoralrcof gaining access to your medical records to disprove it

They can do nothing

Aprilx · 10/08/2021 10:31

@GreenWillow

Businesses can enforce whatever rules they choose, whether they are law or not. Uniform policy

Not if it discriminates against anybody with a protected characteristic, like a disability, such as a hearing impediment.

Your boss is totally in the wrong on this.

Where there is a disability, the employer needs to consider reasonable adjustments. They have, they suggested a visor instead, they may further make suggestions that involve face asks that secure in a different manner than round the ears. Both seem reasonable.

Disability discrimination legislation does not mean the person with a disability has free reign to do whatever they want and the employer and other employees have to suck it up.

LongTimeMammaBear · 10/08/2021 10:30

I voted YABU if your reason for not wresting a mask is because of wearing hearing aids. I have two. Yes, some times they get entangled but knowing this, you remove the mask carefully and reposition your hearing aids once your mask is off.

GreenWillow · 10/08/2021 10:23

Businesses can enforce whatever rules they choose, whether they are law or not. Uniform policy

Not if it discriminates against anybody with a protected characteristic, like a disability, such as a hearing impediment.

Your boss is totally in the wrong on this.

ThorIsAGod · 10/08/2021 10:22

@Fullofthejoysofspring and don't get me started on deaf children, particularly secondary school aged who have been excluded more than ever 😞

gardeninggirl68 · 10/08/2021 10:15

Just take her aside and tell her no

You won't wear it. End of

Let it go to a disciplinary and see how far they get with that shit!

ChainJane · 10/08/2021 10:13

Can you not wear a bandana-style mask? Put it round your neck, put your hearing aids on, then pull up/lower bandana when required.

Candleropeheart · 10/08/2021 10:05

@DeflatedGinDrinker

Why?

OP posts:
Fullofthejoysofspring · 10/08/2021 09:46

@DeflatedGinDrinker

YABVU op.
Why's that then, @DeflatedGinDrinker ?
DeflatedGinDrinker · 10/08/2021 09:44

YABVU op.

Fullofthejoysofspring · 10/08/2021 09:33

[quote ThorIsAGod]@Fullofthejoysofspring sorry, yes you are so right I was just saying visors are equally crap but have somehow been hailed as a viable alternative. All the deaf people I know- full range of oral and BSL users don't rate visors as they cause issues too.

Interestingly I have one friend who is very oral and has good use of cochlear implants who likes the paper masks the best as they give her the best sound and the fabric ones are awful but she relies on her implant more than other friends who without lip reading have no chance. [/quote]
Thank you - I agree with you! The pandemic has been horrific for hearing impaired people. I personally have worn a mask as much as I could, but it's been so hard trying to do basic things like grocery shopping with no clue as to what people are saying. I don't want to wear one in the office though because I won't stand a hope in hell of being able to use the tiny amount of residual hearing that I've got left.

ThorIsAGod · 10/08/2021 09:29

@Fullofthejoysofspring sorry, yes you are so right I was just saying visors are equally crap but have somehow been hailed as a viable alternative. All the deaf people I know- full range of oral and BSL users don't rate visors as they cause issues too.

Interestingly I have one friend who is very oral and has good use of cochlear implants who likes the paper masks the best as they give her the best sound and the fabric ones are awful but she relies on her implant more than other friends who without lip reading have no chance.

Fullofthejoysofspring · 10/08/2021 09:25

[quote Candleropeheart]**@Fullofthejoysofspring* Thank you* exactly this!!

Office make their own rules unfortunately.

Clearly deaf people dont matter..i mean its bad enough sitting all day in the office and not being able to partake in the conversations but I went kept my head down and did my work but its only now that ive offended someone else i should 'suck it up' too!! Fu*king hell people are actually unbelievable.

I have been WFH therefore not needed a mask or to invest in one as i can go shopping in fact i have been able to go anywhere for that matter A&E, GP surgery included and have not been made to feel the way She made me feel in that office!

I can do my role completely from home but our director wanted us in one day a week. He spoke once to me and when i said "im sorry X i cant hear you with the mask on..." he just turned on his heel and has ignored me everytime since!![/quote]
I understand exactly where you're coming from with this. I also wear aids in both ears and I'm sorry but regardless of whether it's an ear loop, a band that goes round my head further up, a visor or a bag over my fucking head, IT INTERFERES WITH MY HEARING. There is a reason why there is an exemption for deaf people and also anyone who is with a deaf person who relies on lip reading.

Fullofthejoysofspring · 10/08/2021 09:22

@ThorIsAGod I don't understand your point. Masks prevent lip reading and also distort speech. For hearing aid users they can also interfere with their aids, causing feedback due to unnatural positioning of ears, hair etc.

mog27 · 10/08/2021 09:14

The point here is we've been told time and time again that visors alone are useless so OP is being made to wear one for the sake of keeping up appearances and not because it actually works.

Candleropeheart · 10/08/2021 09:13

@Fullofthejoysofspring Thank you exactly this!!

Office make their own rules unfortunately.

Clearly deaf people dont matter..i mean its bad enough sitting all day in the office and not being able to partake in the conversations but I went kept my head down and did my work but its only now that ive offended someone else i should 'suck it up' too!! Fu*king hell people are actually unbelievable.

I have been WFH therefore not needed a mask or to invest in one as i can go shopping in fact i have been able to go anywhere for that matter A&E, GP surgery included and have not been made to feel the way She made me feel in that office!

I can do my role completely from home but our director wanted us in one day a week. He spoke once to me and when i said "im sorry X i cant hear you with the mask on..." he just turned on his heel and has ignored me everytime since!!

OP posts:
Rosebel · 10/08/2021 09:10

I am exempt and wore a mask even at work for 7 to 8 hours. Yes it was horrendous and plenty of times had to dash outside so I could remove it.
I don't wear them at work now as they aren't mandatory but I would if they made it policy.
They offered you an alternative but you have still decided that's not good enough.
For the sake of toilet visits and leaving the building I think you could do it. My husband wears NHS hearing aids and has never broken them by wearing a mask.

WeAllHaveWings · 10/08/2021 09:08

Your boss should have dealt with it privately.

Did you tell your boss you believed you are exempt, the reasons why and obtain agreement to you working in the office on that basis or just not follow your office guidance?

YABU for not using the alternatives that are available, at work or in public, that do not loop around your ears.

ShortBacknSides · 10/08/2021 09:01

most people comply as a courtesy to others

This.

If there’s one thing we should have learned from this pandemic, it’s that we need to be concerned about the risk WE pose to others.

ShortBacknSides · 10/08/2021 09:00

i felt massively singled out.

YANBU to have difficulty wearing a mask, but YABU not to try alternatives.

The visor or shield is fine.

Are you testing every day? Is your office able to accommodate you socially distancing ?

Masks cut the risk of you transmitting the virus. And you could be doing that, especially with 2 children, when they’re back at school.

You’re not being “Singled out” - your manager is trying to find ways to reasonably accommodate your disability (hearing deficit) while trying to keep everyone as safe as possible.

araiwa · 10/08/2021 08:51

I'm being singled out for being the only person to do this

Aprilx · 10/08/2021 08:47

@toomuchfaster

I think people are completely missing the point: masks are no longer legally enforceable. It matters not what anyone else in the office thinks or feels, *@Candleropeheart* doesn't have to wear one for any reason at all now. Tell your boss it's none of her business and she has no right to even discuss this with you. If she continues then approach HR about DDA allowances. And I say this as someone who works in a health care setting where we are supposed to encourage the wearing of masks, but we are not allowed to demand it or a reason for refusal.
Do you honestly think you are the only person on mums net that knows this? For goodness sake, of course people are not missing the point, because that is not the point.

Many workplaces and public places are still requesting that people wear face masks, and most people comply as a courtesy to others. OP is plainly being difficult abs making up excuses, which other posters have pointed out. Then trotting out the being “singled out” complaint, even though she is singling herself out.

delilabell · 10/08/2021 08:38

Totally yanbu. She should have spoken to you privately not in middle of office!

@Candleropeheart this sounds really daft but you saying visor not very visible....they have a thin plastic protector on that you need to peel off first. Sure you've done that but thought I'd say.