Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mask at work/exemption

111 replies

Candleropeheart · 10/08/2021 06:56

Have been WFH since last march, they started to return us one day a week in June. Ive gone in 4/5 weeks and due to being exempt of the face coverings I wasnt wearing a mask and nothing said to me either.
Until last week when it was almost home time & boss pulled me on it. She did this in front of colleagues too and kept pushing with comments such as id offended someone, others are worried they are more at risk and youve not covered up for the bathroom trips etc.. i said my reasons again and felt very pressured and watched.. but still said no. She got up and and came back 5 or so minutes later with a box full of visors for just me to wear...

I am hurt, and annoyed at this behaviour. Surely she cant behave like this! & surely she can't force me when ive clearly stated why im not wearing one to her.

Ive hearing aids in both ears, nhs ones not private as my earing is too far gone. I used to wear masks at the very start but they get caught around them and ive lost/broken hearing aids before so now ive decided along with my GP that i am exempt. (A broken hearing aid that i cant fix could mean waiting 6 months on a new one! I cant hear without mine at all! & ive two children this was also explained to boss who clearly didnt care..

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
whatisforteamum · 10/08/2021 18:59

I really feel for you OP.My dh wears hearing aids and masks do pull them out. He has persevered where I probably would be fed up by now.
Sounds like it was handled badly.
When I mentioned having asthma and panic disorder to my colleague s and my concern of wearing a mask the response was someone with a 60% lung capacity can wear one.!! I wasn't aware it was a competition.
I do wear mine.we don't have to wear them at work now though.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 10/08/2021 18:21

Just get one of the masks people have provided pictures of. I know plenty of people with hearing aids that wear masks, not one has tried to claim exemption.

FrancesFlute · 10/08/2021 16:12

@Candleropeheart

Yeah its more the way she handled the situation tbf and whether she was right to do that and if she can force me to wear the visor in the office days im asking about? & not whether strangers think i am exempt or not..
Your poor GP. They can't give exemption notes. Please don't waste their time asking for one or encourage others to do so.
Ihavehadenoughalready · 10/08/2021 16:07

They make extra bands that you can attach to the ends of the loops so that the loops don't go directly behind your ears.

I think you're being unreasonable in not trying to find something suitable.

For example, I work in a overheated lab every dang day and I sweat underneath the mask and my whole face turns red and I suppose I could say I just can't wear a mask, but I do it anyway because it's the right thing to do.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 10/08/2021 15:48

They have about the same effect on an airborne virus as goal net stopping a marble

Only if you are wearing a rubbish mask. A decent mask does make a difference. As was seen in a Swiss hotel last year. During an outbreak at the hotel, the only staff members that contracted covid were the ones not wearing masks.

There's more scientific info here. One study showed a 79% reduction in transmission in households if everyone was wearing a mask prior to showing symptoms. www.pnas.org/content/118/4/e2014564118

Blanketpolicy · 10/08/2021 15:05

but I went kept my head down and did my work but its only now that ive offended someone else i should 'suck it up' too!! Fuking hell people are actually unbelievable.*

I actually avoided the canteen as more people would use it and I didn't want to offend someone..

You are not "offending" anyone by not wearing a mask, you are offending people by not being truthful about the reasons why you think you should be able to bypass the health and safety measures in place to reduce the risk of covid transmission and protect others.

For whatever reason, you are being awkward, and tbh look a bit of a fool when everyone knows you can wear one without ear loops. Is it because you just don't want to wear a mask, you think the wearing of masks does not reduce risk or do you want to WFH? If you admit the real reason you will get more appropriate responses.

Not being able to hear others when they are wearing masks is a common problem I suffer with too, but a separate issue to you wearing a mask and not the original topic of you thread.

saoirse31 · 10/08/2021 14:42

I honestly don't get why you can't wear a mask, plenty options with strings which avoid ear. Your choice, bit I can understand people's annoyance tbh

DolphinFC · 10/08/2021 14:40

I'm deaf and wear BTE hearing aids on both sides.

Stop moaning.

Mask at work/exemption
Everanewbie · 10/08/2021 14:37

YANBU. They're nothing more than a comfort blanket and a reminder that "something is going on". They have about the same effect on an airborne virus as goal net stopping a marble. They make it difficult to interpret emotion and unless worn and stored properly, are an absolute germ rag worn right over the place you don't want germs going.

Even if they do reduce transmission, of which I've seen absolutely no proof beyond emotional 'protect others' BS rhetoric, anyone statistically at risk has had the chance to be double jabbed with a remarkably effective vaccine, and this whole charade of sitting at a desk without masking up, then wearing one whilst marching swiftly thru a near empty office en route to the bog is completely absurd.

Take you vaccine, stay at home if you have symptoms, but the mask stuff is a massive charade.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 10/08/2021 13:42

Op, while I think your boss is being unfair (and visors, imo, are pointless), there are extenders and things that you can get that might help. Or masks designed not to go around the ears.

Might be worth looking at.

Stompythedinosaur · 10/08/2021 13:39

You clearly could wear a mask.

I am in healthcare and we have no exemptions - wearing a mask is required by everyone, all day, including colleagues with hearing aids.

Reasonable adjustment looks like giving access to a type of mask that suits. I would say offering a visor as an alternative is more than fair.

I don't really buy the argument about being singled out. Presumably you being the only one not wearing a mask also singles you out.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 10/08/2021 13:38

I think people are completely missing the point: masks are no longer legally enforceable

While it is probable that the op is in England (just based on numbers), that's not the case throughout the UK.

Having recently travelled from England to Scotland, it's quite clear that many people don't realise that.

BillyIsMyBunny · 10/08/2021 13:30

YANBU if you can’t wear a mask due to your hearing impairment, however YABU to refuse a visor because it’s uncomfortable. Masks are uncomfortable to those of us who have to wear them as well but that’s not a good enough reason to refuse.

At my workplace anybody who cannot wear a mask has to wear a visor instead. It’s not purposefully singling people out, it’s company policy. Those who cannot wear a mask or visor have had to be signed off work.

gogohm · 10/08/2021 13:25

I can understand the issue with the ear straps, perfectly valid to not use them but there's alternatives such as a band, ties etc. None of us want to have to wear masks, it's particularly tricky with glasses steaming up and I have sensitive backs to my ears and across the bridge of my nose so it actually hurts where it touches but I like everyone else wears one for the greater good (I wasn't ill with covid so it's not about me not catching it). Your management didn't handle it sensitively, should have been in private, but ultimately after over a year you could find a solution eg a band

SuperstoreFan · 10/08/2021 13:11

My husband wears two hearing aids and he has a physical disability which effect his arms, if he can wear a mask I'm not exactly sure why you can't OP.

Bloodypunkrockers · 10/08/2021 13:09

@Candleropeheart

It is really nothing to do with WFH, as I have gone into the office and it was fine no issues, I actually avoided the canteen as more people would use it and I didnt want to offend someone.. (yet still managed to ffs) there is only 8/10 people in my office all spread out over a massive floor space and no one shares a desk so the issue is how my boss dealt with it and not me wanting to stay at home Confused
I wouldn't be "offended"

I wouldn't want you near me though

MaMelon · 10/08/2021 13:06

Yes, your boss handled it badly - no doubt about that.

However, you can wear a mask - it's physically possible. What are you going to do now?

Candleropeheart · 10/08/2021 13:05

It is really nothing to do with WFH, as I have gone into the office and it was fine no issues, I actually avoided the canteen as more people would use it and I didnt want to offend someone.. (yet still managed to ffs) there is only 8/10 people in my office all spread out over a massive floor space and no one shares a desk so the issue is how my boss dealt with it and not me wanting to stay at home Confused

OP posts:
MaMelon · 10/08/2021 13:03

@StrangeToSee

Where do you work?

Unless you’re in healthcare a mask enforcement seems very odd. A visor won’t do much, it’s just a splatter guard if people cough or sneeze on you.

I’m NHS and we only mask up in patient areas, as all the offices are ‘covid secure’ with socially distanced desks, ventilation and a one way system.

I'm NHS too - masks have to be worn in all shared areas, including offices and corridors. We also have socially distanced desks, ventilation and a one way system.
knittingaddict · 10/08/2021 13:00

The op's scenario is very similar to me wearing glasses. I have to wear my mask quite high to prevent the lenses steaming up, but I have varifocals which are then pushed up and distort my vision. Ialso have to be very careful when removing the masks to prevent my glasses going flying. They've landed up on the floor more than once.

I still wear my mask. It does sound like the op is making excuses.

StrangeToSee · 10/08/2021 13:00

Where do you work?

Unless you’re in healthcare a mask enforcement seems very odd. A visor won’t do much, it’s just a splatter guard if people cough or sneeze on you.

I’m NHS and we only mask up in patient areas, as all the offices are ‘covid secure’ with socially distanced desks, ventilation and a one way system.

MaMelon · 10/08/2021 12:58

It sounds like you're looking for a reason to continue wfh, although management should not have spoken to you in front of others.

My 90 year old MIL wears hearing aids and just adjusts the straps - it's perfectly possible to wear one.

gardeninggirl68 · 10/08/2021 12:58

if they "insist' then it will be made policy/procedure. where reasonable adjustments will apply

and anyway, if people are claiming to be exempt then what will they actually do?

gardeninggirl68 · 10/08/2021 12:56

[quote luckylavender]@gardeninggirl68 - that's quite a loaded and ridiculous statement [/quote]
not really anything there thats not true.....they cannot enforce wearing of any face covering. If they insist, then good luck with that tribunal!!

all this wearing visors is beyond ridiculous.

knittingaddict · 10/08/2021 12:53

@toomuchfaster

I think people are completely missing the point: masks are no longer legally enforceable. It matters not what anyone else in the office thinks or feels, *@Candleropeheart* doesn't have to wear one for any reason at all now. Tell your boss it's none of her business and she has no right to even discuss this with you. If she continues then approach HR about DDA allowances. And I say this as someone who works in a health care setting where we are supposed to encourage the wearing of masks, but we are not allowed to demand it or a reason for refusal.
They may not be legally enforceable, but a business can insist that masks are worn to protect other employees. It's like lots of other safety equipment and rules that businesses make.