Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think being in a relationship with a convicted drink driver who killed a person is not 'couple goals'

162 replies

lovedayAlleys · 09/08/2021 22:51

On social media I've seen a couple who have gone public with their relationship with a post on social media.
One half of the couple was the perpetrator in a drink driving incident where the victim that was involved was killed. The perpetrator served a few years in prison for said crime and the situation was well publicised in the media.
Lots of gushing comments under the post on social media congratulating the happy couple, including the comment 'couple goals'.
AIBU that nobody in their right mind could ever aspire to or have a goal of being half of a relationship with someone found guilty of killing another person?
The quantity of likes and positive comments really flummoxed me. Is there anyone here who would date a person they knew to have been guilty of killing another person?

OP posts:
thedancingbear · 10/08/2021 12:23

^2017, 22 March: 2017 Westminster attack
2017, 3 June: 2017 London Bridge attack
2019, 29 November: 2019 London Bridge stabbing
2020, 2 February: 2020 Streatham stabbing
All involved the Police using lethal force to stop an ongoing attack.^

There are c150000 police officers in the UK. They have to use lethal force to kill a terrorist, on average, less than once a year. How do you understand the expression 'highly unlikely'?

You actually think that people join the armed forces with the express intent of “shooting and blowing up people?

Yes.

Whatever your thoughts on UK Military operating in other countries there is unequivable evidence that disrupting terrorist organizations elsewhere in the world has a clear impact on the number of terrorist attacks in the UK.

Where? I disagree.

UK Military and Government Organisations have deployed on numerous operations with the express aim of providing aid, peacekeeping and disaster relief in recent times.

But it's not their reason for being. Provision of aid, and disaster relief can be provided without weapons. 'Peacekeeping' is a horrible euphemism.

(ii) someone joining the forces with the express intention of travelling to places thousands of miles away, to shoot and blow up people, many of them conscripts and/or teenagers, who are not a material threat to us at all.

You actually think that people join the armed forces with the express intent of “shooting and blowing up people?

Not a material threat?

Whatever your thoughts on UK Military operating in other countries there is unequivable evidence that disrupting terrorist organizations elsewhere in the world has a clear impact on the number of terrorist attacks in the UK.

That said, regarding (i), I would be suspicious of someone who was too keen to take on a role that involved firearms. I would have serious doubts about their psyche. There are ways of protecting and helping people that don't involve automatic weapons.

Unfortunately, when other people are using “automatic weapons” there is little way of protecting them by being nice and kind. The world is a shit dangerous place, there are some very nasty people who do not operate with compassion and understanding. How do you deal with those?
Helping people – UK Military and Government Organisations have deployed on numerous operations with the express aim of providing aid, peacekeeping and disaster relief in recent times.

thedancingbear · 10/08/2021 12:15

[quote 21Bee]@thedancingbear you are incredibly naive if you think people ‘thousands of miles away’ aren’t a threat to people in this country.[/quote]
I'm not going to bore you with my background and credentials - anyone can claim to be anything on the internet - but I am anything but naive in the field of international relations.

Are these people a threat to our energy supply/standard of living? Absolutely.

Are they a significant threat to our life and limb, such that it's morally justified shooting a teenager who has been brainwashed and given a rifle by his uncle? Probably not.

It all depends on what circumstances you think it's okay to kill or blow someone up. I think we'll have to agree to disagree. It wasn't me who introduced the armed forces to the thread as an example of those who are entitled legitimately to kill people.

Fromablokespoint · 10/08/2021 12:12

Sorry to derail the thread!

No. I draw a distinction between-

(i) someone joining the police, and finding themselves in the highly unlikely position that they need to tackle a terrorist to protect life and limb of themselves and others

Not highly unlikely?

2017, 22 March: 2017 Westminster attack
2017, 3 June: 2017 London Bridge attack
2019, 29 November: 2019 London Bridge stabbing
2020, 2 February: 2020 Streatham stabbing
All involved the Police using lethal force to stop an ongoing attack.

(ii) someone joining the forces with the express intention of travelling to places thousands of miles away, to shoot and blow up people, many of them conscripts and/or teenagers, who are not a material threat to us at all.

You actually think that people join the armed forces with the express intent of “shooting and blowing up people?

Not a material threat?

Whatever your thoughts on UK Military operating in other countries there is unequivable evidence that disrupting terrorist organizations elsewhere in the world has a clear impact on the number of terrorist attacks in the UK.

That said, regarding (i), I would be suspicious of someone who was too keen to take on a role that involved firearms. I would have serious doubts about their psyche. There are ways of protecting and helping people that don't involve automatic weapons.

Unfortunately, when other people are using “automatic weapons” there is little way of protecting them by being nice and kind. The world is a shit dangerous place, there are some very nasty people who do not operate with compassion and understanding. How do you deal with those?
Helping people – UK Military and Government Organisations have deployed on numerous operations with the express aim of providing aid, peacekeeping and disaster relief in recent times.

21Bee · 10/08/2021 12:08

@thedancingbear you are incredibly naive if you think people ‘thousands of miles away’ aren’t a threat to people in this country.

mewkins · 10/08/2021 12:00

I think if I were convicted of killing someone I would very much keep my head down and get on with my life and not be on social media (not least because I would feel absolutely ashamed and also not want to be targeted by anyone linked to the victim). I think what pisses you off is not that he or she is pictured on there but that people are fawning all over them as a perfect couple. That would piss me off too. But then all 'couple goals' things are bollocks anyway. There are no perfect couples and no amount of tan and gloss will convince me otherwise Grin

Jurassicparkinajug · 10/08/2021 11:57

Yes I could as long as they were remorseful. All of us do stupid things sometimes.

I think there's a difference between getting into a car blind drunk than not realising you are still over the limit the next day after drinking too. So it really depends on the circumstances like other posters he said.

thedancingbear · 10/08/2021 11:40

[quote Fromablokespoint]@thedancingbear

"Tell me the last time a member of the armed forces did that in the UK. I'm around all day."

Poster actually said Police Office - do you put them in the same category?[/quote]
No. I draw a distinction between-

(i) someone joining the police, and finding themselves in the highly unlikely position that they need to tackle a terrorist to protect life and limb of themselves and others

(ii) someone joining the forces with the express intention of travelling to places thousands of miles away, to shoot and blow up people, many of them conscripts and/or teenagers, who are not a material threat to us at all.

That said, regarding (i), I would be suspicious of someone who was too keen to take on a role that involved firearms. I would have serious doubts about their psyche. There are ways of protecting and helping people that don't involve automatic weapons.

wheresmymojo · 10/08/2021 11:38

@SupermanWithTheGreyHair

wheresmymojo

I absolutely agree. Neither me or my partner have ever done this. If we’re driving, we don’t drink, ever. We have 2 family members that do and we don’t have anything to do with them. It’s very much looked on as something completely unacceptable by people we mix with.

I've actually finished a friendship over this. She drove 30-40 mins after drinking quite heavily.

I wasn't with her at the time, she told me about it because she decided to cut her friend off who was with her and was worried enough to call her sister and parents and tell them she was driving home completely drunk and she was worried and didn't know what to do (they'd been friends for a long time, since childhood)

According to ex-friend her friend was out of line to tell her family.

I think she was lucky - I would have called the Police even though we'd been close friends for 10 years.

My father killed someone drink driving in the 1970's and then moved to Saudi to avoid prosecution. He was never charged. Came back in the 80's and drove regularly including after drinking and always without a licence or insurance because he didn't dare flag up that he was in the country.

My stepfather also drove regularly after drinking, once a week at least. I judge him as much as if he'd killed someone because it's luck, not judgement that he didn't.

And yes, my lovely DM has absolutely terrible taste in men

lovedayAlleys · 10/08/2021 11:28

@thedancingbear

The revelation that he did it before also came into play when the thread was going heavily in the opposite direction that the OP expected…

In fairness, it seems highly likely that anyone caught drink driving has done it very many times before they're actually caught, and certainly before the end up killing someone. It's the kind of 'one off mistake' that people overwhelmingly make multiple times. In which event, it's not a mistake, it's a conscious decision to be a scumbag.

What way was I expecting the thread to go? From what I have said Is it implausible to think that I may have asked my question as I'm simply interested in what other people would do?

I gave the update as posters were assuming it was a one off.
I don't want to give more detail as it will quite identifiable to the case but what's happened in the aftermath, after the release from prison gives me no indication that it's not a possibility it won't happen again in the future.

OP posts:
wheresmymojo · 10/08/2021 11:27

I also find it kind of bizarre that according to several people on this thread we're not supposed to judge someone who was convicted of drunk driving twice and who killed someone the second time.

I'm not a hugely judgemental person but yes, I absolutely would judge someone like that.

It's not always wrong to judge people.

I mean where do people draw the line with this 'being non-judgemental is the absolute goal' nonsense?

For me - criminal activity absolutely falls into the ' totally acceptable to judge' category.

Being non-judgemental is about not judging people for personal choices, quirks and life decisions that don't impact on other people.

It's not about pretending any range of criminal behaviour is okay...

SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 10/08/2021 11:18

wheresmymojo

I absolutely agree. Neither me or my partner have ever done this. If we’re driving, we don’t drink, ever. We have 2 family members that do and we don’t have anything to do with them. It’s very much looked on as something completely unacceptable by people we mix with.

wheresmymojo · 10/08/2021 11:13

@Dreamstate

I bet lots of people have done lots of stupid things except they are just lucky it didn't end up with terrible consequences but it could have as it did with this guy.

So I find it a bit hard to understand all these comments saying I couldn't be with a person who did that, well your probably eith a person who did drink n drive that one time but lucky to get away with not harming anyone. Or something equally bad.

I find this a bizarre comment. I am absolutely certain that neither me nor DH has ever driven over the limit.

All the friends I socialise are equally strict, I don't think any of us even have one drink if we're driving.

So honestly I think this comment is a poor reflection of you and/or the company you keep if you think this is true.

Fromablokespoint · 10/08/2021 11:12

@thedancingbear

"Tell me the last time a member of the armed forces did that in the UK. I'm around all day."

Poster actually said Police Office - do you put them in the same category?

PlanDeRaccordement · 10/08/2021 10:59

Is there anyone here who would date a person they knew to have been guilty of killing another person?

Probably. As this would include many with military or police partners.....

thedancingbear · 10/08/2021 10:56

The revelation that he did it before also came into play when the thread was going heavily in the opposite direction that the OP expected…

In fairness, it seems highly likely that anyone caught drink driving has done it very many times before they're actually caught, and certainly before the end up killing someone. It's the kind of 'one off mistake' that people overwhelmingly make multiple times. In which event, it's not a mistake, it's a conscious decision to be a scumbag.

JustLyra · 10/08/2021 10:50

@SleepingStandingUp

But there's evidence he will do it again. it's not a one-off; he's a repeat offender. I, and others, can't get over that. There's evidence he did it before he killed someone. No evidence he has done it since. It's a massive distinction
The revelation that he did it before also came into play when the thread was going heavily in the opposite direction that the OP expected…
SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 10/08/2021 10:41

There's evidence he did it before he killed someone. No evidence he has done it since. It's a massive distinction

But would you want to date someone who didn’t stop after that ‘warning’ and had to go on to kill someone before he stopped doing it, if he has stopped, which isn’t known.

thedancingbear · 10/08/2021 10:36

@SleepingStandingUp

But there's evidence he will do it again. it's not a one-off; he's a repeat offender. I, and others, can't get over that. There's evidence he did it before he killed someone. No evidence he has done it since. It's a massive distinction
He hasn't done it since the last time he did it. Therefore, he won't do it again.

Fantastic logic. Just brilliant.

thedancingbear · 10/08/2021 10:34

So you wouldn't date a doctor, because in an emergency they might have to decide between two patients knowing that the other will die?

Comparing this to deliberately shooting or blowing someone up is offensive.

Or a police officer who shot a terrorist who was about to denotate a suicide vest and kill a dozen people?

Tell me the last time a member of the armed forces did that in the UK. I'm around all day.

But a drink driver who killed would be fine because they were so out of it they had no idea what they were doing?

Show me where I said that. Again, I'm around all day.

FaceForRadio1973 · 10/08/2021 10:18

Hi Neverrains

You're right, I didn't word that very well, (Oh for an edit button) I meant to say that the general concensus on this site seems to be that criminals can change, but cheaters can't...

Apologies!

SleepingStandingUp · 10/08/2021 10:13

But there's evidence he will do it again. it's not a one-off; he's a repeat offender. I, and others, can't get over that. There's evidence he did it before he killed someone. No evidence he has done it since. It's a massive distinction

Neverrains · 10/08/2021 10:12

@FaceForRadio1973

Although it is interesting that people who say that killers can change, but cheaters can't change....
Maybe it’s not the same people saying those 2 things?
FaceForRadio1973 · 10/08/2021 10:11

Although it is interesting that people who say that killers can change, but cheaters can't change....

FaceForRadio1973 · 10/08/2021 10:08

I can't imagine how hard it must be on the victim's family (Would they even have seen the social media post though?)

But please bear in mind that we all make very stupid mistakes and decisions sometimes. - Isn't a mistake just a bad decision?

It's just that 99% of our stupid mistakes don't kill someone.

Have I nearly been killed by someone else's mistake? Yes. Several times.

When I was an apprentice, I was bored in the workshop and started just fiddling with a six inch nail nothing serious.... Its a long story, but a certain chain of events led to me very nearly (certainly seriously injuring or maiming) a fellow apprentice.

I'm not at all religious, but "By the grace of God" and all that...

ChainJane · 10/08/2021 10:06

@thedancingbear

What about people that date military personnel?

I would never date someone who had deliberately killed another person, particularly if they did not regret it, or was prepared to do so.

That includes people who have voluntarily joined the armed forces.

So you wouldn't date a doctor, because in an emergency they might have to decide between two patients knowing that the other will die? Or a police officer who shot a terrorist who was about to denotate a suicide vest and kill a dozen people? But a drink driver who killed would be fine because they were so out of it they had no idea what they were doing?