Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother In Law Issues - HELP!

112 replies

newmamabear4 · 09/08/2021 20:52

I am struggling with my MIL so much!! We had our first baby in lockdown last year and sadly that meant she couldn’t see much of our son for the first 6 months. We were limited to walks only and despite telling us she missed him constantly here are some reasons she cancelled walks on me (please keep in mind her husband was WFH at the time) 1. The carpenter is coming. 2. I have to move some logs. 3. The gardener has lit a fire and I can’t leave it. 4. The electrician is coming. This was all after I had been diagnosed with PND too!! So fast forward to present day and no lockdowns and all that missed time. Have we ever been invited over for dinner? No!!! She claws at my son and tries to take over every time I see her. She even takes him out of the room away from me when he gets upset at being taken by her. He’s very attached to me after spending 6 months in lockdown with just me while his Dad was at work. I’m now back working PT and she very very generously offered to have my son 1.5 days a week. This is amazing BUT she ignores my every request. She doesn’t feed him when I ask, she refuses to put him down for a sleep when I say he needs to nap. He comes home covered in food and stains despite us asking a million times to use bibs and try and keep him as neat as possible. He drinks 4 x 5oz bottles a day for us at home, with her she struggles to get 1oz down him. So he’s missing out on 8oz of milk a day on the days he goes to her. Every little noise my son makes she’s rocking him to to sleep! He’s nearly 10 months old and she knows he has 2 naps a day, yet I pick him up and most days he’s had 4 sleeps with her! It is causing a real rift between me and my partner. He loves his Mum so defends her all the time. I wish I could afford nursery or a childminder but we just can’t. I am so stuck as to what to do!! These few little things I’ve written about are just the tip of the iceberg too! Am I being an over neurotic new Mum or is she out of line here? And how do I address it with her? My partner has spoken to her countless times and I have made it clear I’m not happy without confronting her and upsetting her. I’m at a loss and it’s causing me so much stress!

OP posts:
mutedrainbows · 10/08/2021 09:40

I think you need to find childcare. Ignore what pp said above about a loving family member being a better option than a childminder/nursery keyworker. That isn't always true. It was important to me that the few rules I had were followed - don't leave her to cry if she's struggling to nap and no sugary puddings (just fruit for now). If a family member was ignoring those requests, how would they be a better option?

If it makes you feel better though, the lack of milk could happen at nursery or with MIL - it's just a change in routine. My bf baby takes maybe an oz or two while at nursery but feeds constantly from me when we're together. She is also on 2 naps a day but sometimes does 3 if she only takes short naps at nursery as she's still getting used to it. But putting him down for 4 naps when he's not tired does sound like maybe MIL is looking for a break as well and if he wasn't actually tired, I wouldn't be happy with that.

I didn't let PIL look after my 10 month old either because I knew I would disagree with how they cared for her and I would rather pay for nursery than cause a rift.

SarahAndQuack · 10/08/2021 09:34

I agree, it sounds like going back to work is a no-brainer really.

I can see that it's more your MIL's attitude than what she does that bothers you, as you think she's doing it to show she can, but it's a difficult one because honestly, none of it sounds like anything nursery or a childminder wouldn't do.

My DD was a horrible sleeper and wouldn't nap with me unless I drove her around for hours; at nursery she quite often did nap just because all the others were asleep. It pushed her bedtime later but it's what a PP says - the baby you know is going to be very different with other people and it's really weird getting used to that! I found mine was different with me and DP, even.

ChateauMargaux · 10/08/2021 09:29

You have taken 75% pay cut so you could spend time with your child and your partner has taken a 'substantial' pay cut to save his father's business, he us not allowed flexible working or paternity leave and your MIL controls your childcare but refuses to respect your wishes. Your partner has a difficult relationship with his parents and might be the less favoured child.

Take back control, get your high paying job back, let your partner find a job that he us happy in away from his family.

ittakes2 · 10/08/2021 09:25

It can be tricky with m'n'laws - although for what its worth with the exception of the logs I would stay home for all those reasons of repair people coming even if my hubby was working from home. 1 - my hubby doesn't know the history of things and things come up when repair people come and 2) my hubby is very busy working from home he doesn't have time to stop for a repair person.
I think if you can't afford other childcare then you need to lower your expectations until you can. Choose one thing at a time (I think the milk issue is the worst due to dehyrdation) and work on that.
Was your plan before you fell pregnant to reply on her for childcare?

LookItsMeAgain · 10/08/2021 09:23

I'm just going to pick up on this comment you posted @newmamabear4 - My partner took a huge pay cut at the beginning of Covid to help stop his employer go into liquidation.
It was his dad's business that he stopped going into liquidation. Businesses fail for various reasons and your DH shouldn't have had to take a pay cut to save his dad's firm. His father's business should have been able to weather the storm of the lockdown or it should have closed. That is business. That is economics.
It is interesting that you say his employer in that post but you know it's your FiL's business.
My advice about him leaving this business still stands. He could even couch it in nicer terms like he is leaving to gain experience that he could use in the future if/when he returns to the family business perhaps.
I also agree with @Pebbledashery in so far as rethinking the childminding. Perhaps if you don't want to send your DS to nursery or creche, you might be happier with a childminder/nanny who would look after him in your home? Smaller child/childminder ratios there.

AnneLovesGilbert · 10/08/2021 09:13

Can your parents do the extra day and a half?

I think it’s clear your partner needs a different job as his dad/boss is willing to act illegally.

Potatoy · 10/08/2021 09:12

What is your backup plan for childcare if MIL turned round and said she didn't want to do it anymore/can't do it? I'd do that.

Ozanj · 10/08/2021 09:11

I am a nursery practitioner and tbh all of that would happen at nursery too. Babies that age, especially Lockdown babies, are very differently behaved to caregivers compared to parents (I also have one and so I know). The good little child you know who will nap when you need them to and quietly wears their bib / drinks their milk doesn’t exist outside of your presence. I have several 9 mo in my care who refuse to even touch their milk or wear bibs despite doing both at home - they’re just so excited being around someome who isn’t mum / dad that they just want to experience everything.

In my experience those babies who go to nursery 3 times a week or more are less likely to behaved like crazy dictators. As they have a routine. So I know it seems counterintuitive but it might be worth asking if she can have dc more often. You may find he gets used to being with gran and then all the other problems go away.

LookItsMeAgain · 10/08/2021 09:10

There are a few things rolled into these posts @newmamabear4 and I am going to say that I don't think your MiL is entirely to blame for them all.

First thing is first - your DH needs to start to find an alternative employer, unless he is being lined up to take over from his dad and if that is the case, then he can take whatever leave he wants as he will be the boss. It doesn't matter what your FiL says about leave, if it is covered by employment law, he can take it. He will have to change the dynamic from son/father to employee/employer and get that sorted.

Next - you need to have a conversation with your MiL about the key things that you need to get sorted for your son and the way I see them in order of importance is feeding and sleeping. She has to put bibs on before feeding and he needs to be taking his milk when he is with her. This is not negotiable. Then when you have that sorted, he will probably sleep anyway with a full tummy and that may help with the naps.
As someone else has posted, you both want this to work so the only way that will happen is if you both have good communication between each other.

What you do with your DS and your DH is really no business of FiL or MiL so you need to start implementing boundaries here and sticking to them.

MonkeysWedding · 10/08/2021 09:09

It sounds like your MIL is really struggling but not able to admit it. 4 naps a day?! Maybe she’s feeling rusty on how to take care of a baby and finding tiring for such long stretches. (My MIL takes ours for an hour at a time and is ready for a break when I collect him!) And might not want to admit it for pride/ love of being a gran/ feeling of commitment to help.

Freddiefox · 10/08/2021 09:09

How long has you mil been looking after you ds? And what was her response when you told her about the issues?

Motnight · 10/08/2021 09:09

This will only get worse. As others have said you need to untangle your lives from your in laws.

Potatoy · 10/08/2021 09:08

The food is not on, if you don't want him eating meat that should be respected.

I think you need to get a different job, and so does your partner. He doesn't have to work for his dad.

Neverrains · 10/08/2021 09:02

What else could the solution be?

Neverrains · 10/08/2021 09:01

You have unresolved issues with your PIL’s that are causing you resentment. You don’t agree with their approach to lockdown rules. You don’t like the way they look after your son.
You need to find alternative childcare.

newmamabear4 · 10/08/2021 08:56

@Pebbledashery I absolutely agree that nursery is amazing for children. Ideally we would have wanted our son to go to nursery one day a week and do a day each with grandparents but sadly finances won’t allow. My partner took a huge pay cut at the beginning of Covid to help stop his employer go into liquidation. And if I increase my hours I’ll have to increase nursery days and then have the extra cost. I salute you for being a single mother and supporting your family the way you do but everyone’s situations are different.

@Freddiefox I agree with you that lockdown affected everyone differently. We respected others wishes to follow or not follow the rules. Sadly our decision to follow the rules were not respected by family members. Picking up our son and planting kisses all over him when we’ve asked you to wear a mask is wrong. Especially when said parents were mixing with anyone and everyone and could have put us at risk. We were generous enough to allow them cuddles whenever they wanted despite this not technically being allowed and to go against or wishes of staying outside or wearing a mask was unfair IMO. I don’t know if you have children or if any were born in lockdown but until you’ve done it I don’t think you can really understand. If you did it and coped well I salute you and I am very happy to hear. For me and my partner it’s been a real struggle. As parents not our relationship. But that was just our experience.

OP posts:
Neverrains · 10/08/2021 08:50

@billy1966

You have given up a well paid job to depend on a partner who is not well paid and dependent on his father's whim?

Kindly, are you out of your mind?

Your partner is crying over these issues with his family?

You are so vulnerable.
Get back to.work FT.
Put the baby in a good nursery.

Back away from parents in law for whom you depend on for far too much.

^ this in spades. It’s not working for you. It’s causing issues. Change it.
billy1966 · 10/08/2021 08:48

You have given up a well paid job to depend on a partner who is not well paid and dependent on his father's whim?

Kindly, are you out of your mind?

Your partner is crying over these issues with his family?

You are so vulnerable.
Get back to.work FT.
Put the baby in a good nursery.

Back away from parents in law for whom you depend on for far too much.

Pebbledashery · 10/08/2021 08:35

Being in nursery 5 days a week isn't a bad thing to be honest.. My little girl has been in nursery for 5 days a week since she was 1, she does 7am to 5.30pm. I'm a full time, single working parent with no familial help.. I think you perhaps need to maybe think about what is actually best for your son than projecting onto him what you think is best. You might not want him in full time childcare, but I guarantee you he will thrive and flourish and it's good for their social skills. As others have mentioned, you've got free childcare so you're going to have to allow a degree of flexibility and let certain things go. In your situation the simplest solution is to just pay for the childcare.. It'll resolve the issues instantaneously. Your MIL isn't going to listen.

Italiangreyhound · 10/08/2021 08:33

If working isn't giving you and your partner enough money for childcare can you get s pay increase or cut spending a bit.

She doesn"t sound like she's doing a good job and the stress seems bad for you.

Eben though it's free she should still be listening to you.

Freddiefox · 10/08/2021 08:30

Also just to say lockdown affected people in so many different ways. People have such different ideas of risk. Some are more worried than others, some less so.

Try to move forward, but the only way forward is to communicate with her. You both clearly want this to work.

Confusednewmum1 · 10/08/2021 08:29

You seem to have an awful lot of rules and really need to chill out a bit. No wonder it’s coming between you and your partner.

  • The food - being pescatarian is your choice not your babies. Your MIL is likely just lifting baby food up without much care- babies weren’t on faddy diets in the 70’s. There is not harm here.
  • The mess and stains - it’s required for child’s development to play with food and make a mess. She likely finds him really cute all messy.
  • the milk she’s his granny and feeding him up is her job he would drink it if he wanted - no harm not having so much 1 day a week.
  • she has raised children to adult hood and is significantly relaxed to know she won’t break them and that routine matters not a F* something will turn it on it’s head at some point. She’s enjoying her granny cuddles.
  • your parents following your rules is to be expected they have lived with you their whole life and know what your wrath is like (not saying your a monster but we were all awful as teenagers) You will have always been polite enough not to lose your S*.
  • the phase will pass your son will soon be toddler that refuses to sleep and destroys her house.
  • know one knows better than a granny how short the baby years are and she’s enjoying them and soaking them up. To her they everything else is just a side point.

It’s hard allowing your baby to go to someone with completely different set of rules. I was the most chilled out earth mother that loved messy play, naked babies, feeding on demand, cuddles and sleep whenever. I still had a B fit when MIL fed my 9 month old beans out a tin. My poor partner you’d have thought his lovely mother fed my child poison - with a spoon and everything all my baby led weaning. It took ages just to realise that MIL are a different generation which makes them almost another species.
Well now she’s 3, total nut job and I couldn’t give 2 hoots about anything- just keep her alive.

Confused102 · 10/08/2021 08:26

I think yabvu. You have posted about how many issues you have with her yet you choose to leave your son in her care and then still complain about her?? It doesn't make sense. Why would you do that with someone you very clearly have a problem with?

Freddiefox · 10/08/2021 08:26

Is there a lack of not wanting to let him cry? So resorts to rocking him in an attempt to keep him happy?
Is she worried about him crying? Is she confident around him?

I think you hold a bit of resentment to her regarding lock down and I think it’s missed placed.
However I think you can’t let things simmer the way they are and i think you will have to communicate with her your concerns.

My mum would have left dc in dirty clothes to save me on some washing, when I pointed out that you wouldn’t sit in dirty clothes she would just say ‘they are a baby, no one will mind’ but I did.

I think you have to talk to her, and go from there.

Neverrains · 10/08/2021 08:26

Maybe she’s finding it more difficult than she expected to? Looking after a baby all day is hard.
Unless you think she’s doing it out of spite, in which case why would you leave him with her anyway?