Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother In Law Issues - HELP!

112 replies

newmamabear4 · 09/08/2021 20:52

I am struggling with my MIL so much!! We had our first baby in lockdown last year and sadly that meant she couldn’t see much of our son for the first 6 months. We were limited to walks only and despite telling us she missed him constantly here are some reasons she cancelled walks on me (please keep in mind her husband was WFH at the time) 1. The carpenter is coming. 2. I have to move some logs. 3. The gardener has lit a fire and I can’t leave it. 4. The electrician is coming. This was all after I had been diagnosed with PND too!! So fast forward to present day and no lockdowns and all that missed time. Have we ever been invited over for dinner? No!!! She claws at my son and tries to take over every time I see her. She even takes him out of the room away from me when he gets upset at being taken by her. He’s very attached to me after spending 6 months in lockdown with just me while his Dad was at work. I’m now back working PT and she very very generously offered to have my son 1.5 days a week. This is amazing BUT she ignores my every request. She doesn’t feed him when I ask, she refuses to put him down for a sleep when I say he needs to nap. He comes home covered in food and stains despite us asking a million times to use bibs and try and keep him as neat as possible. He drinks 4 x 5oz bottles a day for us at home, with her she struggles to get 1oz down him. So he’s missing out on 8oz of milk a day on the days he goes to her. Every little noise my son makes she’s rocking him to to sleep! He’s nearly 10 months old and she knows he has 2 naps a day, yet I pick him up and most days he’s had 4 sleeps with her! It is causing a real rift between me and my partner. He loves his Mum so defends her all the time. I wish I could afford nursery or a childminder but we just can’t. I am so stuck as to what to do!! These few little things I’ve written about are just the tip of the iceberg too! Am I being an over neurotic new Mum or is she out of line here? And how do I address it with her? My partner has spoken to her countless times and I have made it clear I’m not happy without confronting her and upsetting her. I’m at a loss and it’s causing me so much stress!

OP posts:
Maxiedog123 · 10/08/2021 17:40

Don't whatever you do go and work for FILs business as if you do you will be truly screwed

Maxiedog123 · 10/08/2021 17:36

It sounds like your PIL have very traditional and paternalistic views. Your FIL buys your wedding wing as you are entering the family he heads, expects his son to work for him for reduced pay and refuses him legally mandated leave. Your MIL perhaps sees herself as the matriarch and her decisions for the baby trump yours, or perhaps she feels obliged by your FIL to do childcare to that is too tiring for her so tries to get him to sleep all the time. Your FIL doesn't approve of your working so may progressive ly make childcare more difficult , either from pure misogyny or because it means you as a couple are less dependent on him.
In the medium term I would look at reducing your dependence on your PIL. Can you plan when your son is a little older to increase your work hours and use a combination of nursery and a day from both your own parents and PIL. Your FIL will be very against this as will be not in fitting with his 1950s views of women, but if you don't you will be increasing be dependent on him as the patriarch of the family, and this is not a long-term plan.

Eralos · 10/08/2021 17:23

@newmamabear4 oh dear 😂 sorry I’ve found precious fucking baby hilarious. Sorry op I can see you’re upset. Just explain to your MIL about how you feel and try and relax with childcare there will always be things that irk us. However, feeding meat is not on when you don’t want your baby to eat meat.

Neverrains · 10/08/2021 17:03

[quote newmamabear4]**@Pebbledashery* @Eralos I came here for advice and my initial post asked if I was being unreasonable. There are kind ways of saying yes to that question. I think calling me a Precious Fing Baby is totally against what this site is about.

If I worked FT I absolutely could afford childcare. However I made the decision to work PT (temporarily) on the basis of our parents offering childcare long before we even fell pregnant. What business it is of yours to judge someone on not being able to afford childcare based on their personal circumstances is beyond me. Would you rather I claimed benefits and didn’t work and got handed everything on a plate from your taxes? Didn’t think so![/quote]
PFB is ‘precious first baby’… meaning it’s your first child.

AnneLovesGilbert · 10/08/2021 16:51

@Sadiecow

She claws at my son and tries to take over every time I see her.

I'm sure she doesn't claw at him, not a great turn of phrase!

Let’s take OP’s word for it as we weren’t there. This definitely happened to me, a family member tried to physically take my baby out of my arms then stamped her foot when DD bawled.

Some people act outrageously around babies they feel they have a right to treat like dolls.

Sadiecow · 10/08/2021 16:44

@newmamabear4 PFB is precious first baby not precious fucking baby!

Sadiecow · 10/08/2021 16:43

She claws at my son and tries to take over every time I see her.

I'm sure she doesn't claw at him, not a great turn of phrase!

newmamabear4 · 10/08/2021 16:38

@Pebbledashery @Eralos I came here for advice and my initial post asked if I was being unreasonable. There are kind ways of saying yes to that question. I think calling me a Precious F*ing Baby is totally against what this site is about.

If I worked FT I absolutely could afford childcare. However I made the decision to work PT (temporarily) on the basis of our parents offering childcare long before we even fell pregnant. What business it is of yours to judge someone on not being able to afford childcare based on their personal circumstances is beyond me. Would you rather I claimed benefits and didn’t work and got handed everything on a plate from your taxes? Didn’t think so!

OP posts:
Pebbledashery · 10/08/2021 16:11

Definitely PFB.

Eralos · 10/08/2021 14:50

I was almost with you until you said you couldn’t afford childcare, that is a major cost in having kids. Sounds like your a bit PFB. She’s is looking after your child well, no one will look after them exactly as you would. I think you need to relax a bit.

34nfihsb · 10/08/2021 13:52

something i'v learnt with mine is that you cant force a baby to sleep or drink unless they want to. so dont assume it'll be any different at the nursery. i used both - my kids barely drank any milk unless with us - they also barely napped. some babies are the other way around.

with the bibs.....yeah they should use them but not using them wont hurt them.

a nursery wont pay any more attention to your baby than a granny in my experience. but i get that somehow a grandparent not following your rules is so much more irritating.

Pebbledashery · 10/08/2021 13:51

You would've had to find robust paid childcare if your MIL wasn't around or she refused.. You're either going to have to suck it up and confront her politely or just accept some of this and leave it as it is. You can claim tax free childcare via the government, you pay 80% and the government pay 20% top up. Your issues won't be resolved until you do something about your childcare.

newmamabear4 · 10/08/2021 13:07

@Samafe your POV is a great one, I think I need to take a lot of that on board! Thank you for opening my eyes to another way of thinking.

@Daisydrum yes it’s taken me a while to learn with my own mum that she does things “her way” but we have managed to come to a good compromise between us and she now respects and understands most of our wishes. We have made the same attempts with MIL and sadly despite agreeing that she would try it just hasn’t happened. I think I need to just be happy that my son is safe and in a loving environment and park the annoyance of going against our wishes.

Our work situations can’t change at the moment and that is our personal choice. I can’t force my partner to leave a job he has worked so hard in for so many years, trust me I have been trying for the last 6 months!!

You are absolutely right about the family dynamics though. It’s very different to the way I was brought up but I guess I need to respect that everyone is different. I don’t think I’m going to change a 60+ year old mans view, even if they do belong in the Victorian times! I have spoken with my partner numerous times about the fact I feel he lives almost in fear of his father and his fathers opinion but again I can’t force him to change either. Someone else has suggested that I am reliant on my PIL? I don’t know if they mean financially or for childcare but we are absolutely not reliant on them. We are lucky that MIL is in a position to help with childcare but we are very much financially independent even if we have had to adjust our lives to fit our new financial situation in recent months.

OP posts:
Panickingpavlova · 10/08/2021 12:35

The only issue re post is keeping him neat and tidy as others have said, obviously within the limits its good for baby's to get hold of the food and experiment and get dirty etc

Panickingpavlova · 10/08/2021 11:47

Interesting that she didn't want to walk with you and the baby she just wants the baby alone rather than see the baby any time because other stuff is going on

Daisydrum · 10/08/2021 11:21

OP we had a combination of my DM and my DMIL looking after our first and they both cared for DS very much but there were things I disagreed with in some of their styles but I didn’t feel I had much of a choice. The one thing they did do was always write down exactly how much and what he’d eaten in our little note pad we kept so everyone knew how much and what he’d eaten, this helped me greatly. DS now has a great relationship with both of them.
The thing that stands out to me in your posts is the control issue, i.e. not respecting your choice of being a pescatarian. The fact they have effectively forced your DH to work full time for less money and they impose their outdated views on you all stinks of control and the hierarchy in the family. Definitely some independence is needed from your PILs.

QforCucumber · 10/08/2021 10:34

Go back to your Well paid FT job and let your not so well paid husband go PT and take on the childcare? Since he's taken a huge paycut already this shouldn't cause too much of an issue surely?

Brefugee · 10/08/2021 10:27

FIL owns the company my partner works for and is VERY ‘traditional’ lets say. My partner made a passing comment about him taking the full paternity leave as I was the main breadwinner when we fell pregnant and FIL said he would sack him if he asked to do that as a mans place it at work and a woman’s place is at home!

He has a contract? Not sure what the law is in UK but you can't be fired for that in Germany. Call his bluff?

You sound very PFB and a bit petulant, tbh. The looking neat thing is bonkers, let it go.abd WFH doesn't mean you are available for deliveries or keeping an eye on bonfires. What sort of high paid job did you have that you think this? Wink

In your shoes I'd be: asking my DH to change his job, looking for a job myself; not using MIL for childcare. (agree about the sleep routine though)

Samafe · 10/08/2021 10:23

I think you have to isolate the 2 different issues here:

  • issues with what happens under her supervision: my suggestion is to let it go. My DS stays pretty regularly at my MIL place and life is wild there....honestly, he loves it, I love it, it gives my son the ability to cope with a different environment, different rules, for him is like an adventure everytime. He gets dirty, muddy, soaked wet, full with leaves....you name it! He eats things I generally do not allow him at home, he naps in my MIL bed, cuddled together, with a super old stuffed bunny which belonged to my DH.
He is as happy as a clam and at the same time it is pretty clear to him that grandma house is the place to draw on walls and eat chips out of the bag, it stays there, and does not impact in any way our life at home. This works great for a person like me: I am an organized person which need schedules and day planned...kind of a boring mother, I am sometimes afraid of...with my MIL he can live adventures I am sometimes not able to offer him. Maybe it will be the same for your DS.
  • the resentment towards you MIL is a complete different issue, and is the one you need to work on. If you cannot get past the resentment, I suggest you find a nursery for DS. It will never work good.
Skiptheheartsandflowers · 10/08/2021 10:17

@billy1966

You have given up a well paid job to depend on a partner who is not well paid and dependent on his father's whim?

Kindly, are you out of your mind?

Your partner is crying over these issues with his family?

You are so vulnerable.
Get back to.work FT.
Put the baby in a good nursery.

Back away from parents in law for whom you depend on for far too much.

Agree that you both need to rethink your employment. If you can't afford childcare, you can't afford to work. Leaving your full time well paid job was a shame - wouldn't they have been at all flexible or offered you part time?

Your partner works for his dad, gave up cash to keep the business afloat, but still doesn't get paternity leave? I would have been reminding my FIL of this when he refused to be flexible. It's the worst of all worlds in working for a family business. More secure, better rewarded employment for both of you will allow you to pay for the childcare you need.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/08/2021 10:13

Go back to your regular job, DH finds a part time job with an employer who abides by employment law and takes over home responsibilities.

WingBingo · 10/08/2021 10:03

I think complaining about free, family provided childcare is in the top 50 of MN don’ts.

Houseplantmad · 10/08/2021 09:53

There’s more to this than just childcare- your husband is still at their beck and call. He needs to move into another job and you should increase your hours to afford proper childcare. Even the wedding ring purchase was a not so subtle message from your FIL ie you’re marrying the family not just the son and will be at their beck and call too.
Why would you leave your most precious thing with someone you don’t trust and don’t seem to like much?

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 10/08/2021 09:44

YANBU It sounds to me that both PILs disrespect you and your DH. I think she's purposely doing the opposite of what you say as demonstrated during lockdown. Firstly, your DH should find another, better paid job. I can't believe they made him take a huge pay cut. That would resolve the main issue straight away - you could afford childcare and get away from the PILs undue influence. I would also say you and your DH need to be more assertive. Anyone who disrespected my instructions like not kissing the baby would not have been let anywhere near them again.

CallmeHendricks · 10/08/2021 09:41

Not the main point of the thread, I know, but your FIL paid for your wedding ring???
I don't see that as a "beautiful gesture." I view it as a metaphor for him taking control of an important symbol of your marriage. That should have been your husband's role to fulfil.
I think this all sounds way too enmeshed and unhealthy.
Start considering ways to step back from the dependency you appear to have on them.