Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would anyone be interested in trying to do one small thing each week to tackle climate change?

378 replies

riotlady · 09/08/2021 19:39

I’ve seen a few threads on aibu recently with people panicking about climate change and I often find myself worrying about it too, especially in light of the report published today. Studies show that one of the best ways to combat anxiety is to feel like you’re doing something about the problem, so I’ve decided to challenge myself to do one small thing to reduce my impact on the planet each week. I’m wondering if anyone would like to join me? I’m thinking small actions like walking or cycling a journey when you would normally take the car, swapping shower gel for bar soap, switching to a greener energy supplier, etc. No judgement about what is and isn’t feasible for people- for example I have ME and am very fatigued, so often use my tumble drier instead of hanging things out as I just don’t have the energy. There’s no point guilting myself over that, so I might as well focus on the things that I CAN change.

I’ve just sent an email to my MP so that’s my start to this week :)

OP posts:
MoreThanJustANumber · 10/08/2021 23:27

I'm in.

I've been making beeswax wraps, experimenting with different types of shampoo bars and as soon as I've got through my rather large stock of shower gel and handwash I'll be buying bar soap.

What are the alternatives for toothpaste for very sensitive teeth. I always use sensodyne and wondered if there was something that would be as good but more environmentally friendly?

Otherpeoplesteens · 10/08/2021 23:14

If I couldn't buy British then I would go without.

Nice idea, but unless you want to survive on potatoes, beets and turnips from November through to April then come down and join us on Earth, if you can find a patch that isn't on fire.

Otherpeoplesteens · 10/08/2021 23:11

@riotlady The UK's byzantine energy market isn't my area of expertise, but as far as I can understand it works like this.

Getting electricity into your home or business is divided into four parts: the generators who pump electricity into the grid (i.e. power plants, turbines, solar panels, etc); the transmission (the high voltage pylons which send electricity from the generation points to the local substations); the distribution (from the substation to the end user - homes, businesses etc); and the suppliers or retailers (the people to whom you pay your bill).

You sign a contract with a supplier and they, in turn, will have contracts with one or more generators to take delivery of a certain amount of electricity in any given period, typically a half hour at a time. Your "green" supplier may only have such contracts with a renewable generator. All fine so far.

The problem is that if your supplier's renewable generator(s) relies on solar and wind, and you turn on your airconditioning, charge your car, and run a 2,200w vacuum cleaner at the same time your DD is using her hair dryer, and this all takes place late on a hot still night when there's no wind or sun, the renewable generator cannot meet the demand which your green supplier has contracted for. Your green supplier therefore must buy additional electricity in real time through what is effectively a clearing system from other generators putting electricity into the grid. By the same token, if you are out at the beach on a sunny, windy day then you cannot use the electricity which your supplier has bought from its contracted generator(s) for those half hour periods when you'd normally be using it, so they sell it to other suppliers. They all then sort out the money later on their side through a 'balancing payments' system. National Grid ensures that supply and demand is roughly balanced by shutting down or activating surge capacity as and when needed.

There's no way you can distinguish between surge capacity coming from a gas-fired power station in East Anglia, nuclear power coming from France, or stored hydro-electric power coming from Dinorwig in Wales, all of which goes into the grid at peak times and ends up in your home even though you only pay money to the "green" supplier which only has contracts with renewable generators. The transmission and distribution costs are split between the retail suppliers (which tacks them onto your bill) and the generators (which tacks them onto what they charge the suppliers).

As far as I can tell, if I could meet the regulatory standards there is nothing to stop me setting up Otherpeoplesteens Electricity plc, buying electricity from Back of Beyond Windfarm Co Ltd and selling it to you as renewable energy. The thing is, I could also buy electricity from Old Smoker Coal Generation Company, then buy carbon credits - which are actually quite cheap - from any old company which has them spare, or on the open market through one of a number of emissions trading exchanges, and still sell 'carbon neutral' electricity to you.

The other issue, of course, is that electricity doesn't account for anywhere near all domestic energy use. Most people in Britain use natural gas for central heating and hot water and while there is some renewable biogas getting into the system, gas is a fossil fuel by definition to all intents and purposes. Anyone peddling renewable gas or duel fuel tariffs is either generating said gas from their arse, or talking out of it.

DelphiniumBlue · 10/08/2021 22:59

Some great ideas!
I'm having our family reduce the amount of meat we eat, have been trying out veggie recipes which have gone down surprisingly well. Linked to that, I'm also trying to waste less, so keeping a closer eye on when things need to be used up, freezing any excess if I have enough space, and making recipes using those items while they are still useable, eg soup, stir fry etc.

PrincessNutNuts · 10/08/2021 22:35

[quote twinkletoesimnot]@PrincessNutNuts
But no reason not to.

If I couldn't buy British then I would go without.

This definitely goes for meat too.

These are the kind of changes we need to make.[/quote]
I guess you're not buying much fruit and veg from supermarkets at the moment then.

twinkletoesimnot · 10/08/2021 21:34

@PrincessNutNuts
But no reason not to.

If I couldn't buy British then I would go without.

This definitely goes for meat too.

These are the kind of changes we need to make.

PrincessNutNuts · 10/08/2021 20:04

@twinkletoesimnot

But tomatoes and asparagus grow here in the UK!

Point in evidence!

Yeah, and usually the asparagus and tomatoes I buy are British in summertime.

(Or from some of our nearest neighbours.)

Not this year though.

PrincessNutNuts · 10/08/2021 20:02

@mustlovegin

The tomatoes in my fridge are from Morocco and the asparagus from Peru

This has been the case for years. Nothing to do with Brexit

At this time of year?

In summer I'm used to being able to buy British of a lot of things like this, or Spanish/German/Italian/French.

Stuff coming from Africa or South America instead doesn't sit well with me.

riotlady · 10/08/2021 19:36

In terms of putting pressure on large corporations, here’s a link to a campaign asking Microsoft (one of the biggest users of corporate flights) to use Teams (their own software!) for meetings

justuseteams.com/

OP posts:
Maireas · 10/08/2021 19:35

You're right, @PrincessNutNuts and it's getting harder.
I'm making a concerted effort to try to buy from local producers, but as you say, not an easy task.

mustlovegin · 10/08/2021 19:35

The tomatoes in my fridge are from Morocco and the asparagus from Peru

This has been the case for years. Nothing to do with Brexit

twinkletoesimnot · 10/08/2021 19:35

But tomatoes and asparagus grow here in the UK!

Point in evidence!

PrincessNutNuts · 10/08/2021 19:22

@Maireas

Stop eating food that has to be flown halfway across the world. Buy from local producers where possible.
I feel like that's becoming a bit trickier since we voted to make it harder to deal with the 27 countries nearest to us.

The tomatoes in my fridge are from Morocco and the asparagus from Peru.

Maireas · 10/08/2021 19:08

Stop eating food that has to be flown halfway across the world. Buy from local producers where possible.

PrincessNutNuts · 10/08/2021 19:07

@Maireas

Don't use or consume anything with palm oil. It's the growing of palm oil that is responsible for the destruction of rainforest. It's in a huge amount of products.
Yeah. That's a huge one.

It didn't used to be in everything -but seemingly now it is.

BahHumbygge · 10/08/2021 18:55

Mining for lithium and rare earth metals for electric vehicles and renewable energy projects are destroying the planet just as much as coal, oil and gas extraction. We can't switch to renewables, we have to curtail industrial energy systems and resource extraction full stop. An industrial economy is incompatible with life on this planet, no matter what the full source.

Maireas · 10/08/2021 18:43

Don't use or consume anything with palm oil.
It's the growing of palm oil that is responsible for the destruction of rainforest. It's in a huge amount of products.

RantyAunty · 10/08/2021 18:38

Remember when you vote to look at who is supporting coal.

Vote for people who are for green energy, renewables.

PrincessNutNuts · 10/08/2021 18:14

If anyone is looking to replace cotton wool pads for acid toner etc I bought a couple of sets of these "cleansing and toning pads" last year and they're great.

I save them up in a delicates laundry bag then wash them in with the next white load.

www.mylittleecoshop.com/collections/health-beauty/products/pink-dreams-hemp-cotton-6-pack-cleansing-makeup-pads

I'm currently weighing up whether to buy a Sodastream or similar for sparkling water, or if I should get over myself and just drink plain tap and be grateful I'm not a climate refugee. (Yet)

mrwalkensir · 10/08/2021 17:55

eco balls - can do a full load on a "quick wash". Saves water as well as electricty

PrincessNutNuts · 10/08/2021 17:50

@MeanderingGently

This is a brilliant thread! I am already mostly meat-free...not entirely but don't often buy it or eat it these days. Low plastic use, could be better. One of my long-term aims is to not have the car. I did it for three years but currently living out in the sticks and can't get to work without a car; however, I have changed jobs to one that is only a 10 minute drive away. No local transport sadly but once I retire the car is going....
I fervently hope that the number of people who can now work from home due to covid and thus avoiding a pointless, planet- destroying commute 5 days a week must be making a difference.

We wanted to go car less but it's just that "in an emergency" thing that's holding us back.

I had to take DH to A&E in the middle of the night recently on 111 instruction and it would have been harder without our own car.

Maybe we need to find people to share it with?

riotlady · 10/08/2021 17:48

@WindFlower92 that’s brilliant to have done all in one go! I’m so glad people are finding this thread helpful :)

@Otherpeoplesteens can I ask you a bit more about green energy cos I don’t really get it? I switched to a green energy tarrif with Octopus and while I understand that on a literal level, all energy runs through the same grid so the energy running my house could come from anywhere, I thought my money was funding the generation of renewable energy? From reading their website it looks like they generate a portion themselves and buy some from other renewable energy generators- is that the credits part?

OP posts:
BahHumbygge · 10/08/2021 17:48

Now pristine Greenland is going to be plundered for minerals for the components of electric vehicles and renewable energy production...

www.reuters.com/business/billionaire-backed-mining-firm-seek-electric-vehicle-metals-greenland-2021-08-09/

Digging up and laying waste to the planet for industrial scale energy and transportation isn't by any stretch of the imagination green.

PrincessNutNuts · 10/08/2021 17:45

@midgemagneto

Consumer changes are not useless They do matter and I think we can see in data that they are having effect

For example Less red meat is being eaten and whilst you might only changers meat feee 1day a week, so many other people are doing the same , so it's noticeable at a national level

Yes. Agreed.

One of the big recommendations from the climate scientists this week was

Reduce the consumption of beef and dairy products, which contribute to deforestation and a significant amount of emissions from cattle.

What is that, if not a consumer change?

https://www.bostonglobe.com/2021/08/09/metro/with-climate-change-getting-worse-here-are-seven-steps-experts-say-world-needs-take-right-now/?outputType=amp&twitterrimpression=true

PrincessNutNuts · 10/08/2021 17:30

Thank you for this thread.

I know we need to do more.

Every little helps - as Mr Tesco used to say.

And the cultural shift to focusing on doing our best for the future of our planet, and urging our elected representatives and the companies we give our money to do their best also is as important as the individual actions themselves.

We're quite good on the big things, we don't fly, we're vegans, we walk or cycle everywhere, especially lately. We just got rid of one of our cars. We were thinking about going carless entirely, but if not our next will be small and electric. Our new house doesn't have gas central heating and when we move we won't put it in.

But I get supermarket deliveries and all the tomatoes and apples and everything are sealed in plastic.

Too many of my work blouses are polyester.

I take baths....

And have pets. (All rescue cats but big meat eaters. At least we recycle their cat food pouches.)

I'm off to read through the thread now and get ideas.