Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Garden landscape. Not happy. What do you think?

64 replies

Livinginchaos · 09/08/2021 19:38

I had my garden landscaped recently. This is the first time I have ever had a big job done in my house. Something I have saved up for a long time for.

The tradesman is in tomorrow and I am not sure if aibu re some of the issues I want to bring up. Can anyone help me please?

The edge of the patio isn't straight. See picture 3 as an example but this is all around the edge of it.

The step doesn't seem finished and looks ugly. We agreed to a wooden edging but you can see the concrete layer above it. See picture 2

He has put wood alongside the edges of the patio but it looks rubbish. See the gap between the wood and the paving slabs, and between the two adjoining sections of wood. He also has put little wooden struts alongside it which looks awful and doesn't seem necessary. See picture 1

He also said he would take out a tree but now says its too difficult and I need to pay a tree surgeon to do it. He has left me with a stump.

Patio is not evenly placed: some gaps where pointing is are extremely thin and some much wider. Mumsnet won't let me upload another picture but you can probably see from the ones here. I know he will say that the nature of the slabs is that they are uneven, but this seems like an excuse for the level of differences between the slabs.

Am I being unreasonable? Would you be happy with this?

He comes over tomorrow to finish off so I need to be prepared with what I want to say.

Garden landscape. Not happy. What do you think?
Garden landscape. Not happy. What do you think?
Garden landscape. Not happy. What do you think?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
billy1966 · 14/08/2021 17:13

We have a lovely WhatsApp group in my very urban setting.

Many of the neighbours I don't know, despite living here for 25 years.

However, their are constant requests for a recommendation for different trades etc., and invariably they will come back and confirm the recommendation.
The amount of work these guys get from it is phenomenal.

Absolutely no one comes on my property to do anything without being highly recommended.

It saves so much heartache.

I feel for you OP, paying for cowboy work is terribly upsetting.
Flowers

RightYesButNo · 14/08/2021 16:58

Also, I don’t know what you paid, OP, but here’s a guideline to determine if the quote was “fair” to begin with (if your patio is 40m2, it should have been between roughly £2,200 and £6.000 - and the £6K is only assuming you had very expensive pavers selected.

www.checkatrade.com/blog/cost-guides/patio-laying-cost/

FizzyPink · 14/08/2021 16:16

Don’t feel like a mug OP. It’s so hard to know with tradespeople. We had 3 quotes for our garden. I was dreading the last one as I really liked him and he definitely came across as the most knowledgeable so thought he’d be ridiculously expensive. He actually quoted half the price of the other two and did a fantastic job.
One thing I would recommend is asking for recommendations on a site like NextDoor. That’s where we found ours and it was so reassuring to speak to someone who’d previously had their garden done by them and see their photos.

billy1966 · 14/08/2021 16:03

Did you pay them because you felt threatened?

If so, go to the police.

A woman on her own?

Feeling coerced to pay for awful work when she complained because she felt threatby their anger? Police matter.

Awful job. You poor woman.

RightYesButNo · 14/08/2021 15:33

I was almost wondering about DIY…

B&Q, Wickes, Homebase all have videos on how to lay a patio yourself. It’s as if he watched one of those and just thought he’d do it.

OP, I’m sorry! Quite a few people have had this kind of issue with a tradesman once (when dealing with plasters, plumbers, electricians, all at the same time, it’s understandable that one of them might be less than stellar). It’s just unfortunate because you’re only having one job done on your house, so that’s that. I think small claims court should easily be in your favor with photographs, the expert opinion, and I’m sure some MN users can come with you Grin “I couldn’t believe how terrible her thread was! Those bastards should pay up!” Definitely swing the decision in your favor.

MrsSkylerWhite · 14/08/2021 09:46

Looks like DIY.

Where did you find the person who did this? I think in this past year or so a lot of people have turned to alternative work they’re not qualified to do, wondering if this may be such a case?

So sorry, you must be so disappointed.

QueenStromba · 14/08/2021 09:43

Oh no! What a nightmare. I hope you get it all sorted soon.

Arsebucket · 13/08/2021 19:20

[quote Livinginchaos]@QueenStromba no. Its beyond repair. They turned nasty and were swearing etc. I was glad to see them leave as I felt vulnerable.

I have had an expert in to look at the work and it's not only cosmetic unfortunately. The patio runs water towards the house and is at the same levels and the damp proof course. That is one big issue of many.

The whole garden needs taking up and redoing.

I was an idiot a had already paid them. No idea why I have been such a walkover. Next stop: small claims court.Sad[/quote]
Oh, i’m so sorry Sad

Livinginchaos · 13/08/2021 18:16

@QueenStromba no. Its beyond repair. They turned nasty and were swearing etc. I was glad to see them leave as I felt vulnerable.

I have had an expert in to look at the work and it's not only cosmetic unfortunately. The patio runs water towards the house and is at the same levels and the damp proof course. That is one big issue of many.

The whole garden needs taking up and redoing.

I was an idiot a had already paid them. No idea why I have been such a walkover. Next stop: small claims court.Sad

OP posts:
QueenStromba · 13/08/2021 18:04

@Livinginchaos has the builder put it right?

essentialhealing · 10/08/2021 21:48

I would be very disappointed with the standard of work if that's the finished job. It looks like somebody with barely any skills or knowledge did it, really rough around the edges

I'd expect the wood to rot at some point in the future too. The elements always seem to destroy wood eventually

DP is in the process of taking apart a raised flowerbed that was already here when we bought the house ten years ago. Back then it looked great but now the wood has began to rot and the soil is coming through

Looubylou · 10/08/2021 21:28

YANBU - looks more like a keen DIY job, and passable as such with no labour costs. When I bought my house I had my quite large garden done - went for the cheapest quote. Looked fab - but years down the line realised the choice of plants was very inappropriate, with no vision for the future in terms of how much space things need and how enormous some things would grow. I would always try to go on recommendations in future. I hope he is reasonable when you challenge him OP.

CiderJolly · 10/08/2021 18:17

You’re not stupid.

I’ve had no end of trouble with tradesmen as a single parent- I think they often try and take the piss.

Had you paid upfront?

QueenStromba · 10/08/2021 09:16

@PeanuttyButter

That doesn't look great at all. How he has arranged the flags too are completely wrong and spoils the asthetics. Gaps are uneven.
Yeah the pattern is all wrong - it should look like Etymology's picture.
PeanuttyButter · 10/08/2021 08:46

That doesn't look great at all. How he has arranged the flags too are completely wrong and spoils the asthetics. Gaps are uneven.

Branster · 10/08/2021 08:24

Forgot to add: the top layer of the paved area should cover the top edges of the vertical sides unless the top of the sides create a proper edge all the way around. In this case, the wood should not be levelled with the stone but underneath it. The visible horizontal surface all the way would be just the stone.

Plexie · 10/08/2021 08:21

To be fair, your paving slabs are very unevenly cut and you can't create a perfect geometric pattern with slabs that aren't identical sizes and aren't perfect squares/rectangles. That's why the slabs near the bamboo screen are sticking out - they're not the same size and he's aligned them on the inner edge. Some of the slabs aren't cut square so of course there are varying gaps when laid next to each other.

Did you source the slabs yourself or did he? If he chose them I would reject the entire work as he provided poorly cut slabs that are impossible to lay well.

Branster · 10/08/2021 08:18

I'd say he needs to rectify the following:
Wooden edging is an awful idea and needs to go, ideally that should have been brick/stone or brick clad with a weather resistant finish of your choice like a composite material or ceramic or something you like the look of depending on the colours you want. But to build it, you'd need to start from scratch 😞

As a minimum, The edging is very poor and needs to be rectified - again remove slabs, cut (new ones probably) and replace.

The uneven gaps are only acceptable up to a point where the edges of the slabs are uneven. In this case they are very bad but if everything else was rectified, it's probably something you could live with.

Very harsh lesson here I'm so sorry you're dealing with this mess. For future work, gave daily discussions before work commences and at the end of each work day as it helps rectify any issues as they appear.

Forget about the tree stump for now, write it off, and get someone with a tree grinder to do the job later.

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 10/08/2021 08:18

The step looks unfinished. Aside from the rotting/moving/shrinking/expanding issue. Good luck, OP.

Etymology23 · 10/08/2021 08:05

I had a patio laid with similar slabs and it doesn't look uneven - and this wasn't laid by an expensive company or anything.

You may or may not be able to see but the holding edge is faced with partial slabs, instead of wood. The sides aren't faced equivalently, but that's because I had got a total bargain on the slabs so had a fixed quantity and we were working with what we had!

It then has a step down to the lawn, which doesn't have faced edges but was done so tidily that it still looks good.

Garden landscape. Not happy. What do you think?
MydogWillow · 10/08/2021 07:53

@RightYesButNo

I’m afraid every single piece of wood involved looks like completely untreated (unless I’m missing something?) which means in probably less than a year, all of the wood will rot in UK weather. Here; have some liquid courage Gin as then tell him it’s complete crap.
It's oak by the look of it which doesn't need to be treated, but any timber moves so can't understand why it's been used where it has. It actually looks like fresh sawn oak (not kiln dried) so it will move even more.
HurryUpAndWait23 · 10/08/2021 07:42

My husbands a landscaper and has recently done our garden in an almost identical way. I think we even have the same slabs!

And your work is not great.

The only thing I will say is, ours also has a slight mismatch of gaps between the slabs.
I was going to ask DH about this but when I've seen other houses with the same slabs they all have a slight mismatch of gaps. I'm not sure if this is because they are always down to guess work or the slabs are a little uneven therefore impossible to get a correct gap each time.

icelollycraving · 10/08/2021 07:41

Oh dear, I feel for you. It’s so disappointing when you save hard for something and it isn’t right.

LagunaBubbles · 10/08/2021 07:37

No I wouldn't be happy.

BlueSuffragette · 10/08/2021 07:35

Sorry OP it needs major work doing to make it look decent. Do not pay anything until it is put right.

Swipe left for the next trending thread