Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Restricting WiFi at night for teen

34 replies

MrsPatrickDempsey · 09/08/2021 19:23

Opinions please

15 yr DS wants unrestricted WiFi access in school holidays, specifically at nighttime. Currently turns off at midnight but this is embarrassing apparently.

What are your rules?
Yabu - no restrictions
Yanbu -turn it off at night

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
rookiemere · 10/08/2021 09:53

Midnight is DS 15 switch off wifi time for holidays and weekends, on school nights it's 10pm.
Midnight is more than late enough for him to be up gaming. He's more likely to keep going if wifi is still on. Uni is time enough to learn that sort of self regulation, whilst he's still in full time school and under our roof he needs to keep to a roughly normal daytime routine.
I thought midnight was pretty generous tbh.

AliMonkey · 10/08/2021 08:37

WiFi never turned off here but all our phones go off when we each go to bed. And DC (similar ages) always go to bed by 11 (usually earlier) unless a particular reason like an occasional event that finishes very late. That’s basically set bed times / screen time when they were younger morphing into self regulation. DD does say that when she turns her phone on in morning there’s sometimes hundreds of messages but in a “why on earth are they up so late regularly” way not “I’m missing out”.

So encouraging self regulation is better in my view but if he’s incapable of that then WiFi off at midnight seems very reasonable.

TootTootTootToot · 10/08/2021 08:36

I didn’t restrict my DCs Wi-fi once they were older teens but I think I should have done. I think 12 during the week and 02:00 on Friday and sat sounds more than generous. It would depend on behaviour etc. My kids school was 5 mins away so they didn’t have to get up early.

ILiveInSalemsLot · 10/08/2021 08:25

I restrict my dcs too. There’s no conflict as they know why and agree. They’ve never been good at self regulating so I’m hoping forming good habits will help instead.

Ducksurprise · 10/08/2021 08:20

In the summer if they don't have anything else to do the next morning I let them have it and then let them sleep in, teenagers have different body clocks, if you want him off turn it off in the afternoon.

uggmum · 10/08/2021 08:17

I have never had any wifi controls or restrictions for my dc.

They have always been allowed to self regulate.

They are 18 and 22 now and are good functioning adults.

Heyhohi · 10/08/2021 08:11

I highly recommend app Circle, my oldest 17 yo used to bypass parental settings on his iPhone for years, I set let’s say 5 hrs daily use but he managed somehow to end like with 10 hrs. Now all the gadgets at home for 3 kids are easily controlled

MegBusset · 10/08/2021 08:04

Ours are 12 and 14, phones live downstairs at night after bedtime (9.30/10ish in term time, 10.30/11 in holidays) and they switch their laptops off. We are pretty relaxed about screen time in the day (unless we are eating or doing something as a family) so they get hours a day. But they need sleep!

Oneborneverydecade · 10/08/2021 07:56

We take 14yo DSs Xbox controllers when we go to bed at about 10.30/11. His phone is set to go off at 11/11.30 during term time and a bit later in the holidays. We also take the lounge TV controller.
That probably seems a bit uptight reading this thread but I have a friend whose 13yo goes up to bed lights out at 9pm

tigger1001 · 10/08/2021 06:09

Mine are not allowed phones etc upstairs after bedtime. Xbox is downstairs.

Non negotiable here.

Mintjulia · 10/08/2021 05:53

Here, it's no devices upstairs. DS spends too much time on computer games anyway. He reads when he goes to bed and normally falls asleep reading.

StarlightLady · 10/08/2021 05:43

Surely, if is turned off at night he will use 4G or 3G instead?

anothermansmother · 10/08/2021 00:21

My ds is 14 and his goes off at 10pm no argument or he just doesn't have it on the following day. I have however started to let him regulate his own use on a Saturday evening since it's the holidays and find he still brings me the controllers and his phone around the same time anyway.
Maybe meet him in the middle and allow it in certain days.

CloudPop · 10/08/2021 00:02

@stripedbananas

My DC do have a couple of friends each who have internet and equipment restrictions which all their friends accept but everyone does think it's unnecessary and a bit controlling and all feel very sorry for them.

Especially as these DC are just expected to sit alone quietly for that time and aren't participating in any family time so are just bored and friendless for a few sad hours.

A few sad hours after midnight?
Fauvist · 09/08/2021 21:57

I let my 14 year old DD have wifi as much as she wants during the day and she is good at self-regulating and taking a break. But the rule is phones downstairs at night to charge and nobody should be on them in bed. And actually that's a good rule for people of any age.

megletthesecond · 09/08/2021 21:47

I think they should be off tech in the middle of the night. My 14yo's phone is locked by 11pm and he's much chirpier for it. He games and sees mates in the day.
I have behavioral problems with my 12yo and currently unable to lock her phone, she stays up until gone 3am. She cannot regulate at all.

toconclude · 09/08/2021 21:34

@whiteroseredrose

My DC always self regulated. If something is freely available it is less desirable.
Not necessarily. DS1 would game all day and all night if he didn't have to work (his admission)
GreenLakes · 09/08/2021 20:23

At 15 I really wouldn’t expect to be imposing restrictions on wifi or screen usage.

So long as all homework and revision is completed to a high standard in my house, I have no rules on electronics.

At your DS’s age, he really needs to begin self regulating as he’ll be off to uni presumably in a few years and you won’t be there. To be frank if he stays up until 2am in the holidays, so what?

Ime it tends to be the DC whose parents are excessively strict with things like electronics (and alcohol) who become addicted in later life.

Landlubber2019 · 09/08/2021 20:19

I have younger teens but I absolutely wouldn't allow 24 hr internet access, it's not necessary whilst sleep is.

Whilst I appreciate many kids are well behaved and don't need regulating, I was absolutely like this. Fortunately my parents just didn't know the half of what I was doing as I made sure they never found out!

parentalhelpline · 09/08/2021 20:12

Hell no to Internet at night. They get 3 hours during the day, and in the holidays they can use this whenever they want. But it goes off at bedtime, even when there is no school the next day.

It's not that I mind them talking to friends. But I do mind the opportunity cost of spending too much time online. Some of my kids self-regulate better than others. But all of them have needed someone to switch off the wifi so it doesn't intrude on sleep, socialising in person, and other activities like reading or playing sport.

I wish my kids could make better decisions about the time they spend online. But I'm pretty good at wasting time on screens and I'm 50. So we have an app that controls their internet access until they are old enough to be responsible - or at least old enough to deal with the consequences of their own decisions.

cheesepizza22 · 09/08/2021 20:05

My parents left the wifi on at night once after I begged and begged. I was about 15?
I stayed up until around 5am and she knocked on my door at 7:15am ready for school the next day.
I never ever used it after 11pm ever again.
I now have my own house and I'm in bed off the internet at 11:30 😂 lesson well and truly learnt.

Ghosttile · 09/08/2021 20:00

I assumed there was some reason for a time being set like neglected school work or not getting up in the morning. If he’s not abused it then it does seem OTT.

stripedbananas · 09/08/2021 19:49

My DC do have a couple of friends each who have internet and equipment restrictions which all their friends accept but everyone does think it's unnecessary and a bit controlling and all feel very sorry for them.

Especially as these DC are just expected to sit alone quietly for that time and aren't participating in any family time so are just bored and friendless for a few sad hours.

stripedbananas · 09/08/2021 19:43

I have no WiFi restrictions for DS 15 or anyone else for that matter.
Everyone here has always self regulated and as he did well in his mocks and knows so long as School work never suffers then I'm pretty relaxed about most things. I don't mind him playing and chatting for hours with his friends and having a haphazard routine during the holidays as he snaps straight back to a routine once back at school. I wouldn't want to get into a battle about it. I've pretty much smoothed out any rough areas over the years so I'm pretty pleased with the outcome so far of my DS and other DC.

If however he was failing at school and behaving badly then yes I would absolutely set restrictions but never just for the sake of it.

ExtraOnions · 09/08/2021 19:34

I leave it in the holidays … she has the odd very very late night .. but is normally quite good. As long as she’s up and about for appointments and trips our, I don’t see the harm