Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think "its impacting on my mental health" is over used

229 replies

54321nought · 09/08/2021 13:38

I just seem to hear this constantly.

I know you can't judge what another person is going through. Every single individual time I hear it, I give the person the benefit of the doubt.

But overall, I just don't think that many people are having their mental health impacted!

I think it sometimes just means " I don't like this situation" /" this makes me anxious/nervous" / " this is annoying"

We have such easy lives, for the most part. Why is everyone suddenly saying that not getting their own way in something or other is giving them mental health problems?

I have cared for a lot of children and adults with mental health problems, I know how painful and debilitating they can be. Its not what I see in people who are telling me "XYZ is impacting on my mental health".

I know some mental health problems might be invisible, not surely not on this scale, when we all have food, shelter, drinking water, sanitation etc, and in places I have lived without these things, people don't seem to be claiming so many mental health problems....

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BiBabbles · 12/08/2021 13:11

Mental health being impacted is a pretty neutral phrase. Within a lot of coping strategy work, it's a common practice to track what 'impacts' our mental health so we can be aware and handle our own health, even when we aren't sure how to articulate it. Impact doesn't mean negative, it just means we noticed an effect and it's acknowledged not all of them are under our control - I often have dreams that affect my moods and mental wellbeing, for better and for worse & I've little control of my dreams, but being aware of their impact means I know after a bad night - like one I had recently where I was reliving my mother trying to kill me in new ways and locations - I know what I can do to try to minimize that impact because I had a lot of coping skill training as a child. Doesn't make it easy and sometimes the impact is all I can articulate, I can't always put an emotional label on these things that I feel is accurate. If I say something has impacted my mental health or similarly vague, that means something has had an effect and I'm not sure how to otherwise explain that & may need help finding better words, not that I'm trying to get something.

While I agree the UK and other places may have pathologized too much as part of a spiral where things aren't taken seriously so we apply a fancy label which is then still not taken seriously so we up the ante further and lost some of the nuance along the way, this desire to erase suffering in the UK is ridiculous. Palestinian doctors - and many others who live in on-going conflict zones - have discussed the different language used around mental ill health, but even with different language, it's still noticed as it has been across place and time.

Life can cause mental health problems, trauma, etc, but very few people actually fall into this category ( in the UK).

Using US stats, because that's where has the most data, and I don't imagine are too different from the UK, 61% of adults have at least one Adverse Childhood Experience, and 16% have 4 or more. I'm in the latter category, with the most unwanted perfect score ever. There may not be war on our own soil, that does not mean we are at peace or that conflict isn't going on in our home and the environment around us. Things are more complicated than that.

Most mental health problems are not in any way related to life experiences and whether we talk about our feelings or not.

More and more, these conditions viewed as 'mental' are shown to have physical, genetic, and environmental components. Bodies, including our mental state, are complicated - pretty much how all illnesses are expressed has some environmental component.

I personally prefer therapy around developing coping strategies over talking, but we don't fix anything by not talking about it. The people who taught me not to talk about it or to only use minimal language were not the one who cared about my well-being.

People are not taking care of mental health though, that is my point. They are just flashing the "mental health" card, to get what they want, without actually having any understanding or knowledge of what mental health actually means.

Maybe in some cases, there are those who intentionally are assholes in any group and those not intentionally doing so may benefit coping skill training that includes emotional skills and in other cases they may mean more than "I am annoyed" or "I don't like it when" or what they're feeling doesn't fit what they imagine 'annoyed' or 'don't like' should feel like.

Not everyone actually has the skills to label emotions well -- actually, humans in general are pretty bad at this, even more young ones, and we're generally terrible at identifying why we're having certain emotions and the sensations we link to them. They may just know something has been impacted and that's the language they have, it's likely worked for them before, so that's what they use. Your posts OP make it sound like this should be a very easy skill that people are just purposefully choosing not to do to manipulate others, when really it's like identifying any sensory information - we rely on experience and the skills we've developed and as a society, we talk a lot about mental health now - which is why people use that language - but these skills are no more prioritized than identifying bird calls. I think as a society we have a lot of surface representation of feelings and other aspects of mental health and assume people will get it from there and I don't think that's happening.

I think it's pretty sad that you're seeing many people with obvious skill gaps and you write about them in such a negative dismissive way. You can claim you give people the benefit of the doubt all you want, but that is not what is coming across here. I'm really glad young-me got better help from people who saw my gaps, understood my behaviour was my poor attempt at communication, taught me & tried to limit the damage of those who looked down on my limited language and emotional skills.

For all your training, I'm not sure you understand what mental health actually means, at least, not holistically as something that can be impacted by our daily lives just as much as the rest of us. You seem to have a rather pathological view of it that it's only to be discussed as part of an illness, that regular emotions aren't part of it. Having had mental health care from early childhood with no one using that term until I was 15 & getting assessed for possible hospital admission (I did not qualify, but the admissions assessment team was amazing, confusing for teen-me, but long-term helpful), that's not how a lot of therapeutic systems work. Most of them I've experienced are about daily life emotions and coping because, you know, even with a trauma disorder, I still live one day at a time like everyone else & the dealing with the little things prevents snowballing into worse.

54321nought · 12/08/2021 06:40

@FrenchCovidInfo

Taking responsibility and care over physical health is considered normal. Mental health should be exactly the same. Why is mental health less important? Why shouldn't people want to protect and prioritise their mental wellbeing?

I do think that when finally, there is a meaningful push for people to talk openly about mental health with the same importance as physical health, to want to close them down is very hard to understand.

People are being too precious about their "mental health" these days

I don't even know what this even means. Why the speech marks?

People are not taking care of mental health though, that is my point. They are just flashing the "mental health" card, to get what they want, without actually having any understanding or knowledge of what mental health actually means.

It is just being used to mean " I am annoyed - I don't like it when...."

OP posts:
54321nought · 12/08/2021 06:37

@SheilaWilcox

Maybe 30yrs is too long and you're just not as up to date as you should be to cope with modern health expectations? Giving YOU the benefit of the doubt, maybe you had a bad day and were just venting. I'd hate to think that you really think people in the UK have it easy so couldn't possibly be suffering, or at least not in numbers you find acceptable. It took me a long time to seek help for my mental health as I was convinced everyone would think 'what has she got to be depressed about?' it appears some people in the field do.
You don't understand how these things work, do you, training is updated annually, so I have done ALL the training, from 30 years ago to current day, and deliver the training myself.

That's standard - that is how all such training works, all of it, in all such charities and medical settings.

OP posts:
FrenchCovidInfo · 12/08/2021 01:00

Taking responsibility and care over physical health is considered normal. Mental health should be exactly the same. Why is mental health less important? Why shouldn't people want to protect and prioritise their mental wellbeing?

I do think that when finally, there is a meaningful push for people to talk openly about mental health with the same importance as physical health, to want to close them down is very hard to understand.

People are being too precious about their "mental health" these days

I don't even know what this even means. Why the speech marks?

SheilaWilcox · 12/08/2021 00:48

Maybe 30yrs is too long and you're just not as up to date as you should be to cope with modern health expectations?
Giving YOU the benefit of the doubt, maybe you had a bad day and were just venting. I'd hate to think that you really think people in the UK have it easy so couldn't possibly be suffering, or at least not in numbers you find acceptable.
It took me a long time to seek help for my mental health as I was convinced everyone would think 'what has she got to be depressed about?' it appears some people in the field do.

54321nought · 10/08/2021 18:30

@Hobnobsandbroomstick

I didn't ask you to name the charities you work for, I asked why you've chosen to work in the area, and for free, and what training you've had and what your role is. You haven't answered any of that in your reply, just repeated that in your eyes a lot of people are faking it.

I don't understand why you would choose to spend your free time doing something when you sound quite cynical and resentful of people asking for help.

I have chosen to work in this area because I| am a caring person.

I am not detailing the training I have had, because it is too outing, suffice to say, all of it over many decades, and I now deliver it.

I don't resent people asking for help. I am frustrated with the obfuscating, and the consequential misdirection of time and resources

OP posts:
DeeCeeCherry · 10/08/2021 18:26

30 years training and so derisory and sceptical, because on your personally devised scale, they don't appear to be suffering enough for them to count.

I know people who work with Asylum Seekers who are racist af, don't believe anything unless the person is in rags, and maybe not even then, and talk to asylum seekers as if they're nobodies.

If you cared, you wouldn't put up such a post especially as you know it'll encourage scorn of people for not being tough or resilient enough, not pulling themselves together as it were. & It reflects badly on available services as you're implying they can't assess mental health so are gullible, being fooled by clients.

The services out there are poor as it is, made worse by people who lack empathy (but likely sound good on paper so get an inroad) and appear to be drawn towards areas where vulnerable people can be found.

Personal prejudices that lead to bias and pre-judging is common enough in care and health services

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 10/08/2021 18:21

I didn't ask you to name the charities you work for, I asked why you've chosen to work in the area, and for free, and what training you've had and what your role is. You haven't answered any of that in your reply, just repeated that in your eyes a lot of people are faking it.

I don't understand why you would choose to spend your free time doing something when you sound quite cynical and resentful of people asking for help.

54321nought · 10/08/2021 18:15

@Hobnobsandbroomstick

I'm still curious about why you've chosen to volunteer in the area OP?

What is your role and what training have you had?

well, I am not going to name the charities I work for, but I have been involved for around 30 years, and not only have I had 30 years worth of training myself, I have also trained in how to deliver training, and have been delivering it for the last 15 years.

And, as I have said, for any individual in front of me, I take them at their word, and train others to do so as well. \Its only when I sit back and think of the sheer numbers that are talking about having their mental health impacted ( both in charity work, and in normal life) that i know the numbers are wrong.

Its a bit like working with asylum seekers, I know statistically half of the asylum seekers in front of me will be found not to be genuine, but every individual in front of me, I take to be 100% genuine there and then, even though I know overall, many are not

OP posts:
Hobnobsandbroomstick · 10/08/2021 18:10

I'm still curious about why you've chosen to volunteer in the area OP?

What is your role and what training have you had?

WildBluebell · 10/08/2021 17:53

YANBU

People are being too precious about their "mental health" these days.

TractorsAndHeadphones · 10/08/2021 17:47

@Monday26July these are the conditions that are the most easily conflated with normal moods and also the easiest for people to ‘identify’ with

windysocks · 10/08/2021 17:25

Yes it is overused and diminishes the impact for those whi suffer from poor mental health- i heard someone on the news the other day saying, "well with the rise in mental health.." what does that even mean?

Monday26July · 10/08/2021 17:24

@Sagealicious

Oops accidentally pressed too soon...

As I was saying, the thing that bothers me the most is that while it's fantastic mental health/illness is being spoken about and that more and people are trying to fight the stigma, the disorders that are the least stigmatised anxiety and depression are the ones that get spoken about more. Whereas the highly stigmatised illnesses such as schizophrenia are barely mentioned of course I'm not saying that someone with anxiety or depression has never been stigmatised against but it's very different to having something like a psychotic disorder. I've lost friends because "they can't be friends with someone like me" or people have said "am I safe around you"? I've never been violent in my life and I'm way more at risk to myself.

It’s only ever about destigmatising anxiety and depression, you’re absolutely right. Very little work done to destigmatise unglamorous mental health difficulties such as addiction or personality disorders.
Monday26July · 10/08/2021 17:17

YANBU. It can be quite manipulative.

54321nought · 10/08/2021 17:06

Really? Few? Let's add all the grownups with ACEs, all the kids that are being abused and neglected right now, all the people being abused ,raped,beaten by a partner ,friend,family member,boss,stranger, all the people with jobs that can cause trauma (police,health care,armed forces ,firefighters etc). That's without adding in many other variables and circumstances. Still think it's "few"?

exactly, I know all that, I deal with people in these situations very day, and yet the sheer number of people saying they are "having their mental health impacted" vastly outnumber the people who are experiencing/have experienced trauma like this, over 100:1, I would say.

Although in every single individual case, I will give the person the benefit of the doubt, the sheer numbers means they cannot having impacted mental health!

OP posts:
Sagealicious · 10/08/2021 16:17

Oops accidentally pressed too soon...

As I was saying, the thing that bothers me the most is that while it's fantastic mental health/illness is being spoken about and that more and people are trying to fight the stigma, the disorders that are the least stigmatised anxiety and depression are the ones that get spoken about more. Whereas the highly stigmatised illnesses such as schizophrenia are barely mentioned of course I'm not saying that someone with anxiety or depression has never been stigmatised against but it's very different to having something like a psychotic disorder. I've lost friends because "they can't be friends with someone like me" or people have said "am I safe around you"? I've never been violent in my life and I'm way more at risk to myself.

Sagealicious · 10/08/2021 16:08

About 10 years ago I became very mentally ill and was diagnosed with depression. I was put on antidepressants and the depression pretty much went away. However I had other symptoms that kept persisting. I would stay awake for a week and then sleep for 1 hour then go back to not sleeping for a week. I was highly energised, saying and doing very inappropriate things that was way out of character for me, I was convinced that people were trying to steal my thoughts and they were inserting their thoughts into my head so I would say and do things I would never normally do. I was hearing voices and often those voices would scream at me that I had to hurt myself or the world would end so I started self harming. I was convinced that people were after me so I barely left the house. I would scream at people in the street to stop stealing my thoughts. When I tried to talk to anyone about it people would usually say "I saw you smiling the other day so you must be ok" or "just fake it til you make it and you'll be fine"

I did end up telling my doctor about the people who wanted to hurt me and who were stealing my thoughts and he gave me the number for the mental health line (I'm in Australia) I gave them a call, can't remember what I told them but they called me back and told me they had serious concerns and I had a choice I could either volunteer to go into the psych ward or they would send the police to get me. I volunteered. Unfortunately my experience in the hospital was awful. The doctor refused to listen to me. Told me I was depressed because I didn't like myself (I've always liked myself) and when I tried to tell him about the voices he scoffed, stood up and walked out of the room. I was then released from the hospital, still with all the symptoms. I was then readmitted a few weeks later and diagnosed with bipolar, given a prescription at the end of my stay and sent on my way, no counselling, no therapy, nothing. I floundered for several years, in and out of hospital, not being able to work or barely function. Then a couple of years ago I went into hospital again. This time I was listened to, my diagnosis was changed to schizoaffective disorder and I was put on different medication that has made the world of difference. It took nearly 10 years for me to be listened to, properly diagnosed and put on the correct dosage. It should not have taken that long.

Do I get annoyed when it seems like those who are anxious/depressed are getting a lot of help? Yes and no. Yes because I think many (not all) are confusing feeling anxious/depressed with having diagnosable anxiety/depression -we all get anxious but it doesn't mean we have clinical anxiety and they are taking services away from those who really need them. On the other hand I try not to be too annoyed because that person could be in crisis - often times being mentally unwell is the symptom of something else such as abuse or domestic violence and I know how it feels not to be listened to when you are unwell and how traumatic that can be.

The thing that bothers me the most is that while it's

TractorsAndHeadphones · 10/08/2021 15:21

Also to add - of course something seems less serious when everybody appears to have it. If it’s ‘normal’ by default it’s not a problem.

That’s why the concepts of mental illnesses (not normal) and mental health (normal) should be kept very very distinct and clearly separate. You have a mental illness that impacts your mental health.

Other people may have situations that impact their mental health but don’t have any mental illness - which probably pertains to the vast majority. Making a large fuss about these devalues the seriousness of your condition

TractorsAndHeadphones · 10/08/2021 15:19

@jb7445

This is a hard one, because I have really REALLY struggled with getting any help with my mental health. I am 'normal' (whatever that is) 95% of the time. I am well spoken, I hold down a very well paid professional job, have a caring lovely family, I have my own house and a loving husband - all the stuff that creates that veneer of 'normality'.

I also have BPD and C-PTSD. Every once in a while I have a mental health episode that usually ends in being sectioned, or suicide attempts, or attacking my husband, or a mix of the above. I can feel when I am spiraling and I do say to others that things they are doing (mainly my husband tbh) are sending me into an episode. I might look OK at that point but I know full well that I will shortly not be. I have tried to explain this to my husband, my family, my GP, even the panel after being sectioned - but because I seem outwardly fine it's largely ignored.

I would really argue against the idea that mental health services are easily obtained by uttering the magic words of 'mental health'. Certainly not for me. Although I would agree that the words aren't always used accurately (I mean, we've always had drama queens in society!), I would also argue strongly that you, personally, cannot know whether the person involved is truly being affected and is moments away from throwing themselves out of a window (yes I have done this, directly after seeking support from family) or is just exaggerating. Personally, I think we should generally assume the former.

But that’s the thing. ‘Mental health’ has become so routine and used for even passing feelings that nobody believes people like you anymore because of all the time wasters. Also as a pp have mentioned - making it something that ‘everyone suffers from’ and creating the impression that it’s easily fixed means that real, complex conditions which (like physical illnesses) can’t be ‘fixed’, only managed with careful monitoring etc are shoved under the carpet.

Mental illnesses are a serious issue and should be taken as such. The conflation with mental health is detrimental. The pathologisation of normal human reactions is detrimental.

jb7445 · 10/08/2021 14:54

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LolaSmiles · 10/08/2021 13:04

It's certainly replaced being a bit pissed off.
Interesting that during the Olympics it was used to withdraw from an event yet the person was a week later OK to compete in another event
When someone is experiencing a mental block that means they lose their ability to concentrate on where they are in the air, placing them in a highly dangerous situation, I'd say it was fairly sensible to step back and regroup.

Unless of course you're willing to do several rotations on both axis several metres in the air with limited coordination and not being able to think straight? I highly doubt any of the people sticking the boot into Biles for making a call on her safety would be willing to do half of what she does.

Givemebackmylilo · 10/08/2021 12:24

We lose sight of the fact half of the humans in the world don't have these things.Also in the UK, we are living in peace, not war.

Ahhhh you're one of those.

"You access to water darling, you can possibly have any issues"

Take a trip over to the stately homes thread.

Givemebackmylilo · 10/08/2021 12:23

I know you can't judge what another person is going through. Every single individual time I hear it, I give the person the benefit of the doubt.But overall, I just don't think that many people are having their mental health impacted!

Surely you can't have both of these sentences together? They totally contradict each other.

Also, I would strongly advise you stop volunteering for mental health related charities.

ObviousNameChage · 10/08/2021 12:11

And I do have a history of anxiety, panic attacks, depression, not leaving my room or eating or sleeping for weeks on end ,self harm like i mentioned etc. It's just not documented because at first I was too young, and the people that were supposed to care didn't, and then I was too fucked up to be able to do it. It doesn't mean it didn't happen or that they aren't part of my history .