Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Work telling us we wont get opportunity's if we don't show our faces?

431 replies

lovemenomore · 09/08/2021 10:35

Hi all,

Wanted to know if IABU for being peed off/demoralised at this message from the owner of the company I work for.

Basically started the job in Jan & it has been 100% remote due to Covid/office closed etc. Since the restrictions have lifted I have been in and met colleagues but continued to wfh as do 75% of the company. There has been talk of us never having to go back in full time and people can choose what to do. Nothing formal has been announced. If we do want to go in we have had to book in. However the other day this was posted on our internal comms site;

"While booking is now no longer required, we are noting who turns up. Expect those that do to get the best opportunities and progression. It's obvious that being 'front and centre' means you are top of mind. We've always been a company that prioritises what you do and achieve over simple time served, this is just one aspect of that."

What are your thoughts? To me that is saying if you dont come in you will not be given the opportunities....

Lots of the staff arent local and live all over the country/world. A few of my colleagues are miffed but some friends have said all companies are like this?

OP posts:
rottd · 10/08/2021 08:23

And what increments and increases? We haven't had any for years.

Your experience is not everyone's hence why I gave my experience. Anyone not doing their job will not get an increase or a promotion where I have worked. I don't think that's a revolutionary idea!

You can't just sack someone because you don't like them.

Who suggested otherwise? However if someone is not doing their job correctly of course that needs to be managed.

RampantIvy · 10/08/2021 08:20

@rottd you still can't change someone's basic personality. There are difficult people in all walks of life. You only need to read mumsnet to know that. You can't just sack someone because you don't like them. They weren't committing sackable offences. The bully was the type who "knew her rights". Lockdown made it easy to end her employment

And what increments and increases? We haven't had any for years.

rottd · 10/08/2021 08:10

Yes, they were managed, but they didn't change their behaviour in spite of being pulled up on it several times when we were office based.

That's bad management though! Everywhere I've worked you have performance reviews & appraisals & these link to any increment or increase

Ceara · 10/08/2021 08:04

This is such a depressing thread.

I pointed out that a policy of rewarding office attendance with the good projects and the best opportunities will disproportionately impact women (or anyone with caring responsibilities but that includes far more women than men) and people with disabilities. I got jumped on with a load of "oh there's always one!" type comments.

Is it that hard to imagine why parents, carers and people with disabilities particularly value being able to WFH?

Especially in the SE where commutes of 1-2 hours each way into London are very normal (and nothing to do with lockdown relocations)?

And other people will value the work life balance that WFH or (in most cases) hybrid working brings.

I WFH pre-pandemic, with 1 day/week in the office and 3 from home. I have a long commute, a school aged child with SEN and a husband with a chronic pain condition. He is also mostly WFH, full time and managing others.

WFH allows me to continue to do the professional, London-based job that I am good at and enjoy. It keeps me and my skills in the workforce. It's as simple as that. In my husband's case, most of his energy and time goes on work and evenings/weekends are for resting and recovering to be fit for work next day, but not commuting and being in an environment that's fully adapted for him enables us to salvage a little bit of quality of life and family time a couple of days a week if we are lucky.

As a p/t, mostly WFH member of the team I know the pre-pandemic reality and downsides of reduced visibility, and the ignorant assumptions that you're less productive. (Which is nonsense - I work longer and get more done on at home days and I was doing 60 hour weeks at the height of the pandemic as a part timer.) I really thought the pandemic would be a turning point, as so many people experienced WFH for the first time and learned that, even if it didn't suit them best personally for the long term, it is perfectly possible to do an excellent job mostly remotely, and as organisations sorted the tech and learnt the skills. I thought there would be more flexibility, more enlightened policies and improved connectedness regardless of location, as we emerged from Covid restrictions.

Reading this thread it feels like we've gone backwards not forwards. I could cry.

RampantIvy · 10/08/2021 08:03

Yes, they were managed, but they didn't change their behaviour in spite of being pulled up on it several times when we were office based. It took lockdown for things to change. Over a year later we are still finding work that the micromanaged employee didn't complete.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 10/08/2021 08:01

@VladmirsPoutine

This is terrible. WFH has been a godsend for so many people!! For example if you have kids, have disabilities, are an ethnic minority! The only reason they want people back in the office is pressure from middle managers whose job description involves annoying junior members of staff and having pointless meetings; and also the pressure from commercial landlords.
What do you mean if you are an ethnic minority?
ExpressDelivery · 10/08/2021 08:01

Out of interest
What was she like before WFH?

In the office she's not always the smartest, but perfectly acceptable business attire for the environment. Professional and good at the technical aspects of her job, not always great at meeting deadlines, easily distracted. I'd imagine she's not great at applying herself wfh (neither am I TBH)

rottd · 10/08/2021 07:58

Or the employee is a piss taker, and no amount of good management is going to change that.*

You still have to manage them, see below

*Fortunately the team member in our team who needed to be micromanaged found another job and left, and the bully who used to intimidate other team members was furloughed straight away, then made redundant.

Marmitemarinaded · 10/08/2021 07:57

@ExpressDelivery

Last summer one of our senior staff members attended a team meeting in her bikini!
Out of interest What was she like before WFH?
rottd · 10/08/2021 07:57

@ActonSquirrel I don't think your workplace experience sounds normal & as pp pointed out why are the staff not being managed?

RampantIvy · 10/08/2021 07:56

My point being that if people are behaving poorly, and are continuing to be able to do so despite being told otherwise, then there are probably very crap managers involved.

Or the employee is a piss taker, and no amount of good management is going to change that. Fortunately the team member in our team who needed to be micromanaged found another job and left, and the bully who used to intimidate other team members was furloughed straight away, then made redundant.

rottd · 10/08/2021 07:56

My post makes it clear that the baby was in her lap as she had a screaming fit as she didn't fancy nanny at that point. Nanny = childcare so so it wasn't in lcokdown

So she could have gone to work because the office was open but instead chose to wfh?

rottd · 10/08/2021 07:54

So what will be the underlying recession driver?

I think there will be economic fallout from increased remote working & furlough ending. The NHS desperately needs more investment & income taxes have been raised by stealth.

People have been saying the housing bubble is about to burst for decades.

In my part of London house prices have been pretty stagnant since Brexit & I think they will continue to stagnant. Equity drives so much of the housing market. And we don't know if interest rates will rise.

I'm not sure if we will have a recession but I think we are in for a tough time & will have less disposable income.

ExpressDelivery · 10/08/2021 07:50

Last summer one of our senior staff members attended a team meeting in her bikini!

JassyRadlett · 10/08/2021 07:49

I don't know. I'm not going to be privvy to that and they refuse to come to the office so I can't very well ask them

My point being that if people are behaving poorly, and are continuing to be able to do so despite being told otherwise, then there are probably very crap managers involved.

ActonSquirrel · 10/08/2021 07:47

@JassyRadlett

Also our lot had to be told it was disrespectful to have your camera switched off during a monthly meeting. So the same offenders started telephoning into the zoom instead audio only.

What did their managers do?

I don't know. I'm not going to be privvy to that and they refuse to come to the office so I can't very well ask them
ActonSquirrel · 10/08/2021 07:46

@rottd

One of my colleagues did a meeting with her 1 year old in her lap and a tracksuit on. She didn't fancy nanny at that and had a screaming fit.

You wouldn't be permitted to do that at the office so I don't see why it's allowed wfh. It does happen

Was this during a lockdown? It's not normal to work & have your dc around you but it's not normal for childcare settings & schools to be closed.

My post makes it clear that the baby was in her lap as she had a screaming fit as she didn't fancy nanny at that point. Nanny = childcare so so it wasn't in lcokdown
JassyRadlett · 10/08/2021 07:45

Also our lot had to be told it was disrespectful to have your camera switched off during a monthly meeting. So the same offenders started telephoning into the zoom instead audio only.

What did their managers do?

rottd · 10/08/2021 07:44

One of my colleagues did a meeting with her 1 year old in her lap and a tracksuit on. She didn't fancy nanny at that and had a screaming fit.

You wouldn't be permitted to do that at the office so I don't see why it's allowed wfh. It does happen

Was this during a lockdown? It's not normal to work & have your dc around you but it's not normal for childcare settings & schools to be closed.

ExpressDelivery · 10/08/2021 07:44

I do think wfh once everything's back to normal will be different to what some people are expecting. Or at least it should be.

During lockdown we had meetings "attended" by all manner of children and pets. It was all a bit cute and "we're all in this together" working at the kitchen table, but surely you can only wfh in normal circumstances if you have a private space and childcare?

JassyRadlett · 10/08/2021 07:44

Not being in possession of a functioning crystal ball, strangely I can’t put a date on it. But having lived through five recessions, I’m perfectly able to recognise the perfect economic storm that makes one inevitable. The UK is holding the highest level of debt since 1945, the housing market is a huge bubble, businesses are going bust, as soon as furlough ends unemployment will soar - frankly if there wasn’t a huge recession it would be miraculous.

So what will be the underlying recession driver? And why do you think the IMF has it so wrong?

National debt isn’t an inherent driver of recession. People have been saying the housing bubble is about to burst for decades. There are lower levels of household debt/higher levels of savings than we’ve had in quite a while. Demand remains fairly strong. We have some Brexit fundamentals that could fuck things up, sure, and I wouldn’t be massively surprised by that. But I’m not clear that the conditions currently exist for a recession equivalent to or bigger than 2008 when you look at government policy direction. Housing doesn’t look that shaky - LTV on mortgages is lower than previously and crucially the economic impacts on Covid are (horribly) disproportionately falling on those less likely to be home owners.

Trying to apply past experience to the current situation is unlikely to be very illuminating - we’ve never experienced this kind of artificial shutdown of an economy. The territory is pretty uncharted and I think a year ago I would have agreed with you; now I’m not so sure.

Hekatestorch · 10/08/2021 07:42

I don't work in Pj's. Mainly because my PJ'S are shorts and a vest top. I don't want to spend all day in them.

I do, do team meetings in hoodie or t-shirts. But we had a relaxed office dress code before. If a meeting is a very senior one or with outside people, I would of course put 'business wear' on.

As would my team. I haven't ever had to monitor what people wear.

Our company offered to furlough anyone, who was trying to juggle childcare and work, but did say you couldn't be in sole charge of young children and work. Because you couldn't work properly or wouldn't be able to supervise the children properly. But, as I said, they would furlough you. Or you could, if you were able, to work flexible hours.

Then a senior manager went on a leadership call with his one year old sat on his knee and there was a big kick off. This was at the start. Never happened again. That was one of the managers whose poor performance was highlighted, but wfh. Not just this incident either.

But in the office he was pulled on occasion occasion not thinking policy applied to him. This attitude wasn't just because he was wfh. It was just how he was.

rottd · 10/08/2021 07:41

I think remote working is a good thing but there will be fallout to all the auxiliary businesses that support the commute to office lifestyle. Some will adapt but it's been a very fast change & obviously public transport will likely see increased fares & service reductions.

ActonSquirrel · 10/08/2021 07:41

Also our lot had to be told it was disrespectful to have your camera switched off during a monthly meeting. So the same offenders started telephoning into the zoom instead audio only.

It's just pathetic so they can hide what they're really doing

WeAreTheHeroes · 10/08/2021 07:38

Without a clear message from the company as to their expectations of how much people will be in the office, the barbed statement is useless. It also sounds really childish.

Swipe left for the next trending thread