Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Work telling us we wont get opportunity's if we don't show our faces?

431 replies

lovemenomore · 09/08/2021 10:35

Hi all,

Wanted to know if IABU for being peed off/demoralised at this message from the owner of the company I work for.

Basically started the job in Jan & it has been 100% remote due to Covid/office closed etc. Since the restrictions have lifted I have been in and met colleagues but continued to wfh as do 75% of the company. There has been talk of us never having to go back in full time and people can choose what to do. Nothing formal has been announced. If we do want to go in we have had to book in. However the other day this was posted on our internal comms site;

"While booking is now no longer required, we are noting who turns up. Expect those that do to get the best opportunities and progression. It's obvious that being 'front and centre' means you are top of mind. We've always been a company that prioritises what you do and achieve over simple time served, this is just one aspect of that."

What are your thoughts? To me that is saying if you dont come in you will not be given the opportunities....

Lots of the staff arent local and live all over the country/world. A few of my colleagues are miffed but some friends have said all companies are like this?

OP posts:
Foxyloxy1plus1 · 09/08/2021 11:52

I assumed the phrase about ‘time served’ was meant to indicate that it wasn’t a question of how long you’d been with the company, but about how effective your work is, even if you’ve been there only a short time. Reading the comments, it seems I was wrong.

On a related note, I heard this morning, that some organisations are considering pay cuts for those who are wholly working from home. I guess that if you worked in London and accepted a London salary and then moved much further away, where things are less expensive and there are no commuting costs, then your costs are less.

Mantlemoose · 09/08/2021 11:51

My company hasn't said this but surely it doesn't come as any surprise?

If I'm working with someone or doing/attending a presentation you create a connection when it's in person, not over the internet. When the boss sticks her / his head in the office just because they're passing the door, it's the person who is sitting at their desk they see, not something prearranged via the internet. It's that 30 second good morning when you pass the receptionist at the front desk.

"This is terrible. WFH has been a godsend for so many people!! For example if you have kids, have disabilities, are an ethnic minority!" You're paid to work, not look after your kids. Your hours don't work for you - request different hours or get a different job. Your workplace should have made alterations for your disability - assuming you were previously in the workplace with your disability these must have been in place so what's different now (I do have a disability so perfectly aware of the issues). No idea what an ethnic minority will gain wfh!

Honestly, yes there needs to be work life balance but if your current job and employer doesn't suit your life then find something else.

PegasusReturns · 09/08/2021 11:50

Besides anything else your employer have told you clearly what success looks like at your organisation and it involves showing up.

You might not be interested in progression. And that’s fine, plenty of people are not. But if you are you now know what is required.

Ceara · 09/08/2021 11:49

Some of those women, or people with disabilities, will have been working flexibly/from home pre-Covid too.

I don't think it's terribly sensible, or good management, or good for diversity and inclusion, as an employer to say those who are physically in the room will get the good projects and the promotions.

PegasusReturns · 09/08/2021 11:45

Despite all the objections I see on these types of thread I suspect there is a strong correlation between those that physically show up and those whose work product is superior.

There’ll always be exceptions, but success includes myriad factors beyond being able to meet your objectives. Being seen to pull your weight; being trustworthy and likeable; stepping up in others absence; willingness to go above and beyond.

MurielSpriggs · 09/08/2021 11:45

[quote VladmirsPoutine]@MurielSpriggs Office-based micro/macro-aggressions. I'm Black/mixed race and honestly could write a book about the struggles of being Black in the workplace. WFH is bloody amazing!!

I think in the end most companies will have to go with a hybrid approach. WFH is just far too popular to be completely eradicated.[/quote]
Ok, thanks @VladmirsPoutine, this had not occurred to me, white privilege in action!

Dongdingdong · 09/08/2021 11:45

I don't know what the issue is here - they're just being honest. It's obvious that if you're never in the office and other people are, you will get forgotten about pretty quickly.

MurielSpriggs · 09/08/2021 11:40

Indirect discrimination? This policy will disproportionately disadvantage women and those with disabilities...

Not really - everyone can go in - like they did before Covid so if they choose to stay home that is their own choice entirely.

It might not be that simple, but it's a good question. Almost certainly coming soon to an Employment Appeal Tribunal near you!

Staffholidayclubrep · 09/08/2021 11:39

Different businesses will take different approach to wfh and hybrid models. You are not chained to a business so if you don’t like it apply for a position in another company.

MorrisZapp · 09/08/2021 11:39

Our company have specified no wfh at all now unless arranged directly with the partners.

Lots of companies don't thrive with off site working, they have every right to expect staff to be in the office every day unless there's a demonstrable reason why they can't come in.

EBearhug · 09/08/2021 11:36

It wouldn't fly with us. We have teams and departments split across different offices, even different countries. Being able to collaborate via online tools is key. We aren't often all physically present together (though pre-pandemic, they'd try for once a year,) but if you can't manage and notice people who aren't physically in the same place as you, you don't have enough skills to be a manager here.

There are other ways of being noticed than just turning up to sit at a desk - in fact, sitting at a desk has little correlation with how good someone is at their job.

ufucoffee · 09/08/2021 11:36

You can't have it all ways. Work from home because you fancy it and it's easier for you, or go to work, be visible and get a chance of progressing. The choice is yours.

mewkins · 09/08/2021 11:33

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

I think they need to improve their communication to be honest. It isnt clear from what you've said, what they expect in terms of attendance. Eg lots of companies are saying minimum of x days per week or month in the office. They have stayed silent and then said it may affect your career if you don't do x....why not just be up front and create a proper policy on office attendance so people are clear. What did you agree when you started? As it was always clear covid isnt going to be around for ever. What's your contract, are you home or office based or hybrid?
Yes. Why not just say we expect you to be in the office xx days per month in order to maintain team morale or whatever? Oh, they can't because some people were employed overseas and will have no chance of even leaving their country. So on the one hand it will foster a weird competitiveness of how many time you can show your face at the office, while those overseas become demotivated knowing that however hard they work they will probably still be overlooked for promotion.
Monday26July · 09/08/2021 11:31

I mean, I don't have an issue with the point they're making (that they'd like people back in even if they're not forcing it), but the message in general would piss me off. It's very passive aggressive. They're basically saying we would like to make you come in, but as we can't do that we're going to pretend that it's your choice but really here are the consequences if you don't... it's treating you all like children. And their sentence about valuing what you achieve over time served has literally nothing to do with the preceding information.

Poor.

alltheemptyfields · 09/08/2021 11:27

Or they've realised that there is a need to come into the office for collaboration/training/mentoring type/team building activities and that these things can't be measured purely by "productivity".

we always had to plan and schedule training days, team building activities... even when people were in the office, you just don't randomly tell people to pop in a meeting room or to go to another building/city!

WFH is no different. You can plan and organise similar.

PizzaCrust · 09/08/2021 11:26

It’s a harsh reality. Networking is important within a company (certainly in my industry it is, anyway). You certainly want to be known by the higher ups and not just a faceless name on a rota.

Obviously, though, they still should take performance and the like into account. It would be utterly daft to promote Dave over Andrew when Andrew sells more/has better feedback/has more experience.

But, yes. For anyone wanting to progress you’ll have to put yourself out there more and make more effort. If that means coming into the office regularly, so be it. If you’re happy in your role and don’t care to progress and climb the ladder, then WFH as you have been and leave it at that.

alltheemptyfields · 09/08/2021 11:24

@VeryLongBeeeep

If you are experienced and just work from home and refuse to work as part of a team that’s kind of selfish and you are only performing one aspect of your job.

I've done more coaching and mentoring since WFH 75% of the time than I did when I was office-based (to the extent that I won one of our internal awards for it fairly recently) because I'm dragged into far fewer pointless meetings, and thanks to modern technology it's possible to share screens, have collaborative online work spaces, video calls etc.

I agree!

We recruited a (surprising) number of people since the first lockdown, including many graduates with no experience.

It worked very well.

The ones who said it was weird was the more experienced ones, quitting a job on a Friday (and logging out) and logging in a new place the Monday.

Whatever happens, I highly recommend WFH on your very first week. Instead of being bombarded with procedures, names, and waffle, you have set meetings to be introduced to various people and department, it makes it so much easier to understand and remember immediately who is who.

SeasonFinale · 09/08/2021 11:21

@Ceara

Indirect discrimination? This policy will disproportionately disadvantage women and those with disabilities...
Not really - everyone can go in - like they did before Covid so if they choose to stay home that is their own choice entirely.
Heartshapedrocks · 09/08/2021 11:20

It's weird how many people are championing those who really struggled with working from an office before this, their voices were quite quiet until they decided they wanted to stay working from home also, and now use them to try and justify it. Funny that, definitely no ulterior motive there is there.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 09/08/2021 11:14

I think they need to improve their communication to be honest. It isnt clear from what you've said, what they expect in terms of attendance. Eg lots of companies are saying minimum of x days per week or month in the office. They have stayed silent and then said it may affect your career if you don't do x....why not just be up front and create a proper policy on office attendance so people are clear. What did you agree when you started? As it was always clear covid isnt going to be around for ever. What's your contract, are you home or office based or hybrid?

Lavender24 · 09/08/2021 11:13

I think it's fair enough tbh.

VeryLongBeeeep · 09/08/2021 11:11

If you are experienced and just work from home and refuse to work as part of a team that’s kind of selfish and you are only performing one aspect of your job.

I've done more coaching and mentoring since WFH 75% of the time than I did when I was office-based (to the extent that I won one of our internal awards for it fairly recently) because I'm dragged into far fewer pointless meetings, and thanks to modern technology it's possible to share screens, have collaborative online work spaces, video calls etc.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 09/08/2021 11:07

It smacks of a company/management saying "We'll only pay attention to those who dance for our notice" which is lazy management really.

You can be good at your job, and noticeably so, without having to sit in front of someone.

I can see where the company are coming from but it still comes across as a bit off, really.

DameFanny · 09/08/2021 11:07

@Cuddlyrottweiler

They'll favour the people who go above whats required and develop stronger relationships with collegues/management for promotions. Makes sense. It's always been the case, don't know why they're even telling you.
People who develop stronger relationships with colleagues and management are most often the same gender/class/colour/nationality as those colleagues and management, where those relationships are built on water cooler type interactions. Yet another way to reinforce white males as a norm.
UserStillatLarge · 09/08/2021 11:07

So they've basically told you they don't care as much for your productivity as they do for seeing you take up space.

Or they've realised that there is a need to come into the office for collaboration/training/mentoring type/team building activities and that these things can't be measured purely by "productivity".

If people are doing exactly the same thing in the office that they would do at home, then I'd agree you had a point.