Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think contribution to child should be proportional to income?

81 replies

Ulltiger · 09/08/2021 09:39

Hello all, I'm looking for advice and thoughts on the following scenario, me and my ex share care of our son 50/50. Despite her earning at least 3 times what I do (£75k last I knew and she's got another job since then, so likely more) she expects everything split 50/50 cost wise. The latest thing being school meals when he starts back in September. Am I unreasonable to think a more equitable solution would be for it to be even losely proportionate to income?

Not that im counting it into anything but for context she has a partner and I don't, so household incomes are vastly different. Also if relevant a little background, when we were together at one point we had a similar wage, she then did a degree, which I supported her in, running the household, looking after our son (feeding, getting ready, dropping off/picking up from nursery, bathing etc) so she could focus on that. After that her career took off, she worked away a lot, so again I was doing all of the above.
Even now I'm the one who regularly reads with him and helps him do his homework.
I also administer the childcare account, his swimming lessons etc and she's proposing I also administer the school meal account, which I feel almost obliged to do because if I don't our child will probably not eat! That's not sour grapes on my part, just a fact :-)

OP posts:
Aliceinunderland · 09/08/2021 10:24

Do you pay maintenance? If not, everything else is irrelevant. You and your ex partner are each 50% responsible for your child.

sofiegiraffe · 09/08/2021 10:19

@mewkins

Yes if I knew you are earning 25k vs. me on 75k then I would suck up more of the expenses like school dinners. I know some people wouldn't and it would obviously be affected by things like whether you still had a decent coparenting relationship but I wouldn't want to see my ex partner struggle to afford stuff like trips swimming, etc just because I was insisting on costs being split straight down the middle while I could well afford to take on more of the costs.
This is exactly why I don't insist on 50/50 costs.
mewkins · 09/08/2021 10:17

Yes if I knew you are earning 25k vs. me on 75k then I would suck up more of the expenses like school dinners. I know some people wouldn't and it would obviously be affected by things like whether you still had a decent coparenting relationship but I wouldn't want to see my ex partner struggle to afford stuff like trips swimming, etc just because I was insisting on costs being split straight down the middle while I could well afford to take on more of the costs.

honeylulu · 09/08/2021 10:08

If it's 50/50 shared care then it should be 50/50 shared expenses, sorry.

You're no longer a couple and you are no longer supporting/ enabling her career.

You don't say if you were married but if so your domestic contribution should have been reflected in how the joint assets were divided on divorce. If you weren't married, bad luck. Marriage is a way of protecting the lower earning partner who makes career sacrifices for the family.

The only way she will pay more is if you have more than 50% care in which case she will pay you CM. Is that an option?

sofiegiraffe · 09/08/2021 09:59

I earn more than my ex partner. I also have a partner who earns similar to me whereas my ex is single, so our household income is a lot higher. I don't expect 50/50 split - I recognise that I'm in a stronger financial position so I provide more, eg I pay for all school uniforms, school trips, school dinners, school buses, and my daughter's mobile phone contract (she's a teenager). We don't have 50/50 shared care though - I'm the resident parent (she stays with her dad EOW and half of school holidays), so he pays me maintenance. But no, I don't insist on 50/50 of all costs.

Auntienumber8 · 09/08/2021 09:46

Her having a partner is completely irrelevant.
Really 50/50 shared expenses should be just that. It’s just that her earning position and due to sharing expenses means she is far better off than you. It may stick in your throat a bit but do not dwell on it otherwise bitterness will consume you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread