Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think contribution to child should be proportional to income?

81 replies

Ulltiger · 09/08/2021 09:39

Hello all, I'm looking for advice and thoughts on the following scenario, me and my ex share care of our son 50/50. Despite her earning at least 3 times what I do (£75k last I knew and she's got another job since then, so likely more) she expects everything split 50/50 cost wise. The latest thing being school meals when he starts back in September. Am I unreasonable to think a more equitable solution would be for it to be even losely proportionate to income?

Not that im counting it into anything but for context she has a partner and I don't, so household incomes are vastly different. Also if relevant a little background, when we were together at one point we had a similar wage, she then did a degree, which I supported her in, running the household, looking after our son (feeding, getting ready, dropping off/picking up from nursery, bathing etc) so she could focus on that. After that her career took off, she worked away a lot, so again I was doing all of the above.
Even now I'm the one who regularly reads with him and helps him do his homework.
I also administer the childcare account, his swimming lessons etc and she's proposing I also administer the school meal account, which I feel almost obliged to do because if I don't our child will probably not eat! That's not sour grapes on my part, just a fact :-)

OP posts:
pianolessons1 · 09/08/2021 12:01

Your solicitor should have addressed that during the divorce. If they didn't, you may have a claim against them.

sofiegiraffe · 09/08/2021 11:57

My point I guess to those saying costs should be 50/50 is that she's in the stronger financial position now, because I helped enable her to be there during our marriage, if I hadn't it'd be more of an even footing now. Does that count for anything, or not? I'm guessing not

It does when a woman posts about being your situation. I'm guessing you'll (wrongly) get different responses simply due to your sex.

I agree entirely with you. Like I say, I earn more than my ex and always have done, so my relative contribution to our child's upbringing reflects that disparity. Over the years, if I'd insisted on 50/50 for all costs, there are many things I'd have had to say to my daughter sorry you can't do that school trip / activity / hobby etc because your dad can't afford to pay half. Why would I do that? If I've got the affordability and it would enhance her life in some way, then I'll pay for it. Makes no difference to her which proportion is coming from which parent.

Ulltiger · 09/08/2021 11:48

@ReginaGeorgeIsAFuglySlut

Wow I am from Australia and things are quite different here, unless you have a private maintenance agreement. If you collect through the child support agency both parents income and care percentage are taken in to account when deciding on the cost of things. This is to maintain the child's standard of living as best it can. It is not perfect but seems a lot better for the kids.
This seems a much fairer way of dividing things and ensuring a more balanced experience for the child(ren) moving forwards in life, which is surely the most important thing here, is it not?

I'll be honest I guess I'm a little surprised at how many people are very insistent that everything should be 50/50 regardless of any circumstances but I guess that's why I posted, to get a feeling for what is the norm out there in similar situations.
Also I wasn't wishing to imply that her new partners income should be included in anything, I'm not that naive to think it would be, it was just added for context.

For additional context we were married but split was done more or less 50/50 upon divorce with little, to no, recognition of the fact that I effectively gave up my career to look after our son whilst she progressed hers. That was partly down to me wanting to extricate myself from an awful situation and put it all behind me as soon as possible. In hindsight foolish of me to agree to that and maybe in some way I'm looking to redress that a little now. Which I'm sure will be a red rag to a bull for some ;-)
My point I guess to those saying costs should be 50/50 is that she's in the stronger financial position now, because I helped enable her to be there during our marriage, if I hadn't it'd be more of an even footing now. Does that count for anything, or not? I'm guessing not :-)

OP posts:
Kithic · 09/08/2021 11:39

@Aliceinunderland

Do you pay maintenance? If not, everything else is irrelevant. You and your ex partner are each 50% responsible for your child.
If the child is 50 50 then why would op pay maintenance?
NoSquirrels · 09/08/2021 11:30

Two parents equally responsible for the children they have together.

50-50 care therefore equals 50-50 costs.

It might be nice if your ex picked up more of the incidental stuff to help you out- but they’re under no obligation to.

Splitting costs proportional to income would be riddled with pitfalls (one person earns less but has only 1 DC, the other earns more but went on to have more DC etc).

You had a child together, you now pay, support and raise the child together. That’s fair.

Getawaywithit · 09/08/2021 11:24

you must cover half of the basic costs e.g. uniform, shoes plus their costs the days the child is with you e.g. school dinners, childcare

Must?

Says who? There is no legislation for this. Neither parent can be compelled to pay anything. I have split time with my ex on a 50/50 basis and paid 100% of childcare, uniforms, haircuts, shoes, school lunches etc etc etc .

Way too many people with absolutely no clue.

NothingIsWrong · 09/08/2021 11:21

Could you ask her to administer the school meals account and just send a packed lunch on the days he's with you? I find packed lunches to be significantly cheaper - mine have school dinners because they like them and it is much easier for me, but I can definitely make 5 lunches a week for less than the £11.50 the school ones cost.

RedMarauder · 09/08/2021 11:19

OP if you can't afford the 50/50 cost split for extras like swimming lessons then you need to say so. However if you do, you can only talk about the other parent's income not their partner's. The partner's earning are nothing to do with your child.

However you must cover half of the basic costs e.g. uniform, shoes plus their costs the days the child is with you e.g. school dinners, childcare.

Isababybel · 09/08/2021 11:18

Nope, 50/50.

Getawaywithit · 09/08/2021 11:17

I agree, OP. It’s totally unreasonable that where there is a discrepancy in income, both parents are paying the same. It should be in proportion. Unfortunately, this forum thinks 50/50 is the only acceptable way to bring up a child post-separation. I really don’t understand why. Makes no logical sense.

maryberryslayers · 09/08/2021 11:12

YABVU, stop trying to get out of paying for your own child. 50/50 care equals 50/50 split of costs. It's completely irrelevant what she, or her partner, earn. Why shouldn't you do the admin for 3 things in his life, you are his parent.

sofiegiraffe · 09/08/2021 11:11

I can't understand why anyone would want there kids to experience such disparity depending on which parent they are staying with.

Me neither

MiddleParking · 09/08/2021 11:00

Am I unreasonable to think a more equitable solution would be for it to be even losely proportionate to income?

The thing about separating from a partner and having 50/50 care is that there’s no expectation of an ‘equitable solution’ as far as your disposable income goes. Lots of the information you’ve given in your post sounds like things that would have been legally recognised had you been married, but sounds like you weren’t - like lots of women do, you’re now seeing the consequences of that. I can understand the argument that you’d have more money available for things for the kids if she contributed more to the existent costs, but if I was her my response would be okay, as long as every penny you reduce your contribution by goes towards things to directly benefit the children.

mewkins · 09/08/2021 10:58

@ReginaGeorgeIsAFuglySlut

Wow I am from Australia and things are quite different here, unless you have a private maintenance agreement. If you collect through the child support agency both parents income and care percentage are taken in to account when deciding on the cost of things. This is to maintain the child's standard of living as best it can. It is not perfect but seems a lot better for the kids.
This makes sense. I can't understand why anyone would want there kids to experience such disparity depending on which parent they are staying with.

Also I think some people who earn quite a lot more than 25k a year don't really understand that every month will feel like a juggle of budgets etc. He won't be 'maintaining a lifestyle', more like hoping another bill doesn't come in to wipe out any buffer he has. He should get to decide whether to provide a cheaper packed lunch. As many families get to decide.

Herja · 09/08/2021 10:51

I think it's fair enough. I have my DC 60/40 in my favour. ExH would rather 50/50 (the children would firmly not, so I don't back down), as such I claim no maintenance (no maintenance is a major reason in his desire for 50/50 so this stops court...).

I am a student on student finance. He has a professional role and a very well paid partner. Their household income is around 8x mine. I pay for everything on my days, he pays for everything on his days. Uniform is split to the closest quid. School shoes we take in turns. Extra curriculars he picks he pays for, mine I pay for. Childcare he needs, he pays for and vice versa.

I make bloody sure that it is a pretty even split, but if he is paying half (or near half), then I really don't see it as an issue. It's my choice to be a low incomed student, my choice to have the kids with me despite a low income, my choice to be the only adult in my household and my choice how I spend my cash. His choices are his and I don't see why either of us should benefit from the other.

ReginaGeorgeIsAFuglySlut · 09/08/2021 10:49

Wow I am from Australia and things are quite different here, unless you have a private maintenance agreement. If you collect through the child support agency both parents income and care percentage are taken in to account when deciding on the cost of things. This is to maintain the child's standard of living as best it can. It is not perfect but seems a lot better for the kids.

Outbutnotoutout · 09/08/2021 10:45

I guess the children belong to you both 50/50, you have them 50/50, so all finances should be split 50/50.

That said if I earnt a lot more, I would suck up more of the costs

Tinkerbellfluffyboots79 · 09/08/2021 10:44

You administer the school meals account? - I do that too. I check what days they (x3 children) want dinners and I pay for it it’s not difficult it takes 5 minutes once a week. Same for swimming etc. My ex and I pay 50:50 for all children’s expenses. You’d be paying the same if you lived together so it makes little difference what she earns. I earn less than my ex. I went part time as childcare doesn’t operate at our shift pattern times but I still pay the same to make sure they have what they need sometimes you do just have to go without.

DaisyWaldron · 09/08/2021 10:42

Suggest that she pays for all school meals when your son is with her and that he has packed lunches when he is with you.

I think if there is 50/50 care and a disparity of income, then the better off parent doesn't get to decide both to split all costs 50/50 AND what amount of money to spend. If you want to split costs equally, the costs have to be within the lower earner's budget.

Cuddlyrottweiler · 09/08/2021 10:38

You're both equal amounts his parents so you should be spending the same on him. You may have supported her while you were together but You're not anymore and if you didn't have a kid you'd have lost that contribution anyway. You need to draw a line between parenting and your relationship

tiredofthisshit21 · 09/08/2021 10:37

You're basically expecting your partner to subsidise your lifestyle because she has a better job. Her partner is irrelevant (and may have their own kids to support anyway?) I remarried but I don't expect my husband to pay anything towards my child.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 09/08/2021 10:31

I see both sides tbh- but I tend to come down on the side 50/50 care is 50/50 costs, Maintenace is a separate issue -8l if you were married when you put your earning potential on the back burner to care for the child then that I assume should be compensated in the split

Dragon50 · 09/08/2021 10:29

I think that’s fair enough.

Maybe point out that you’d like to do more with DC and would if a earnings split was taken into account?

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 09/08/2021 10:29

50/50 shared care so 50/50 on costs is fair regardless of income. Both parents are equally responsible not just the one with the better career.

SimonJT · 09/08/2021 10:27

If you were married your career sacrifice would have been taken into account during the divorce.

Unless incomes are wildly different it should be 50/50 and a new partners income shouldn’t be taken into account, they’re not the parent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread