Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prescription charges for over 60s

293 replies

herewegogc · 09/08/2021 06:53

Just found out that there is a government consultation going on about this. The aim is to raise the age for free prescriptions to the state pension age. Ends on 1st September. AIBU to be unhappy that this is being done by stealth? Or have I missed the massive publicity campaign? Fill in the consultation here: www.gov.uk/government/consultations/aligning-the-upper-age-for-nhs-prescription-charge-exemptions-with-the-state-pension-age

OP posts:
foxandbee · 09/08/2021 08:55

That is a daft idea ActonSquirrel. The admin costs of mean testing everyone would be colossal.

senua · 09/08/2021 08:55

it seems grossly unfair that some people get things free by dint of age that can well afford them.
We get them "by dint of age" because of that age. I take two tablets a day; DH takes seven. Neither of us took anything until we were around the 50 y.o. mark. Just because the Government has raised the pension age it doesn't mean that our bodies have stopped the natural ageing process.

All those saying that people of working age should pay for prescriptions: do you pay for contraceptives?

StoneofDestiny · 09/08/2021 08:53

I pay for my prescriptions by prepayment and see no problem with this. I also see no problem with older people who are in the financial position to do so paying for theirs

Same thing could be said about any age group or any benefit - like Child Benefit, Maternity Care etc.

Pazuzu · 09/08/2021 08:52

There's no such thing as free. Someone pays for it. Either directly through tax, or higher prices through other peoples/companies taxes. It's also very very easy for politicians to give away other peoples money.

We have a growing and aging population and decisions have to be made accordingly.

I pay for my prescriptions by prepayment and see no problem with this. I also see no problem with older people who are in the financial position to do so paying for theirs.

ActonSquirrel · 09/08/2021 08:51

@LemonRoses

I cannot see any reason to not charge over sixties who are on good incomes. I despise the Tories but a working sixty year old is probably better off than a younger person.
I can't see any reason not to charge the children of wealthy parents for their prescriptions.

I can't see why we give all pregnant women free prescriptions regardless of income.

I'd love to see means testing for all. I say that as someone who wouldn't qualify for free prescriptions for children etc if they did.

StoneofDestiny · 09/08/2021 08:51

the money saved could go towards education or really work towards sink estates in terms of education, stock food banks who heavily rely on charity & the kindnesses of supermarkets who have to pay staff who sort out the donations

But the money saved wouldn't - never does!.

Binnaggy · 09/08/2021 08:51

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Fifthtimelucky · 09/08/2021 08:51

It seems sensible to me and I am 60.

ittakes2 · 09/08/2021 08:50

I can't comment on the over 60s but the UK does have in my opinion some pockets of unnecessary free prescriptions. I have ceoliac's disease and I am therefore eligible for free gluten free biscuits, bread, pasta etc if I want it. Really unhealthy options though like those made from white gluten-free flour and no nutrition (unless its changed since I last looked at the options). I totally get gluten-free bread is more expensive and I completely support the idea of people who can't afford it accessing this service but a) why does the tax payer have to pay for unhealthy biscuits...they are not a necessity and b) it should be means tested c) bread is nice to have but not essential and either are biscuits and pasta etc. I choose not to access my free prescriptions but given the number of eligible coeliacs out there getting loaves of bread, pasta and buscuits each month it must be a hefty bill. Gluten free food is not medicine in my opinion and I think more consideration needs to be given to what is on offer for free via the NHS.

pascheretloire · 09/08/2021 08:50

My husband has a chronic condition and has a regular repeat prescription of four items. He's had an annual prepay certificate for years. Makes sense to do that for anyone who needs more than one prescription a month.
Now that retirement age for many is 68, 60 does seem a low age for benefits to kick in, but the 60 year olds that I know aren't going to turn them down. I have a friend who now gets free Oyster card travel, Senior railcard, free eye tests, and these are the only benefits she's ever had in her life. Free prescriptions are applied automatically - there is no option for over 60s to pay.

foxandbee · 09/08/2021 08:48

When I know of somebody who has never worked a day in her life, has a free home (not council or HA), has her pension, pension credit, private pension, council tax paid for yet is a health hypochondriac

How does she have a private pension if she has never worked? It can't be very big if she still gets pension credit. Unless it is her husband's private pension?

Ragwort · 09/08/2021 08:45

I think it should certainly be reviewed .. my DH and I are both working, both over 60, we absolutely don't need 'free' prescriptions... neither do my elderly DPs who receive very good pensions, in fact my DF used to try and insist on paying but there was no way his money was accepted 'due to the system' so he would donate the equivalent to the community fund at the surgery.

But you do need a proper system to ensure those over retirement age who are on a low income/pension are able to received free prescriptions.

Greeneyedminx · 09/08/2021 08:45

Itsasin77, you do realise if we follow your natural conclusion, all stay at home parents, who are obviously not working- therefore not contributing to society in general, should also not be entitled to any form of benefits, be that child benefits etc!!!
You cannot universally state who is/isn’t entitled to whatever benefits because of their age/employment status/and what you feel they have/are contributing to society!!!
No one age group is more deserving than another.
This government as all governments, pit people against each other by removing certain benefits that others have fought long and hard for.
We never really know how other people manage their lives, so shouldn’t be unilaterally decide who can/can’t claim certain benefits that will help them. Or decide who is more important and deserves the maximum care and benefits that they “deserve” !!!
When you are older, regardless of how you worked/didn’t work you may need help and care, the same as if you are younger with children or no children.
If you need help and care, regardless of age, then someone else decides they are going to remove it-regardless of how it might affect you, then I think you’d be pretty hacked off.
Everyone in society should be treated as an equal, stop this....my children and me are far more important than anyone else rubbish!!!
Remember that older people were once in your position with children and worries for their future.

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 09/08/2021 08:43

@VikingVolva

Other home nations are abolishing prescription charges.

Does anyone know how much is raised by the charges each year, and how it compares to the total cost of the drugs and estimated pharmacist time? Just wondering if it's drop in the ocean, or major inroad

I know that for years I was prescribed a particular asthma medication because it was cheaper than the cost of the prescription. When it was no longer effective, the replacement was more expensive.
midgemagneto · 09/08/2021 08:42

In Scotland where all prescriptions are free, people who earn more pay more with higher taxes payable at lower incomes than in England

Strikes me as the best way

It's insurance for health and social care without any profit motives as in USA snd the richer pay more whilst the poorest are protected

StoneofDestiny · 09/08/2021 08:41

If you are still working why shouldn't you pay for your prescriptions

If you choose not to work (eg SAHM/F) why should you get free prescriptions? .

foxandbee · 09/08/2021 08:40

Ooh there is some hate being spewed on this thread. Those horrible people making up all their illnesses and getting free houses etc. 🤮

StoneofDestiny · 09/08/2021 08:39

Sorry - that's from The Guardian

StoneofDestiny · 09/08/2021 08:39

I'd caution on Means Testing

Means testing benefits will not be efficient or fair. But if society was a small family and politics like housekeeping, that might be enough said. But governments, politicians, political ideology and social policy, as we all know, just aren't like that. So it's helpful to look at this issue of means testing versus universal benefits, not from our experience of divvying up domestic budgets, but from the real and very different perspective of how politics and policy actually work

And what we actually know about means testing is that it tends not to be efficient, fair or in the interests of the most disadvantaged.

One of the great strengths of universal benefits is that it is simple and economical to administer and operate. The opposite is true of means testing.

What means testing generally means is a lot more bureaucracy. This is quite likely to eat up any apparent savings that it is suggested it will make possible. It's no different in our computerised age. All that has meant is huge IT-system bills that almost invariably end up unfit for purpose.

Means tested benefits aren't actually fair. It has long been known that large numbers of needy people tend to miss out on such benefits. Either they don't know about them, they don't realise they are eligible for them, or perhaps, particularly important, they are reluctant to claim them.

This is because they have increasingly been encouraged to think of receiving benefits as meaning being dependent and "not standing on their own two feet". This is especially well known about older people and can result in them encountering health and other problems from under-claiming, which ultimately increases costs, as well as failing to ensure their access to entitlements.

When benefits have been universal, people have paid for them in their taxes. To change them into means tested benefits – as has recently been happening – is quite simply a fraud, denying people entitlements they have contributed to and earned.

Means testing hurts those who are neither rich or very poor. Means testing always hurts people who are neither rich or very poor. Because there's always a cut off point, some who are far from well off and who would "genuinely" benefit from them are excluded.

There are also many people who may seem comfortable to the outside world, but who don't necessarily feel so themselves. So they are frugal for fear of rainy days, not realising that the rain has already come.

Thus, older people who could afford an occasional taxi to make up for the inadequacy of public transport see it is a luxury they can't afford. They increasingly stay at home. The resulting isolation is strongly associated with bigger physical and mental health problems. So cutting travel passes can actually end up causing greater public expense.

One of the great strengths of universal benefits is that they create a sense of solidarity and shared understanding. Means tested benefits create the opposite, divisions and misunderstanding.

When benefits are universal it means that there are better placed people concerned to fight for them. That has always been one of the strengths of child benefit. When benefits are means tested, they lose these advocates and the most disadvantaged, with much weaker voices, don't have the political clout to ensure that they stay sufficiently resourced and constantly uprated. It's a vicious circle.

Of course, there's the argument that getting rid of universal benefits means that the jam can be spread more fairly. Please show me one example where cuts made in one valued service ever resulted in politicians spending more on another valued service.

Speaking as someone who had the misfortune to spend years living on means tested benefits and was delighted to be able to escape them, I'd also ask how many of those who proclaim their virtues have anything other than an ideological interest in the issue.

Put another way, how many of them have ever had to rely for any length of time on such benefits or go through the process of getting them? Not many I would suggest. The rest of us should steer clear of them too.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 09/08/2021 08:38

I thought thats what happened already. If you are still working why shouldn't you pay for your prescriptions.

EmeraldShamrock · 09/08/2021 08:37

Next step - everybody should pay to see their doctor, no exceptions, followed by everybody should pay for any hospital treatment no exceptions...
Do you think those who can afford to pay should pay? the money saved could go towards education or really work towards sink estates in terms of education, stock food banks who heavily rely on charity & the kindnesses of supermarkets who have to pay staff who sort out the donations.

cptartapp · 09/08/2021 08:35

Absolutely should.
FIL in his 80's is massively smug about his lump of non means tested benefits in general despite needing none of them, heating allowance, attendance allowance, bus pass, prescriptions. Thousands like him.
MIL never worked a day again after 25 when she had her first child. Thousands like her too.
I can't believe it's cheaper to give free prescriptions than means test.
Why did that not apply when they removed my child benefit? (quite rightly btw, we didn't need it).

rookiemere · 09/08/2021 08:33

I believe it costs too much to adjust based in income, but it seems grossly unfair that some people get things free by dint of age that can well afford them.
In Scotland all prescriptions are free which seems even odder to me who lives there. I buck the trend by paying for a branded contraception that doesn't seem to trigger my endometriosis rather than the generic one available on the NHS that is allegedly identical.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/08/2021 08:32

Sounds reasonable: would like to see the detail.

SmokeyDevil · 09/08/2021 08:32

@StoneofDestiny

Yes SmokeyDevil like lemmings heading over the cliff.......
Yes, it doesn't affect the rich. But everyone just goes 'well it's better than labour' then complains about the outcome. How people haven't caught on yet is beyond me, its not like the tories have ever cared about the lower classes. Thatcher, anyone?

Stuff like this should be means tested, all of it should. The wealthy don't need any perks and shouldn't get them, even if they are old. We'd waste less money then and at least it goes to the right people who do need it. Might even be able to increase some benefits by removing those who don't need it. I wonder how many on here still took child benefit despite two big incomes. Hmm