Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Favouritism shown by grandparent - Would this piss you off?

59 replies

olldbones · 08/08/2021 23:02

My sister and her partner moved back in with my parents 3 years ago when she had a baby to get out of renting and save for her own home. My Mum went to all the baby scans and has lived with them all up until recently when they moved out. My mum adores my sisters son, always buying him things and talking about how's he's her lovely little man. She raves about him to anyone that will listen.

I had my own daughter last year. She is nearly 1 and my mum doesn't give her the time of day. When she was tiny, she used to portray that holding her was a chore and would quickly pass her over to anyone else around. She only seems to make comments which sort of come across as digs as she says them in such a way. Examples are "god, she's just all for grandad isn't she" and "all I see is her dad and his family in her... None of us and its a shame " If we have a family get together she will always say love you to my nephew as they leave but never tells my daughter that she loves her.

It makes my blood boil. I understand that she's naturally going to be close to my nephew as she lived with him for so long but I feel she could at least attempt to try and hide her obvious favouritism. It obviously upsets me more than my baby at this point because she has no idea what's going on but if this continues, it will eventually get clocked.

AIBU to be pissed? Tonight when we all left after a family get together I made a point of only kissing my Dad goodbye to try and let her know how it feels. I know that's petty and I do deeply regret acting like that but her attitude is so upsetting when my baby hasn't done anything wrong Sad

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Silversun83 · 09/08/2021 15:23

Also have this with the PILs.

YY about the first set being favourites and geographical distance.

What a PP says about a primary care-giver relationship also really resonates.. BIL and his ex-girlfriend are pretty useless so MIL has been a third parent.

Thing is they're quite doting when we're alone with them, but it's so obvious when all together so try and avoid that.

I was so hurt when it became apparent but I've started to just try and take it for what it is.

It's hard though because my mum died last year (had dementia since before DC were born so they've never had a grandmotherly relationship with her) and my dad is an alcoholic so no other grandparents.

FatCatThinCat · 09/08/2021 14:41

I don't think this is just favouritism. It's worse than that. Telling one child you love them and not saying it to the other isn't favouritism. It's cruelty.

LovePoppy · 09/08/2021 14:34

@80sMum

I think proximity and familiarity play a huge part in grandparents/grandchildren relationships.

Your mother has actually lived with her grandson, so there is bound to be a deeper bond between them than with those she sees less frequently. It's a pity that she doesn't try to compensate where your daughter is concerned though.

My own DCs were closer geographically to one set of grandparents than the other, so naturally they saw more of them and a bond formed early in their lives that persisted into adulthood.

I lived next door to one set of grandparent. Saw them frequently

I was closer emotionally with my other grandmother.

I don’t think your hypothesis is always the case

billy1966 · 09/08/2021 14:24

I think you need to decide what and whom is more important.

Your mothers feelings whilst she she isn't very interested in your daughter or your daughter not being exposed to such favouritism?

Monitor how things progress for sure but if you continue to feel this is a big issue, nursery might be your best option.

Being mindful of your daughters feelings as she grows should guide you.

Everydayimhuffling · 09/08/2021 13:32

Please send her to nursery. Personally I would have to respond to the "you don't trust us" comment: you rightly DON'T trust them because it does seem likely that your daughter won't be treated equally.

If your sister agrees with you about what is happening I would also try to do more with her and her son without your mum there. Hopefully you can build a relief between the cousins which is not damaged by your mum's favouritism.

It won't be long before your daughter notices, so you need to act now to minimise the impact on her.

Devon1987 · 09/08/2021 12:42

Please send her to nursery, I say this as someone who was on the receiving end of favouritism. My gp greatly favoured me over my brother and it breaks my heart looking back at the differences. It effects him today still and I hold a lot of guilt that he was treated so badly.
I would state you fee it would be better for your daughter’s social skills to attend nursery.

Ozanj · 09/08/2021 12:31

Mum is like this with my DS. The only time we left him with her DB and DS descended with their kids and left them there & we arrived home to find Mum had gone upstairs with the older kids to put them up bed while my DS (then only 14 months old and the youngest) was wondering around downstairs, totally unsupervised. I was furious but thought at first it was accidental - then she said she left him downstairs on purpose as he was so quiet. Confused

She never had him unsupervised again

follygirl · 09/08/2021 12:29

I'm in the same situation. We had our kids first and they were doted on by my PILs. Then their daughter had a son and it's always been about him. They have another GC who is a few months older than the favoured one but it's always about him.
My ds was about 7 at the time and asked me if he'd upset Granny. I asked him why he thought that and he replied that she didn't spend time with him anymore.
That broke my heart and shows that they do know what's going on.
Due to many other reasons we're NC with them and it's bliss. More importantly my kids know that their GP's behaviour has nothing to do the them.

Mary46 · 09/08/2021 12:27

Its hurtful op yes. My mam fell out with me. Blanked my daughter at party. Dont take it out on the kid! Honestly op its so hurtful.

80sMum · 09/08/2021 12:26

I think proximity and familiarity play a huge part in grandparents/grandchildren relationships.

Your mother has actually lived with her grandson, so there is bound to be a deeper bond between them than with those she sees less frequently. It's a pity that she doesn't try to compensate where your daughter is concerned though.

My own DCs were closer geographically to one set of grandparents than the other, so naturally they saw more of them and a bond formed early in their lives that persisted into adulthood.

JudgeRindersMinder · 09/08/2021 12:23

Fortunately I’ve never experienced this for my kids but I and 1 of my cousins were the less preferred kids with a grandparent and it bloody well hurt! The favourite could do no wrong. My less preferred cousin and I have never had a relationship with the favourite which is a shame, but it’s way too late now

QueenBee52 · 09/08/2021 12:15

I feel stuck. I don't want to upset anyone or cause rifts in our wider family but more importantly, I don't want my baby girl to feel unloved.

People bank on this... they know you will say nothing and accept whatever they throw your way..

time to make a stand for your precious baby girl 🌸💕

olldbones · 09/08/2021 12:10

@Marmitemarinaded Yes, so that's been our plan for a long time. It's a bit of a mess really.

My mum looks after my nephew while my sister is at work. She charges for this, but not nearly as much as say sending them to a nursery or childminder. When my daughter was born, my Dad signed my mum up to do the same for our daughter. My Mum went along with it saying that it would be fine but with some added comments like "but you better make sure you don't have any more because I'm not doing it for any others."

In a way, I would prefer my mum to have her because I know my Mum (I know she make sure she was fed, watered and that she wouldn't ever let anything bad happen to her) and obviously, we would save quite a lot of money by doing this and we would be very lucky in that sense. That said, one of the main reasons I am trying to reduce my hours at work is to limit the amount of time my DD has to spend with her. I have visions of her sitting on her own playing in a corner while my nephew has my Mum's undivided attention.

Me and my husband have discussed with both my mum and dad whether sending her to a nursery might be better. We were met with comments like "but that would really hurt us if you did that, it would seem like you don't trust us and we're only trying to help."

I feel stuck. I don't want to upset anyone or cause rifts in our wider family but more importantly, I don't want my baby girl to feel unloved.

OP posts:
TillyTopper · 09/08/2021 11:05

That's really hard OP, and horrible of your Mum. I think I'd go low contact and just concentrate on having a good relationship with your Dad. Try not to let it hurt you and concentrate on your own little family and building up a good friendship network. I can see that's hurtful but try to overcome it if you can.

Serendipity12 · 09/08/2021 10:49

I think that posters recommending that you talk about it with her are spot on, and if she fails to respond this time start looking at what you can control and what you want your own boundaries to be to avoid emotional harm to your DD. You can communicate these boundaries and your expectations to her.
Hopefully you can gain some insight as to whether this is genuinely an (admittedly hurtful) oversight on her part or whether there is more intent/game playing going on. Sadly my experience with my own mother was that she would enjoy playing favourites with The GCs and the ensuing drama, and when she was challenged on it she didn’t choose to/was unable to stop. That’s a worst case scenario and led to no contact. Hopefully you will have better luck! At least you will know you have done what you can.

Marmitemarinaded · 09/08/2021 10:35

I’m confused as I recall you from another thread very recently where you say your mother is looking after your child during the week whilst you work?

GreatAuntEmily · 09/08/2021 10:30

My DM was like this, besotted with a DGS, not so with any of the girls. Or the other boy come to that.
She was close to her DF and not so with her DM, I don't know what the history was there,, she also had an older sister, maybe she was jealous, maybe her own DM favoured her sister and she felt she missed out or something.
Is there a bit of history like this with DGM. It doesn't offend as much if you can see there was a family or childhood dynamic affecting her behaviour.
But my DDs were great, so I didn't care too much and we were quite far away so didn't see her much.

FlorenceNightshade · 09/08/2021 10:25

@Sprogonthetyne I totally agree with you! It does feel like your DC are missing out on close relationships when GPs act this way.

I think it’s partly because you imagine how you’d treat your own GC and when others don’t act in that way it’s sad and disappointing. My DC barely see the set that treat them this way, they never ask about them, never seem bothered. I hope over the years they’ve had more than enough love and attention from others to know that their GPs are undeserving and not them.

ittakes2 · 09/08/2021 10:24

I think you need to speak to her but I would ignore others that say cut contact. Your daughter is 1 years old - not everyone bonds with very young babies. I would wait until she is older and talking and if its still the same go low contact then. But don't do anything without speaking to her as you are pressuming she knows. I think this sort of situations happens in a variety of families - some times its down to how the grandparent sees their relationship with their own child (the mother or father) and their parenting. There are 5 kids in my family and we have noticed if my mum finds the 'rules' around being a grandparent very ridiculous she tends to back away a bit.

Sprogonthetyne · 09/08/2021 10:19

@charmingthebirds

Sprogonthetyne

You say that both your children are missing out on a relationship, but isn't it more a case that your children are being saved from a relationship that will damage them?

I know your right really, it's just difficult to see it that way when we don't have any other family around, so they effectively lose the chance at having a wider family.

Rationaly I know this is probably a hangover from being the less favourite child, and at the time been happy for any affection/interest I got. But knowing that and having your emotional reaction match that isn't the same thing.

Ducksurprise · 09/08/2021 10:11

Did you even read OP's situation... which is nothing like your situation at all

But we only ever see the op side, it's reasonable to question that there maybe another narrative. Fwiw I wonder if the sister feel smothered by her mum (as they shut the door in her face)

BluebellsGreenbells · 09/08/2021 10:05

Mine were the oldest GC - they favorited the youngest.

To the point DN had his own room his own toys in their house and mine weren’t allowed to play with them - always pointed out they were ‘DN toys’ mine had no toys there.

FIL set up a game of cricket with DN and they refused to let mine play because they were girls - they were 6 and 4 - DN is a week younger than DD -

Once we took a slip n slide to their house so they could have something to play one hot afternoon, MIL insisted DN had such fun playing that we leave it for him!!

We didn’t have much to do with them after that. Not worth the effort.

billy1966 · 09/08/2021 09:46

Awful behaviour OP.

The most important person in this is your daughter.
So I would step well back and choose to relegate your parents.
Don't speak about them, don't mention them.
Talk to your daughter about other things.
By doing this and not giving them status, she will take from your lead.
It is awful for children to see this and terribly hurtful.
I haven't had it in my family but over the years a few friends have mentioned it a bit.
It is always the first set of grandchildren getting the priority attention.

One of my friends had this with her inlaws.
She found it very hurtful as her own parents were dead.

It was her inlaws daughters children that were the very clear favourites.

They did sleepovers and days out.

My friends children just weren't ever invited.
The boys were VERY aware of it, and it did hurt them.
They NEVER visited my friends home.

She mentioned it once and was dismissed as being silly so she let it go.
So she left it to her husband to visit his parents and only went infrequently.
Her sons grew less interested in going.

She liked her sister in law, but it obviously suited her that her children were given so much attention, particularly when they were young.

Her BIL got a promotion to the US with his company and they moved.
Huge tears and drama.

You know the rest of course.

Suddenly they were calls asking when were they coming to visit?
When could they see the grandsons?
Could they visit?

Her boys were mid teens by this stage and had zero interest.

She didn't intervene, she left it to her husband, as she didn't feel her boys should be suddenly expected to visit weekly when they didn't see them more than once every couple of months all their lives.

She kindly hosted them sometimes, but she never insisted her boys be around as by this time they had lots of matches etc. and their own lives.

Her MIL is dead now and her son's never visit the grandfather, they have absolutely no interest.

charmingthebirds · 09/08/2021 09:32

Sprogonthetyne

You say that both your children are missing out on a relationship, but isn't it more a case that your children are being saved from a relationship that will damage them?

Sprogonthetyne · 09/08/2021 08:37

We have this kind of dynamic in our family, it started off as my nephew (eldest gc) been flavoured above both my DS, and worse his own sister. We shielded my DS from seeing this by seeing them separately, but I always felt so bad for my niece, who would watch her brother been picked up and taken on outings while she was left behind. (mum claims she was "to young" despite being years older then nephew was when she started taking him)

Unfortunately it has escalated since my younger child was born, as it has become apparent that she is similarly 'chosen' as a favourite. There's no way that I will allow the same different treatment that my sister overlooks, so for now both my children are missing out on a relationship.