Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to buy a new (to me) car in current situation?

67 replies

itsonlyaradish · 08/08/2021 21:13

I am torn between a feeling of lifes too short and if I want nice things I should have them, but a more practical feeling that it's an unnecessary liability.

I don't drive that much, I WFH so driving is mostly local plus a 400 mile round trip journey twice a month. I have a practical diesel car which is a real workhorse, I got it cheap, it's done 130000 miles, costs me under 500 a year to keep on the road (new brakes, tyres etc but the engine is great) my insurance is fairly low. It's nice to drive but it's 12 years old and lacks bells and whistles - no cruise control, no bluetooth (though I have got a plug in thingy which does the job), no parking sensors etc.

I see all these fancy cars on the road, with automatic boot openers, and all kinds of added extras and think I'd like something that was just more fancy than the sensible car I have now.

That said, I don't want something too big that I'm struggling to park it anywhere, or so high end that I'm worrying its going to get stolen or damaged. And although I could afford something better, I can't help feeling its a waste of money and I'm just falling into the trap of wanting shiny, flashy things for the sake of it.

If you were me, would you stick with sensible practical car or ditch it for something 'better'?

OP posts:
BeetleyCarapace · 09/08/2021 09:14

I always feel it's better the devil you know with cars, especially older ones. It sounds like you know your current car inside out, foibles and all. And if it's meeting your needs, and not giving you trouble right now, why change it?

I also think you might be falling into a consumerist trap by wanting to replace it just because you fancy a new one.

The car market is going to change a lot over the next decade and I wonder if you might be better placed to keep your current one for another few years, then look to replace it.

Lanique · 09/08/2021 09:13

Shade17 - that's great, it's so rare for a car to appreciate in value!

Lanique · 09/08/2021 09:12

Agree about lifestyle inflation.

I bought a lovely car three years ago. I'd wanted one of that particular model for ages, and at first it was such a novelty to drive. In fact it still is - I love it! However a newer model has since come out and when I was in the dealership recently having mine serviced I browsed around the showroom and gazed in wonder at all the shinier, newer models. Thing is, just five years ago my car would have been fit for that showroom. But there will always be something bigger and better come along!

Luckily we bought the car outright so there are no pcp / hp / loans to pay back each month, but I've had to give my head a wobble over my car envy.

I would say with cars to never buy brand and never overstretch yourself as the novelty will wear off before you've paid it back!

Shade17 · 09/08/2021 09:11

Do NOT do PCP. It’s such a scam and so bad for the environment.

It rather depends on the interest rate. One of our cars is on a 0% PCP. You’d have to be stupid to tie capital up buying it outright in those circumstances. Contemplating getting rid as we’re now being offered more for it than we paid brand new a year ago.

Sprig1 · 09/08/2021 09:08

Keep the car you have. It sounds great. Unless you have millions in the bank and nothing better to do with it buying a new car would be a total waste of money. It's all very well having a car with all the bells and whistles but there is more to go wrong and things are more expensive to fix than on a basic older car.

Iluvfriends · 09/08/2021 09:06

If it's right for you do it......i just did.
I have always had a wee runaround for £1300 ish. I just decided one day i wanted a newer car and last month i got a 6 yr old diesel Note and i love it. Went for finance though, PCP is not for me.

Comedycook · 09/08/2021 09:05

*proves nothing not prices nothing

Comedycook · 09/08/2021 09:05

@PivotPivotPivottt

If you can afford it go for it. I drive a 16 year old car which has a few problems. I can't afford to buy a new car and the insurance on it is really cheap I'm still a relatively new driver. I hate it so much if I had the money I would definitely buy something else. I'd be happy with something from around 2013. I'm so embarrassed driving around in my rust bucket but I don't have any other choice.
Why are you embarrassed? Confused this is so weird and so indicative of the stupid British class system and keeping up with the Jones crap. I drive an old car...I actually own it, unlike the newer cars on the road which are mostly on finance. A new flash car generally prices nothing except you managed to take out a finance agreement...hardly a huge achievement
user1493494961 · 09/08/2021 08:59

I'd keep your old, reliable car, better the devil you know.

Essentialgarage · 09/08/2021 08:23

I would stick with what you've got, every extra that a car has is another thing to go wrong. Q7 tyres over £1000 for four, fancy LED light cluster on a Mercedes over £1000, parts maintenance everything is more expensive.

Kerberos · 09/08/2021 08:16

Personally I'd stick with the car you have for now, but put £200 a month away for six months and research what you'd like. Test drive a few but don't buy anything just yet.

Then you'll be making a solid decision based on fact not emotion and you'll have a sense of how much it's going to cost you and whatever other lifestyle adjustments you might need.

I like owning my car outright. It's also 14 years old, diesel and has done 130k miles.

It's an expensive mistake to make if you are scratching an emotional itch.

MrsBede · 09/08/2021 08:05

I was in a very similar position a few months ago and upgraded. I am so glad I did. I spend about 90 minutes a day in my car for a commute and then more for holidays/day trips etc so not having AC and my ds being cramped in the back became untenable. I was scared because the car I had was reliable but it did have 120 000 miles and I thought I would rather be in control of when I switch than have it die in the middle of winter when work is stressful etc. Even if it would have lasted another couple of years I'm glad upgrading it was a positive exciting experience, rather than a stressful one thrust upon me at an inconvenient time.

I also think having a loan (not pcp) is fine, as long as the monthly payments are affordable and it won't stop you doing other stuff, including saving.

Toomuchspinning · 09/08/2021 07:54

@SmokeyDevil that was my first reaction!

@itsonlyaradish there is a massive difference between upgrading to a 2/3/4 year old hybrid, with some jazz about it, and plunging a second mortgage into a Range Rover.

If I were you, and could afford it without a damaging finance agreement, then yes, I would upgrade to something economical (in both finance and environmental senses) and that I enjoyed/was fun.

SmokeyDevil · 09/08/2021 07:32

Get a new one if you want one. But don't get yourself into debt because of it. I am surprised that you have an old vauxhall that is still working though, you got a good one there, always known them to be reliable at breaking down and nothing else. Grin

thecatsabsentcojones · 09/08/2021 07:21

Two years ago I spent £16k on a 3 yo 5 series BMW. My car previous to that was bought for £2.5k (still got it). No regrets for me, it’s great to have something that I know will get to where it’s going, it’s a joy to drive, it’s practical (estate) and barely sips fuel. Previous to it I was spending big repair bills and had the uncomfortable worry about it letting me down.

Also I’m really aware of safety, my husband and son were in a scary accident a few years back and the car saved them, so in my mind it’s good to have a really safe, strong car.

Rogue1001 · 08/08/2021 23:58

The only thing I'd point out is there's v soon going to be a tax on driving less green vehicles in London.
Don't know if other big cities are doing too?
There's a penalty for diesels.
However, if you don't drive in those places, there's no issue

Xmassprout · 08/08/2021 23:36

Do you actually want a new car, or is it just because your friends have fancy new cars?

PivotPivotPivottt · 08/08/2021 23:36

If you can afford it go for it. I drive a 16 year old car which has a few problems. I can't afford to buy a new car and the insurance on it is really cheap I'm still a relatively new driver. I hate it so much if I had the money I would definitely buy something else. I'd be happy with something from around 2013. I'm so embarrassed driving around in my rust bucket but I don't have any other choice.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 08/08/2021 23:33

@bridgetreilly

Do NOT do PCP. It’s such a scam and so bad for the environment.
Very sound advice! Only buy what you can afford to buy, tax, maintain and fuel plus a budget for out of warranty consumables depending on your mileage.

All financial products look attractive especially the “this will only cost you monthly payments of £XYZ” but actually very expensive rip off loan with silly interest rates etc. I never buy if I will be stretched financially and need finance. It’s a car which depreciates fast not a property which should have investment value! Why pay another equivalent of a mortgage on a car that you don’t need?!

These days in big cities Uber taxis are not too over priced and even some car club rental on demand schemes look a possible option for those who rarely drive as otherwise the car will be parked up depreciating and being taxed for little daily or weekly use.

Alcesalces · 08/08/2021 23:28

It sounds like you don't have a need for a new car but a want. So will the car improve your life?
Is there anything else you could spend the money on that would improve your life more? Will the cost of the car be detrimental to your lifestyle?

For me buying a massive 7 seater so I can carry lots of passengers and stuff has been great. Well worth the cost.

Don't get too bogged down in it all either. You are allowed to want a nice car just because. Some people get very pious about how little they care about their car. That's great for them but some of us like a nice car.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 08/08/2021 23:21

If the budget allows - splash out and have no regrets or forever what if etc?

Your current Vauxhall is as you may imagine technically scrap value as old cars are worthless these days. However as a car for essential and basic personal transportation - it does the job, relatively reliable and low cost motoring. It’s by your own admission not particularly much fun nor spark joy but is rudimentary and fit for purpose in a no nonsense modest manner.

Don’t buy a new car to impress anyone but yourself. Keeping up with your friendship group and neighbours should not be dependent on the car you own and drive but more you, your friendship, character and frankly its more important what you have in the bank than on your drive. I don’t take note of judgemental types especially if you have sound financial firepower and no need to display it in a superficial manner.

Cars are obviously depreciating assets. That means you will lose money with an upgrade but the purchase price will be discounted for both new and especially more value with preowned.

Buy the car that suit your needs and also importantly add that little extra which sparks joy and pride which is difficult to calculate in hard cash terms. Look at cars that you find interesting and would imagine yourself driving, then do the online reviews research eg Honest John www.honestjohn.co.uk/carbycar/ amongst countless car websites and get a test drive to see it in the metal and work out your budget accordingly. Obviously a “nice” new car will be pricey and basically £20k plus including discounts or £10k plus for a basic nicer older car. Don’t buy a cheapo banger as it could be a money pit for repairs and dangerous. You have a safe if boring car already so don’t buy something with unknown history (lots of mechanical and electrical issues can be easily hidden from the uninitiated!) ideally if budget suits you will need to consider hybrid cars as that should be the way forward to be permitted without detrimental financial penalties as many cities are taxing older cars out and new E10 fuels will soon come on tap etc. Electric will be the longer term option but not if you don’t have a drive for at home charging as infrastructure for electric vehicles is still in its infancy unless you buy a preowned Tesla.

Good luck and if you think you deserve a new shinny car with all the usual bells and whistles - then go for it but make sure you do the research and drive suitable cars first.

I am a petrol head and happy to help! I drive high end cars (silly big money cars) but started with modest cars initially at school as soon I passed my test age 17 and then university etc back in the day! My first car was a sporty Volkswagen Golf Convertible though as gifted by generous parents who brought all siblings their first car! Loved that convertible and had always driven a proper sports convertible ever since plus a Chelsea tractor family wagon. But don’t drive much these days as only for leisure drives and household chores.

bridgetreilly · 08/08/2021 23:11

Do NOT do PCP. It’s such a scam and so bad for the environment.

bridgetreilly · 08/08/2021 23:10

Don’t buy new, buy nearly new. You can still get the bells and whistles for a lot less money.

MonsterChopz · 08/08/2021 23:09

I've just done the opposite. I've gone from a pcp deal on a shiny, reasonably new car and bought a 10 Yr old diesel with 157000 miles on the clock. I've been working from home since March 2020 and only running to shops and ferrying the kids to their clubs. I figured I'd much rather spend that £300 car payment on something better.

I did like having a shiny car but the one I've got now is nice to drive, fuel efficient and best of all if it doesn't get through its next Mot I've still saved myself money on car payments.

HarrietSchulenberg · 08/08/2021 23:07

The more bells and whistles, the more things to go wrong, IME. I've wondered about changing my 14yo diesel workhouse but it's so reliable I daren't risk it. It's the best car I've ever owned (and I've had a fair few) and I don't want to risk upgrading and ending up with a pile of shite.