Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What do I do , I want more children husband doesnt

59 replies

Baby2020triplets · 08/08/2021 21:12

To cut a long story short, we got pregnant last year with triplets and lost them, it made me realise how much I wanted another child, we have a 7 year old, my husband doesn't want anymore children .
When we found out last year he wanted to get an abortion but lost them at 9 weeks it broke my heart.
Our 7 year old keep asking for a brother or sister.
We have a lovely house and good jobs but he wants better for us bigger house but what's the use of a bigger house with no-one to fill it?

He just keeps saying no and never to ask again im broken what do I do ? I love him so much and love our live but I can't seem to get over this.he doesn't seem to listen when I try to tell him how I feel

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LifesNotEnidBlyton · 09/08/2021 14:13

You have more than one problem here.

You want another child and he doesn't. You think he isn't listening to you but he is likely thinking the same when he says no. All you can do is make a choice about what you want more, him or another baby. You can't have both if he doesn't want one can you, so do you stay with him or do you leave to have another by yourself or in another relationship?

Then you have the big problem of contraception. You want another baby obviously but until you've made a choice about what you're going to do about that do you want to be on the pill? Try not to think about babies when thinking about that. Just think about if you are ok with taking the pill when he isn't using any contraception or getting a vasectomy himself. Because if you don't want to take the pill but you do make the choice to stay with him and not have more children how are you going to do that? It's a big problem. Because if you don't want to take contraception and he doesn't want to use condoms or get a vasectomy then all the choice you have left is abstain or have unprotected sex isn't it? You already know you're ok with having a baby so you are ok with unprotected sex. But he doesn't want one so he needs to pick what he wants to do.

So, after you know if you're staying and not having a child (because if you're leaving you don't need to worry about contraception in this relationship) you need to talk to him and you both need to listen. Because if you don't want to take the pill what contraception are you going to agree on?

Because you need to agree on something. So if he doesn't want a vasectomy or to use condoms (and another thing you both need to think about is the failure rate of whatever you use, and if you're both ok with it) and you don't want to take any birth control or get sterilised (and you both have the right to not want any of them, and you both don't have the right to make eachother take one) then you need to agree to abstain from things that will make a baby or that you will just have unprotected sex and both agree that if/when you get pregnant you'll be having a baby (because you don't want a termination, so that isn't something he can tell you to have, anymore than you can tell him to have something he doesn't want done to his body). Then if you still can't agree your relationship is really over anyway because you need to be able to agree on these things in a relationship.

But you need to know what you want OP.

You need to think about if another baby is a deal breaker. Then if yes, you tell him and you leave. But if no you need to talk to him about contraception.

When you talk to him about contraception he needs to know you now won't be asking about another baby and will be staying in the relationship. Then that you now need to talk about contraception.

He might not want to talk about it but he'll either have to or the relationship will be called into question again.

You need to know what you want OP. No one here can tell you, and when you know what you want start talking to him and if he won't listen you know you can't make him.

What you don't want is both of you not being on contraception and having some sort of competition over if he'll break first and go for it unprotected or if you'll both just abstain and hate eachother. You're both adults.

So if you can't agree one of you needs to be the bigger person and understand the relationship is over anyway. Most importantly of all you have a child to think about, and what happens with their parents is important, so you agree together or you don't agree and do what you need to to stop your child living in the middle of your arguments.

Candlesinthewind · 09/08/2021 14:04

I would accept his decision at the moment. Once you’re sure he understands your depth of feeling, then stop talking about it and try to get your head around it.
Leave it for a couple of years or so - don’t keep prodding for a different answer from him.
Then if you still feel as strongly in a couple of years, talk to him again about it (assuming he hasn’t had the snip in the meantime).
Sometimes feelings do change, on either side.
But do your best to come to terms with it in the interim.

Cukku · 09/08/2021 13:55

This isn't a fantasy - it's the current reality. It will have a MASSIVE effect on your children's lives. You are making this decision on the child's behalf. It's a big responsibility.

Cukku · 09/08/2021 13:53

The right time to think about climate change is before deciding to have another baby. What will that child's life be like? Why isn't that relevant? Why is having a child all about the parent and their wish to experience having a (second in this case) baby, rather than about the child and their likely future? If you can't be selfless towards your own prospective children...

Chloemol · 09/08/2021 13:43

He doesn’t want one, and you dont want to leave, so you have to find a way forward, counselling perhaps?

As to him wanting you to go on the pill. He won’t have a vasectomy, that’s a different story. Why should you fill your body with chemicals when he can have a simple op that thousands have

So my response to that would be I am not taking the pill. We use condoms or you get the snip, or no sex. His choice

LemonKitten · 09/08/2021 13:38

[quote Mamascoven]@Cukku

I dont think this is the right time or place for your posts. OP is wanting genuine help and answers about her situation that has nothing to do with climate change.[/quote]
thank you for saying this, I didn't know how to and took the cowardly way out.

Mamascoven · 09/08/2021 13:37

@Cukku

I dont think this is the right time or place for your posts. OP is wanting genuine help and answers about her situation that has nothing to do with climate change.

CutePanda · 09/08/2021 13:14

@pianolessons1

Don't forget that your kids would have an at least 8 year age difference. That will have a big impact on your existing child. He may thinks he wants a sibling but he's getting to the age where you can do different things on holiday etc and stepping back to the baby years will impact him in ways he can't possible consider.
I agree. I’m closer to my sibling who’s a year younger than me than the one who is nearly 10 years younger than me. When your eldest is at university, the other is still at primary school. They won’t really grow up together.
Wearywithteens · 09/08/2021 13:03

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Bythemillpond · 09/08/2021 12:57

I know this is an odd way of looking at and I will probably get flames because it might not come across how I mean it but are both of you still processing the grief of the miscarriage, but with out communication your Dh has got stuck in the moment you lost them and doesn’t want to put you or himself through that again rather than not wanting children for another reason. Whilst you are processing the grief and have moved on to wanting to plan for the future which involves more children.
This is why I think the mixed signals of not wanting to take charge of the contraception but leaving it up to someone who is desperate for a child maybe is a way of him saying I don’t want children snd if you get pregnant and miscarried then I can protect myself because I didn’t want the pregnancy in the first place.
You need to talk as I don’t think it is as cut and dried as he doesn’t want children because…
I think there is still a lot of grief to work through for both of you

Dogfan · 09/08/2021 10:31

I wonder if part of the issue is not being able to express yourself because he shuts down the conversation. Maybe you could try saying "I know you don't want any more children. I respect that decision and I won't try to change your mind but I would like to talk to you about how I'm feeling". Then go on to be open with him about how you feel. I would also talk about the contraception thing. You need to be a team and at the moment it sounds like you are working against each other. If he won't discuss your feelings I think that is another matter altogether. Stonewalling is not an appropriate way to behave in an adult relationship.

LemonKitten · 09/08/2021 09:25

Have you had any couselling after the loss of your babies last year?

You say that before finding out that you were pregnant, you were happy with only having one child.

Is it possible (and I don't know, I've never been in your situation) that you are still grieving for the babies you so sadly lost?

Cukku · 09/08/2021 08:56

I think everyone considering more children (or even any children, unfortunately) should read this thread. It's not all about the adults: www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4317214-If-it-s-that-bad-why-aren-t-we-panicking-more

pianolessons1 · 09/08/2021 06:46

Don't forget that your kids would have an at least 8 year age difference. That will have a big impact on your existing child. He may thinks he wants a sibling but he's getting to the age where you can do different things on holiday etc and stepping back to the baby years will impact him in ways he can't possible consider.

CrazyNeighbour · 09/08/2021 06:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Highfivemum · 08/08/2021 23:33

You are grieving your lost babies. I am sorry for your loss.
You need time to grieve your DH maybe does too. . Maybe talk to someone about it.
Best wishes.

Hankunamatata · 08/08/2021 23:21

Id try counselling. You can hear each other in a neutral setting and try to move forward

Zeev · 08/08/2021 23:15

@Clumsyvolcano

He is well within his rights to not want another child. If that’s his choice then he needs to take charge of that and get a vasectomy.

He’s being totally unreasonable to expect you to keep putting synthetic hormones in your body indefinitely to ensure that his wishes are kept. It should not be always down to the woman.

This. If he wants to be sure, then he needs to make sure. It is not on to put the whole responsibility on you.
Unfashionable · 08/08/2021 23:06

There are two separate issues here.

The first issue is about whether or not you have more children. Neither of you is in the wrong here. You are perfectly entitled to want more, he is perfectly entitled not to. You just want different things and it’s a binary choice. He wants the current situation to remain. You want it to change. The ball is therefore in your court, and you have to decide whether or not you want to stay married to someone who doesn’t want more children.

The second issue is about contraception. He is being entirely unreasonable in expecting you to take responsibility for contraception despite you wanting more children and you are absolutely entitled to refuse to do so. He will then be faced with the consequences of his decision not to have more children : taking responsibility for contraception himself or a sexless marriage.

Wolframhart · 08/08/2021 23:03

He shouldn’t be expecting you to take the responsibility for birth control. The pill is an amazing liberator, but it also comes with harsh side effects that we only accept because pregnancy is so extreme in comparison. If he is really sure he is done, it’s time for him to take over the birth control by getting a vasectomy which is much less risky than you taking the pill.

But before you get to that….

It’s entirely possible that the desperation you feel to have a child and the strength of his feelings against are not entirely grounded in what it would be like to actually add another child to your family. You are both processing a loss and people handle that differently. Some want to try for another child. Some don’t ever want to open their hearts to hope again.

Summerfun54321 · 08/08/2021 23:02

The thought of my DH getting me pregnant then asking for a termination is gross. If he feels that strongly about not having children, he needs to do something about it and get a vasectomy. So sorry to hear about your loss Flowers

Mischance · 08/08/2021 22:55

His "Don't ask again" attitude is pretty dismissive.

He needs to talk about this, not dismiss you. He needs to talk about the loss you have both suffered. He needs to take some responsibility for contraception if it is his decision to have no more. He needs to hear why you want anther child; and you need to hear why not.

If you are not communicating and he is just swatting you away like an irritating fly, then this will fester.

Bythemillpond · 08/08/2021 22:47

I love my husband and would never leave him over this he means the world to me, I just find it hard as he never talks about it just says no more I'm not talking about it end off

I would make sure that this is mutual. Saying he won’t give reasons is not fair on you. At least if you know his reasons you can either come to terms with it or leave.

Not talking is just cruel as you don’t know why.
I would look at Dh very differently if he was so adamant on anything and wouldn’t explain why.

Cukku · 08/08/2021 22:44

This is such a terrible time to be bringing children into the world.

Clumsyvolcano · 08/08/2021 22:31

He is well within his rights to not want another child. If that’s his choice then he needs to take charge of that and get a vasectomy.

He’s being totally unreasonable to expect you to keep putting synthetic hormones in your body indefinitely to ensure that his wishes are kept. It should not be always down to the woman.

Swipe left for the next trending thread