Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is CF expectation

107 replies

Habber · 08/08/2021 17:04

Backstory is my kids DF (my ex) was a bit crap, had them once a week for 1 night, never took a day off if they were sick (even though he worked closer to school than I did) rarely helped with childcare during school holidays, never helped pay for any childcare while we both worked and gave bare minimum child support. His family never helped with kids and if he did ever take them on holiday in summer it was always in term time which was no help at all in terms of 6 week summer holidays.

Now he has a child under 5 and expects our older kids (over 16) to be his free childcare for their sibling all day during the holidays. Neither of my kids drive yet so there is a lot of back and forth with picking them up and dropping off. One of my children chose to say no thanks to it this year and under pressure from ex and older child has now given in. I was dragged into it when one of my kids was pressuring the other one to agree and now they aren’t speaking to me because I said he was being a CF.

AIBU to think you book your own paid for childcare like the rest of working parents have to? Just because you are family doesn’t mean they must babysit for you to save money?

OP posts:
Habber · 09/08/2021 09:38

My older daughter needs to get help for her mental well-being and I think she is now considering doing this all my efforts to get her on board with that previously failed. but I think she’s starting to understand about caring for herself not just people pleasing as it’s so stressful. This is what happens when someone is a people pleaser and why she’s dragged her sister into it, she’s so stressed about letting him down she makes bad decisions. I was hoping she would naturally disengage from him when older as working and it’s normal for kids to go get their own lives but no, he’s got a small kid she now feels responsible for it’s so wrong!

OP posts:
Habber · 09/08/2021 09:32

@Billybagpuss

Have you protected them over the years for how much of an arse he’s been?
Yes I have protected them by not putting them in the middle like he does, but I couldn’t withhold them, he is their father on the birth certificates and has PR for them, I could not afford court but it did me a favour without court, he didn’t have them very much as less exposed to him, for a few hours once a week was manageable and the younger one has distanced from him in the past few years since he has another child. It’s only recently I have been a lot more honest with them because they would get so upset if I said anything they saw to be detrimental about him but they see I have separated myself from him I barely speak to him as I don’t have to and don’t involve him in their life with me because 1. He’s not really that bothered and 2. I don’t need any of his drama. I have had to be more neutral I do not discourage or encourage them over anything to do with him unless it’s like this and a total piss take. I didn’t give him any room to take the piss out of me as I never asked him for anything to do with the kids so he didn’t mess me about too much.

The older one was always going to be difficult from day 1 as he’s always managed to get her on his side. It’s so frustrating as she swings between totally understanding what I am saying but the FOG kicks in (yes I know of this and she is in deep). I said to her last night you are not responsible for this little child, their parents are! She said she knows that and that it’s wrong but next breath says oh the kids club is £90 and expensive. It’s at that point I can’t keep on at her it’s pointless. I also said she must not keep on trying to get her other sister involved it’s not fair and if she does it again maybe she needs to live with him instead as it makes us all unhappy

OP posts:
Billybagpuss · 09/08/2021 08:35

Have you protected them over the years for how much of an arse he’s been?

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 09/08/2021 08:19

And refuse do do it even if they pay you. It's not petty.

billy1966 · 09/08/2021 08:19

OP,
I think @DeRigueurMortis has given good advice but I also believe that you shouldn't be allowing your older daughter pressurise the younger one.

Your older daughter should not be trying to guilt her younger sister.

This is a moment to say to her she should respect her siblings decision and to back off.

In effect your younger daughter needs protecting too.

Tell eldest daughter that she can be used if she wishes, that is unfortunately her choice, but that she is to leave her sibling alone.

Very unfair of her to do that and more proof of the damage that selfish man is doing.Flowers

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 09/08/2021 08:16

Oh and absolutely do not assist in them getting there or back in any way whatsoever. Not a lift, not a penny, nothing.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 09/08/2021 08:15

You need to support the younger one to say no and stick to it.
If the older one is keen to do it then that's up to them but they don't have the right to force the younger one to split the load.

PegasusReturns · 09/08/2021 08:15

Keep supporting your DDs to say no. This is the best lesson you can teach them.

If their dad is only happy with them when they are providing services on his terms then they need to understand that.

Newestname001 · 09/08/2021 08:11

@Habber

He’s got money and a nice big house, we have always struggled and a lot of it was barriers he put in my way on purpose, he left me with kids almost full time and no money.

Then he can pay for a cab/taxi to/from his house if he wants his elder children to provide childcare for his younger. The distance or costs involved in this is not your problem - particularly as a) he's then getting free childcare and b) he left you with a load of debt to bring up your joint children.

You have to be strong and consistent here, OP and not facilitate this arrangement any more. Your children need support in not being manipulated by their uncaring father - and you are being manipulated by your Ex through your children. 🌹

Velvian · 09/08/2021 07:33

He's expecting you to deliver his free childcare to and from the door as well? Despite not actually doing his share with your joint children? So he sees childcare of a child, that has nothing to do with you, as more your responsibility than his?

His entitlement is astounding!

Habber · 09/08/2021 06:50

@Wolframhart

Op, I’ve been thinking about this thread and about how you did not disclose the sex of either child. I can’t help but wonder if the child who has capitulated to being a free nanny is female and the child who has refused is male. If this is a case of patriarchal expectations being placed on women as caregivers, I actually think you need to step in and out a stop to this.
Morning no they both female but younger one is clued up that he is awful and came to that decision by herself a while ago. She doesn’t like conflict so doesn’t like getting into rows so can avoid him more than stand up for herself she knows her own mind and just doesn’t engage in a lot of things. She sees her sibling on her own terms usually and not that frequently but to the older child this is even more reason to make DC2 help out and DC2 gave in to shut DC1 up
OP posts:
timeisnotaline · 09/08/2021 03:22

Kids I have cared for you with your dad being more of an active obstruction than a help nearly all your life. I am not providing any free input to care for his other child!! He can bloody well pay a professional like I had to, he isn’t disadvantaged by my having offloaded serious debt onto him and run off with the goods bought with that debt, or a careers and income slowed by working around wvery school holiday. I love you, but I owe your dad absolutely nothing and that’s what he’s getting from me in terms of childcare for his other child. Including lifts so he can keep pressuring you into being his free childcare instead of being a parent to you like he should be.

They are old enough to hear it in black and white.

Wolframhart · 09/08/2021 02:52

Op, I’ve been thinking about this thread and about how you did not disclose the sex of either child. I can’t help but wonder if the child who has capitulated to being a free nanny is female and the child who has refused is male. If this is a case of patriarchal expectations being placed on women as caregivers, I actually think you need to step in and out a stop to this.

SoNotRainbowRhythms · 09/08/2021 01:15

Put your foot down and stop facilitating this madness

DeRigueurMortis · 09/08/2021 00:17

OP, if discussions are still ongoing with DC1 tomorrow I'd suggest you respond as follows (but in your own words).

"You are not speaking to the right parent about this issue.

If you want to look after your half sibling, then the conditions under which you are prepared to do that need to discussed with your father.

Be that the amount of time you're prepared to give or how you get to his house and back.

If he isn't prepared to meet those conditions you have a right to say no.

Just as I do and does your sibling, because it's not our responsibility to provide free childcare.

If your sibling doesn't want to do this then it's not your responsibility to lobby them into compliance on your father's behalf because you're unwilling to "do it all".

It's his responsibility to incentivise both of you into wanting to do this, either through providing transportation or paying for the service you're providing.

Even then it's still ok to say no. The same way I'm saying no, because childcare is the responsibility of the parents, not the elder children or ex partner.

I respect that your old enough to make your own decisions. You need to respect that your sibling and I can do the same and my decision is firm and final.

So if you want to move forward with this, speak to your father. Negotiate with him, the person who wants the favour and stop discussing it with me."

billy1966 · 08/08/2021 23:50

@Habber

I’m going to go to sleep now and just keep sticking to my guns thanks for your time in giving me advice on this
Sleep well and stick to those guns.

This is about more than that wankers childcare.

QueenBee52 · 08/08/2021 23:49

@Habber

I’m going to go to sleep now and just keep sticking to my guns thanks for your time in giving me advice on this

Stand your ground ... 🌸

DeRigueurMortis · 08/08/2021 23:48

@SusieSusieSoo

OP glad you have stood up for yourself - could you also think about how you could help your dc's stand up for themselves?

I know a lot of pp's are saying they are old enough to stand up for themselves but if he is utterly awful to them it is incredibly hard for them to do this.

I agree that you were right to say no to the lifts but can you now help them to feel sufficiently empowered to say no to their "d"f?

At 40 something my then 70 something dm told me several times not to stick up for myself and young ds when my dsis was being incredibly difficult/nasty.

This was because she was scared my dsis would blow up/kick off like my "d"f used to do. DM would throw me & DS under a bus to avoid upsetting dsis. DF died many yrs ago so no longer have to deal with his shenanigans.

I realised very recently that until I had DS I have literally never stuck up for myself in my whole life. I've had to challenge DM and dsis in order to stick up for DS and it has been truly awful at times.

I'm finally learning to stick up for myself but (as Richard Gere says I'm Pretty Woman) it's taken thousands in therapy to get anywhere near there.

You're not married to him anymore. He can't hurt you. Help them see that too if you can. They deserve to have lives too xx

I understand where you are coming from, but it's really important that the OP erects and maintains clear boundaries with her Ex.

The only way to help her children is to lead by example.

She can't make them see their father is a selfish and manipulative man because to do so she'd have to discuss/disclose his (many) flaws and poor behaviours.

That's feeds right into his playbook. That's she's nasty, mean and unreasonable.

Sadly they have to come to those conclusions for themselves. Something they won't/can't do if she keeps smoothing the way (even with the best of intentions).

The elder child in particular is behaving as if in FOG.

Acting out of fear, obligation and guilt (OP you might want to research FOG - outofthefog.website/toolbox-1/2015/11/17/fog-fear-obligation-guilt).

Fear of her father's disapproval, obligation to her half sibling and guilt about leaving him without childcare.

Part of living in FOG is a susceptibility to self sacrifice to appease the person responsible and the request to pay the OP for lifts is textbook.

They can't see the irony in spending their summer job money to subside their father not having to pay for childcare.

The OP won't help her children out of the FOG by railing against their father. She'll push them deeper into it as he manipulates them (and her) further.

She can only refuse to play his game by disengaging.

QueenBee52 · 08/08/2021 23:48

@billy1966

Kindly OP,

You have been utterly failing your children for facilitating and allowing them to be used by this man.

Do you wish them to grow up as complete doormats?

I'm glad to read you have now said No.

Verbalise clearly that YOU will NOT be used.

Nor will you facilitate in any way their bei g used either.

Be firm, strong, completely unapologetic for your stance.

Model NOT being a doormat to your children.

Flowers

Yip 🌸

SusieSusieSoo · 08/08/2021 22:25

OP glad you have stood up for yourself - could you also think about how you could help your dc's stand up for themselves?

I know a lot of pp's are saying they are old enough to stand up for themselves but if he is utterly awful to them it is incredibly hard for them to do this.

I agree that you were right to say no to the lifts but can you now help them to feel sufficiently empowered to say no to their "d"f?

At 40 something my then 70 something dm told me several times not to stick up for myself and young ds when my dsis was being incredibly difficult/nasty.

This was because she was scared my dsis would blow up/kick off like my "d"f used to do. DM would throw me & DS under a bus to avoid upsetting dsis. DF died many yrs ago so no longer have to deal with his shenanigans.

I realised very recently that until I had DS I have literally never stuck up for myself in my whole life. I've had to challenge DM and dsis in order to stick up for DS and it has been truly awful at times.

I'm finally learning to stick up for myself but (as Richard Gere says I'm Pretty Woman) it's taken thousands in therapy to get anywhere near there.

You're not married to him anymore. He can't hurt you. Help them see that too if you can. They deserve to have lives too xx

DeRigueurMortis · 08/08/2021 22:22

@Habber

I’m going to go to sleep now and just keep sticking to my guns thanks for your time in giving me advice on this

Sleep well.

You're not the "bad guy" here - quite the reverse.

Thanks
Habber · 08/08/2021 22:20

I’m going to go to sleep now and just keep sticking to my guns thanks for your time in giving me advice on this

OP posts:
DeRigueurMortis · 08/08/2021 22:13

@Habber

DC1 thought I am joking about the lifts and now offering me money to take them so they don’t have to stay overnight there

That not the solution.

It's not just about time or money. It's about boundaries.

It's not yours or their responsibility to provide free childcare for their father.

If they want to do this, then they are old enough to make that decision but not at the expense of dragging you or their sibling into the drama.

If that means staying overnight with their father that's the deal.

If they want to "negotiate" this point then they can do with their father who can give them a lift home or pay for an Uber after all the money he's saved on free childcare.

You need to make clear this is not your problem to solve.

Rinse and repeat as often as you need to in a calm, disinterested voice.

growinggreyer · 08/08/2021 22:09

She is now feeling the cognitive dissonance. That is good, push harder here. "So, you actually WANT to pay to babysit? You are aware that you could advertise yourself and other people would pay YOU to babysit?"

Another idea would be - what would you estimate 4 weeks petrol money would be? Perhaps offer that amount to your kids to share between them for treats for their summer holiday. They could be spending their time relaxing in the park, with snacks etc.

StoneofDestiny · 08/08/2021 22:05

He can pick them up and drop the off and pay them the going rate for babysitting - otherwise, it's a no go! He can't expect you and your kids to be running around and inconvenienced for his responsibilities - surely?

Swipe left for the next trending thread