Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister wanting to stay in our house

58 replies

Emrew05 · 08/08/2021 16:37

So my sister lives 100 miles away, moved away when she got with her husband. We get on well and what not but don't spend a massive amount of time together. We just don't gel together for long periods, our parenting views differ etc. Quick bit of a back story. My sister isn't known for a well kept house and things often mysteriously break when she borrows them... so we recently moved house. Our new house has a bigger garden and more living space. When my sister and her family came to see the new house one of the first things she said was that they had been talking about us and them doing a "house swap for a weekend". She described it as an air B&B style scenario. It felt a bit on the spot ish and after they left DH and I both agreed we don't really fancy it and it just felt odd. She now knows that we are going camping for the weekend and is asking when we are going (I'm guessing so she can ask if she can stay in our house while we are away). DH said he'll happily just tell her straight that he's not comfortable with it but they are more than welcome to stay to spend time with us. AIBU to want to make up an excuse to avoid the awkwardness of that (is it awkward or am I over thinking it?!)

Thanks for taking the time to read! 😊

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Emrew05 · 09/08/2021 16:27

@JosephineDeBeauharnais

Loving this thread as DH’s sister, her husband and DC landed on us uninvited this weekend with four hours notice. They’re traveling round GB for their hols from their home down south and so far have managed to blag free accommodation and meals for every night of the past week Grin and they’re by no means short of money. They were a bit reluctant to leave tbh and DH hissed at me “don’t tell them we’re away tomorrow night otherwise they’ll stay”. Grin They have form for doing that before- came one Xmas and when they found out we we’re going away for NYE just stayed on. We thought they were never going home Grin.
Haha! Glad I'm not the only one dealing with stuff like this!!!
OP posts:
JosephineDeBeauharnais · 09/08/2021 15:30

Loving this thread as DH’s sister, her husband and DC landed on us uninvited this weekend with four hours notice. They’re traveling round GB for their hols from their home down south and so far have managed to blag free accommodation and meals for every night of the past week Grin and they’re by no means short of money.
They were a bit reluctant to leave tbh and DH hissed at me “don’t tell them we’re away tomorrow night otherwise they’ll stay”. Grin
They have form for doing that before- came one Xmas and when they found out we we’re going away for NYE just stayed on. We thought they were never going home Grin.

Emrew05 · 09/08/2021 15:16

@GrandmaSteglitszch

YABU to want to make up a pathetic excuse that she won't believe anyway.

Leave it to DH, as you're too much of a wimp.

Phew....no punches held here!
OP posts:
Emrew05 · 09/08/2021 15:15

@TwoLeftElbows

I know PPs are right that no is a complete sentence etc.

IRL I would be tempted to go with something like "absolutely not, I'd have to do a tonne of cleaning and tidying to make it guest ready, I really can't do all that extra work on top of camping." She'll say oh but you don't need to, you say you would inevitably would for any guests, and it's just not an option on top of prep for camping. Point out and reject the extra work, rather than her. But then, I am a sap.

This is prob something I would do too with my husband in the background mouthing "just tell her straight!!!" 🤣🤣🤣
OP posts:
Emrew05 · 09/08/2021 15:13

[quote Newestname001]@Emrew05

I'm a shameless people pleaser that hate confrontation....totally right about the irony of the situation!

That's why she's asked you! She's got a tougher skin than you think so say No clearly, however nicely, so there's no room for her to negotiate.

BTW saying "no" is a useful life skill and gets easier the more you do it. 🌹[/quote]
You are right, she's pretty shameless to be honest, for example; one time while she was visiting she out of the blue asked me if I had any clothes or toys she could have for her son that mine had grown out of or didn't want anymore. If she was skint I could understand but her husband earns about 30k more than mine does and we don't struggle! So yes intentionally or not she's using the fact that I always try to help people and don't like to feel like I'm letting people down but that's on me to toughen up!

OP posts:
IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 09/08/2021 04:35

Good for you, southwestrunningmum, but the op isn't you, her sibling isn't your sibling and she doesn't want a messy person who breaks her belongings let loose in her home while she's not there. If you're fine with your messy relatives breaking your belongings then fair enough.

QueenBee52 · 09/08/2021 04:27

@Southwestrunningmum

I would not have an issue with any of my family staying in my home when away m.

I don't believe you 🤣

DerAlteMann · 09/08/2021 03:38

@Southwestrunningmum

I would not have an issue with any of my family staying in my home when away m.
I bloody would! No way would it happen and I don't care who gets offended.
TwoLeftElbows · 09/08/2021 02:02

I know PPs are right that no is a complete sentence etc.

IRL I would be tempted to go with something like "absolutely not, I'd have to do a tonne of cleaning and tidying to make it guest ready, I really can't do all that extra work on top of camping." She'll say oh but you don't need to, you say you would inevitably would for any guests, and it's just not an option on top of prep for camping. Point out and reject the extra work, rather than her. But then, I am a sap.

QueenBee52 · 09/08/2021 01:48

@WeightlossBarbie

Many years ago my BIL was going through a rough patch with my SIL who lived in NZ. We offered for BIL to come over and stay with us if he was going to end the relationship and wanted a break. He ended up patching things up with her but then asked if he could bring her over so they could have a working holiday whilst living with us. They expected us to discount their board for 6 months so they could fund trips and getaways. For context we don’t get along with SIL (the whole family have a strained relationship with her) . We politely declined and said that if they wanted to come over together they needed to fund their own place (just like we had) and we would let them stay for 2 weeks whilst they found a place. The offer was only extended to BIL to help him out in a time of need.

Moral of story is that although it can be socially uncomfortable or awkward to be assertive you do have to suck it up and just say no. If the person reacts rudely to you declining then they didn’t value or respect you as a friend or family member.

wow... good on you for saying No .. ☺️

Newestname001 · 09/08/2021 01:41

@Emrew05

I'm a shameless people pleaser that hate confrontation....totally right about the irony of the situation!

That's why she's asked you! She's got a tougher skin than you think so say No clearly, however nicely, so there's no room for her to negotiate.

BTW saying "no" is a useful life skill and gets easier the more you do it. 🌹

GrandmaSteglitszch · 09/08/2021 01:39

YABU to want to make up a pathetic excuse that she won't believe anyway.

Leave it to DH, as you're too much of a wimp.

WeightlossBarbie · 09/08/2021 01:34

Many years ago my BIL was going through a rough patch with my SIL who lived in NZ. We offered for BIL to come over and stay with us if he was going to end the relationship and wanted a break. He ended up patching things up with her but then asked if he could bring her over so they could have a working holiday whilst living with us. They expected us to discount their board for 6 months so they could fund trips and getaways. For context we don’t get along with SIL (the whole family have a strained relationship with her) . We politely declined and said that if they wanted to come over together they needed to fund their own place (just like we had) and we would let them stay for 2 weeks whilst they found a place. The offer was only extended to BIL to help him out in a time of need.

Moral of story is that although it can be socially uncomfortable or awkward to be assertive you do have to suck it up and just say no. If the person reacts rudely to you declining then they didn’t value or respect you as a friend or family member.

BizzyIzzyfruitpie · 09/08/2021 01:17

Yanbu - i wouldn’t let anyone stay in my house if I wasn’t there. I never understand it when people do house swaps. Couldn’t stand people snooping through my stuff ! I’d tell her straight.

QueenBee52 · 09/08/2021 00:46

Ultimately it's your house so your right to say no, but just seems a bit mean to me.

Define 'MEAN' ?

My sister isn't known for a well kept house and things often mysteriously break when she borrows them

OP stated clearly ... so would you seriously let someone who lives like this... carte blanche in your new home.. because I call bull shit.. It always amazes me how generous people are with 'other' people things... 😳

You sound nuts

Flavabobble · 09/08/2021 00:10

Ultimately it's your house so your right to say no, but just seems a bit mean to me.
Don't be ridiculous, it's not 'mean' to not want folk staying in your house when you're not there.

Whatinthelord · 09/08/2021 00:04

@HilaryBriss

I don't think you need to make up an excuse, just say no and explain that you don't want anyone staying in your house while you are not there.
This.

Don’t give a reason or “excuse”. You don’t need to justify why you don’t want someone in your house when you’re away.

Don’t avoid it by making up excuses because she’ll just pressure about another weekend. It’s good for her to know you have and can hold boundaries.

Tiana4 · 09/08/2021 00:00

@Emrew05

Thanks for the replies everyone, I think I just need to toughen up! I know she will take offence at anything that us honest so I'm essentially just trying to passify everyone!
Glad PPs replies have been helpful. It doesn't matter if yourDsis takes offence. She is asking for something that you don't want to do. It's your house, your family hole and your stuff and leave of mind whilst you are away . Just because Dsis thinks up something in her head, it doesn't mean you have to go along with it! If she "takes offence" then she has issues nor you. You are allowed to say "no thankyou" anytime you want. I'd encourage you to do it more,
Emrew05 · 08/08/2021 20:19

Oh and those who mentioned a spare key, not to worry there isn't one. Only me and DH have one! Phew! 😄

OP posts:
Emrew05 · 08/08/2021 20:18

Very true! 😊 thank you

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 08/08/2021 20:13

I wouldn’t try to pacify anyone trying to stay in my house!

Howshouldibehave · 08/08/2021 20:11

‘No, I don’t want to’, is a good enough answer.

Emrew05 · 08/08/2021 20:11

Thanks for the replies everyone, I think I just need to toughen up! I know she will take offence at anything that us honest so I'm essentially just trying to passify everyone!

OP posts:
Emrew05 · 08/08/2021 20:10

@MBM18

Definitely don't make excuses otherwise she'll keep asking and you'll run out of them. Just say no and be honest with your reasonings, however awkward it'll be 😬

Always makes me laugh how some of us feel awkward saying no to cheeky requests but the person asking has no shame! (Don't worry OP, I am the person who feels awkward saying no too!)

I'm a shameless people pleaser that hate confrontation....totally right about the irony of the situation!
OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 08/08/2021 20:05

You tell her "No" and that's all you need to say. All these pp suggesting ridiculous excuses, just ignore that nonsense. You're an adult, you don't need to make excuses for anything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread