Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get rid of an AGA

135 replies

Cookiedough123 · 08/08/2021 15:50

Can someone tell me whether they would swap an AGA for a range cooker for example..

We are possibly buying a house with an AGA. It's run on gas. Are they worth it? Apparently the gas bill is between 125-200 a month! These are people who have their heating on a lot though.. I am a bit more scrimpy. I am keen to keep but BF wants to get rid.

Can I have thoughts on an AGA please

OP posts:
FlowerPower3110 · 11/08/2021 16:45

I love love love our (electric) Aga, but it definitely took some time getting used to. I'd suggest waiting a couple of months before you make a decision.

CMZ2018 · 11/08/2021 15:05

Ours is LPG doesn’t cost nearly that much, I’d estimate £2 a day. I’d keep it they’re fantastic, ours is off in the summer though and we use the electric aga mate

EmmaStone · 11/08/2021 14:51

The house we bought had an Aga, and we removed it.

Pros: made amazing pancakes
was nice to rest your bum on a cold day
kettle was always warm
kitchen was always warm (we moved in autumn)
it heated our water so we always had hot water (although if the tank was emptied after 3 showers, it still needed time to refill)

Cons: we were being bankrupted in oil costs
we're generally out of the house from 7:30am to 6pm (when it's not Covid...), so seemed exceptionally wasteful
Because of the short amount of time actually in the house, I needed to be able to control temperature for cooking
No space for a 'summer' oven, so would have had to keep on all year around - when we viewed the house in the summer, they basically kept all downstairs doors open constantly.

Some of the arguments we were given for keeping them just didn't work for me - when I do the washing, I generally do 3-5 loads a day. I could dry about 1/4 of a load on the Aga, and it would always be in the way of me trying to cook, and I didn't really want clean clothes in my kitchen being used to prep/cook food. I also managed to burn some clothes that were drying on the Aga, which didn't fill me with confidence that it was a safe thing to do.

As for converting it, the cost was also eye watering, and I wasn't convinced electric was going to be the best method for us either.

We couldn't sell ours in the end - it was an oil Aga, and these are very out of fashion, we had to pay someone to come and take it away.

We now have an electric range oven with an induction hob, I can switch it on and off and choose the temperature at will. What a luxury!?! Be aware though that Agas are also not standard widths, so if you do decide to replace it, you'll need to come up with a solution on how to bridge the gap left (we had 1 unit next to it which we had moved as part of a general kitchen refrub - we couldn't afford to re-do the kitchen, but you may be able to ). We're now the only house in the village without an Aga (probably an overstatement, but every house I've been to in our small village has one), so could be deemed as devaluing the house, but seeing as we plan to be here for a very long time, I'll live with that!

CruCru · 11/08/2021 14:14

AGA pans are awesome too. Ours have lasted and lasted.

DelphiniumTea · 09/08/2021 10:41

Phurnacite apparently. I have been corrected. Never seen it written down before.

DelphiniumTea · 09/08/2021 10:31

Indeed they can last 50+ years so in that respect are good for environment than rushing out to replace it with a new range cooker!

My mil has had hers 70 years this year and it was already in the house when they moved in so will be years older than that even. It originally ran on furnacite but had it converted to oil a decade ago. Think how many standard ovens you'd need to buy in that length of time!

FullMoonInsomnia · 09/08/2021 09:42

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

Chill, Aga-lovers. I'm not coming to take away your ridiculous lumps of cast-iron.

It's just personal preference. I spent a decade with no choice but to dry my laundry in the room where I lived, cooked and slept. I'm damned if I'm going to live like that, now that I have an option. If you want to live with laundry all over your kitchen, that's your choice.

It’s not all over the kitchen. It’s out of the way in a pulley and dries like a dream. Saves a lot of money and is super convenient.
callmeadoctor · 09/08/2021 09:40

We love ours, laundry goes on the pulley above every evening, its dry by the morning (no need for tumble drier). (Not left all over the kitchen). The posters saying about the length of time to boil a kettle suggests that their Aga needs a service. Indeed they can last 50+ years so in that respect are good for environment than rushing out to replace it with a new range cooker! Serviced and used properly they are no worse than others, however unfortunately many people do not do this.

Elsielouise13 · 08/08/2021 23:31

Love our AGA. We all gravitate to it like the giant radiator it is. Am sure I’d be Nigella without it but with it we are fantastic at pizza, bread, anything roasted and our kitchen is always toasty. We have an Aga Companion if it gets too warm in the summer but this year it’s stayed on.

tinselvestsparklepants · 08/08/2021 23:26

Flowerycurtain did you convert yours to electric / solar? We have inherited one in our new house and it is run on oil - would love to change to solar. Any hints / tips would be appreciated.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 08/08/2021 22:53

Chill, Aga-lovers. I'm not coming to take away your ridiculous lumps of cast-iron.

It's just personal preference. I spent a decade with no choice but to dry my laundry in the room where I lived, cooked and slept. I'm damned if I'm going to live like that, now that I have an option. If you want to live with laundry all over your kitchen, that's your choice.

leli · 08/08/2021 22:51

I have a 4 oven oil fired AGA. I bought the house because of it. We all love it. We use it for cooking, clothes drying and comfort. DH in particular loves it and feels he can cook on it. It is too hot for a hot summer so we have a scrappy 2nd electric cooker for the hot bit of the summer.

But AGA is going in a month's time. We've gone electric with the car and I feel guilty about the huge oil tank in the garden, expensive yes, but also environmentally unsound. So AGA is going and Everhot (electric heat storage range cooker) is coming. We are replacing our ancient kitchen at the same time.

Apparently the Everett emits less heat, is powered with electricity so we can choose renewable, has a part induction hob and is generally much more eco and flexible. Here's hoping. Bet I'll still the AGA though.

MauveMagnolia · 08/08/2021 22:49

We never has a hairdryer growing up- dried our hair over the aga.

And we had a lamb in the warming oven once.

Sleepingdogs12 · 08/08/2021 22:48

We had one which we loved but we had another cooker and turned it off in the summer. We moved and haven't had another and can't say I have missed it . I would try it and see how you feel about it. They are lovely to look at. I was disappointed the heat never seemed to circulate around the house much in winter though.

LemonRoses · 08/08/2021 22:43

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

My granny had to dry the laundry over the Rayburn, but she had no choice - and it was also her only source of heat and hot water. It's beyond me why anyone who can afford an Aga these days would choose to faff around with drying the laundry in the kitchen.
We do send laundry out - bedding, shirts and towels. I don’t send many other clothes out to the commercial laundry though. If the children are home they may need laundry turned around quickly and not have time to wait for the laundry to be collected and returned.

It’s not a faff at all. A simple A frame stand above the Aga overnight. If there was more, I’d use the Sheila but generally with two of us, the Aga top aired is sufficient.

FullMoonInsomnia · 08/08/2021 22:39

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

Personally I use a Lakeland dryer *@MauveMagnolia*. Costs 5p per hour and I don't have wet washing all over my kitchen.
No but you have wet washing on the drier steaming up the room which is a lot more hassle. I know as I have one. They are useless and a lot more hassle than a pulley .
Shmithecat2 · 08/08/2021 22:38

@3luckystars

I can’t believe they cost that much to run!! That’s shocking! I pulled into a petrol station once and the car in front of me had put €100+ into their car I just don’t know how people afford to spend that much on fuel. I could not pay that much for it to go up in smoke, it’s like burning money (to me anyway, I am not wealthy though so feel free to ignore my opinion) I don’t see the attraction of them, except the fun we had spitting on my grandparents one as children and watching it roll off and disappear, but that’s not worth €150 a week though. Grin Anyway, good luck with it whatever you decide.
Eh? My car has a 95ltr tank, so it's always going to cost more than £100 to fill it. Different cars have different fuel tank capacities. It's no different to filling a 50ltr tank twice Confused
LemonRoses · 08/08/2021 22:37

I think they are a joy for certain lifestyles. We love ours - but turn it on and off if we are away, in the summer etc. We have an alternative stove for summer.
For the other three seasons, it earns its place. Cooking, drying clothes and shoes, heating half the house, stopping pans rusting, saving ironing, airing things, sterilising preserving jars, warming plates, during fruit or herbs and giving a focus and welcome to the kitchen. It’s lovely but not especially cheap to run. Ours is on a timer, so cheaper than most but still not a budget option. They are also large and take up a lot of space,
If you like a quick stir fry and use a tumbler drier, they may not suit. If you’ve a larger family or entertain a lot and like slow cooking, they are perfect.

MauveMagnolia · 08/08/2021 22:32

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

Personally I use a Lakeland dryer *@MauveMagnolia*. Costs 5p per hour and I don't have wet washing all over my kitchen.
So where do you have wet washing? Where does the heated dryer go? You need a ventilated room with solid flooring and heating? Do you have a drying room?

I am pretty sure that an Aga dries it quick than a heated dryer?

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 08/08/2021 22:30

Personally I use a Lakeland dryer @MauveMagnolia. Costs 5p per hour and I don't have wet washing all over my kitchen.

MissM2912 · 08/08/2021 22:27

Keep it. We have a four oven oil one and it is fab. It was particularly good during lock down when working from home and the kitchen/ family room was lovely and warm all the time.
We turn ours off May to September and I really miss it.

MauveMagnolia · 08/08/2021 22:21

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

My granny had to dry the laundry over the Rayburn, but she had no choice - and it was also her only source of heat and hot water. It's beyond me why anyone who can afford an Aga these days would choose to faff around with drying the laundry in the kitchen.
How else would you dry it? It rains a lot in the UK?

Or do you mean they would send there laundry out to be cleaned? Surely no-one does that?

FullMoonInsomnia · 08/08/2021 22:21

It’s not a faff. If you have a pulley above it the washing dries really quickly. It saves having a tumble drier.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 08/08/2021 22:15

My granny had to dry the laundry over the Rayburn, but she had no choice - and it was also her only source of heat and hot water. It's beyond me why anyone who can afford an Aga these days would choose to faff around with drying the laundry in the kitchen.

FullMoonInsomnia · 08/08/2021 22:13

We had one when I was growing up. It dried the washing, heated the house and the the hot water. The people who bought the house ripped it out. 😒

Swipe left for the next trending thread