Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get rid of an AGA

135 replies

Cookiedough123 · 08/08/2021 15:50

Can someone tell me whether they would swap an AGA for a range cooker for example..

We are possibly buying a house with an AGA. It's run on gas. Are they worth it? Apparently the gas bill is between 125-200 a month! These are people who have their heating on a lot though.. I am a bit more scrimpy. I am keen to keep but BF wants to get rid.

Can I have thoughts on an AGA please

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cookiedough123 · 22/08/2021 21:02

Thanks after joining the I love my AGA group and some of the posts I definitely think it might be worth trying it for 12 months. We could also turn it off in summer as the kitchen has a built in microwave/oven thing. Just need to learn how to use it out. The thing that I'm suprised at is the cost of pots and pans!! I've had cheap asda ones for 3 years now and still looking good. Wondering if they will all need replacing etc.

OP posts:
Shadowboy · 17/08/2021 22:14

Ours is a Sandyford but basically an AGA. I do t understand why people pay so much to run them… so far this year we have put into the oil tank £500 of oil but it’s still half full. Ours also does the hot water and radiators. So per month ours costs about £42 in oil. It’s on all the time but turned right down when it’s hot so we BBQ instead.

RinkyStinky1 · 17/08/2021 22:10

@user1471447863

You can certainly spot the mansion dwellers on this thread, with their football pitch sized kitchens that can fit an aga and a normal Cooker (for the summer only) + summer kettle, summer toaster clothes airers etc. Now back in the rest of the world we have to trip over the kids handwashing step stool every time we manoever between the cooker and fridge.
And? Are people with larger houses not welcome?
Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 17/08/2021 22:08

I did live in a vast 5 bed house with an Aga for a year and it was just unacceptable in terms of energy consumption.

user1471447863 · 17/08/2021 13:23

You can certainly spot the mansion dwellers on this thread, with their football pitch sized kitchens that can fit an aga and a normal Cooker (for the summer only) + summer kettle, summer toaster clothes airers etc.
Now back in the rest of the world we have to trip over the kids handwashing step stool every time we manoever between the cooker and fridge.

tilder · 16/08/2021 21:52

Am loving the way people try to convince themselves having an Aga is an energy efficient way of life. It's really not.

www.ethicalconsumer.org/home-garden/shopping-guide/gas-electric-cookers

Plus a myriad others.

If you want one, own it and be honest about the fuel consumption. Maybe switch to electric and a renewable source.

LuaDipa · 16/08/2021 17:15

[quote PattyPan]@LuaDipa so you bought two kettles and toasters and a specific airer, and most people with an AGA seem to have a second cooker for summer as well. Surely that duplication is much more expensive than just having a normal cooker, kettle, toaster and airer? Plus a waste of space[/quote]
You are forgetting that I didn’t buy the AGA or the alternative cooker, I simply inherited them when I moved house. Then took the decision to embrace it and bought a stovetop kettle, toasted sandwich maker and airer to fit on the advice of a very knowledgeable chap who told my that all of this would help me to maximise my usage. I already had (and still have) an electric kettle and toaster from my previous house, they are just popped away over winter. It would have cost me far more to rip the AGA out. Plus my kitchen is huge, it’s one of the reasons I chose this house.

PattyPan · 16/08/2021 16:58

@LuaDipa so you bought two kettles and toasters and a specific airer, and most people with an AGA seem to have a second cooker for summer as well. Surely that duplication is much more expensive than just having a normal cooker, kettle, toaster and airer? Plus a waste of space

LemonRoses · 16/08/2021 16:51

left the £6k noisy lump of hokum behind.

In defence of our Aga, it is silent and there are absolutely no lingering cooking smells. It cost a whole lot more than 6K though - you should have sold it.

BurningTheToast · 16/08/2021 14:41

I'd do a course - Sarah Whittaker's Zoom demos are fantastic - and live with it for a bit. If you like it, but don't fancy the gas bills/fossil fuel aspect, then you could have it converted to the Electrickit system which makes it a lot more controllable and flexible. And join the I Love My Aga Facebook group - loads of advice there for new Aga cooks.

LuaDipa · 16/08/2021 14:26

@NotMeNoNo

Well if I left my Neff oven on all the time, I wouldn't have to wait for it to heat up and it would make the kitchen hot. That would be a waste of electric though.. oh hang on.
Well possibly, although I very much doubt a Neff or other electric oven would heat my kitchen or withstand a period of continuous use.

I don’t see it as a waste at all, and I don’t think it’s much more expensive when you tot everything up. The engineer who serviced ours when we first moved in is a real enthusiast and gave me some great tips on how to get the best of it and recommended some excellent cookbooks in the same vein. On his advice I bought an Aga kettle and toasted sandwich maker (our electric kettle and toaster are put away in winter), have a special rack that hooks over the front to dry our clothes when it’s too wet to line dry (our drier is seldom used in winter or summer) and I often leave a meal cooking all day (or all night). The fact it’s constantly on doesn’t necessarily mean it’s wasteful, it just means it’s constantly used. I’m not a domestic type, but all of these things make my life easier. Plus we rarely have the heating on only at the kitchen end of the house as it heats far more than just the kitchen. I wouldn’t go so far as to say it saves energy or money, but I don’t think it uses as much power as you might think given it’s multiple uses.

Honestly, until we moved in I had the same opinion as you, and I certainly wouldn’t have chosen it beforehand. But you really can’t compare it to a standard oven as it does so much more.

NotMeNoNo · 16/08/2021 12:44

Well if I left my Neff oven on all the time, I wouldn't have to wait for it to heat up and it would make the kitchen hot. That would be a waste of electric though.. oh hang on.

LuaDipa · 16/08/2021 12:22

@TheDivineOddity

Definitely keep the Aga, yes they're generally expensive to run but it's also your kettle, your toaster, your slow cooker, your clothes dryer and airer as well as your oven. Your kitchen will also always be warm and welcoming. If you do get this house op then allow yourself six months or so with the Aga and then make your decision.
This.

I hated mine (oil fired, we don’t have mains gas) when we moved in and was terrified to use it. I’m not a domestic goddess and like things as easy as possible and the thought of it scared me to death. After a week I was hooked. It can be used for all of the above and it makes the kitchen so warm and cosy in winter. No waiting for the hob or oven to heat, just bang it in. Super handy and saves loads of time. You can also leave casseroles etc overnight or all day in the simmering oven and it’s pretty much impossible to burn anything in there. Plus, and I may be biased, but everything tastes better when cooked in the Aga.

Ours does go off in the summer as it is just too hot, so I would ensure you have an alternative just in case. We inherited an all singing, all dancing electric oven as well as the electric side of the Aga so plenty of capacity in summer.

Give it a try and I think you will love it.

AngelicaSchuylerAndHerSisters · 16/08/2021 00:14

I hated my aga. I would never have another one. I cook a lot and found it too restrictive.

user1471447863 · 16/08/2021 00:11

Hydrogen boiler. All your new boilers are meant to be hydrogen compatible (sub 1 hour conversion of something) soon enough as one of the plans is to change the natural gas supply over to hydrogen. Air source heat pumps just won't be an option for many existing homes.

Of course there hydrogen will come from collecting unicorn farts or something...

MauveMagnolia · 15/08/2021 22:39

@Ritasueandbobtoo9

Solar, green electricity. Have a A rated house.
Can’t have solar here.
Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 15/08/2021 22:38

Solar, green electricity. Have a A rated house.

PattyPan · 15/08/2021 22:30

@MauveMagnolia solar? Heat pump? 100% renewable electricity tariff?

MauveMagnolia · 15/08/2021 20:48

@Ritasueandbobtoo9

As above: We have maybe 25 years to save the earth and people are happily using fossil fuels to ensure that they look a bit “country”. It is pretty shocking really.
How do you heat your home and water?
Cherrysoup · 14/08/2021 10:38

I’d get rid. My mother has one, I hate it. It’s boiling in her kitchen and my room which is above. It does boost the heating and hot water, tho.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 14/08/2021 10:26

As above: We have maybe 25 years to save the earth and people are happily using fossil fuels to ensure that they look a bit “country”. It is pretty shocking really.

user1471447863 · 14/08/2021 09:59

While certainly not an environmentalist id say they sound like the worst thing ever from an environmental, efficiency and usability standpoint.
I wouldn't even say stick it on Facebook marketplace, go straight for weighing it in for scrap.
Everybody here with one either melts in summer or has a 'summer oven' - so basically a proper oven that they could just use all year.
As for you don't need a kettle - well you have your special aga kettle that probably cost more than half a dozen electric kettles, that you can continue to use in summer when you finally turn the Aga off. The toast might be nice but it would be easier to just press the handle down on a conventional toaster - which you would need anyway in the summer if you turn the Aga off.
For those that aren't still living in the '50s and have unchained their women folk from the kitchen, let them wear shoes, not be pregnant and go to work then your house is empty most of the day and this daft thing is pumping out unnecessary heat all day benefiting nobody.
On top of that you have to go on a course to learn how to use one! Everything else you just follow the instructions on the back of the thing you are trying to cook (40 mins in a 200°C preheated oven - one knob to turn and done).
Seriously phone a scrap man to come take it away and get yourself a nice electric oven and either a 5 ring gas hob or induction hob.
Between the scrap money and and the gas savings they'll be paid for in no time

NotMeNoNo · 11/08/2021 19:02

We had one in a rented house for a while, despite being a modern one I didn't get on with it at all. I'd replace it with a normal cooker - even if you can afford to run it the fuel consumption/carbon emissions are embarrassing.

leli · 11/08/2021 18:25

None of the AGA lovers are attacking those who don’t like them. “£6k noisy lump of hokum” is a bit harsh! I love mine (though it’s being replaced). It is silent and works brilliantly. For those of us who live in places where it rains and is grey and cold much of the year then an AGA is a friend.

DivaVergent · 11/08/2021 17:40

These old bangers seem to impress some people as a lifestyle/status symbol, but I really don't care at all what other people think of my equipment. Grin

Why not choose a cooker/oven on the basis that it does what I want, when I want? An Aga or similar requires slavish attention - one I bought with the house made the kitchen so hot in the summer I had to install a room fan which helped only slightly and when I moved I left the £6k noisy lump of hokum behind.