Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I can’t look at this tombstone without seeing a fanjo

114 replies

UnitedWire · 08/08/2021 13:23

Aibu? I mean … I guess it must be a stylised letter M, but …

I can’t look at this tombstone without seeing a fanjo
I can’t look at this tombstone without seeing a fanjo
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UnitedWire · 08/08/2021 22:00

@user16395699

Calling a poster's views on the distasteful nature of your thread "rubbish" is hardly polite.

They were public statements of identity/status and now they are part of the urban fabric. That context matters, I think

The fact that we are still ultimately talking about human beings matters more.

If you just wanted to discuss the symbol, why post an extra image including their names?

You've literally started a thread mocking a memorial in honour of people's dead loved ones. How is it anything other than a piss-take?

I absolutely didn’t call that poster’s views “rubbish”. You’re not telling the truth. In fact, you saying that makes me wonder if you’re just her under a different username.

I responded politely to her a couple of times. When I did sufficiently rise to her remarks to wheel out the (really quite gentle) term “rubbish”, it was in very specific reference to the completely unnecessary it’s not difficult sarcasm she had previously directed at me, not to her views.

As for “human beings”: yes, it’s because I find human beings and their stories interesting that I like reading old stones in the first place. If a Victorian family used stylised initials on their public memorial that also look a bit like a fanjo, whether intentionally or otherwise, well, that’s totally fascinating to me and absolutely no insult to them. It is a completely legitimate thing to be amazed by and to discuss.

A lot of people telling me off seem to have no awareness that it’s possible to find something amusing not for purposes of taking the piss, but in the context of loving the fact that you’ve stumbled across it, being totally intrigued by it and laughing and wanting other people to see and like it too.

This idea that the only form of respectful interaction with a historic gravestone is serious, reverent, discreet — I’m sorry, it’s just not the case. Amusement is fine. Honest speculation is fine. Posting images of historic monuments online is absolutely fine — there are huge websites dedicated to doing this. These stones are not private. They’re literally designed to be public.

If I were going “bunch of repressed Victorians, I bet they had no idea it looks like a cunt! Clueless idiots lol”, then yes, that would be a piss-take. Obviously, very obviously from my posts I’d say, that’s not where I’m coming from though Hmm

OP posts:
TheMarzipanDildo · 08/08/2021 21:43

EverybodyIsInteresting

I like the way you think Wink

EverybodyIsInteresting · 08/08/2021 21:39

@TheMarzipanDildo

When I’m dead, you all have permission to mock my tombstone Grin

I won’t be too bothered (because I’ll be dead and it’ll be my loved ones fault if there is a picture of a woman bending over on it)

Let me know where, and I'll construct a marzipan dildo every year and leave it graveside on the anniversary of this post.
TheMarzipanDildo · 08/08/2021 21:39

@ShowOfHands

I saw an interesting gravestone in Scotland. In fact I photographed it, though I won't put the picture on here. Changing names it said...

In loving memory of
John
His wife Laura
Their daughter Laura Jr
His wife Jane
His daughter Annie
Annie's Mum Clara

All in the same grave. The man died last and chose the be interred with his two wives, child from his first marriage, child who appeared much later and a poor woman who didn't get to be described on her own merits.

It was quite remarkable.

Shock John sounds like a bit of a one
TheMarzipanDildo · 08/08/2021 21:36

When I’m dead, you all have permission to mock my tombstone Grin

I won’t be too bothered (because I’ll be dead and it’ll be my loved ones fault if there is a picture of a woman bending over on it)

terrywynne · 08/08/2021 21:30

Whilst the language used in the OP is bound to cause controversy I'm actually quite reassured that strangers are interested enough to discuss a memorial that is over 200 years old - whether in terms of iconography or in terms of how we speak about memorials/show respect.

Memorials are the property of the family and the reality is that, once the immediately family have died, they are often not cared for (beyond basic health and safety repairs). Thousands of memorials around the country from the last 100 years or so are now broken and illegible. And then there are the memorials that are:

  • turned over and used for someone else, damaged by iconoclasts, used as paving slabs, relocated to the edge of a churchyard to make space for new burials, moved to a dark corner of a church to make space for whatever the latest liturgical changes were, destroyed because the churchyard is being turned into a road/building/car park etc.

That these people had a memorial (so many didn't), that is still legible, and that people are interested in it is pretty impressive in the grand scheme of 1000s of years of burials.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 08/08/2021 21:02

The fact that we are still ultimately talking about human beings matters more

I can't speak for everyone, but I'm pretty sure most people are talking about the headstone and not the people.

If you just wanted to discuss the symbol, why post an extra image including their names

Presumably for context. I agree it's not wholly required, but I don't think it's a huge issue.

You've literally started a thread mocking a memorial in honour of people's dead loved ones. How is it anything other than a piss-take

To be accurate 'a memorial of long dead people's long dead loved ones'.

There's nobody alive now that will remember any of them. And it's an observation. Nobody is mocking it. Some people are amused by it. Some not. But being amused by something is not the same as mocking it.

RoastedHazelnutLatte · 08/08/2021 20:49

[quote Treacletoots]Here it is..

m.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/10/29/vagina-gravestone-milan-marinkovic-wifes-vulva-tomb_n_2039378.html[/quote]
"A true likeness was achieved as Milena helpfully left a series of close-up photos of her vagina"

Bloody hilarious!

user16395699 · 08/08/2021 20:39

Calling a poster's views on the distasteful nature of your thread "rubbish" is hardly polite.

They were public statements of identity/status and now they are part of the urban fabric. That context matters, I think

The fact that we are still ultimately talking about human beings matters more.

If you just wanted to discuss the symbol, why post an extra image including their names?

You've literally started a thread mocking a memorial in honour of people's dead loved ones. How is it anything other than a piss-take?

BSintolerant · 08/08/2021 20:38

As for whether or not posters are offended, when people describe something as being in bad or poor taste, or disrespectful those terms are synonymous with the word “offensive.” It’s easy to assume these posters are offended, even if they claim they’re not.

Not many people would say, “This is a hilarious thread, but I’m not amused by it.” Wink

Disneycharacter · 08/08/2021 20:36

Looks like a bare arse bending over

Weirdlynormal · 08/08/2021 20:35

@Greydove28

Wow, you need to take a look at yourself. This is really poor taste! Can't believe you put a photo on too.
Oh give over. It's a 300 year old tombstone.
ShowOfHands · 08/08/2021 20:25

I saw an interesting gravestone in Scotland. In fact I photographed it, though I won't put the picture on here. Changing names it said...

In loving memory of
John
His wife Laura
Their daughter Laura Jr
His wife Jane
His daughter Annie
Annie's Mum Clara

All in the same grave. The man died last and chose the be interred with his two wives, child from his first marriage, child who appeared much later and a poor woman who didn't get to be described on her own merits.

It was quite remarkable.

Greydove28 · 08/08/2021 20:22

Wow, you need to take a look at yourself. This is really poor taste! Can't believe you put a photo on too.

Carboholic · 08/08/2021 20:20

@BSintolerant It goes to show there’s no rest for the wicked!

Shock Amazing!! Smile

Carboholic · 08/08/2021 20:18

It’s clearly a dentist’s tombstone and this is a stylised molar Grin

(Or a tasteful feminist depiction of a 300yo fanjo.)

UnitedWire · 08/08/2021 20:18

Muddy, in my earlier posts I’ve explained I’m not just “taking the mick”. This symbol is in a public place, it’s unusual and looks slightly racy, so it raised a smile. That’s not hurting or insulting anyone or invading anyone’s privacy. There’s literally no reason to blur out the names on the stone.

You are not the final arbiter of taste and nor am I obviously, it’s subjective and context-dependent. Not sure why you keep saying “just blur the names”.

You can feel differently of course but you are mischaracterising the post by insisting it’s a cynical piss-take.

OP posts:
BSintolerant · 08/08/2021 20:09

@Postitmug

Marvellous OP! Without doubt, a fanjo Grin

Bonus points for enraging all the joyless prudes trying to protect the identity of those on the gravestone. Imagine being outed so humiliatingly whilst trying to enjoy one's second or third century of eternal rest.

It goes to show there’s no rest for the wicked! Wink
Wingedharpy · 08/08/2021 20:00

I wonder if it is just something as simple as the stonemason dying before he finished it?
Compared to the ornate swirly things on the side (you can tell I'm an expert with the terminology), the carving under discussion looks a bit crude/basic/unfinished.
Or maybe the family ran out of money and just paid for what was done up to that point?

MuddyStiletto · 08/08/2021 19:52

@UnitedWire it's about the symbol, so just blur the names..I have made my point
I'm on board for any piss take but not one about memorials
You don't know whether is cultural or personal, it doesn't matter
It's distasteful to take the mick

Postitmug · 08/08/2021 19:51

Marvellous OP! Without doubt, a fanjo Grin

Bonus points for enraging all the joyless prudes trying to protect the identity of those on the gravestone. Imagine being outed so humiliatingly whilst trying to enjoy one's second or third century of eternal rest.

Bimblybomeyelash · 08/08/2021 19:43

*MuddyStiletto

Then blur the names as previously suggested 🙄 it's not difficult @UnitedWire*

Why? Because you said so?

phishy · 08/08/2021 19:32

Sorry but that is soooooo boring, was expecting something more.

UnitedWire · 08/08/2021 19:26

@MuddyStiletto

Then blur the names as previously suggested 🙄 it's not difficult *@UnitedWire*
Muddy fgs, I’m not going to get the photo of a historic tombstone in a busy public location taken down and repost it with blurred names, on the basis of a few people’s opinions about this light-hearted discussion of a carved symbol on it being in poor taste.

If I thought it looked like something else, a surprising cultural symbol maybe, would that be in poor taste? No, it’s only because fanjos have been mentioned and a glimmer of humour is involved that anyone’s getting aerated about taste. Which is really silly. And IMO slightly sad.

I’ve acknowledged your opinion politely but it’s not one I agree with. Nor was it the point of the thread so please knock it off with the “it’s not difficult” rubbish.

OP posts:
LanaDelBoy · 08/08/2021 19:15

I can't unsee it either! The little indents on either side suggest it MUST be intentional...?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread