Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being irritated at "would of, could of....."

335 replies

DuchessOfDisaster · 08/08/2021 10:46

I cringe when I see this written down. Along with "defiantly" for definitely and other examples. I don't see there is ever any excuse. And the excuse that "language evolves" doesn't wash, because "to of" is not a verb and never will be no matter how language evolves. It's not the same as adopting words from other cultures, new words like selfies, or a different meaning for "sick", for example.

OK, when we say "would've", "could've" etc, it may SOUND similar, but that's no excuse either. It implies the writer has never seen "would have" etc written down, therefore doesn't read much. What did they do at school? Was this style of writing used then and never corrected?

Another cringeworthy example is the inability to differentiate between there/they're/their and your/you're.

Just why do people do it and worse, why is it excused?

OP posts:
FangsForTheMemory · 09/08/2021 16:31

People don't read enough. Even on the internet, most of what you see written has come from someone who understands the rudiments of grammar. However if people get most of their information aurally, they miss the distinction between 'of' and 'have'.

LizzieW1969 · 09/08/2021 16:28

It was always a thing, simply because it’s the way ‘would have’ is pronounced. English is a language that uses contractions, like ‘isn’t’ for ‘is not’.

The proper contraction of ‘would have’ is ‘would’ve’, not ‘would of’, which is meaningless.

CecilyP · 09/08/2021 16:20

To be fair this was in the late 70s when 'would of' was just not a thing.

Thanks for your explanation, Pointythings. However ‘would of’ really was a thing. I remember an English teacher in 2nd or 3rd year secondary telling class it was ‘would have’ not ‘would of’. I don’t think I was one one of the culprits but there must have been enough people doing it for her to say it to the whole class. This was a selective school in the 1960s.

pointythings · 09/08/2021 16:06

CecilyP obviously not. I came into a British school in year 6 with very little written or spoken English. I picked it up as I went along, doing as much of the work as I could alongside work sent by my Dutch school. I struggled until around Christmas and then it just fell into place. Spoken English definitely came first, the written stuff followed. To be fair this was in the late 70s when 'would of' was just not a thing.

Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 15:38

@Eilatan2018

I work with a medical secretary who says ‘we was’ rather than we were and it infuriates me! Just sounds so thick!
That’s pretty racist.
CecilyP · 09/08/2021 15:34

Fair enough, Pointythings, but are you saying you just learned to speak English without doing any writing?

CecilyP · 09/08/2021 15:32

I work with a medical secretary who says ‘we was’ rather than we were and it infuriates me! Just sounds so thick!

That’s more a dialect thing. If you’re brought up by and with people who say, ‘we was’, you are much more likely to continue to use it yourself.

pointythings · 09/08/2021 15:24

CecilyP I did not learn my English in the classroom. I learned it by immersion when I was 10. I was clueless about English grammar until I started doing my mum's marking for her. (She taught English in a Dutch secondary school). I was older, but I learned English in the same way British people learn it, by hearing and speaking it.

Eilatan2018 · 09/08/2021 15:24

I work with a medical secretary who says ‘we was’ rather than we were and it infuriates me! Just sounds so thick!

CecilyP · 09/08/2021 15:15

lazylinguist

As has been explained a million times...nobody is saying "could of". They are saying "could've"

Nope. Lots of them are saying 'could of'. That's why they also type 'could of'.

I have certainly noticed in recent years, some people (not necessarily lots) actually saying, ‘could of’ rather than ‘could’ve’ It’s almost like they think ‘could’ve’ isn’t formal enough and are trying to correct it.

CecilyP · 09/08/2021 15:04

Yesterday 20:00 pointythings

I hate it too. I am a foreign national, though fully bilingual. If I can get these basic things right, so should native Brits.

I disagree, pointythings. If you learn English as a foreign language in a classroom, you will be learning to write it at the same time as learning to speak it. You will be learning ‘to have’ before ‘could have’; you will be unlikely to be taught the contraction ‘could’ve’ first. Native speakers will have heard could’ve for years before learning to write, and ‘could’ve’ and ‘could of’ sound remarkably similar.

I think a lot of it is to do with people not reading for pleasure. You get a really good feel for a language just by reading and it doesn't have to be serious literature.

Again, I disagree. Some things need to be taught and understood. They are not picked up subliminally from reading. Most people who make these mistakes can read perfectly well.

DuchessOfDisaster · 09/08/2021 14:54

@JaniieJones

'This has really upset you, hasn't it? You mentioned on the first page that someone once pulled you up on poor SPAG. It's okay to let it go. They can't hurt you.'

No, they can't hurt me you're right. Thankyou for reassuring me Grin. I'm pulled up on poor soag all the time, I could not give a rat's ass as luckily I have a wealth of fabulous attributes to compensate.

My point is the people wanging on about poor spag seem to be such patronising arses! It baffles me why they get so hung up on would have/of when tbh their superiority complexes are far more embarrassing than any missed comma or spag error.

There's nothing wrong with how you write.
OP posts:
ChameleonKola · 09/08/2021 14:03

@JaniieJones

'This has really upset you, hasn't it? You mentioned on the first page that someone once pulled you up on poor SPAG. It's okay to let it go. They can't hurt you.'

No, they can't hurt me you're right. Thankyou for reassuring me Grin. I'm pulled up on poor soag all the time, I could not give a rat's ass as luckily I have a wealth of fabulous attributes to compensate.

My point is the people wanging on about poor spag seem to be such patronising arses! It baffles me why they get so hung up on would have/of when tbh their superiority complexes are far more embarrassing than any missed comma or spag error.

Language matters a great deal to some people :) I haven't actually seen anyone on the thread claim they have perfect SPAG, yet others have delighted in tearing them to pieces. It says more about those doing the tearing than it does the posters who have a bugbear for a specific SPAG error.

It's okay to be bothered by plummeting standards of literacy and to consider why so many people have a really poor grasp of written English imo.

Your SPAG seems absolutely fine btw, it's not like every post on a message board has to be absolutely perfect!

Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 12:55

Because who decides what ‘speak properly’ means? What about those of us who have accents or speak in dialect?

DuchessOfDisaster · 09/08/2021 12:53

@Pumperthepumper

Exactly this, it drives me nuts! Speak properly or don't speak at all.

That’s pretty racist.

How is it racist?
OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 12:50

Exactly this, it drives me nuts! Speak properly or don't speak at all.

That’s pretty racist.

NanaPorsche · 09/08/2021 12:48

@Teaandscone

Teacher here. While making due allowances for dyslexic children, it’s often laziness. So often, when I point to one of the mistakes you mention, the child will be able to tell me what’s wrong. Children hate proofreading.
Would appear most do not proof read. 😬
kerrya1234 · 09/08/2021 12:48

@DuchessOfDisaster

I cringe when I see this written down. Along with "defiantly" for definitely and other examples. I don't see there is ever any excuse. And the excuse that "language evolves" doesn't wash, because "to of" is not a verb and never will be no matter how language evolves. It's not the same as adopting words from other cultures, new words like selfies, or a different meaning for "sick", for example.

OK, when we say "would've", "could've" etc, it may SOUND similar, but that's no excuse either. It implies the writer has never seen "would have" etc written down, therefore doesn't read much. What did they do at school? Was this style of writing used then and never corrected?

Another cringeworthy example is the inability to differentiate between there/they're/their and your/you're.

Just why do people do it and worse, why is it excused?

Exactly this, it drives me nuts! Speak properly or don't speak at all.
SueSaid · 09/08/2021 12:48

'This has really upset you, hasn't it? You mentioned on the first page that someone once pulled you up on poor SPAG. It's okay to let it go. They can't hurt you.'

No, they can't hurt me you're right. Thankyou for reassuring me Grin. I'm pulled up on poor soag all the time, I could not give a rat's ass as luckily I have a wealth of fabulous attributes to compensate.

My point is the people wanging on about poor spag seem to be such patronising arses! It baffles me why they get so hung up on would have/of when tbh their superiority complexes are far more embarrassing than any missed comma or spag error.

Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 12:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 12:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

DuchessOfDisaster · 09/08/2021 12:42

[quote Pumperthepumper]@DuchessOfDisaster but none of that can be true because you don’t see it at university. No dyslexic students, no ESOL students, no dyspraxic students, no students from a difficult background, no lazy students.[/quote]
We have all of those. But to get to university they need good grades. They will have had support at school or college to get those grades, or taken a pre-sessional course if English is not their first language. This would have helped them with any grammar or spelling issues.

As I said, the college I worked at was a totally different demographic (local students) from the students at the university I work at (from all over the country and overseas).

The vast majority of college students I taught did not go on to university anyway. They took vocational courses.

OP posts:
herewegoagain202106 · 09/08/2021 12:42

@IceLace100

Does anyone else judge grammar when using internet dating apps? Blush
I do Blush
herewegoagain202106 · 09/08/2021 12:41

@IceLace100 I do 🙈.. it is a deciding factor on if I reply or match back . Admittedly, it greatly reduces the pool Blush

Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 12:37

@DuchessOfDisaster but none of that can be true because you don’t see it at university. No dyslexic students, no ESOL students, no dyspraxic students, no students from a difficult background, no lazy students.