Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being irritated at "would of, could of....."

335 replies

DuchessOfDisaster · 08/08/2021 10:46

I cringe when I see this written down. Along with "defiantly" for definitely and other examples. I don't see there is ever any excuse. And the excuse that "language evolves" doesn't wash, because "to of" is not a verb and never will be no matter how language evolves. It's not the same as adopting words from other cultures, new words like selfies, or a different meaning for "sick", for example.

OK, when we say "would've", "could've" etc, it may SOUND similar, but that's no excuse either. It implies the writer has never seen "would have" etc written down, therefore doesn't read much. What did they do at school? Was this style of writing used then and never corrected?

Another cringeworthy example is the inability to differentiate between there/they're/their and your/you're.

Just why do people do it and worse, why is it excused?

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/08/2021 11:36

All those things do make me despair of the school system, when most of them should have been sorted out by the end of primary school.

I used to teach English to (largely) speakers of Arabic, and it would take me just one session to sort out e.g. it’s/its. These things really are not at all difficult, if they’re explained properly.

Though having said that, plenty of people don’t care or like to think they don’t matter. IMO anyone who tells kids that these things don’t matter any more, nobody but fusty old pedants care, are doing them a great disservice.

Just for starters, where there are a lot of applications for the same job, the easiest way to weed them out is to bin any with basic SPAG mistakes. And no, spellcheck is not an adequate substitute.

Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2021 11:36

That you think "pedants" are the people who like to criticise others.

Grammar pedants. Which you changed to language pedants.

DameAlyson · 08/08/2021 11:36

It can contribute to the communication failing, though, can't it?

Yes. If someone writes 'she defiantly told the teacher she had not done the homework' do they mean defiantly, or do they mean definitely? And how might it affect the way the situation was handled?

And people certainly do say 'could of', two separate words, not 'could've'.

seasonalremarks · 08/08/2021 11:35

I do feel a bit sorry for mono-linguals who struggle to write to a minimum standard in their one language.

OK. I'm sure they appreciate your pity.Hmm

CecilyP · 08/08/2021 11:35

so I feel it's unfair to judge somebody for saying would of, could of, or we was or lore and awdah!. You might as well judge them for not speaking opening their mouth and speaking out loud in Italian.

The thing is, everyone says would’ve, could’ve but many don’t have the grammatical understanding that it is would have and not would of. With the added complication that while of sounds like ‘ov’ it is spelled ‘of’.

Geamhradh · 08/08/2021 11:34

@Pumperthepumper

No. Language pedants say nothing of the sort. We go off for hours talking about why, historically and linguistically something happens. We find it interesting. Smug people who (as evidenced here) think they know about language rarely know as much as they think, and resort to "oooh listen to the thicko".

What does ‘no’ mean here? Which part are you disagreeing with?

That you think "pedants" are the people who like to criticise others.
Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2021 11:32

No. Language pedants say nothing of the sort. We go off for hours talking about why, historically and linguistically something happens. We find it interesting. Smug people who (as evidenced here) think they know about language rarely know as much as they think, and resort to "oooh listen to the thicko".

What does ‘no’ mean here? Which part are you disagreeing with?

SusieBob · 08/08/2021 11:32

In formal writing of course it matters.

People who correct grammar/spelling mistakes on informal internet forums/ SM etc are proper dicks though.

PuppyMonkey · 08/08/2021 11:32

@Caramellatteplease

Language changes. We dont speak Beowulf, Chaucer or Shakespeare style English. Verb tenses are dropped, verbs change.

The main thing is to convey meaning. You understand could of as easily as could have and actually it makes just as much sense.

So it doesn’t matter if novels and newspapers and important reports are full of could of and would of? As long as the meaning is clear, no need to edit them out? Confused
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/08/2021 11:31

I do feel a bit sorry for mono-linguals who struggle to write to a minimum standard in their one language

This is a much more polite way of expressing exactly how I feel about it than I ever could. Halo

seasonalremarks · 08/08/2021 11:31

Well said. @Pumperthepumper

Geamhradh · 08/08/2021 11:30

@Pumperthepumper

English isn’t everyone’s first language. Some people have additional educational needs. Some people had horrible childhoods meaning their basic education took a back seat.

Grammar pedants say they hate mistakes like ‘of’ or ‘there/your’ in the wrong place, buts it’s a lie. They fucking love it. It’s an opportunity to point out how clever they are and tut about laziness. It’s a chance to gather a tribe to look down on people, it’s their most favourite thing. That’s why so many of them point it out publicly - it’s to shame the writer, not to help them learn. If it was to help them learn they’d send a PM. It’s pathetic.

No. Language pedants say nothing of the sort. We go off for hours talking about why, historically and linguistically something happens. We find it interesting. Smug people who (as evidenced here) think they know about language rarely know as much as they think, and resort to "oooh listen to the thicko".
ElliottSmithsfingers · 08/08/2021 11:29

I'm fluent in three European languages, have a basic knowledge of a further three. English is by far the easiest of all. I frequent a number of forums in different languages and there are very few mistakes of the type you are talking about (i.e. fundamental misunderstanding of grammar and syntax relating to the specific language) in non English forums. Not sure why. It feels like the poorly educated in the UK are much more poorly educated than in other (European) countries. Perhaps the reason is that English is so easy, hence no need to really engage with grammar or syntax to speak and write at a basic level? I do feel a bit sorry for mono-linguals who struggle to write to a minimum standard in their one language.

Geamhradh · 08/08/2021 11:28

@BizzyIzzyfruitpie

I think some people write as they talk.

I get annoyed at the use of your instead of you’ll. it makes absolutely no sense! Same as saying “ instead” of “aitch”. Winds me up no end and it is unreasonable to get so annoyed by it but I just do 😂

You might want to read some of the threads on Northern Irish sectarianism before finding the haitch v aitch argument quite so funny. Hmm
Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2021 11:28

English isn’t everyone’s first language. Some people have additional educational needs. Some people had horrible childhoods meaning their basic education took a back seat.

Grammar pedants say they hate mistakes like ‘of’ or ‘there/your’ in the wrong place, buts it’s a lie. They fucking love it. It’s an opportunity to point out how clever they are and tut about laziness. It’s a chance to gather a tribe to look down on people, it’s their most favourite thing. That’s why so many of them point it out publicly - it’s to shame the writer, not to help them learn. If it was to help them learn they’d send a PM. It’s pathetic.

Geamhradh · 08/08/2021 11:27

@PearlFriday

. Once upon a time I might have thought ''why can you not say "have gone'', why do you say ''have went'' but as I read in books like the language instinct (I think!) we learn what's modelled to us at a young age and it's a miracle how consistent it is. How we learn it exactly! What's modelled to us is what we learn. That's language.

By the time you get to school and some teacher is saying ''have gone not have went'' or ''brought not brung'' or ''have run not have ran'' it's too late. The correct language in that deep part of our brains is formed.

I'm not saying that we shouldn't try to improve our language, I have improved my spelling over the years. But saying you ''cringe'' at mistakes is really harsh imo.

There's also the interesting aspect of hyper-correction with child language acquisition. Children will learn irregular forms first, because they become hard-wired more quickly. They then learn regular forms, and apply those rules to what's already been hard-wired. It's why children will go through a period of saying "I ran" then briefly, it will turn to "I runned" as their brains "experiment" with rules.
LizJamIsFab · 08/08/2021 11:27

I was quite a “good” student (compliant, did homework) but not a natural at English. Our English teaching was rubbish in primary and secondary, rarely marked, nearly no grammar taught. I only really know that since my eldest did secondary school exam preparation, a lot new to me.

Children need to be told they have made a mistake and learn to write correctly. I think this is not done everywhere.

Who is going to correct adults? Siblings maybe, colleagues? Only if they know better, have good relationship, see them writing and think it significant enough to mention ie probably no-one

Sparklingbrook · 08/08/2021 11:26

@SilentPanic

The purpose of language is to communicate. If you're making yourself understood, then you're doing it right. Grammar is a really weird thing to shame people about. You're not superior because you know what you feel are the definitive rules of how people should communicate. I say this as someone who has made a living out of writing for many, many years. Chill out.
I agree with this.
CecilyP · 08/08/2021 11:26

OK, when we say "would've", "could've" etc, it may SOUND similar, but that's no excuse either. It implies the writer has never seen "would have" etc written down, therefore doesn't read much. What did they do at school? Was this style of writing used then and never corrected?

Actually, it implies nothing of the kind. People can read plenty and just not take this sort of thing in. In addition correcting work without explanation, does nothing to further understanding of why this is wrong.

BizzyIzzyfruitpie · 08/08/2021 11:25

That’s “haitch” instead of “Aitch” 😂😂😂😂😂

Sakura7 · 08/08/2021 11:25

I see "quite" and "quiet" mixed up a lot too.

"Of" instead of "have" drives me nuts.

BizzyIzzyfruitpie · 08/08/2021 11:24

I think some people write as they talk.

I get annoyed at the use of your instead of you’ll. it makes absolutely no sense! Same as saying “ instead” of “aitch”. Winds me up no end and it is unreasonable to get so annoyed by it but I just do 😂

PearlFriday · 08/08/2021 11:23

@Knittingupastorm of course, and guidance in the areas you're weak in is a great resource. Especially when job-hunting. But it's the reaction to the mistakes that shows wisdom and empathy (or not). Is that reaction an inclination to support and guide and teach - with the understanding that it's actually counterintuitive to UN learn the language patterns solidified at a v young age? Or is the reaction to be irritated? to ''cringe'?!

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/08/2021 11:23

Bane of my internet life. I find it horribly discordant and it has an effect on me similar to the 'nails down a blackboard' that sets most people off.

I know why people do it, because they've heard 'could've', 'would've' etc, and mistakenly assumed they are hearing 'could of', but I can't help but wonder if any of the culprits ever attended school, or if they did, did their school not teach basic written English?

No academic institution would ever permit the flagrant use of 'could of', or absolute dogs breakfasts like 'I would of have to of', so yes, it might be pompous, but as someone who would have been reamed into next week for writing something like that in school, I always wonder where on earth people picked it up. I mean, it's an entirely incorrect word, not just a spelling mistake or something trivial Confused

RubyGoat · 08/08/2021 11:22

I take your would of / could of, & raise you would on / should on, and confusingly, all on, pronounced ornen. (All on = all of)

Swipe left for the next trending thread